Mac OS 10.5.6 problems? Apple suggests shampoo

WoodPeckr

Protuberant Member
May 29, 2002
47,086
6,215
113
North America
thewoodpecker.net
Mac OS 10.5.6 problems? Apple suggests shampoo

By Rik Myslewski in San Francisco • Posted in PCs & Chips, 19th December 2008

Apple has finally responded to numerous reports from disgruntled Mac users about their inability to upgrade Mac OS 10.5, Leopard, from version 10.5.5 to 10.5.6. Their advice: Try again.

Seriously.

Essentially, Apple's six-step advice can be boiled down into two steps:
1. Navigate to /Library/Updates and trash everything in that folder.
2. Download the update again and cross you fingers.

Or, as it says on a bottle of Head & Shoulders, "lather, rinse, and repeat."

Over at MacInTouch, the possibly Welsh poster Dafydd Williams posits an interesting - and, for Apple, somewhat embarrassing - theory about the upgrade degradation:
The long and the short of it is that the 190MB "delta" update (some delta updates appear to be bigger, at the 360MB or so mark) does not download correctly, stopping at around the 45MB mark. However, Software Update thinks that it has completed the download, and tries to proceed accordingly!

So, what's happening is that a partially complete file is being treated as a fully complete one. What's more, it's somehow getting past the checksum stage, which implies that the checksum is correct... for the 45MB partial file! This is a pretty major foul up.

Dafydd goes on to agree with our original advice, which is to eschew Software Update entirely and instead download and install the full Mac OS X 10.5.6 Combo Update from Apple's support site.

It should also be mentioned that Apple's "advice" doesn't address any of the other problems experienced by 10.5.6 updaters, such as dropped network connections, audio "pops" upon restart, Mail.app refusing to quit or failing to connect, problems with Apache and Contribute, and iSights going blind. (Oh, and if this last one has happened to you, make sure to reset both the SMU and the SMC.)

It appears that Apple's engineers are all preoccupied with preparing for their final Macworld Expo.
 
We discovered it was a problem with the installation process and the receipt is created before the package is installed and exits with a fail ... but with the receipt already existing the systems thinks the install was successful.
Bug Report created.....
 
Mac OS 10.5.6 update saga continues

Apple suggests fix for Mail suicides

By Rik Myslewski in San Francisco • Posted in PCs & Chips, 23rd December 2008 16:59 GMT

Apple is hoping that its latest support bulletin will calm down some of the uproar over problems caused by its latest Mac OS X upgrade - in this case, the propensity of Apple's email client to unexpectedly quit.

As we reported first one week ago and then again last Friday, the Mac OS 10.5.6 update has gone less than swimmingly for Apple - or, we should instead say, for Mac users who run the most recent version of the company's operating system, Leopard.

As we and many others have discussed, Mail.app has been particularly problematic. Point your browser to MacInTouch's 10.5.6 discussion, for example, and seach for "Mail" - as of this morning, you'd find over 100 references.

Apple's support bulletin confirms what many users have suspected: that Mail's unexpected serial suicides are the result of "outdated third-party Mail plugins." Apple also allows for the possibility that the errant behavior might be the result of a "copy of Mail that wasn't updated properly."

The fix? First run Software Update to see if your copy of Mail is, indeed, up to date - which we're assuming it is, because no Mac user smart enough to read The Reg would be dumb enough to not keep their apps up to date.

Then review your Mail plug-ins to make sure you're running the most-recent versions. Apple suggests that two particularly problematic offenders may be Christopher Atlan's OMIC and Sente's GPGMail.

If all your Mail plug-ins are fresh and healthy, try moving them all out of ~/Library/Mail/Bundles and/or /Library/Mail/Bundles anyway - hey, you never know where file-corruption might lurk.

If all is still not well - and if you've been around the Mac for a while - you know what Apple suggests that you do next. Correct: back up all your files, perform an Archive and Install reinstallation of Mac OS X 10.5 (preserving settings), then run the Mac OS X 10.5.6 Combo Update. Again.

Hey, it's the holiday season - you've got plenty of free time, right?
 
Awwww woodpeckr...still bitter over that Linux/Mac market share episode? Or is it the fact that Apple basically said, "no real need for anti-virus software"?

Is that why you're now harping on this Mail issue? One that seems to be caused by user-error or third parties rather than Apple themselves?

P.S. Did you know that Linux has almost as many anti-virus programs as Mac OS X yet it has only a tenth of OS X' market share? Merry Christmas! :D
 
LOL!
Not bitter at all. Just take delight in pointing out Mac is NOT as trouble free as Apple fanboys claim in all them silly Mac/MS commercials where they endlessly poke fun at MS.

ALL OSs have bugs even linux. As you know Both Mac and Linux have "no real need for anti-virus software". As far as linux having more AV apps as Mac, there are over 100 linux distros, so of course linux will have more AV apps than that pricy linux distro Apple sells.

Face it Mac is basically a Linux Distro you pay through the nose for.
Mac is far more pricy than MS, while Linux does all a Mac or a PC does without costing you a penny.

Hope you had a Merry Christmas also danibbler...:)
 
Funny, but I did not have any problems with any of my iron. Just lucky, I guess.

While no OS is perfect and completely trouble free, the Mac OS is more stable than Windblows. The total cost of ownership of a Mac computer still remains much lower than TCO of a similar Windblows machine.
 
WoodPeckr said:
ALL OSs have bugs even linux. As you know Both Mac and Linux have "no real need for anti-virus software". As far as linux having more AV apps as Mac, there are over 100 linux distros, so of course linux will have more AV apps than that pricy linux distro Apple sells.

Face it Mac is basically a Linux Distro you pay through the nose for.
Mac is far more pricy than MS, while Linux does all a Mac or a PC does without costing you a penny.

First off, once you claim that OS X is a Linux distro then your credibility is shot since the OS is based on Unix. Linux is essentially a clone of Unix.
Second, Linux takes quite a while to master and is not as user-friendly as OS X. I'd rather not spend my time futzing around with Linux, time that is worth money. How long did it take you to master Ubuntu? How much time did you spend on the Ubuntu forum?
 
Big deal, be it a Mac, Linux or Unix, point is they are all related and free unix/linux are even more stable than the Mac which you pay dearly for.

Ubuntu is easy to master, took only a few hours for the basics. About the same time it took to master a Mac. As stated above there are ~100 linux distros some being far more difficult which mainly use command line. Ubuntu is a snap to pickup and is laid out so well now there is no need to futz around. Played around with openSUSE for a couple months, that does require some futzing around with. Fedora was easy also but isn't being developed as much as the more popular distros. Dam Small Linux and Xandros, a couple lightweight distros, are even easier to master than a Mac.

Been using Ubuntu over 2 years now and really don't need MS or Apple at all. Learned at my own pace using the very helpful excellent free Ubuntu Forums for answers to more advanced questions. They are excellent as long as you don't come across as a 'know it all putz' whining about something that 95% of the time has a simple solution.

Hanging/playing around in the Apple Store I noticed they try to sell/push their 'Apple Classes' for those who want to learn Mac as they move away from MS which many folks seem to opt for. If Mac is soooooo simple to master, as you claim why are these 'classes' pushed so and they do cost a pretty penny to boot! The Ubuntu Forums are free! Sure there are Mac Forums and there you will see the problems folks are complaining away about with their Macs. They have good reason to complain though. Afterall they paid double or some triple for their Mac when compared to a PC and then there is Linux which doesn't cost you a penny..:cool:
 
You keep harping about how easy it is to pick up Ubuntu Linux and, frankly, it's not. I tried it two years ago and my problems included not being able to use my wireless card (no thanks to the Ubuntu forum which could not solve that issue) and not being able to update OO (even got a book but the instructions were incorrect...again, no help from the Ubuntu forum). And, I'm someone who's not scared to use the command line if need be.

In fact, I can't use OO for my work because it can't handle Word formatting correctly. That's just one example of what people who are deeply involved with Linux development admit are the too "rough around the edges" for widespread, mainstream deployment.

As for your "Apple Classes", glad you brought that up...they're only an hour long and they're free. You can get "One to One" training for a year if you sign up for a $99 membership but the group classes are free. That's all users need, an hour of instruction for them to switch over to OS X from Windows. Nice. :cool:

Tell me something, why is it that you come on here ragging on OS X? I don't see any "Mac fanboys" here posting specific threads on a consistent basis ragging on Windows or Linux but you've done at least two threads in the last two months. Does it involve something called "small penis syndrome"?
 
I'm completely self taught on PCs and never took any formal training.
Learned Windows on my own, same with Mac and Linux.
It's surprising you who seem more knowledgeable in this have had so much trouble with Ubuntu which is widely considered to be an easy distro to master.

Wireless is buggy with many linux distros. Only had some problems here after getting a laptop however hardwired linux always ran great. Had wireless with Hardy Heron then lost it after some updates. Upgraded to Intrepid Ibex (8.10) and at first had no wireless. Asked a question on wireless in the Ubuntu Forums and had a solution in <5 hours. They gave a link to correct wireless using Command Line which I also was able to 'pickup' with the help of the Forums. CL is neat and usually the fastest way to fix a bug. I never used CL on Windows but can use it when needed on linux without fear.

Never had any problems with OO. OO updates and upgrades trouble free on any distro I've used. Don't know why you have had such difficulty in this regard.

$99 for Apple classes!
Give me a break!
Never took any Windows classes so why bother shelling out extra bucks here. My first PC was a Gateway with Win95 in 1997. Gateway still has excellent phone support for free on this old Pent II. FWIW gave Gateway a phone call a couple years ago about an upgrade question on the internal HDD and Gateway told me my 'free lifetime support' that came with that PII will run until 2025 if that PC is still running......it still runs XP Pro and Ubuntu 8.10 pretty good for an antique PC. Have noticed the Mac salesmen push this 'extra expense classes' on newbies who are worried about the move from MS to Mac.

As far as ragging on OS X, lol.
Just having a little fun pointing out Mac isn't as trouble free as the Apple fanboys make out. ALL OSs have their bugs, everyone of them.
Just can't justify shelling out all that money on a pricy Mac when a closely related unix linux distro will do all the same for free.....;)
 
WoodPeckr said:
Never had any problems with OO. OO updates and upgrades trouble free on any distro I've used. Don't know why you have had such difficulty in this regard.

I said it was formatting incompatibility with Word documents.

WoodPeckr said:
$99 for Apple classes!

Have noticed the Mac salesmen push this 'extra expense classes' on newbies who are worried about the move from MS to Mac.

Did you not notice the bolded text for the word "free"? Let's try again. Apple's classes are FREE as in you do NOT need to pay them.

WoodPeckr said:
As far as ragging on OS X, lol.
Just having a little fun pointing out Mac isn't as trouble free as the Apple fanboys make out. ALL OSs have their bugs, everyone of them.

You need a new hobby because this one is making you look bad.

WoodPeckr said:
Just can't justify shelling out all that money on a pricy Mac when a closely related unix linux distro will do all the same for free.....;)

Once again, Linux is a Unix clone. It's NOT Unix. You play really fast and loose when it comes to facts, even when you're not actually ignoring them.

And, once again, as for paying for a UNIX OS, that's fine..a lot of people value their time and do not want to futz around with stuff like NDISwrappers when that UNIX OS works just fine out of the box.
 
danibbler said:
I said it was formatting incompatibility with Word documents.
Why mix apps?
When in MS I use Word or OO. When I use linux I use OO. Surely Mac must have a pricy app even better than both, no? I never used WINE, see no need to mix apps from different OSs. You're just asking for trouble, eh?
This 'formatting incompatibility' thingy seems self-inflicted.


danibbler said:
Did you not notice the bolded text for the word "free"? Let's try again. Apple's classes are FREE as in you do NOT need to pay them.
Hey you're the one who said you still have to shell out $99 for a silly 'membership fee'. That don't sound like free to most folks.


danibbler said:
You need a new hobby because this one is making you look bad.
Hey my linux hobby doesn't cost a penny.
Can you say the same about Mac?


danibbler said:
Once again, Linux is a Unix clone. It's NOT Unix. You play really fast and loose when it comes to facts, even when you're not actually ignoring them.

And, once again, as for paying for a UNIX OS, that's fine..a lot of people value their time and do not want to futz around with stuff like NDISwrappers when that UNIX OS works just fine out of the box.
If your time was sooooo important you would do what the majority of the world does and use Windows. This way you would save both time and a lot of money you're dishing out to Apple.
Me, I just save both time and money using linux....:)
 
Getting back to topic, I encountered a strange wireless issue when I upgraded. Basically my airport would drop connection after a bit of activity and would refuse to even show my network in the scanned list.

Eventually after a few PRAM resets the issue seems to have gone away for now.
 
WoodPeckr said:
Why mix apps?
When in MS I use Word or OO. When I use linux I use OO. Surely Mac must have a pricy app even better than both, no? I never used WINE, see no need to mix apps from different OSs. You're just asking for trouble, eh?
This 'formatting incompatibility' thingy seems self-inflicted.

No, it's because OO is incompatible with the Word templates that the people who pay the majority of my salary send me. Which part of my original:

"In fact, I can't use OO for my work because it can't handle Word formatting correctly."

did you not understand?

WoodPeckr said:
Hey you're the one who said you still have to shell out $99 for a silly 'membership fee'. That don't sound like free to most folks.

Ok, let me make it as clear as I can:

First, ALL GROUP CLASSES are FREE.
Second, if you want the One on One training option, then, you pay a membership fee. This is for the One on One training.

So, there are TWO options. One is a free route and the other is a paid route. Understand? You do NOT have to pay for training if you do not want to.

If you don't understand that then you're either being deliberately obtuse or well...I don't know how you ever picked up Linux.

Edit: In fact, let's forget about the second option. Make it realllllll simple for you and we will just say that there is NO need to pay for hour-long training classes at the Apple Store. There.

WoodPeckr said:
Hey my linux hobby doesn't cost a penny.
Can you say the same about Mac?

Frankly, it's taking a LOT more time laying out the facts about OS X to you than I have ever spent learning OS X.

WoodPeckr said:
If your time was sooooo important you would do what the majority of the world does and use Windows. This way you would save both time and a lot of money you're dishing out to Apple.
Me, I just save both time and money using linux....:)

I strongly doubt that you saved any sort of time with Linux from the responses I have gotten so far.
 
crystalpalace said:
Getting back to topic, I encountered a strange wireless issue when I upgraded. Basically my airport would drop connection after a bit of activity and would refuse to even show my network in the scanned list.

Eventually after a few PRAM resets the issue seems to have gone away for now.

That's very vague...can you tell us a bit more about your setup? Your OS? Hardware? I've never heard of PRAM resets being involved with wireless but there's always a first time.

edit: Actually, you may be better served by posting in a NEW thread asking for assistance. Those who can help you may not be reading this thread.
 
crystalpalace said:
Getting back to topic, I encountered a strange wireless issue when I upgraded. Basically my airport would drop connection after a bit of activity and would refuse to even show my network in the scanned list.

Eventually after a few PRAM resets the issue seems to have gone away for now.
Phone Apple.
Doesn't Apple have a free support 800 phone number to call?
My old Gateway PC had great phone support, still does and you talk to someone in the USA! Used to call them frequently when learning my first PC. In fact I still have 'free phone support' till 2025 if that antique is still running then.

Doing a quick scan of the Mac Forums you appear to be not alone with your wireless issues. It's common with Linux distros of which Mac is related to.
 
WoodPeckr said:
Phone Apple.
Doesn't Apple have a free support 800 phone number to call?
My old Gateway PC had great phone support, still does and you talk to someone in the USA! Used to call them frequently when learning my first PC. In fact I still have 'free phone support' till 2025 if that antique is still running then.

Doing a quick scan of the Mac Forums you appear to be not alone with your wireless issues. It's common with Linux distros of which Mac is related to.

That's incredibly unhelpful.

First off, if crystalpalace's comp is out of warranty then it's not a free support call.

Second, I don't see how you can diagnose cp's wireless issue with the paucity of information provided. Linux distro issues with wireless are more often attributable to driver issues or the particular chipset not being recognized.

Crystalpalace, start another thread and you may get much better help than in this one.
 
danibbler said:
That's incredibly unhelpful.

First off, if crystalpalace's comp is out of warranty then it's not a free support call.
No more 'incredibly unhelpful' than what you posted above, lol.
It was a mere sugestion, who knows maybe her Mac is still under warranty. Brand new Mac's do breakdown just like PCs. A buddy at work ended up taking a brand new Power G4 back because he had so many problems with it. He wanted it for video editing but said it was too big a hassle so he went back to Windows. I used to joke around with him and say he was just 'Mac Challenged'.....you know like you, who appear 'Ubuntu Challenged'...lol!

I still have 'free phone support' on my 12 yr old Gateway Pent2 PC till 2025 and since you feel Mac is the greatest thing since sliced bread, I'm sure Apple will help if she gives them a ring. Afterall it's a Mac so she is no doubt used to being overcharged....

danibbler said:
Second, I don't see how you can diagnose cp's wireless issue with the paucity of information provided. Linux distro issues with wireless are more often attributable to driver issues or the particular chipset not being recognized.
LOL!
You Gotta be a Mac Salesman!
Read much???
That was hardly a 'diagnosis' just an observation made on a quick scan of the Mac Forums and what I've overheard in the Apple Store. Folks do have problems with Mac wireless. Like I said my buddy was so frustrated, he had to take his brand new G4 back....and he's a full blown computer Geek who probably knows more about computers than the both of us!...:)
 
danibbler said:
That's very vague...can you tell us a bit more about your setup? Your OS? Hardware? I've never heard of PRAM resets being involved with wireless but there's always a first time.

edit: Actually, you may be better served by posting in a NEW thread asking for assistance. Those who can help you may not be reading this thread.

Thanks but my issue has gone away. I just posted that as to maybe it could help someone else.

Honestly I'm not very advanced with the Macs but eventually my issue went away with a couple of PRAM resets. Not 100% sure if this was the solution to the problem but I can't think anything else I did helped it.

My setup is an Early 2008 MacBook OS X 10.5.6
 
WoodPeckr said:
Phone Apple.
Doesn't Apple have a free support 800 phone number to call?
My old Gateway PC had great phone support, still does and you talk to someone in the USA! Used to call them frequently when learning my first PC. In fact I still have 'free phone support' till 2025 if that antique is still running then.

Doing a quick scan of the Mac Forums you appear to be not alone with your wireless issues. It's common with Linux distros of which Mac is related to.

I appreciate your suggestions. I do have support and extended Apple Care but I'm too lazy to call and go through the support procedure unless it's something I cannot fix myself.

Fortunately this problem went away and my Mac is back to its bulletproof stable self.