Lies about drunk driving?

You must be joking. It would be even easier to dismantle any mechanism to check for intoxicaton.

Not really, try an dismantle your vehicle security system... good luck with that. You can easily check it at any routine stop and make vehicle confiscation the penalty. Any time a cop stops, he can do a quick test with an alcohol swab...
 
Not really, try an dismantle your vehicle security system... good luck with that. You can easily check it at any routine stop and make vehicle confiscation the penalty. Any time a cop stops, he can do a quick test with an alcohol swab...
I wonder whether you can blow into it with a bicycle pump
 
So what will they be based on?
 
That stat is a perfect illustration of the perils of data mining. There are so many factors. I bet a vast majority of the drivers was wearing pants. some had facial hair. but we understand there is no link between those things and accidents. what about age? experience? location of accident? there are so many factors. the anti-drunk-driving lobby is motherhood and apple pie. doesn't mean that they're right all the time. or even some.

unfortunately, attacking the wrong causes doesn't help resolve the problem. presuming that was the goal in the beginning (which i doubt).
 
That stat is a perfect illustration of the perils of data mining. There are so many factors. I bet a vast majority of the drivers was wearing pants. some had facial hair. but we understand there is no link between those things and accidents. what about age? experience? location of accident? there are so many factors. the anti-drunk-driving lobby is motherhood and apple pie. doesn't mean that they're right all the time. or even some.

unfortunately, attacking the wrong causes doesn't help resolve the problem. presuming that was the goal in the beginning (which i doubt).

This.

I will again qualify my remarks As i said pages back, i have no sympathy for truly paired drivers. I have relatives dead / disabled because they or someone else drove when they were impaired. But the use of the frequency of alcohol related crashes is flawed. To assume that every crash in which a driver has alcohol in their blood, that alcohol was "a factor" is a stretch. From a post a few pages back

"It should be remembered that even a drink or two before driving can lead to a deadly outcome. Almost 12% of drinking drivers killed in crashes had a BAC lower than 50 mg%."

That is much different than proving that less than 0.05 causes deadly crashes. It is an association. Not causation. For example More deadly crashes occur at night. Nighttime is when more drivers have been out and had "some" alcohol. But other factors like diminished visibility, fatigue etcetera could be more important, and need to be controlled for to estimate the "attributable risk" of a few drinks. From the statistics, as provided usually, we have no clue until other confpunders are taken into account.
 
Canadians spend $667 a year each on booze and you think there are much less then 30% of people on the road with some alcohol in them at any given time?

Far less. For example, I think there is almost no-one driving drunk in the morning. Many people do their drinking at home, take the subway, or have a friend drive. Most people don't drink much or at all during the week and save it up for Friday night--they're not drinking $1.82/day but rather more like $12 once a week.
 
Another MADD lie I guess:

http://www.thestar.com/news/crime/a...an-in-mississauga-crash-appears-in-court?bn=1

Darren Millett, 20, teary-eyed with his head bowed, limped into a Brampton court Monday morning. He faces nine alcohol-related charges, including impaired driving and criminal negligence causing death, after a collision in Mississauga left a 40-year-old man dead, his two-year-old son in hospital and his wife devastated.

Millett, who appeared to have family and friends in court, was remanded back to hospital until Dec. 21 for his bail hearing, which may be changed as lawyers meet in court Tuesday to discuss an earlier date.

Police say Millett was intoxicated as he sped westbound from a Queen Elizabeth Way off-ramp around 3:30 a.m. Sunday with three passengers in a black, four-door Dodge Caliber.

Mounir Mahious, with his wife and two-year-old son, drove southbound on Cawthra Rd. when, according to police, the hatchback barrelled into the driver’s side of Mahious’s Kia Rio.

The force of the collision ejected Mahious and his son, Djibril, from the car, despite both being buckled in. The crash left the driver’s side of Mahious’s Kia shorn off and the Caliber came to rest hundreds of feet away, flipped on its roof.

“The collision was so violent that it may have shredded their seatbelts,” said Const. Marlon Colthrust of Peel police. “But the collision reconstruction team is continuing their investigation.”
 
Opinions on this:

http://www.duigulag.com/facts.htm


seems to me that DUI is just another law enforcement side business to keep the lawyers, judges and police in business. Too bad about the pub owners and community though...
What if it is? Why would you imagine anyone would have any more success against their pig-ignorant stupidity than we've had against the drunks who imagine they're sober enough to assess their own driving skills?

There's only one way to prove your point: end drunk driving and stiil kill the same numbers of folks on the road. Clearly the point has escaped many, it's about being the best driver you can be, not about how bad you can be and get away with it.

No one ever needs to drive after drinking.
 
This.

I will again qualify my remarks As i said pages back, i have no sympathy for truly paired drivers. I have relatives dead / disabled because they or someone else drove when they were impaired. But the use of the frequency of alcohol related crashes is flawed. To assume that every crash in which a driver has alcohol in their blood, that alcohol was "a factor" is a stretch. From a post a few pages back

"It should be remembered that even a drink or two before driving can lead to a deadly outcome. Almost 12% of drinking drivers killed in crashes had a BAC lower than 50 mg%."

That is much different than proving that less than 0.05 causes deadly crashes. It is an association. Not causation. For example More deadly crashes occur at night. Nighttime is when more drivers have been out and had "some" alcohol. But other factors like diminished visibility, fatigue etcetera could be more important, and need to be controlled for to estimate the "attributable risk" of a few drinks. From the statistics, as provided usually, we have no clue until other confpunders are taken into account.

Actually in this case causation is pretty much made out. Correlation or association does not equal causation where the mechanism of causation is not clear or proven.

In this case...it is. For years we have mountains of scientific evidence that proves consuming alcohol, even at every low levels, impairs ones ability to drive.
 
What if it is? Why would you imagine anyone would have any more success against their pig-ignorant stupidity than we've had against the drunks who imagine they're sober enough to assess their own driving skills?

There's only one way to prove your point: end drunk driving and stiil kill the same numbers of folks on the road. Clearly the point has escaped many, it's about being the best driver you can be, not about how bad you can be and get away with it.

No one ever needs to drive after drinking.


if you really feel that way, then don't drive whenever you are feeling less then 100% ban driving when people are over 60, don't drive on rainy days, don't drive after sunset, don't drive when it snows, etc etc etc..
 
It's interesting the number of idiots that feel compelled to argue against the simple concept of not driving while impaired. When people are that stupid, it always amazes me they are able to type; and yet they can.
 
It's interesting the number of idiots that feel compelled to argue against the simple concept of not driving while impaired. When people are that stupid, it always amazes me they are able to type; and yet they can.

Of course they can type, how do you think they text while they drive.
 
looks like that wise question killed his tirade.

Plus there is that whole rule against self incrimination problem...

Seemed like a resonable question to ask since he started this whole thing. No answer yet.
 
It's interesting the number of idiots that feel compelled to argue against the simple concept of not driving while impaired. When people are that stupid, it always amazes me they are able to type; and yet they can.

How do you define impaired?
 
Seemed like a resonable question to ask since he started this whole thing. No answer yet.

Amazing you guys have questions but are clearly too lazy to read the link I posted.. maybe they use too many big words.
 
touch analysis with lasers.

Well, I looked it up myself since you didn't provide a link. Quite frankly it sounds like a scam. Just what people need. Another barrier to being able to start their car that could easily fuck up. I can pretty much quarantee there will be an underground business based on circumventing such an idea. What a waste. Have we become that paranoid about each other?