Listerine... branding scam!

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
I'm sure the stuff is quality mouthwash, but...

Have you noticed all the different brands of Listerine there are on the market? Teeth whitening. Tartar control. Advanced Plus. All these variations...

Well anyway I buy them at random. I just want to clean out my mouth. I bought my replacement bottle today, and it was "Tartar Control", whereas before I had "Advanced Plus" (teeth whitening).

Out of curiosity I read the ingredients to see what was different. Guess what the difference is? NOTHING. They have EXACTLY the same ingredients.

Oh they tried to make it look different. On the teeth whitening one they list "Whitenol (Zinc Chloride) 0.09%" and they prominently display on the packaging that it contains "Whitenol" as well. On the regular "tartar control" one? It just lists "Zinc Chloride 0.09%" without bothering to call it Whitenol.

Hilarious!
 
You just came to that startleling revelation? Just wait when 15 yrs from now, you realize toothpaste,deoderant, shampoo, laundry detergent, dishwasher soap, face cream and basically every other product on the market is up to the same 'scam'.
 
Listerine

It's marketing brilliance! Speaking of Listerine variety, I just purchased "Listerine Zero" yesterday and I read this thread... lol. Maybe ingredient is exactly the same but it definitely feels less alcohol-ish or burn on my gum-line. My dentist swears by Listerine mouthwash for years and claims nothing else kills germs except this brand.

I guess it's mental satisfaction that we all pay extra coins for ;:rolleyes:

ps. I only buy 'em if it's on sale and same price as generic brand... lol
 
Playing devil's advocate, the makers don't always include the exact formulation on the label. Some of the ingredients could be combined and re-classified.
 
You just came to that startleling revelation? Just wait when 15 yrs from now, you realize toothpaste,deoderant, shampoo, laundry detergent, dishwasher soap, face cream and basically every other product on the market is up to the same 'scam'.

Oh I know they are all fundamentally the same thing. But I had expected to see some slight difference in the ingredients. I always figured the "whitening", etc., was just a gimmick, but I thought they would at least have some snake oil in there to base their claim on. I was shocked that it was actually identical to the non-whitening one. Not that I care about any of those things--I just want to rinse my mouth out and they all do that perfectly well. (Identically well, apparently.)