Nicklas Lidström:
- Norris Trophy winner seven times
- Conn Smythe playoff MVP once
- All-Star 12 times
- Best in playoff career plus-minus, all-time
Raymond Bourque:
- Norris Trophy winner five times
- All-star 19 times!
- Most career points by a defenceman
- Most career goals by a defenceman
- Third in career regular season plus-minus, only Robinson and Orr are ahead of him
I opt for Bourque. More of an offensive threat, better all-around. While both Lidström and Bourque controlled games, you noticed Bourque more. He did it all.
I would go as far as to argue that Bourque and Lidström are the two best defenceman since Bobby Orr, ahead of Robinson, Potvin, Park, Coffey, Chelios, Salming, Karlsson, Pronger, Stevens, Niedermayer, or anyone else you care to name in the last fifty years. Only Doug Harvey (along with Orr) might rank ahead of Bourque and Lidström. Never saw Harvey play, but by all accounts he is second all-time to Orr.
- Norris Trophy winner seven times
- Conn Smythe playoff MVP once
- All-Star 12 times
- Best in playoff career plus-minus, all-time
Raymond Bourque:
- Norris Trophy winner five times
- All-star 19 times!
- Most career points by a defenceman
- Most career goals by a defenceman
- Third in career regular season plus-minus, only Robinson and Orr are ahead of him
I opt for Bourque. More of an offensive threat, better all-around. While both Lidström and Bourque controlled games, you noticed Bourque more. He did it all.
I would go as far as to argue that Bourque and Lidström are the two best defenceman since Bobby Orr, ahead of Robinson, Potvin, Park, Coffey, Chelios, Salming, Karlsson, Pronger, Stevens, Niedermayer, or anyone else you care to name in the last fifty years. Only Doug Harvey (along with Orr) might rank ahead of Bourque and Lidström. Never saw Harvey play, but by all accounts he is second all-time to Orr.

