Marketplace: no difference between Premium and regular.

There were many things that were done in the pass that does not apply today, like pumping you gas pedal a few times before you start your car. or pumping the brakes when your car skids. Many today have accelerator pedals that are no longer mechanically connected to the fuel system, and cars with ABS do the pumping of the brakes for you in a skid.

Many years ago, if a car pistons were covered in crud, a tank or two of premium would might have cleaned out some crud to make the engine run better because premium gas back then had cleaners in them.

All of this do not apply today, but many people are going by the methods of years ago.

Proof you didn't watch the show. They talked quite plainly about the crude in todays engine and the 'need' for cleaning agents in todays fuel and engines. Your actual message is a little foggy though. Are you saying todays fuel and engines don't generally all these 'extras', which is what the programs research showed or that the public should join the 21t century?
 
If your car does not NEED a higher octane fuel, then it is correct, you will not bennefit by purchasing a higher octane fuel in the least.

But if you have a higher compression engine and you want better peformance (gained by advancing the timing - which on an older car with a distributor, you can easily alter yourself as opposed to a newer computer controlled ignition system (which requires the correct software and tools)) you need higher octane fuels.

By the way,

Octane does not deliver power.

Octane simply prevents premature ignition of the air fuel mixture during the compression stroke of the piston.

And 87 89 91 etc. are not percentages, they are octane ratings.

That is correct. Premium gas is not better gas than regular gas. It is gas that has a higher octane rating, i.e gas for engines that generally have higher compression ratios and where the ignition is set for higher octane gas.
 
One of the experts has a corvette, among others vehicles, and it is his fun car. He's driven it with regular for a long time and sees no difference. Of course the fuel companies refused to be interviewed. That should tell you something.

I watched the episode.

The guy with the Corvette says it is a waste to run premium in your car if it was designed for regular. This is true.

Regarding his Corvette, The expert says if he was taking the car to the track, he would use premium, but he said he just cruises around. That is consistent with what I said. If you have a performance car and regularly take it to the redline, you need the higher octane to prevent engine damage.

The dyno test was at a steady state 50 km/h, no where near the redline. If they hooked up a diagnostic computer to the ALDL on the Corvette running regular and made a run down the quarter mile, they would see several degrees of knock.

The episode also goes on to say that UNLESS the car is knocking, premium is a waste.
 
I watched the episode.

The guy with the Corvette says it is a waste to run premium in your car if it was designed for regular. This is true.

Regarding his Corvette, The expert says if he was taking the car to the track, he would use premium, but he said he just cruises around. That is consistent with what I said. If you have a performance car and regularly take it to the redline, you need the higher octane to prevent engine damage.

The dyno test was at a steady state 50 km/h, no where near the redline. If they hooked up a diagnostic computer to the ALDL on the Corvette running regular and made a run down the quarter mile, they would see several degrees of knock.

The episode also goes on to say that UNLESS the car is knocking, premium is a waste.

I would be careful about using this advice. If an engine is designed and the ignition set for high octane gas, I would not risk damaging the engine by saving a few bucks.
 
I would be careful about using this advice. If an engine is designed and the ignition set for high octane gas, I would not risk damaging the engine by saving a few bucks.

I have a car that needs 93 octane, and I feed it 93 octane because once and a while I step on it. In my regular car, I just run regular gas. I do know people who will put in regular gas in their performance car if they're going on a long trip somewhere. As long as they don't go near the redline, it's not an issue, they won't get knock. I myself can't be bothered trying to keep track of the mixture of my fuel, so I just pump premium if the car takes premium.
 
As long as they don't go near the redline, it's not an issue, they won't get knock.

incorrect. Most engines knock at lower rpm under heavy load. Mine seems to want to knock at ~ 4K rpm.... my rev limit cut is at 7500.

Agree with everything else though. If you don't load the engine you "generally" won't need the octane. Another thing to consider besides load is intake air temp... more likely to knock on high temp days when you are flooring it - at any rpm.
 
I watched the episode.

The guy with the Corvette says it is a waste to run premium in your car if it was designed for regular. This is true.

Regarding his Corvette, The expert says if he was taking the car to the track, he would use premium, but he said he just cruises around. That is consistent with what I said. If you have a performance car and regularly take it to the redline, you need the higher octane to prevent engine damage.

The dyno test was at a steady state 50 km/h, no where near the redline. If they hooked up a diagnostic computer to the ALDL on the Corvette running regular and made a run down the quarter mile, they would see several degrees of knock.

The episode also goes on to say that UNLESS the car is knocking, premium is a waste.


Damn I'm gonna read my owner's manual. Mind you, I have a company cc but still, I shouldn't pay more than I need. I don't drive a 'Vette either, but still somewhat of a high-performance engine.
 
I have a car that needs 93 octane, and I feed it 93 octane because once and a while I step on it. In my regular car, I just run regular gas. I do know people who will put in regular gas in their performance car if they're going on a long trip somewhere. As long as they don't go near the redline, it's not an issue, they won't get knock. I myself can't be bothered trying to keep track of the mixture of my fuel, so I just pump premium if the car takes premium.


What if I drive my non-vette aggressively or with a heavy foot (not necessarily/dangerously over the speed limit, but with high acceleration)?
 
The main point of the episode wasn't the corvette guy who can get away with regular if he is careful, but rather that most cars out there do not need premium, and a lot of people are pumping premium unnecessarily due to misconceptions. The corvette guy is an exception - if the owners manual calls for higher octane, use it.
 
I have a hard time understanding that someone would use lower octane gas than what the car manual calls for. The car company has no interest in having its customer's buy more expensive fuel than necessary, as it increases the cost of ownership. Most, if not all MB cars require 91 octane gas, and I put nothing else in the tank.
 
What if I drive my non-vette aggressively or with a heavy foot (not necessarily/dangerously over the speed limit, but with high acceleration)?

Engine load... if your car say it needs hi test and you drive with a lead foot - use hi test. If however you drive with less than half the power you have on tap - then regular is all you need.
 
Also - I think Shell 91 is the best gas you can get right now as it has no alcohol added to establish 91 octane. Alcohol is an easy way to increase octane but at the cost of energy/volume (about half) as well as corrosive to plastic and rubber - gaskets.
 
The main point of the episode wasn't the corvette guy who can get away with regular if he is careful, but rather that most cars out there do not need premium, and a lot of people are pumping premium unnecessarily due to misconceptions. The corvette guy is an exception - if the owners manual calls for higher octane, use it.

Bravo.....
 
Also - I think Shell 91 is the best gas you can get right now as it has no alcohol added to establish 91 octane. Alcohol is an easy way to increase octane but at the cost of energy/volume (about half) as well as corrosive to plastic and rubber - gaskets.

That is good advice. Also, use the Shell 91 (without alcohol) in all outdoor equipment, like chain saws, lawn mowers etc. The plastic tubing used in these engines are corroded fast by alcohol.
 
My car takes regular. I tried premium on a few occasions to experiment but noticed 0 improved mileage.
 
Unless you're car requires premium like some Porsche, but even cars that require premium like a corvette ran well on a regular.
All kinds of test were performed , they don't run cleaner, no better mileage nada.

http://www.cbc.ca/marketplace/

great video. I knew this and always argued with friends about regular vs premium. Some people you just can't convince. If you want to help the environment take that extra $500 you save in a year by using regular over premium and donate it to an environmental organization instead.
 
great video. I knew this and always argued with friends about regular vs premium. Some people you just can't convince. If you want to help the environment take that extra $500 you save in a year by using regular over premium and donate it to an environmental organization instead.

The purpose of higher octane gas is NOT to run cleaner or get better mileage. It is to protect the engine from Knocking, which puts undue stress on an engine.
 
This topic once came up on the CNN consumer advice show(can't remember the name of the show) One of the senior Porche engineers was interviewed, he said that a Porche will run just fine with lower octane fuel under normal driving conditions. Reason that the car manuals recommend using higher octane is all about the HP, HP impresses high performance car consumers.
 
If your engine over-compresses the fuel prior to the spark, the fuel might self-ignite, or pre-ignite. You hear this as pinking /pinging /knocking. Pinking over a long period can damage the engine.

Modern engines have a microphone that detects the pinking sound, whereupon the computer adjusts the ignition timing - which then spoils performance and efficiency.

The higher the octane rating of the fuel, the higher its ignition temperature, and the smaller its tendency to self-ignite, compared with a high-octane fuel at the same compression ratio. Over-compression is more likely in a car with a higher compression-ratio (which usually means a high performance car) -- so engines with a higher CR require fuel with a higher octane rating, to reduce the tendency to pinking.

If you hear the pinking noise, you can make it disappear by easing off on the gas -- as an alternative to switching to a high-octane fuel.

A supercharger on your engine increases the compression-ratio as seen by the fuel, which makes pinking more likely, and therefore a supercharger makes the use of a higher octane more of a necessity.

Another bad effect of higher CR arises because car engines use air rather than oxygen. A car engine is a machine that turns carbon into carbon oxides -- but is also a machine that turns nitrogen into nitrogen oxides. Emission of nitrogen oxides becomes a problem in cars with the higher CRs. The use of higher octane does not save the nitrogen from being turned into (toxic) N-oxides.

The octane rating has nothing to do with how much energy the fuel gives when it burns -- except that pinking wastes some of the fuel's energy - as does changing the ignition timing. Easing off on the gas saves energy - but wtf?
 
For older cars, bullshit. Own fleets in one of my companies, that is pure nonsense.

Typically see about 50 km/tank difference on older fleet cars, not to mention less wear and tear
on parts.

Premium gas is actually worth it ... can't comment on earlier model vehicles as I've never
tested them in the same data-driven way.


Don't know your definition of'old' but in the most recent engines, the management system really makes a difference in what the engine does, If a tank of premium give you 50 km more per tank, ~5 or 10% more does that compensate for the 10% increase in price, of premium. I get ~750 km per tank on the highway, ~500 km in the city, some other vehicle get close 1000 km; that's not much of a saving.