McGuinty has a majority!!!!

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
27,836
5,501
113
Looks like one of the Cons is running for speaker...one thing about Cons, is you know for sure they can be bought...lol...
 
Frank Klees stated he doesn't have to vote Liberal if called upon to break a tie vote. There is no rule that you have to , although history says they always vote with the government party. Needless to say Hudak is not impressed.
 
AS the standings are 53 seats held by Liberals, and 54 by all other parties, taking the Speaker from the 'all others' total gives McG only a tie-total not a majority.

Klees' attempt to have it both ways by reserving his right to vote his conscience—which no person or precedent stands in the way of—doesn't say much for his commitment to the Speaker's impartial role as the one MPP who speaks for the whole house. Which is why the quite common precedent, that the Chair's casting vote is always for stability, exists in the first place. The Speaker's first concern of conscience should be the good order and clear sense of the will of the House. His somewhat rash statement leaves all the MPPs facing some version of the conundrum: How do I balance my sense of his partisanship/principles with my sense of the best way for the numbers to work, never mind does he have the wisdom for the job?
 
He sounds like an opportunist who has just burned his bridges with the Tories. However, unless all the other candidates pull out, he is not likely to get elected as Speaker
 
Frank Klees stated he doesn't have to vote Liberal if called upon to break a tie vote. There is no rule that you have to , although history says they always vote with the government party. ...
As others have already pointed out, this isn't quite right. Well, it's wrong.

The Speaker traditionally votes to maintain the status quo: that is, to continue debate (i.e. in favour of a Bill at First or Second Reading), or to maintain the current situation (voting against a Bill at Third Reading).

Whether the Government could fall on a tie-breaking vote by the Speaker would be a longer discussion, but it would probably be that the Government would concede that they could not proceed with their Agenda and would ask the LtGov to dissolve the House, rather than the Speaker's vote, that did it.
 
…Whether the Government could fall on a tie-breaking vote by the Speaker would be a longer discussion, but it would probably be that the Government would concede that they could not proceed with their Agenda and would ask the LtGov to dissolve the House, rather than the Speaker's vote, that did it.
Which is why Klees' bandwagon lost a wheel when he 'reserved his right' to vote as pleases him rather than as serves the body he would be heading.

Easy enough to take away the Speaker's vote with a rule that 'any motion with a tie-vote fails', as many organizations do. The precedent he clearly didn't grasp was a sweet way of the Speaker keeping his vote as MPP and keeping the Leg going. Which is the Speaker's job.

It's that old 'politics is the art of the possible' thing, not the current 'politics is about getting power' crap.