Madonna VS GaGa

IMO:

Looks: Madonna wins. I think she really was hot in her day, whereas Lady Gaga is made up. Madonna keeps up a better body as well.

Music: Draw slightly in Madonna's favor. Madonna did provide a steady stream of hits for almost 2 decades, while Lady Gaga remains to be proven under the test of time. I'm not so sure Madonna's music is her own, and I don't know how much work Madonna put into it. Lady Gaga definitely gets point for being a pianist, and arguably, a genuine musician. But Madonna's got the time on her side, assuming she put in a fair amount of work on each album.
 
Wasn't Ms Ciccone originally from Detroit?

yes she is from detroit

here is Madonna's controversial "SEX" book in it's entirety http://www.beautifulmadonna.com/madonnasex/index1.html click the book to enlarge images

I think Lady Gaga has talent, time will tell if it will be lasting.
Madonna has already proven to be timeless and very talented

Madonna at the same age was WAY better looking, as you can see from the sex book

"Sex is a coffee table book written by Madonna with photographs by Steven Meisel Studio and film frames taken from film shot by Fabien Baron. Sex was released on October 21, 1992 by Warner Books. The book was released by Madonna as an accompaniment to her fifth studio album Erotica, which was released a day earlier.
The extremely controversial book featured strong adult content and softcore pornographic photographs depicting simulations of sexual acts, which included sadomasochism and analingus. Madonna wrote the book as a character named Mistress Dita, inspired by 1930s film actress Dita Parlo.
Featured in the book, aside from unknown models, are actress Isabella Rossellini, rappers Big Daddy Kane, Vanilla Ice and Alan Driscoll, model Naomi Campbell, gay porn star Joey Stefano, actor Udo Kier, the European socialite Tatiana von Fürstenberg, and nightclub owner Ingrid Casares.
For the release of Sex Madonna gave a party at New York City's Industria Superstudio, which she attended dressed as Little Bo Peep with a stuffed toy lamb."
from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_(book)
 
I will see LG next month. I think she reminds me of a young Madonna but as others have said, she has a lot of time still to prove her impact on the music industry.

i'm sure it will be a great show. it's actually a pretty good compliment to be compared to Madonna. but at this point everything she does has been done before.