Look out below

onthebottom

Never Been Justly Banned
Jan 10, 2002
40,880
197
63
Hooterville
www.scubadiving.com
Interesting read... further support to another thread on this topic some weeks ago....

OTB

Look out below

After years of lecturing America about loose lending, Canada now must confront a bubble of its own

Feb 4th 2012 | TORONTO | from the print edition

IN FEW corners of the world would a car park squeezed between two arms of an elevated highway be seen as prime real estate. In Toronto, however, a 75-storey condominium is planned for such an awkward site, near the waterfront. The car park next door will become a pair of 70-storey towers too. In total, 173 sky-scrapers are being built in Toronto, the most in North America. New York is second with 96.

When the United States saw a vast housing bubble inflate and burst during the 2000s, many Canadians felt smug about the purported prudence of their financial and property markets. During the crash, Canadian house prices fell by just 8%, compared with more than 30% in America. They hit new record highs by 2010. “Canada was not a part of the problem,” Stephen Harper, the prime minister, boasted in 2010.

Today the consensus is growing on Bay Street, Toronto’s answer to Wall Street, that Mr Harper may have to eat his words. In response to America’s slow economic recovery and uncertainty in Europe, the Bank of Canada has kept interest rates at record lows. Five-year fixed-rate mortgages now charge interest of just 2.99%. In response, Canadians have sought ever-bigger loans for ever-costlier homes. The country’s house prices have doubled since 2002.

Speculators are pouring into the property markets in Toronto and Vancouver. “We have foreign investors who are purchasing two, three, four, five properties,” says Michael Thompson, who heads Toronto’s economic-development committee. Last month a modest Toronto home put on the market for C$380,000 ($381,500) sold for C$570,000, following a bidding war among 31 prospective buyers. According to Demographia, a consultancy, Vancouver’s ratio of home prices to incomes is the highest in the English-speaking world.

Bankers are becoming alarmed. Mark Carney, the governor of the central bank, has been warning for years that Canadians are consuming beyond their means. The bosses of banks with big mortgage businesses, including CIBC, Royal Bank of Canada and the Bank of Montreal, have all said the housing market is at or near its peak. Canada’s ratio of household debt to disposable income has risen by 40% in the past decade, recently surpassing America’s (see chart). And its ratio of house prices to income is now 30% above its historical average—less than, say, Ireland’s excesses (which reached 70%), but high enough to expect a drop. A recent report from Bank of America said Canada was “showing many of the signs of a classic bubble”.

http://media.economist.com/sites/de...idth/images/print-edition/20120204_AMC524.gif

The consequences of such a bubble bursting are hard to predict. On the one hand, high demand for Canada’s commodity exports could cushion the blow from a housing bust. And since banks have recourse to all of a borrower’s assets, and Canadian lending standards are stricter than America’s were, a decline in house prices would probably not wreck the banks as it did in the United States.

However, the Canadian economy is still dependent on the consumer. Fears about the global economy have slowed business investment, and all levels of government are bent on austerity. The Conservative government’s next budget is expected to put forward a plan to close the federal deficit, now 2% of GDP, by 2015—modest austerity compared to Europe’s, but still a drag on the economy. Few new jobs are being created. Assuming there is no setback in Europe’s debt crunch, slowdown in America or drop in commodity prices, GDP is forecast to grow by a meagre 2% this year. If consumers start feeling less well off, Canada could slip back into recession.

The inevitable landing will probably be soft. Increases in house prices and sales volumes are slowing, and the 2015 Pan American Games in Toronto should prop up builders. “The national housing market is more like a balloon than a bubble,” says a report by the Bank of Montreal. “While bubbles always burst, a balloon often deflates slowly in the absence of a ‘pin’.”

Moreover, the government is trying to cool the market. The banking regulator is increasing its scrutiny of housing in response to concerns about speculators. The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, a government mortgage-insurance agency, says it will have to start reducing its new coverage because of legal limits. And the finance ministry has cut the maximum term of publicly insured mortgages from 35 years to 30. Some bank managers are calling for it to be reduced to 25, the historical norm. Canada’s reputation for financial sobriety is not entirely unwarranted.

However, the state has refused to use its most powerful tool. To protect business investment, the central bank has made clear that it plans to keep interest rates low. As long as money stays cheap, the balloon could get bigger—perhaps big enough to become a fully fledged bubble after all.
 
There will no doubt be a housing correction in Toronto but not to the extent that we have seen in the US. Lenders here were not nearly as irresponsible as our US counterparts and we don't have the equivalent of a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. Still the average debtload is a concern that needs to be addressed. We are seeing a slowing of the Canadian economy, particularly in Ontario, that will put pressure on owners of high mortgages.
 
There will no doubt be a housing correction in Toronto but not to the extent that we have seen in the US. Lenders here were not nearly as irresponsible as our US counterparts and we don't have the equivalent of a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. Still the average debtload is a concern that needs to be addressed. We are seeing a slowing of the Canadian economy, particularly in Ontario, that will put pressure on owners of high mortgages.

It might be as dramatic in Vancouver and surrounding areas. Their real estate is off the deep end!
 
Last month a modest Toronto home put on the market for C$380,000 ($381,500) sold for C$570,000, following a bidding war among 31 prospective buyers.

This information is totally mis-leading. The place was deliberately under priced by an attention seeking whore (realtor) and sold at a price that's close to what it's worth based on similar places in that neighbourhood.
 
All true. It was our lack of foresight, decades ago when we had the chance to destroy our in-town neighbourhoods by running expressways through their hearts and didn't. With neighbourhoods still vibrant, healthy and well serviced in the urban core, it was the poor or poorer and not the established middle-class that moved out to the burbs, and ou there's where developers first built vertical slums, clustered together on large single-tract land buys to duck the NIMBYs.

But slumlords have always 'served' the aspiring young as well as the hopeless poor, and what they realized was they could take their formula back downtown where no one would question yet another tower. Our crop ranges all the way from local engineers pumping their first deals to the Donald himself selling skypads for millions in the choking downtown our 'Don't Tax Me' Mayor is cutting services for. And of course the advantage is that in TO, somewhat analagous to Manhattan, downtown is still desireable. Charge and keep more bucks for the same built square foot.

T'ain't all a bad thing, But when the design-life of the buildings is twenty years, the condo-buyers are taking out thirty-year mortgages and everywhere you look there's no clear owner of this tower, or that one, or…, it does start to look a lot like the only smart money's in the flim-flam, not the steel and glass.
 
I lived on Queens Quay 2000 - 2003 before the Telus condo boom near Skydome took off. As all of those teeny tiny condos were being built I just shook my head as I was so glad to get out of that area. I was on top floor, 23 stories up, and it sound like the Gardiner was within arms reach just out side my window. The car noise never stops. I could not sleep with windows open due to the noise. Try to drive a car in or out of your garage when you are in that fall or spring season when baseball hockey and basketball overlap. With the build up in the last 10 years it is only worse.

Yes it is a funky place to visit IN THE SUMMERTIME and that I will continue to visit but I will never live there again.
 
I would rather buy a small little house in Etobicoke than some pad of a condo downtown.

Simply put - I believe that there is far greater potential for a larger correction in the condo market than the house market.

As to the Original post, you can find the talking heads pontificating about the price of real estate bad or good in Toronto. One guy says the sky is falling, the other guy says things can only go up. Just yesterday the CMHC released a report that said that housing was not going to burst anytime soon in Toronto.

Bottom line, I've said this before and I'll say it again......

There are only 2 things that will cause a housing crash in Canada - 1. Interest Rate Spike of about 3 to 4 points, or 2. A Depression.


I know that there are lots of people who love talking trash about home ownership in Toronto on this board, but usually I figure that they just want to get in the market and are hoping for a major correction. But here's the hell of it. As per above, there are only 2 ways you're going to see a major correction in RE prices in Toronto (by major I mean 30 to 50 percent). Huge interest spike? Well, you won't be able to afford the payments either. Depression? You probably will be out of work too so you won't be able to get a mortgage.

What On the Bottom keeps forgetting in his Canada bashing is that Canadian Banks were never in the business of giving away money to people who don't make enough to afford a mortgage (unlike our American cousins).

I know, I've been dealing with the Royal Bank on this very issue.

Canadian Banks will (and always have) only loan you about 3 to 3.5 times your annual salary in the form of a mortgage. In other words, if you make 100 grand a year (and who does) - Royal Bank of Canada will give you a mortgage at most of $350,000.00. When I was young, I used to curse the Canadian banks as being too conservative. Now - I think that they are smart fucking guys.

In the USA, they were giving mortgages of $500,000 to guys making 8 bucks an hour and amortizing over 100 years for fucks sakes. It was all predicated on the notion that real estate had nowhere to go but up.

Here's the hell of it:

If the American banks and lending companies had been regulated to a Canadian model of not giving mortgages greater than 3 times annual salary - the whole financial meltdown in the USA would never have occured. There would never have been so much easy liquidity in the system

Here, I found the article from the CBC that referenced a CHMC report that said that Canadian Real Estate prices would be stable for the next 2 years:

http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/story/2012/02/13/cmhc-housing-market.html

So for every yin, there is a yang. Who knows wtf to believe. For that matter, who the fuck cares. I can't live my life in fear. I never bought my house as in investment. I bought it as a place to live (and fix up).
 
Comparing ...

This information is totally mis-leading. The place was deliberately under priced by an attention seeking whore (realtor) and sold at a price that's close to what it's worth based on similar places in that neighbourhood.

Realtors to whores is a serious insult to whores!!:Eek:
 
What On the Bottom keeps forgetting in his Canada bashing is that Canadian Banks were never in the business of giving away money to people who don't make enough to afford a mortgage (unlike our American cousins).

I know, I've been dealing with the Royal Bank on this very issue.

Canadian Banks will (and always have) only loan you about 3 to 3.5 times your annual salary in the form of a mortgage. In other words, if you make 100 grand a year (and who does) - Royal Bank of Canada will give you a mortgage at most of $350,000.00. When I was young, I used to curse the Canadian banks as being too conservative. Now - I think that they are smart fucking guys.

In the USA, they were giving mortgages of $500,000 to guys making 8 bucks an hour and amortizing over 100 years for fucks sakes. It was all predicated on the notion that real estate had nowhere to go but up.

Here's the hell of it:

If the American banks and lending companies had been regulated to a Canadian model of not giving mortgages greater than 3 times annual salary - the whole financial meltdown in the USA would never have occured. There would never have been so much easy liquidity in the system

Here, I found the article from the CBC that referenced a CHMC report that said that Canadian Real Estate prices would be stable for the next 2 years:

http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/story/2012/02/13/cmhc-housing-market.html

So for every yin, there is a yang. Who knows wtf to believe. For that matter, who the fuck cares. I can't live my life in fear. I never bought my house as in investment. I bought it as a place to live (and fix up).


cap, don't know if the banks are still that conservative but my cousins just bought a 4 bedroom house in the burbs for 500k in Ajax and their income was 100k. I agree with you regarding the banks in the USA, a mechanic friend of mine made 4k a month and was approved for an 800k home in LA, lol.
 
I would rather buy a small little house in Etobicoke than some pad of a condo downtown.

Simply put - I believe that there is far greater potential for a larger correction in the condo market than the house market.

As to the Original post, you can find the talking heads pontificating about the price of real estate bad or good in Toronto. One guy says the sky is falling, the other guy says things can only go up. Just yesterday the CMHC released a report that said that housing was not going to burst anytime soon in Toronto.

Bottom line, I've said this before and I'll say it again......

There are only 2 things that will cause a housing crash in Canada - 1. Interest Rate Spike of about 3 to 4 points, or 2. A Depression.


I know that there are lots of people who love talking trash about home ownership in Toronto on this board, but usually I figure that they just want to get in the market and are hoping for a major correction. But here's the hell of it. As per above, there are only 2 ways you're going to see a major correction in RE prices in Toronto (by major I mean 30 to 50 percent). Huge interest spike? Well, you won't be able to afford the payments either. Depression? You probably will be out of work too so you won't be able to get a mortgage.

What On the Bottom keeps forgetting in his Canada bashing is that Canadian Banks were never in the business of giving away money to people who don't make enough to afford a mortgage (unlike our American cousins).

I know, I've been dealing with the Royal Bank on this very issue.

Canadian Banks will (and always have) only loan you about 3 to 3.5 times your annual salary in the form of a mortgage. In other words, if you make 100 grand a year (and who does) - Royal Bank of Canada will give you a mortgage at most of $350,000.00. When I was young, I used to curse the Canadian banks as being too conservative. Now - I think that they are smart fucking guys.

In the USA, they were giving mortgages of $500,000 to guys making 8 bucks an hour and amortizing over 100 years for fucks sakes. It was all predicated on the notion that real estate had nowhere to go but up.

Here's the hell of it:

If the American banks and lending companies had been regulated to a Canadian model of not giving mortgages greater than 3 times annual salary - the whole financial meltdown in the USA would never have occured. There would never have been so much easy liquidity in the system

Here, I found the article from the CBC that referenced a CHMC report that said that Canadian Real Estate prices would be stable for the next 2 years:

http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/story/2012/02/13/cmhc-housing-market.html

So for every yin, there is a yang. Who knows wtf to believe. For that matter, who the fuck cares. I can't live my life in fear. I never bought my house as in investment. I bought it as a place to live (and fix up).

You'd better see the Economist about Canada bashing, I just posted their article....

OTB
 
Just yesterday the CMHC released a report that said that housing was not going to burst anytime soon in Toronto.

Not exactly an impartial source. They are 2 or 3 months away from RUNNING OUT OF MONEY. They will be at their cap of 600 BILLION, which is what they (the taxpayers) are guaranteeing. I would be shocked if they said anything that even hinted at negative.
 
cap, don't know if the banks are still that conservative but my cousins just bought a 4 bedroom house in the burbs for 500k in Ajax and their income was 100k. I agree with you regarding the banks in the USA, a mechanic friend of mine made 4k a month and was approved for an 800k home in LA, lol.

Another thing Canadian banks have been doing is giving "cash back" mortgages. These have essentially allowed for people to purchase homes with zero down payment. The Canadian banks have been acting foolishly in the last couple of years and the rock solid faith many people have in this could well be proven wrong.
 
I know that there are lots of people who love talking trash about home ownership in Toronto on this board, but usually I figure that they just want to get in the market and are hoping for a major correction.

I'm hoping for, if not a crash, at least a sharp correction in condo prices, and it has nothing to do with wanting to get into the market (or moreso than I already am by owning the condo I live in). I just would like to stop seeing every other block of downtown being turned into condos, or slated to be turned into condos. The way things are going, within 10 years every building with any character, every independent store, and (sadly for me) every strip club downtown will be a 50-storey skyscraper with a few chain stores at street level.

As for whether a crash will happen, who knows, but better that it happens now than after half the city is torn down to make way for hundreds more towers that suddenly no one wants to live in.
 
Another thing Canadian banks have been doing is giving "cash back" mortgages. These have essentially allowed for people to purchase homes with zero down payment. The Canadian banks have been acting foolishly in the last couple of years and the rock solid faith many people have in this could well be proven wrong.

Sort of.

They will give you "cash back" if you get a mortgage at the posted rate.

But the "posted rate" and the rate that you can actually get are 2 different things.

For example, RBC discounted my mortgage by about 1% or so (can't remember the exact figure, but it was in that ballpark). But if I take the discount, they don't offer you any "cash back"

If you do the math, it's far more sensical to get the lowest rate you can possibly get - fuck the cash back.

And if you don't have 20 or 25 pecent equity in your house (can't remember the exact number) - you can't get a discounted rate PLUS you need to pay a certain additional premium in terms of a percentage to insure the mortgage with the CMHC.

In short - there is no free lunch.
 
Kirk, what makes sense and what most people do are two very different things. There's no shortage of people out that that will think, ooh, free money.. and low monthly payments for the next 30 years. There's far more people who think like Homer Simpson does than I care to imagine..

The fact that these were being offered is a big red flag.
 
You'd better see the Economist about Canada bashing, I just posted their article....

OTB

"The Economist", another American based magazine right.

Like I said, for every Yin, there's a Yang. I'm not about to live my life in fear about what could happen.

Here's another article about Canadian Housing prices that says that prices will be stable written by BMO, published in the Globe and Mail.


http://www.theglobeandmail.com/repo...-housing-crash-for-canada-bmo/article2319474/

I'm not saying that Real Estate Prices will not fluctuate. What I'm saying is that they will need a catalyst and that catalyst is an interest rate spike or a depression / severe recession. (Neither of which is something that anyone wants to see, both of which are entirely possible I admit.) Canada is not an island and we are very much subject to what is happening in the USA, Asia, and to a lesser extent Europe.

If anything, I'm afraid that all the growth we are seeing in Canada in the resource industry is based on "the China Play". Now there is a house of cards if there ever was one.

Canada will be severely FUCKED when that house of cards collapses because our idiot Federal Government has put all its eggs in the resource basket of Western Canada and has largely cut Ontario and Quebec lose to twist in the wind.

Canada will be severely fucked when China crashes and burns.

Then you will see a 40 percent haircut in Real Estate prices.

Problem is - you will be unemployed and unable to afford to buy the cheap real estate anyway. Only the rich fuckers wtih money in the bank will bennefit.

That as they say is the hell of it.
 
Kirk, what makes sense and what most people do are two very different things. There's no shortage of people out that that will think, ooh, free money.. and low monthly payments for the next 30 years. There's far more people who think like Homer Simpson does than I care to imagine..

The fact that these were being offered is a big red flag.

True, people are stupid.

Always do everything you can to squeeze ever last fraction of a percentage point in interest out of the bank.

But I bought my house in 1996 and they had those same cash back deals back then too.

And you could buy a house with 5% down, which a few years later, they lowered to 0% down, then in 2008 they put back to 5%.

I truely think that you should need 10% down to qualify for a mortgage.
 
I don't agree that the only catalyst could be an interest spike or a depression/severe recession. Look over the Toronto skyline at all the cranes building all those condos that we don't need. Houses will fair better, but the day or reckoning for condos is coming and it's coming soon. It's simple supply and demand and interest rates won't do a damn thing, just like they didn't for Japan. It's not about living in fear, it's about looking at things objectively and using logic. BMO says housing is good? Case closed, don't worry about the evidence.
 
I don't agree that the only catalyst could be an interest spike or a depression/severe recession. Look over the Toronto skyline at all the cranes building all those condos that we don't need. Houses will fair better, but the day or reckoning for condos is coming and it's coming soon. It's simple supply and demand and interest rates won't do a damn thing, just like they didn't for Japan. It's not about living in fear, it's about looking at things objectively and using logic. BMO says housing is good? Case closed, don't worry about the evidence.

What you are refering to is "over built"

Being over built does not mean that there will be a major correction in housing or condo prices in particular.

All it means is that they stop building condos and let the ones they have get bought up. Tough news if you're in the construction industry.

No different than the Commercial office space glut in Toronto for the last 10 years - how many office buildings did you see being built in the last 10 years? Not too many.

I won't disagree with you that the Toronto condo market is overbuilt, however, Canada takes 250,000 immigrants a year and most of them locate to the GTA. Not saying that most immigrants have money, but they do need to live somewhere.

Overbuilt doesn't scare me.

Interest rate spikes, Depressions, ponzi schemes, banking crashes - they scare me.
 
What you are refering to is "over built"

Being over built does not mean that there will be a major correction in housing or condo prices in particular.

All it means is that they stop building condos and let the ones they have get bought up. Tough news if you're in the construction industry.

I won't disagree with you that the Toronto condo market is overbuilt, however, Canada takes 250,000 immigrants a year and most of them locate to the GTA. Not saying that most immigrants have money, but they do need to live somewhere.

Overbuilt doesn't scare me.

Interest rate spikes, Depressions, ponzi schemes, banking crashes - they scare me.

It's amazing how for so many years the supply of housing was good enough for the immigrants we were taking in. Suddenly when prices are insane on a supply that seems limitless the immigrants are coming to save the day.
It ain't immigrants buying these condos.. it's "investors", but they should really be called gamblers. I've heard on numerous buildings that they represent up to 80% of the buyers. Unless you're putting down massive (and I mean MASSIVE) down payments it's financially impossible to buy virtually any condo in this city - pre-construction or existing - and rent it for enough money to just break even. If you think being over built doesn't mean there will be a correction then you need only look at Dubai. Mark my words, in a year or two condo will be a dirty word.