Manning Superbowl?

No...

Not possible.

The younger Manning revealed his true(r) nature yesterday. They won the game DESPITE him.

He aint' a Superbowl quarterback...not yet anyway.
 
MLAM said:
Not possible.

The younger Manning revealed his true(r) nature yesterday. They won the game DESPITE him.

He aint' a Superbowl quarterback...not yet anyway.

Unlike some people around here, I am not so much a home team fan that I can't see the logic in your point. To reiterate what I said in another post, Manning Jr. sucked yesterday, and it took a great effort by the Giants' defense to bail out his sorry ass. But no matter what happens, I am satisfied with Eli's progress and would consider this Giants' season a success.
 
Agreed...

homonger said:
Unlike some people around here, I am not so much a home team fan that I can't see the logic in your point. To reiterate what I said in another post, Manning Jr. sucked yesterday, and it took a great effort by the Giants' defense to bail out his sorry ass. But no matter what happens, I am satisfied with Eli's progress and would consider this Giants' season a success.

...the Giants are definately improved year over year, and there is no question that Eli is doing just fine for a 2nd year NFL QB.

But some people seemed to be awful ready to crown him as one of the premier quarterbacks in the league. I think yesterday showed he isn't quite there yet.

I find it interesting though that Eli is more like his Dad than his brother however. Eli has a bit of "gunslinger" in him, while his brother is more of the cerebral technician. Both style can make for a fine NFL quarterback though (see John Elway versus Kurt Warner, for example...both have Super Bowl rings).

The kid will be alright...especially if he gets a good quarterback coach / offensive coordinator to show him the way (because Tom Coughlin is NOT the man for raising up young quarterbacks...). But if he goes to the Super Bowl this year it will be as a guest of his brother....