tboy said:
Well, there's a few caveats in that article:
1) Sure toyota ships the nickel all over the world before it gets made into batteries. Sure this is stupid to say the least but that is what I've been preaching all along about how to increase efficiency: stop shipping goods from here, to zimbabwe and shipping the exact same goods from zimbabwe to here (ok I used orillia in a previous post, not zimbabwe but you get my drift.
Toyota are pretty smart, they do that because it is currently the most efficient way. The nickel comes from here, because that is where it is. They could build a battery plant here, but that is highly inefficient at present volumes, it is more efficient to ship it to Japan and back for processing.
tboy said:
2) It mentions that hybrids aren't driven as much per year as conventional vehicles and they won't be used for as many miles in their expected lifetime. Sorry, but that is a GOOD thing, not a bad.
Yes and no, when you are looking at total energy cost per mile, the less you drive, the less value you are getting for the initial cost of making it. If you are only going to drive a little, it is not worth the high initial cost of the hybrid, you really would be better to get a conventional economy car, the extra gas per mile is made up for by the simple manufacturing.
tboy said:
3) That article uses an energy/cost per mile. What about environmental impact during the vehicle's lifetime? There is NO way a hummer produces less air pollution than a hybrid, especially when the hybrid automatically uses more fuel (gas) than a hybrid
But the hybrid does use more, because of the extreme energy cost of making it in the first place. Even if you never drive it, a lot of energy was consumed just to make it, way more than to make a Hummer.
tboy said:
4) Sure, the cost for a hybrid right now is higher because it is relatively new technology and the cost of R n D hasn't been spread over 30 yrs.
Yes, that is true, it would be interesting to see what the lifecycle costs would be if hybrids were made in large volume, it would be different.
tboy said:
5) Again with the shipping of the nickel: Anyone remember when ALL hondas were built in Japan? Well, now some are built in Cambridge which significantly DECREASES shipping costs/mile. So maybe toyota ought to refine the nickel here, produce the batteries here, and install them here then the shipping costs would be minimal?
Yes, same as 4), in volume, it would be different.
tboy said:
6) SInce there are only a few North American built hybrids, but many north american built pickups the data will be immensely skewed. So why didn't they include shipping F150s to Japan? (because they don't ship em there). Did they include the variable of shipping smaller vehicles to their home country? ie: did they only include shipping imports here or did they include shipping of hondas produced in japan TO japan?
The article was based on the choices a North American consumer can make, so shipping F150s to Japan does not matter. Presumably the Prius in Japan versus the F150 in Japan would be different because the shipping is reversed.
tboy said:
This is typical of statistical analysis: you can get whatever it is you want from statistics depending on what criteria you enter into your formula.
I found the article interesting, I can believe that it really would consume less total energy to drive a Hummer than a Prius. But as tboy says, it might still be better to get the Prius, because once they are sold in volume things will be different. Personally, I do not buy that, I think the greenest choice today would be a highly fuel efficient conventional gas or diesel car, not a hybrid.