McDavid vs Ekblad

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
45,778
11,215
113
If you had to build a team from scratch which one of these two players would you build your team around?

The hype surrounding McDavid was overbearing. He was on the receiving end of two hits in the pre-season and crumpled like a rag doll. Mind you what the Flyers did to him was a bit of a goon job but he could be brittle in the long term. The Oilers are a hot mess, that does not help him.

Aaron Ekblad was the least hyped first round pick ever. He got run into the boards by Matt Hendricks, he returned after three games. He's already an elite defenseman in the NHL and he's not yet 20.

 
Good hit, most of todays players rely on the rules to protect them as opposed to protecting themselves, he should have more hockey sense than that..........I'd take Mcdavid in a heartbeat, he would have had 100 points this year, but we'll see how durable he is........I hope you're not a scout.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure you'll see the goal he just scored, he should be named captain now, still a shame he's in edmonton. It will be him and Kane battling it out the next 5 years or so.
 
I'll take McDavid but I would not play him right away. 1 year in JRs and 1 year in the minors before the NHL. McDavid is tall and slender, he needs to bulk up. Edmonton had to rush him in the NHL because they needed the tickets sales. Different story in Toronto where Leafs games sell out anyways.
 
^^^^lol Thats's ridiculous, he's top 5 in the NHL right now and he's played 14 games, he's so much more skilled than the guys he plays with they can't keep up, they just give him the puck.
 
The problem is McDavid is going to get hit and hard. His team-mates are all high skilled dandies with not a leatherneck grinder in sight. I fear playing for the Oilers will cut his career short.

McDavid needs to get on Gary Roberts regimen, Ekblad is already a member.
 
Present day logic favours a dominating No.1 Defenseman as your foundation. However you can also ruin a defensman worse by puting to much on their shoulders too soon.

And rookies like McDavid come around much less often these days. I mean stepping in at such a young age and being his teams best forward by a mile essentialy from Day 1.

There was a time it wasn't so rare. Setting aside the special cases of Gretzky & Lemieux, in the late 70's & early 80's. you had Bobby Smith, Bary Pederson, Steve Francis & Dale Hawerchuk & Steve Yzerman who all walked out of Junior and essentially were their teams' top forward immediately. (In the case Francis, Smith & Pederson, it took very little time for them to get on the short list of the best two-way forwards in all pro hockey). . So from that perspective McDavid is an even more scarec commodity
 
The problem is McDavid is going to get hit and hard. His team-mates are all high skilled dandies with not a leatherneck grinder in sight. I fear playing for the Oilers will cut his career short.

McDavid needs to get on Gary Roberts regimen, Ekblad is already a member.

That's the reason he need to bulk up. The reason to wait until he's 20 when he fills out his skinny frame.
 
^^^^lol Thats's ridiculous, he's top 5 in the NHL right now and he's played 14 games, he's so much more skilled than the guys he plays with they can't keep up, they just give him the puck.

What Insidious Von said. McDavid is going to continue to get hit hard. The reasons to wait until he's 20, it gives him time to fill out his skinny frame. He needs to bulk up. He's still a kid.
 
I love Ekblad he's a key part of an impressive Florida Panther squad. But McDavid is a once in a decade type talent. A player of his caliber makes everyone around them that much better. I think when all is said and done he has a better chance of leading his team to the Stanley Cup than Ekblad.
 
I love Ekblad he's a key part of an impressive Florida Panther squad. But McDavid is a once in a decade type talent. A player of his caliber makes everyone around them that much better. I think when all is said and done he has a better chance of leading his team to the Stanley Cup than Ekblad.

The Panther's with Ekblad will get there before Edmonton, not because Ekblad is better than McDavid but because the Florida organization is far a head of Edmonton.