Mattress recommendations

mmouse

Posts: 10,000000
Feb 4, 2003
1,861
42
48
About 3 years ago I bought a not-inexpensive Sealy mattress from the Bay and the f*cking thing has already got mountain valleys, despite regular rotations and no fatties on it.

Googling around, I now see that the entire mattress industry is scam. Worthless warranties, shady sales tactics, massive markups; components like springs are basically the same in all brands, and even multiple brands are made by a single factory due to outsourcing.

The only solution I can see is to avoid the big 'S' brands - Sealy, Simmons, Serta - and find a good local manufacturer. Does anyone have any recommendations?

I'm not interested in foam because apparently it makes you hot. I just want a good firm no frills mattress that will last.
 
I disagree about foam. I have a foam mattress from Foamite, local manufacturer, I had no choice because a king size spring mattress wouldn't go up my narrow 3rd floor stairs. Its in great shape after many years and I've never found it hot.

I recommend Foamite all the time.
 
Thanks, I'll check it out. Foam doesn't sag? Is it firm?
 
This is a very timely thread as I am in the market as well (or will be in about 6 months)

I agree with you that Simmons / Sealy are all shit now.

I was having this conversation with my boss and he recently bought a "Zed Bed" which he swears by and he's a very particular guy.

http://www.zedbed.com/accueil.html


I have also stayed at the "le Germain" in Montreal and have never slept on a better bed. Lo and behold, they sell them.

http://www.collectionsg.com/en/germain/collection/bed/mattress/default.idigit
 
Thanks, I'll check it out. Foam doesn't sag? Is it firm?

High quality foam, or high quality springs, both will serve you well. High quality foam doesn't sag. You can buy super firm foam, or less firm, it's up to you. I have a fairly hard foam mattress.

C.Cat's bowling ball example is right--the thing I like about it most is that it does not have the bounce and jiggle effect when one person gets in and out of bed--my wife gets up about an hour before I do in the morning, and I sleep right through. When we had a spring mattress her getting out of bed would bounce me around and I'd wake up. It doesn't have to be memory foam though maybe that's even better--but even just regular form there's much less of a bouncing effect.
 
I have a memory foam bed. That is te one where they drop a bowling ball on the bed and the other person is not disturbed. I paid 40% of the cost because it is not the well known brand that goes for $2500.

http://www.mybobs.com/Bob_O_Pedic.aspx
 
"thetree1" I think at one point was selling kingkoil matresses, not sure if he is still in the business....
 
Last edited:
About 3 years ago I bought a not-inexpensive Sealy mattress from the Bay and the f*cking thing has already got mountain valleys, despite regular rotations and no fatties on it.

Googling around, I now see that the entire mattress industry is scam. Worthless warranties, shady sales tactics, massive markups; components like springs are basically the same in all brands, and even multiple brands are made by a single factory due to outsourcing.

The only solution I can see is to avoid the big 'S' brands - Sealy, Simmons, Serta - and find a good local manufacturer. Does anyone have any recommendations?

I'm not interested in foam because apparently it makes you hot. I just want a good firm no frills mattress that will last.

You seem to have done your homework so you know how over inflated the prices are. When I bought mine, I went to all the large retailers comparing similar mattresses, found the lowest price and took it to one of the competitors and asked him to beat it.
I think you can generally look at reducing the price by around two thirds. Most people don't realize the huge mark up and are satisfied with a token discount, not realizing they should be asking for a bigger reduction in price.