MBA Advice

Surfbum84

New member
Feb 6, 2008
344
0
0
Heyo.

So here's my deal. I'm 27, have a very well paying job (about 130k a yr), own a condo, don't have to stress myself working that hard, things are good.

I got into a few MBA programs back in Aussieland. Do any of you members have MBA's? Do you recommend getting one? I got into 3 really good schools there that are internationally respected, so this isn't just meant to go and dick around (though the location helps a lot).

What are your thoughts?
 
Good to hear you moved out of the parents basement. :p

Don't you miss surfing the beaches in Aussieland? I say go for it!
 
Hard to say sb84 ... an MBA would open doors for you, but it seems like you've opened some doors already. What do you have to gain if you get an MBA? Can you progress further without one?
 
If you're going to spend the money and incur the opportunity costs of an MBA, you should be certain that the degree is a qualification for something you want (like the entrance requirement to a specific profession or position). Otherwise, just getting an MBA, even from a top school, is a very expensive, very speculative proposition. Depending on the school, the specialty (marketing, finance, consulting, etc.) and the regional or world economy, you might end up making less money after your MBA than you are now.
 
Presumably you are familiar with the term ROI. Just do the math.
 
Thanks guys.

I have upward mobility where I am. I like what I do, but I don't love it. The income is great, I can make more in the future for sure, but I like learning and am still unsure if where I am right now is what I want to do for the rest of my life.
 
If you are already making that kind of $ don't bother unless it's from a top 5 US school
 
Presumably you are familiar with the term ROI. Just do the math.

That is the wrong way to approach the question
If you are going to do an MBA because you want it to lead to greater compensation, you may be disappointed.
If you want broaden your skills and understanding, it will be rewarding.
 
 
MBAs are only useful because of the networking that goes on while in school. So if you are going to do it make sure to get into the top schools.

Thats not at all correct
The value of an MBA is in what you learn and the skills you develop.

The ability to Network for promotion and compensation is the wrong primary motivation for enrolling in an MBA
 
Thanks everyone.

Yeah, i'm 50/50 right now. I killed my GMAT and have good work experience, and one of the schools I got into is the best in Australia (UNSW), so I'm severely thinking about it.
 
That is the wrong way to approach the question
If you are going to do an MBA because you want it to lead to greater compensation, you may be disappointed.
If you want broaden your skills and understanding, it will be rewarding.

I completely disagree. It is exactly the right way to look at it. Putting aside for a second that all education has intrinsic value, why do something that may not advance your career? If you think that an MBA will open doors, lead to advancement, or more money, then go for it. Otherwise, there are other career advancing strategies that you can pursue in place of an MBA such as working harder at your current job, cross training, moving into another related field for experience, just to name a few. These strategies will also not empty your bank account. I do agree though that an MBA is not an instant key into the C-suite. There are A LOT of MBA's out there and often times MBA's walk out of school with an aire of entitlement that is extinguished by a competitive job market. Be honest in you assessment of what an MBA will realistically do for you and you won't be disappointed.

As for schools, why not go to McGill? It is the Harvard of Canada!

 
Heyo.

So here's my deal. I'm 27, have a very well paying job (about 130k a yr), own a condo, don't have to stress myself working that hard, things are good.

I got into a few MBA programs back in Aussieland. Do any of you members have MBA's? Do you recommend getting one? I got into 3 really good schools there that are internationally respected, so this isn't just meant to go and dick around (though the location helps a lot).

What are your thoughts?

1: If the first line is true, then why bother.
2: If the first line is true, you wouldn't need to bother asking us for advice.


I found MBA courses were easy. It is highly overrated. Like much in university it isn't about learning or expanding your mind, but rather getting the credentials needed to impress HR departments who are too inept or lazy to use other markers to pick people, so I guess it doesn't really matter. Granted if you are one of those type A types you can easily grind yourself into dust, but there is little need for it. You will find many of your classmates unable to see the bigger picture and end up making things much harder on themselves then they had to.
 
Surfbum, other than the pleasure of going to Australia, why not consider MBA programs near where you live? Many MBA programs offer classes either on weekends or in the evening.
 
1: If the first line is true, then why bother.
2: If the first line is true, you wouldn't need to bother asking us for advice.
.

They are true. Do you want me to pm you a copy of my T-4 to prove this to you?

Let me know.
 
Surfbum,

I was thinking at one time of getting an MBA and a friend of my father's wanted to discuss it with me. He happened to be the president of a financial institution - and his advice was to not get one. He had hired a significant number of MBA types and did not like the way they thought or worked. He did say that if I was set on getting one then I really needed a clear purpose as to why I was there. Many people get MBAs because their careers are in a rut and it seems like a good thing to do. But it just avoids the hard work they need to do to manage their careers.

My advice to you is:

1. Do you have a clear purpose as to why you are getting the MBA. What will the degree do for you?

2. Have you measured the cost - not just tuition etc - but lost income (in your case around $260,000)

3. As suggested above, can you obtain the education you want through other means? U of T for instance, has a great Continuing Education Program

4. If an MBA is what you want - does your undergrad degree exempt you from courses. Could you compress the MBA into one year.

5. Is it the right degree? For example a Masters in Industrial Relations could be more useful.

6. Many universities offer Executive Education programs that are 2-4 weeks long - could this be more useful? You could do one of these programs in several countries.

7. Talk to some senior exec and business owners in your field of work (or related field) and ask their advice. Get as much input as possible.

Good luck and by the way I did not get an MBA and do not regret it at all
 
Thanks everyone.

Yeah, i'm 50/50 right now. I killed my GMAT and have good work experience, and one of the schools I got into is the best in Australia (UNSW), so I'm severely thinking about it.

What is your undergrad in?

Apply to:

University of Chicago
Harvard
Stanford
Wharton
London School of Economics
Georgetown

University of New South Whales is a very good school but not well known in North America (more so in APac), any of the above are world recognized. Will your employer pay for it? What field are you in, if you're in sales it won't make much difference if you're in finance it's required to get to a certain level.....

OTB