Ok. I give you it is still a he/she said I believe him to be telling the truth. She has been busted lying repeatedly. She is not credible in my opinion.
But the recordings are her own words. You can’t hide that fact.
and I wouldn’t say she is despised because of a toxic relationship. She is despised because she lied about her abuse. At the very least, if you believe everything she said, she lied about her abuse towards him. Women of DV, true abuse, have such a hard time with it, with getting away, with healing, with getting support, and she lied about what many of us have gone or go through. This is what makes us sick, this is what makes us angry. I would equally despise a woman lying about rape.