London: Train Blew Up...

Fatume said:
What do you call 9/11, the train bombings in Spain, and now London? If this isn't war then I don't know what is. It looks like it will take some terrorist act here in Canada before people such as yourself will see the light. Personally being a Canadian I am ashamed that our government allows these terrorist groups to operate in our country with impunity. In all liklihood they haven't struck on our soil because they don't want to put the heat on themselves here, but eventually that will come to an end as well.

The real simple solution is to get the fuck out of Iraq and stop raping it of their resources under the guise of phony morality and justice. Obviously, you can never stop terrorism completely but really if you are gonna suppress a nation and fuck them over then you got to expect payback. Whenever innocent people die it's a sad day but you don't react to that with hatred and more killing or else the cycle will always perpetuate itself. You can never kill hatred but you can lessen it through your own actions and the choices you make. The reason the USA/UK is in Iraq is because of the impending OIL crisis and how they have to stabilize the area for their supply and not because of some phony war on terrorism which in reality is causing more harm than good. When will YOU see the light.
 
train said:
Wow...this was obviously written by someone who is not conflicted about their own self-worth. Nice to be so convinced you have all the answers.

Nearly 40 killed and hundreds of wounded , yet many news stories focused on the quick return to "normality" in London . The resiliency of the British is admirable.

What can I say, I'm a pretty smart guy and I can smell the US bullshit a mile away and it stinks pretty bad from where I am.

It's unbelievable how people are just sheep to propaganda. They must have been saying that crap about the British people for eternity last night and now it is a part of you (such that you feel it is important enough to repeat). Personally I was practically choking on how thick they were laying it on and I am of UK decent so let's get real please. The British act no differently than any other people in a time of crisis really but it is said to reinforce the notion of "US versus THEM" so that we don't question our morality or if morality is sometimes not on our side in the actions that we pursue (since we must be better than them and are “resilient” to the forces of evil). Yes the terrorist acts were wrong but they were in part caused by Western Imperialism and warmongering.
 
burlboy said:
My "Propaganda" come from the CSIS website the following is a summary of terrorist activities in Canada.

By way of example, the following terrorist or front groups acting on their behalf have or had supporters in Canada: Hizballah and other Shiite Islamic terrorist organizations; Hamas; the Egyptian Al Jihad and various other Sunni Islamic extremist groups from across the Middle East and Maghreb; the Provisional Irish Republican Army (PIRA), the Tamil Tigers (LTTE), the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK), and all the world’s major Sikh terrorist groups. Some supporters of the international Islamic Jihad cause are also present in Canada, with a few of them possibly linked to Al Qaida.

Blah, blah, blah. So what is your point? Do you really believe those groups exist because we aren't tough enough on terrorism? Do you believe that because there are terrorist groups in Canada that the war on Iraq is justified and that we got to bring it to them in a big time way? Yes, if those groups are supporters (fundraisers) of terrorist groups and can be proven to be such they should be shut down but it certainly isn't justification for the war on Iraq or a crowning example of its success/necessity. Quite the contrary in fact, the war on Iraq and the western support of it will only cause more of such groups to exist because hatred begets hatred.
 
Fatume said:
They might be innocent at a young age, but they will grow up to be terrorists so why not nip it in the bud and get rid of them. This is unlike any war the world has ever seen, so draconian measures must be taken. We as Canadians have to get over our santimonious attitude of being "peace keepers" and see what is really going on in the world. The only way peace will ever be achieved is the toal extermination of these terrroist groups by whatever means necessary. You naive bleeding hearts will no doubt misconstrue this as rascist, but rest assured it is not. It is called survival. There is a saying that you don't take a knife to a gun fight so why are we inthe western world not fighting fire with fire. The total and complete extermination of these islamic extremists is absolutely necessary. If innocent people suffer so be it, but we are fooling ourselves if we think talking things out and trying to compromise with these people is going to accomplish anything. They are laughing right in our faces. Today at my office I had a Pakistani co-worker tell me England got what it had coming to it. It was all I could do to stop myself from kicking this bastard in the nuts. Let us all wake up people and see what is really going on around us. They are in our midst here in Canada and it is only a matter of time before something happens here as well. Let us all act in unisona and try to stop these bastards.


This is parody, right?

Right?
 
solitaria said:
Whenever innocent people die it's a sad day but you don't react to that with hatred and more killing or else the cycle will always perpetuate itself. You can never kill hatred but you can lessen it through your own actions and the choices you make.

Muslim extremists who were involved in 9/11 had no justification for attacking civilian targets. What kind of person organizes for months and years to commit such an atrocity? Not the kind of person who is impressed by being shown the other cheek.

Moderation and dialogue are valid tools when dealing with disputes between reasonable parties. That's not what terrorism is about.

You may be right that there is no way to completely eradicate terrorism. There is also no way to completely exterminate all of the cockroaches in New York. However, the world is a better place if you eliminate as many of them as you can.
 
solitaria said:
What can I say, I'm a pretty smart guy and I can smell the US bullshit a mile away and it stinks pretty bad from where I am.

.

lol... Does anyone else think you are as smart as you do ?

Yes , werstern actions contribute by providing a focus for terroists.

The "us vs. them" that you so quickly accuse the British of is also a fairly basic tool used by the wackos . In fact it's one of their main tools.
 
Bud Plug said:
Muslim extremists who were involved in 9/11 had no justification for attacking civilian targets. What kind of person organizes for months and years to commit such an atrocity? Not the kind of person who is impressed by being shown the other cheek.

Moderation and dialogue are valid tools when dealing with disputes between reasonable parties. That's not what terrorism is about.

You may be right that there is no way to completely eradicate terrorism. There is also no way to completely exterminate all of the cockroaches in New York. However, the world is a better place if you eliminate as many of them as you can.


Well said!
 
Bud Plug said:
Muslim extremists who were involved in 9/11 had no justification for attacking civilian targets.

I agree but it works both ways. The USA uses "9/11" as an excuse to use military force and gain control over the middle east region and Muslim extremists use "American imperialism" to do likewise. Both are/were wrong for their justifications and wrongdoings. It's too bad most people only see the wrongdoings of the other side though, because that is not how the governments and opposing forces will ever be stopped.

Bud Plug said:
What kind of person organizes for months and years to commit such an atrocity?

The Republican party or Al-Qaeda take your pick. Don't kid yourself, attacking Iraq and in the process killing many innocents (more so than 9/11) isn't any different really. George Bush was going to attack Iraq with or without 9/11 but 9/11 sure helped his flimsy justifications with the masses.


Bud Plug said:
Moderation and dialogue are valid tools when dealing with disputes between reasonable parties. That's not what terrorism is about.

What you say is correct but to stop terrorism you have to alter the environment that leads to that mentality in the first place. Once a person has become a terrorist it's too late because his hate has already seized his intellect.

Bud Plug said:
You may be right that there is no way to completely eradicate terrorism. There is also no way to completely exterminate all of the cockroaches in New York. However, the world is a better place if you eliminate as many of them as you can.

Cockroaches are pretty harmless and the insecticides that you use to kill them are actually worse to your being than the problem.

Same goes for trying to bomb Muslims into oblivion. Aside from the obvious point that Muslims can't be likened to cockroaches and the majority aren't bad people so that it would be immoral to do something like that, it would only make the problem worse. Nuking the middle east would be more akin to wacking a hornet's nest blindly with a stick, it would be only a matter of time before you would be getting stung worse than you could ever imagine and the repercussions of such stupidity would be enormous.
 
Bud Plug said:
Moderation and dialogue are valid tools when dealing with disputes between reasonable parties. That's not what terrorism is about.

You may be right that there is no way to completely eradicate terrorism. There is also no way to completely exterminate all of the cockroaches in New York. However, the world is a better place

if you eliminate as many of them as you can.

Well sure, as long as the RIGHT and RESPONSIBLE terrorists are dealt with.


Any terrorism and crimes against the innocents are abhorrible and wrong, but those deeds never make it right for painting a whole race, or religion of people with such broad brush strokes.

Fatume, I understand your angst towards acts of terror by those extremists. You definitely need to understand more about other's culture. Blind and ignorant hatred will never get things fixed, and will only promote more hatred, misundrestanding and violence.
 
Berlin said:
Well sure, as long as the RIGHT and RESPONSIBLE terrorists are dealt with.

Any terrorism and crimes against the innocents are abhorrible and wrong, but those deeds never make it right for painting a whole race, or religion of people with such broad brush strokes.


Solitaria said:
Same goes for trying to bomb Muslims into oblivion. Aside from the obvious point that Muslims can't be likened to cockroaches and the majority aren't bad people so that it would be immoral to do something like that, it would only make the problem worse. Nuking the middle east would be more akin to wacking a hornet's nest blindly with a stick, it would be only a matter of time before you would be getting stung worse than you could ever imagine and the repercussions of such stupidity would be enormous.

This kind of thing really makes me question the reading skills of some TERBites. Did I ever say eradicate Muslims, or Arabs? No, I said we should eradicate terrorists. What's wrong with that?
 
solitaria said:
The Republican party or Al-Qaeda take your pick. Don't kid yourself, attacking Iraq and in the process killing many innocents (more so than 9/11) isn't any different really. George Bush was going to attack Iraq with or without 9/11 but 9/11 sure helped his flimsy justifications with the masses.

What a load of relativist bullshit.

I did not support GWB's Iraq Invasion and I agree that 9/11 was exploited in order to justify said Invasion. To essentially claim that the two actions are therefore morally equivalent is ridiculous.

A brutal dictator has been removed from power. Oppressed minority groups now share power. Tentative steps towards democracy are occurring. Those are positive outcomes for the people of Iraq, and were clearly "foreseeable" results of the invasion. That does not justify the invasion in of itself, nor excuse the incompetent occupation. Such outcomes, however, cannot be ignored.

Now, pray tell, what positive outcome resulted from the slaughter of Americans on 9/11?
 
Bud Plug said:
This kind of thing really makes me question the reading skills of some TERBites.

LOL ... You hit it right on the nail. Is your handle Fatume ?
 
The Shake said:
What a load of relativist bullshit.

I did not support GWB's Iraq Invasion and I agree that 9/11 was exploited in order to justify said Invasion. To essentially claim that the two actions are therefore morally equivalent is ridiculous.

A brutal dictator has been removed from power. Oppressed minority groups now share power. Tentative steps towards democracy are occurring. Those are positive outcomes for the people of Iraq, and were clearly "foreseeable" results of the invasion. That does not justify the invasion in of itself, nor excuse the incompetent occupation. Such outcomes, however, cannot be ignored.

Now, pray tell, what positive outcome resulted from the slaughter of Americans on 9/11?

IF I stop a guy from murdering a girl only to rape her with the excuse that I am the lesser of two evils and saved her from a worse fate, do you really want to start drawing distinctions between which evil is worse? Coz that would be the only load of relativistic bullshit I'd be smelling.
 
Bud Plug said:
This kind of thing really makes me question the reading skills of some TERBites. Did I ever say eradicate Muslims, or Arabs? No, I said we should eradicate terrorists. What's wrong with that?

ANd how do you propose to eradicate all terrorists by force w/o massive collateral damage? Do you think it is like spraying for cockroaches, like the example you gave? Yeah just tell all the good Muslims to leave while the USA bombs the building because of a few cockroaches. Surely you can't be this naive or impractical about the situation in the Middle East.
 
solitaria said:
IF I stop a guy from murdering a girl only to rape her with the excuse that I am the lesser of two evils and saved her from a worse fate, do you really want to start drawing distinctions between which evil is worse?

First, we can, do, and should draw distinctions between evils. Kim Jong-il is worse than Fidel Castro. Murder is worse than punching someone in the face. Brittany Spears is worse than Ashlee Simpson. And so forth. The world simply isn't black and white.

Second, and more importantly, I simply don't accept that the American presence is "evil". In your analogy, there's no positive outcome for the victim, just a less bad one. That isn't the case in Iraq. The eventual outcome will be positive. The motives of the Americans are secondary to the eventual fate of Iraq.
 
The Shake said:
First, we can, do, and should draw distinctions between evils. Kim Jong-il is worse than Fidel Castro. Murder is worse than punching someone in the face. Brittany Spears is worse than Ashlee Simpson. And so forth. The world simply isn't black and white.

The world isn't black and white but evil is that simple. It exists on both sides and plays back and forth. Do you honestly believe we would have situations like Iraq and 9/11 if it wasn't for the USA exploiting resources and humanity at all costs (by propping up dictatorships that you would call "evil") like they do in the name of capitalism?

The Shake said:
Second, and more importantly, I simply don't accept that the American presence is "evil".

I disagree big time. I view the situation like they are fucking over a girl after she screamed for help and is lying unconscious on the ground. Hey but they chased her assailant away who was their buddy about 5 minutes previously (relatively speaking of course). Ah yes the Americans love to play good cop bad cop to get away with murder.

The Shake said:
In your analogy, there's no positive outcome for the victim, just a less bad one. That isn't the case in Iraq. The eventual outcome will be positive.

You are pretty naive if you believe that. Sooner or later they will be forced out of there which will create a power vacuum explosion.

The Shake said:
The motives of the Americans are secondary to the eventual fate of Iraq.

Yes but motives are primary when talking morality. Ever heard of the expression the end doesn't justify the means?
 
solitaria said:
The world isn't black and white but evil is that simple. It exists on both sides and plays back and forth. Do you honestly believe we would have situations like Iraq and 9/11 if it wasn't for the USA exploiting resources and humanity at all costs (by propping up dictatorships that you would call "evil") like they do in the name of capitalism?

Of course we would. Conflict arises from imbalances in power - specific events are mere triggers. Even if the USA was an entirely benign power (which it certainly is not), conflicts would assuredly arise.

I disagree big time. I view the situation like they are fucking over a girl after she screamed for help and is lying unconscious on the ground. Hey but they chased her assailant away who was their buddy about 5 minutes previously (relatively speaking of course).

I simply don't see it that way. Americans are making mistakes in Iraq, but they are also doing good. It is not a simple matter of the Americans being "less bad" than Hussein. More to the point, we weren't trying to compare the American occupation with the Hussein dictatorship, we were comparing the terrorist attacks on 9/11 to the US invasion of Iraq. The "chasing away" scenario is spurious.

You are pretty naive if you believe that. Sooner or later they will be forced out of there which will create a power vacuum explosion.

Perhaps.

Yes but motives are primary when talking morality. Ever heard of the expression the end doesn't justify the means?

Means are not the same as motives or morals. If someone saves me, I don't care if they did it because they think they expect a big reward. I'm just happy to have been saved.
 
solitaria said:
ANd how do you propose to eradicate all terrorists by force w/o massive collateral damage? Do you think it is like spraying for cockroaches, like the example you gave? Yeah just tell all the good Muslims to leave while the USA bombs the building because of a few cockroaches. Surely you can't be this naive or impractical about the situation in the Middle East.

Some connections need to be re-soldered.

My first post was written to rebut the proposition that terrorism shouldn't be responded to with military force because: a) it propogates a cycle of violence, and b) it isn't possible to completely eliminate it. That post was erroneously interpreted as advocating the eradication of Muslims or Arabs, rather than terrorists. My latter post corrected this misrepresentation. Now, you respond as if my post had been about how you would go about eradicating terrorists, which it wasn't.

It's hard to have a good debate if it's necessary to spend so much time re-iterating what you've already said or responding to arguments which completely mis-characterize the points you've raised.

We'd all be showing each other a little more courtesy if we'd take the time to read the posts and threads that we're responding to a little more carefully.