Marketplace: no difference between Premium and regular.

One thing I am quite surprised is that no one has pointed out how big a rip of premium gas is in Canada compared to the US. They charge 14 cents a liter extra for premium in Canada, that is 3-4 x the upcharge in the US, and tax has NOTHING to do with it.
 
One thing I am quite surprised is that no one has pointed out how big a rip of premium gas is in Canada compared to the US. They charge 14 cents a liter extra for premium in Canada, that is 3-4 x the upcharge in the US, and tax has NOTHING to do with it.

Lately premium is 40 cents a US gallon more, used to be 20 cents and still is at some stations, not Shell thou

A US gallon has 3.7 liters.

Want to feel really rip off, I can get leaded 110 octane fuel for $7.50 a US gallon, that stuff is bad ass but will ruin catalytic converters...a little goes a long ways to boost octane

My Saturn I used to run premium gas till prices went so high, now it gets 87 all the time and they sell stuff to clean F.I. you can add to the gas once in awhile.
 
Yes all newer cars today can run lower octane fuel and the computer will have a knock sensor and will back off the timing to stop the knock. Power will go down but only at full throttle I believe. MPG you have to check, it might, it might not.

Don't forget, some gas has ethanol in it, all gas with ethanol will get less miles per gallon vs straight gasoline with no ethanol..that is a biggest mileage killer..and "they" want to increase it from 10% to 15%, ugh
 
The purpose of higher octane gas is NOT to run cleaner or get better mileage. It is to protect the engine from Knocking, which puts undue stress on an engine.

The guy in the video was driving a corvette and he still uses regular gas. Unless you are on a race track, regular is just fine.
 
Saw the show for the second time fore armed with the opinions in this thread and basically the fuel industry has been caught with it pants down. The CATI tests using the Dynameter are the same test used for you emission tests. Nothing they show should be questioned. The premium gas showed by the numbers no significant difference in the performance, but using premium in engines recommended for regular gas but trying premium actually showed emission increased, read unburned fuel out the exhaust.

The fact that the fuel companies refused an interview tell you they know its a con. The interview with the umnbrella association for the fuel industry became fun to watch when he realized the interviewer was well armed with real facts about the performance and 'requirements' of the car engines, fuel and additives. He really was squirming at the end.

Of course another example of the FDA in the US being miles ahead of the consumer protection departments of the Canadian government. The FDA must have it right as the fuel industry have followed government findings and judgement with little opposition.
 
The Bear drives a Vette in the summer and a Lexus in the winter. Always use premium in the Vette and will alternate premium with regular with the Lexus. My problem is with my boats. If I don't use a mid grade gas it causes all sorts of shit with both my outboard and inboard. GB
 
The Bear drives a Vette in the summer and a Lexus in the winter. Always use premium in the Vette and will alternate premium with regular with the Lexus. My problem is with my boats. If I don't use a mid grade gas it causes all sorts of shit with both my outboard and inboard. GB

I'm sure that the boat motors have the modern engine management systems that handle the differences in fuels.
 
If your engine over-compresses the fuel prior to the spark, the fuel might self-ignite, or pre-ignite. You hear this as pinking /pinging /knocking. Pinking over a long period can damage the engine.

Modern engines have a microphone that detects the pinking sound, whereupon the computer adjusts the ignition timing - which then spoils performance and efficiency.

The higher the octane rating of the fuel, the higher its ignition temperature, and the smaller its tendency to self-ignite, compared with a high-octane fuel at the same compression ratio. Over-compression is more likely in a car with a higher compression-ratio (which usually means a high performance car) -- so engines with a higher CR require fuel with a higher octane rating, to reduce the tendency to pinking.

If you hear the pinking noise, you can make it disappear by easing off on the gas -- as an alternative to switching to a high-octane fuel.

A supercharger on your engine increases the compression-ratio as seen by the fuel, which makes pinking more likely, and therefore a supercharger makes the use of a higher octane more of a necessity.

Another bad effect of higher CR arises because car engines use air rather than oxygen. A car engine is a machine that turns carbon into carbon oxides -- but is also a machine that turns nitrogen into nitrogen oxides. Emission of nitrogen oxides becomes a problem in cars with the higher CRs. The use of higher octane does not save the nitrogen from being turned into (toxic) N-oxides.

The octane rating has nothing to do with how much energy the fuel gives when it burns -- except that pinking wastes some of the fuel's energy - as does changing the ignition timing. Easing off on the gas saves energy - but wtf?

When you get to the point of pre-ignition your engine is toast. Knocking is due to detonation, normally ignition is quite slow and the ignition flames never reach the cylinder walls or piston head, there is a thin layer of gas protecting the engine from the flame so the engine never gets as hot as the flame. Detonation, typically this is due to excess oxygen competing for limited fuel, detonation is essentially a mini explosion, many engines are designed to be have small amounts of detonation under normal operating conditions, they have to in order to be able to deliver high MPG number. During detonation, the thin layer of gas protecting the engine internals is no longer there and the engine begins to absorb the heat of the flame, once the engine has absorbed so much heat then pre ignition starts to happen, fuel gets ignited well before the spark event, your engine is already a melted mess.