Lumosity exercises improve your cognitive functioning, I don't see any claims on their site about improvement of your IQ (which is relatively fixed).
In most sciences experimental designs test hypothesis, experiments are not design to prove your hypothesis, they are design to disprove an alternative explanation. Science is a process of elimination-you eliminate confounds as much as possible and thereby narrow it down to the only possible explanation. And yes, there are always control groups in each experiment.
Also, look at the team behind the project-they all are highly respected, published in peer-review journals academics with PhDs in Neuroscience, Cognitive Science and Psychology from Stanford, Princeton and UC Berkely. These people spent years studying how human brain functions and I'm convinced they know more about your brain than you do.
Improving cognitive functioning for one has been shown to positively affect the onset Alzheimer's so yes, playing games and solving puzzles that are designed to improve your memory, reaction speed, attention and problem solving will give you an overall more effectively functioning brain.
In a lot of ways your brain is like a muscle-it improves with challenge. And yes, learning how to play a sport, instrument or writing a book will improve your brain but you can also achieve this effect with smaller, more manageable tidbits. Ask anyone who is educated on cognitive performance-even such small things as taking a shower with your eyes closed or brushing your teeth with non-dominant hand leads to improvements in cognitive performance.
Small exercises on a regular will make your brain sharper so yes, playing games and solving puzzles does lead to improving your brain functioning.