Lies about drunk driving?

That is crazy, any amount of alcohol impairs your driving. That said, I out ran the police long ago after having a few drinks. 2 lane road with lots of traffic and very high speeds however it took me longer to shake it off vs another time when I kick butt right away...oh that shit is all over with now, Fleeing is a felony now and people drive like shit today, nobody watches out for high speed cars.

Driving today is stopping at every light cause they are red so often. I ran a bunch of red lights the first time I fled but back then--mid 80's people looked both ways if they heard a loud ass car, today drivers have their heads in a cloud taking away on their cell phones.

Cell phones were the worst thing to happen on the roads. People used to rush to make call, now they just sit and talk away behind the wheel..only good thing today is the police have their heads in a cloud also. Was a few times this summer where I ran stop signs and pulled out in to traffic and then notice a cop car a ways back--never got even a warning...drivers need to wake up and look what is going on.

Since you knew you would blow over and were essentially facing a criminal charge... I suppose fleeing arrest is not gonna make it much worse.But that is one of the side effects of "tough on crime" legislation. you raise the stakes...and when you do that, violence and side effects can also go up.
 
Every car should have alcohol detectors--every car right from the factory--not after you been caught drunk a few times.
\

I would not be opposed to this. It is relatively cheap with technology these days, and we can completely dismantle the DUI enforcement mechanism.
 
DUI is a serious offense and must be dealt with in a very serious manner. I agree that criminal charges must be laid against someone especially if it ended up in an accident or injury or even death.

If someone is pulled over and caught, license suspension of a year minimum and a huge fine should be a good enough punishment. (That itself should be enough to scare anyone from driving under the influence.)

Since we live in a civilized country, I think laying criminal charges against someone caught DUI is a little too harsh.


I would agree with you for a BAC of around 0.10....but if the guy is so drunk he cannot stand I say criminal charges are appropriate or at least very serious fines, suspension, community service etc etc..
 
Ok this little gem says 5% of the dead drinkers fall between a BAC of 0.05 and 0.08.... yet 12% of the fatalities have a BAC of LESS then 0.05... please explain what conclusion you can draw from this? At the VERY most you can say people in the 0.05 to 0.08 BAC are responsible for 1.5% of traffic fatalities? And that is a HUGE stretch.. it is statistically insignificant. . Should we be directing our legal system at an activity that increases risks by at MOST 1.5%?

You do realize you just called Human lives insignificant ?
 
You do realize you just called Human lives insignificant ?

No I called the variance in risk insignificant. Have you EVER heard at anytime, anyone say you should not do something because you may increase your risk of death by up to 1.5%? Well that is because it is STATISTICALLY INSIGNIFICANT.
 
I think when he says the probable cause defense he means that low readings can indirectly help to establish a charter argument that there was no reasonable and probable grounds for demand (search) and or detention because the accused was not sufficiently impaired and did not exhibit enough criteria of impairment etc.
Re gold standard: man you are old...the toxicologists don't do that for ages. There was a couple of cases where the courts frowned upon this practice, and then there was a bill c-2 ( constitutionality of which went all the way up to SCC and hopefully we will have a decision soon). Toxicologists still do many things but drinking in controlled conditions is not one of them.

This also makes no sense
An officer can demand a sample whether you appear impaired or not
Failure to provide an accurate sample (his theory of how to "beat" a breathalyser) will automatically impose the harshest sentence

(In other words, under ON law, it is better to blow, and be impaired, as you face a much lesser sentence. If you refuse to blow or screw around you AUTOMATICALLY are assigned the worst possible rating. That's the law and good luck fighting it as many people have tried)

http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/safety/impaired/penalties.shtml
 
This also makes no sense
An officer can demand a sample whether you appear impaired or not
Failure to provide an accurate sample (his theory of how to "beat" a breathalyser) will automatically impose the harshest sentence

(In other words, under ON law, it is better to blow, and be impaired, as you face a much lesser sentence. If you refuse to blow or screw around you AUTOMATICALLY are assigned the worst possible rating. That's the law and good luck fighting it as many people have tried)

http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/safety/impaired/penalties.shtml
You posted this, I posted much the same, he still refuses to listen.
 
I suppose fleeing arrest is not gonna make it much worse.But that is one of the side effects of "tough on crime" legislation. you raise the stakes...and when you do that, violence and side effects can also go up.
What jurisdiction do you live in Nottyboi - it certainly isn't Canada, and it isn't the U.S. east of oh say the Mississippi River and north of the Ohio River (and a line drawn east).
 
"probable cause" is not a defense.

If the officer is not satisfied with how you blow he can charge you with failure to blow. It is up to his discretion.

I don't know if anyone here has ever done a proper Impaired/0ver 80 defense in Ontario, but the gold standard is to hire a toxicologist who then has you drink in controlled conditions and will then do blood and breath testing on an ongoing basis to establish your baseline from which you can then develop the various defenses open to these charges.

But what we do know from that testing by thousands of toxicologists in controlled conditions that driving skills begin to be affected in most individuals around .04 or .05. After that the rest is subjective. The question is how much risk does society want to take from drunk drivers, and at what level or impairment do we want to set the baseline to drive. The government has set the limits at .05 and .08 for which there is a ton of evidence that your ability to drive is impaired.

Nonsense, if they are going to charge you with failure to blow they will probably take you to the station so you can blow on video tape and they have sufficient evidence to support such a charge. They will give you several tries, and if you are being a complete ass hat, they will probably take you to the station and ask you to blow on video so they can show the judge you are not really co-operating. If you are that stupid about your breathing techniques.. then you deserve to go down. I don't think taking a few deep breaths before supplying a breath sample would in ANY WAY amount to a refusal to provide a breath sample.
 
Every car should have alcohol detectors--every car right from the factory--not after you been caught drunk a few times.

there is talk of doing this :

http://www.wired.com/geekdad/2011/1...riving-with-in-car-alcohol-detection-systems/


It seems they are working on doing it when you touch a start button. I would support this 100%, I would also support speed limiters for cars that limit speed below 150 kph... after all, since the province has decided going over 150 kph is tantamount to attempted murder, why not just limit the speed of cars sold here? WTF?
 
there is talk of doing this :

http://www.wired.com/geekdad/2011/1...riving-with-in-car-alcohol-detection-systems/


It seems they are working on doing it when you touch a start button. I would support this 100%, I would also support speed limiters for cars that limit speed below 150 kph... after all, since the province has decided going over 150 kph is tantamount to attempted murder, why not just limit the speed of cars sold here? WTF?

I know this is a bit unfair to people don't drink ect...but I feel this is the best way to tackle the problem. Society in general is proving that this issue is way to hard to just hope that ride scares people out of doing it. Our courts are back logged with impaired driving charges, only for some of them to get thrown out do to unreasnable delay wasting unbeliebable amounts of tax dollars. I think the money could be used much more wisely to bennifit society and nip the problem in the bud.
 
This also makes no sense
An officer can demand a sample whether you appear impaired or not
Failure to provide an accurate sample (his theory of how to "beat" a breathalyser) will automatically impose the harshest sentence

(In other words, under ON law, it is better to blow, and be impaired, as you face a much lesser sentence. If you refuse to blow or screw around you AUTOMATICALLY are assigned the worst possible rating. That's the law and good luck fighting it as many people have tried)

http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/safety/impaired/penalties.shtml

No one is saying anything about refusing to provide a sample. If one uses breathing techniques to lower your BAC reading by about 0.015.. and the cop does not like it he would have a hard time saying you did not provide a breath sample when the machine registers a valid reading. If he is determined to pursue this, his best shot is to take you into the station and do a test on video and then try to convince a judge.. in either case, you can get a bit of margin using breathing techniques, but if you are hammered you will still blow over.
 
I know this is a bit unfair to people don't drink ect...but I feel this is the best way to tackle the problem. Society in general is proving that this issue is way to hard to just hope that ride scares people out of doing it. Our courts are back logged with impaired driving charges, only for some of them to get thrown out do to unreasnable delay wasting unbeliebable amounts of tax dollars. I think the money could be used much more wisely to bennifit society and nip the problem in the bud.

Not only the cost of criminalizing and ruining tax payers and destroying families. Yes I would be 100% ok with a car that checks my BAC when I press the start button. Plus we can get rid of a few thousand lawyers.
 
Nonsense, if they are going to charge you with failure to blow they will probably take you to the station so you can blow on video tape and they have sufficient evidence to support such a charge. They will give you several tries, and if you are being a complete ass hat, they will probably take you to the station and ask you to blow on video so they can show the judge you are not really co-operating.
dude you don't know what you are talking about
if you refuse an ASD at the roadside you will be charged with refuse right there on the spot (and they can run and win the trial based on the officer's notes and viva voce evidence)
there is no need to bring you to the station after that unless say you are impaired and need to sober up before let out
 
This also makes no sense
An officer can demand a sample whether you appear impaired or not
Failure to provide an accurate sample (his theory of how to "beat" a breathalyser) will automatically impose the harshest sentence

(In other words, under ON law, it is better to blow, and be impaired, as you face a much lesser sentence. If you refuse to blow or screw around you AUTOMATICALLY are assigned the worst possible rating. That's the law and good luck fighting it as many people have tried)

http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/safety/impaired/penalties.shtml
absolute bullshit, blowing 200mg is likely not gonna be any better than refuse; refuse may just mean you are stupid, blowing a lot means you are a murderer who just luckily hasn't murder anyone yet

the actual twist is that you cannot be convicted of BOTH over 80 and impaired but you can be convicted of both impaired AND refuse; this difference is real but is not major though
 
Last edited:
How do you define intoxicated?

Either having your reactions or decision making decreased or having to research ways to beat the breathalyzer.

I'm sure we all know cheap drunks who are buzzed off of one drink. For me to get to 0.05, I would need to down three drinks in an hour. A bit more than a casual drink after work.



p.s. I think notty is just ticked that he wasn't nominated for terbie of the year and is trying to prove his credentials.
 
\

I would not be opposed to this. It is relatively cheap with technology these days, and we can completely dismantle the DUI enforcement mechanism.

You must be joking. It would be even easier to dismantle any mechanism to check for intoxicaton.
 
Ok so lets dissect that a bit, 30% of fatal accidents had a driver with some alcohol in their blood

Wow, I had never realized it was such a high percentage!! Seriously, it's that high?

BUT note, just because 12% had SOME alcohol, there is really no determinant to say alcohol was a causal factor in the accident other then it was present

In any individual case, no, but that statistic is staggering. Since far less than 30% of drivers on the road have some alcohol in their system that just goes to show that it does make a huge difference. If alcohol made no difference then there should be roughly the same percentage of people with alcohol in their blood just driving generally (without accidents) as there are people with alcohol in their blood who have fatal accidents.

In other words, if it makes no difference from your stat we would expect to find that 30% of the drivers on the road have some alcohol in their system at any given time, and that'st just not even remotely believable. I don't have a stat for that (we can probably find one) but just back of the envelope, most driving will be by people going to and from work, so presumably sober most of that time. I'm sure that most people drink at some point during the week, but not every day--and most people likely do drive everyday. So it's hard to believe that 30% of the people on the road who did NOT have accidents would have alcohol in their system.

You've just hit a home run for MADD if that statistic is true.
 
...for the purpose of federal government statistics an "alcohol related accident" is one in which one or more parties to an accident, including all drivers, pedestrians and bicyclists, had some alcohol in their systems, regardless of causation and regardless of who was at fault for the accident. In other words, under the existing government reporting system, a totally sober driver could cause a fatal motor vehicle accident to occur and if someone else involved in that accident had any measurable amount of alcohol in their system, that accident would be recorded for statistical purposes as an "alcohol related accident"

This brings to mind how they often say "speed was a factor". Speed is always a factor, whether it's 15km/h or 150km/h. Let's say they only say speed is a factor when it's over the limit.... Was it excessively over the limit or 5km/h over the limit? Was speed really the deciding factor, or did someone make a bonehead move that others couldn't avoid even if they were doing the speed limit? My point is that they always need a scapegoat, and if it can't be alcohol, it'll be speed.

...according to NHTSA statistics nearly two thirds of all drivers and passengers killed in motor vehicle accidents (regardless whether alcohol involvement was a factor in the accident) were not wearing seat belts. The NHTSA estimates that 70% of the driving population wear seat belts regularly. The NHTSA also estimates that 4,000 fatalities and 100,000 injuries could be prevented annually if only 15% more of the driving population would wear seat belts on a regular basis. If MADD and our federal government were really interested in saving lives on the nation’s highways one would assume that they would be directing their energies and their draconian laws against drivers and their passengers who don’t wear seat belts. They will not do that though, because seat belts don’t contain alcohol.

I had no idea that many people drove without seatbelts...! (If that is indeed true)
 
Wow, I had never realized it was such a high percentage!! Seriously, it's that high?



In any individual case, no, but that statistic is staggering. Since far less than 30% of drivers on the road have some alcohol in their system that just goes to show that it does make a huge difference. If alcohol made no difference then there should be roughly the same percentage of people with alcohol in their blood just driving generally (without accidents) as there are people with alcohol in their blood who have fatal accidents.

In other words, if it makes no difference from your stat we would expect to find that 30% of the drivers on the road have some alcohol in their system at any given time, and that'st just not even remotely believable. I don't have a stat for that (we can probably find one) but just back of the envelope, most driving will be by people going to and from work, so presumably sober most of that time. I'm sure that most people drink at some point during the week, but not every day--and most people likely do drive everyday. So it's hard to believe that 30% of the people on the road who did NOT have accidents would have alcohol in their system.

You've just hit a home run for MADD if that statistic is true.


Canadians spend $667 a year each on booze and you think there are much less then 30% of people on the road with some alcohol in them at any given time?