Let's all drive a hummer!!

dcbogey

New member
Sep 29, 2004
3,169
0
0
Perhaps SUVs aren't quite the energy guzzlers we are lead to believe. The same arguement holds for ethanol, discussed on another thread. It's important to think of the total energy cost of anything we use. and what about the replacement cost (buying new ones as well as disposing of the old ones) of the battery units in the new hybrids? Just like nuclear enegry is cheap, but no one wants to talk about what to do about the waste.
 
OK, anyone who thinks a hummer is anywhere in any vacinity of efficient ought to give their head a shake.

I remember reading somewhere that the full sized ones get around 8 mpg.

A couple of other bits of info:
It takes more "energy" to build a vehicle than that vehicle will use in it's entire lifetime. ie: building/buying new vehicles is a waste of energy.

From this you can extrapolate: It costs more energy to produce a larger vehicle because there is more material in it. ie: more steel in an 8 cyl than a 4.

Lean acid batteries are 100% recyclable. There isn't anything in them that can't be used again for something else. In addition, batteries produced today last longer than those of years gone by. I have NEVER had to replace a battery in any of my vehicles.

yes, electric/hybrid vehicles simply transfer the cause of pollution to another source but they still a) use less energy to move you b) cause less air pollution c) cost less to drive.
 
Well, there's a few caveats in that article:
1) Sure toyota ships the nickel all over the world before it gets made into batteries. Sure this is stupid to say the least but that is what I've been preaching all along about how to increase efficiency: stop shipping goods from here, to zimbabwe and shipping the exact same goods from zimbabwe to here (ok I used orillia in a previous post, not zimbabwe but you get my drift.

2) It mentions that hybrids aren't driven as much per year as conventional vehicles and they won't be used for as many miles in their expected lifetime. Sorry, but that is a GOOD thing, not a bad.

3) That article uses an energy/cost per mile. What about environmental impact during the vehicle's lifetime? There is NO way a hummer produces less air pollution than a hybrid, especially when the hybrid automatically uses more fuel (gas) than a hybrid

4) Sure, the cost for a hybrid right now is higher because it is relatively new technology and the cost of R n D hasn't been spread over 30 yrs.

5) Again with the shipping of the nickel: Anyone remember when ALL hondas were built in Japan? Well, now some are built in Cambridge which significantly DECREASES shipping costs/mile. So maybe toyota ought to refine the nickel here, produce the batteries here, and install them here then the shipping costs would be minimal?

6) SInce there are only a few North American built hybrids, but many north american built pickups the data will be immensely skewed. So why didn't they include shipping F150s to Japan? (because they don't ship em there). Did they include the variable of shipping smaller vehicles to their home country? ie: did they only include shipping imports here or did they include shipping of hondas produced in japan TO japan?

This is typical of statistical analysis: you can get whatever it is you want from statistics depending on what criteria you enter into your formula.
 
GM is estimating their full size dual mode hybrid SUV's due out next year (Tahoe, etc) will average close to 20mpg city.
 
tboy said:
Well, there's a few caveats in that article:
1) Sure toyota ships the nickel all over the world before it gets made into batteries. Sure this is stupid to say the least but that is what I've been preaching all along about how to increase efficiency: stop shipping goods from here, to zimbabwe and shipping the exact same goods from zimbabwe to here (ok I used orillia in a previous post, not zimbabwe but you get my drift.
Toyota are pretty smart, they do that because it is currently the most efficient way. The nickel comes from here, because that is where it is. They could build a battery plant here, but that is highly inefficient at present volumes, it is more efficient to ship it to Japan and back for processing.
tboy said:
2) It mentions that hybrids aren't driven as much per year as conventional vehicles and they won't be used for as many miles in their expected lifetime. Sorry, but that is a GOOD thing, not a bad.
Yes and no, when you are looking at total energy cost per mile, the less you drive, the less value you are getting for the initial cost of making it. If you are only going to drive a little, it is not worth the high initial cost of the hybrid, you really would be better to get a conventional economy car, the extra gas per mile is made up for by the simple manufacturing.
tboy said:
3) That article uses an energy/cost per mile. What about environmental impact during the vehicle's lifetime? There is NO way a hummer produces less air pollution than a hybrid, especially when the hybrid automatically uses more fuel (gas) than a hybrid
But the hybrid does use more, because of the extreme energy cost of making it in the first place. Even if you never drive it, a lot of energy was consumed just to make it, way more than to make a Hummer.

tboy said:
4) Sure, the cost for a hybrid right now is higher because it is relatively new technology and the cost of R n D hasn't been spread over 30 yrs.
Yes, that is true, it would be interesting to see what the lifecycle costs would be if hybrids were made in large volume, it would be different.

tboy said:
5) Again with the shipping of the nickel: Anyone remember when ALL hondas were built in Japan? Well, now some are built in Cambridge which significantly DECREASES shipping costs/mile. So maybe toyota ought to refine the nickel here, produce the batteries here, and install them here then the shipping costs would be minimal?
Yes, same as 4), in volume, it would be different.

tboy said:
6) SInce there are only a few North American built hybrids, but many north american built pickups the data will be immensely skewed. So why didn't they include shipping F150s to Japan? (because they don't ship em there). Did they include the variable of shipping smaller vehicles to their home country? ie: did they only include shipping imports here or did they include shipping of hondas produced in japan TO japan?
The article was based on the choices a North American consumer can make, so shipping F150s to Japan does not matter. Presumably the Prius in Japan versus the F150 in Japan would be different because the shipping is reversed.

tboy said:
This is typical of statistical analysis: you can get whatever it is you want from statistics depending on what criteria you enter into your formula.

I found the article interesting, I can believe that it really would consume less total energy to drive a Hummer than a Prius. But as tboy says, it might still be better to get the Prius, because once they are sold in volume things will be different. Personally, I do not buy that, I think the greenest choice today would be a highly fuel efficient conventional gas or diesel car, not a hybrid.
 
C Dick, while you make some interesting arguments, I cannot see

1) how it is MORE efficient to ship a mineral like nickel from Canada, to great britain then to japan, then ship it in completed form to North America. It is far more efficient to produce the batteries here, leave them here, and install them in the vehicles once they arrive here.

2) The comparison is for North American purchasers. While that may be true, something we ALL have to realize is that we can no longer think of it as us vs them. We ALL live on this planet and we ALL pollute it. To make an accurate comparison they should have included ALL variables, not just the cost per mile for North Americans.

3) Mass production WILL bring the cost of the hybrids/electrics down. It is a proven fact in many other areas of production and henry ford perfected it (in fact, his production line idea has changed little in 100 yrs).

4) Because most of the hybrids are made by Japanese companies, the cost per mile is based upon having to ship everything here. IF the big three would get off their asses and start mass producing hybrids and electrics the cost would come WAY down. But as the movie "who killed the electric car" stated: GM had a market, had the production, had the PRE-sales, and due to political BS, they halted production.

Something that was discussed in that movie that I don't see addressed in the article is the parts/chemicals/waste of a typical internal combustion engine. An electric vehicle and to a lesser degree a hybrid, produces ZERO waste oil, ZERO coolant, a tiny amount of grease, ZERO transmission fluid, etc etc etc. Not to mention air filters, oil filters, fuel filters, etc etc etc etc etc.
 
Tboy - not to answer for C Dick but I'm sure Toyota has done a cost/benefit study and for them it currently makes to do it this way. It may not make common sense but the dollar always rules.
As far as full electric cars go a couple of things come to mind. I understand that their cold weather performance is dismal - not much of a concern in SoCal but a bit of a problem in the great white north. And where are we going to get all the new electicity to charge the cars? How "dirty" will that power be?
 
I see his point. More pollution is created by making a vehicle then the emissions over its life time. buy a vehical that lasts
 
Re: electricity and electrical powered vehicles. Yes, SOME of our electrical generation is via coal/fuel fired plants but that is in the minority.

During the movie "who killed the electric car" they discussed nuclear energy and why there hasn't been a new Nuke plant built in North America in the last...oh 30 yrs? Three Mile Island and Chernobyl. A couple of points that no one realizes: No one was killed from Three Mile Island and Chernobyl was an outdated design and was slated for demolition. The difference between Candu reactors and Chernobyl (simply put) is that Candu reactors have to be FORCED to cause the nuclear reaction. It's natural state is non-reactive so if anything happens, it naturally shuts down. Chernobyl and others is the opposite. They start the reaction and then try to control it.

As for electric vehicles being bad in cold weather. That is true, most batteries don't fair well in the cold but Toronto, and southern ontario, really isn't THAT cold. If it is a major concern, we just do what northern towns do: put electrical outlets all over town. (one way is to have electric vehicle parking only places) in fact, there are man office towers downtown who have heated underground parking so the cold affecting batteries while you're at work is reduced.

That is why hybrids are a good idea for Canada. It is a trade off between cleaner electric and dirty gas/diesel.

There is NO easy solution to the POV problem. The only solution that I see (and keep harping on it) is to reduce the rediculous commutes that people go through daily. I honestly think the only solution is to force people to live near their work, at least in the same city/borough/time zone.

As for toyota's battery situation. Sure, the dollar always rules BUT we can no longer look at dollars/cents situations when it comes to environmental impact.

I'd really like to see how this report took into account the environmental impact. How they associated a cost with disposal or waste oil, parts, chemicals, etc. I think it's about 90% of a vehicle is actually recyclable when it's put into the scrap heap.
 
tboy said:
C Dick, while you make some interesting arguments, I cannot see

1) how it is MORE efficient to ship a mineral like nickel from Canada, to great britain then to japan, then ship it in completed form to North America. It is far more efficient to produce the batteries here, leave them here, and install them in the vehicles once they arrive here.
Because it could cost $100,000,000 to build a factory like that, and right now the market is small for the output, so it is cheaper to ship nickel around than build another factory. And building a factory polutes too, and if you build two at once you learn a lot less than if you build one and learn from it before you build the other. So it could easily be more efficient to ship to Japan and back than to build more factories here.
tboy said:
2) The comparison is for North American purchasers. While that may be true, something we ALL have to realize is that we can no longer think of it as us vs them. We ALL live on this planet and we ALL pollute it. To make an accurate comparison they should have included ALL variables, not just the cost per mile for North Americans.
That is true, but we can only make decisions for ourselves, even if we have the world's best interests at heart. It might make sense, due to transport cost, for me to buy an efficient conventional car here, but for my cousin who lives in Japan, and has the same priorities, to buy a hybrid instead.
tboy said:
3) Mass production WILL bring the cost of the hybrids/electrics down. It is a proven fact in many other areas of production and henry ford perfected it (in fact, his production line idea has changed little in 100 yrs).
Yes, I totally agree with you, it may be best to buy hybrids now, even though they are so dirty to make, just because the more that get sold now, the more the manufacturers will learn, to make them cleaner, including producing them. Personally, I don't think that it is, because I think that hybrids are not clean enough to be worth it, but you can make the case.

tboy said:
4) Because most of the hybrids are made by Japanese companies, the cost per mile is based upon having to ship everything here. IF the big three would get off their asses and start mass producing hybrids and electrics the cost would come WAY down. But as the movie "who killed the electric car" stated: GM had a market, had the production, had the PRE-sales, and due to political BS, they halted production.
If electric cars made economic sense, they would be making them, there are enough consumers who would pay a premium for them. The technology just isn't there yet. I will post my plan for what should be done in another posting.
tboy said:
Something that was discussed in that movie that I don't see addressed in the article is the parts/chemicals/waste of a typical internal combustion engine. An electric vehicle and to a lesser degree a hybrid, produces ZERO waste oil, ZERO coolant, a tiny amount of grease, ZERO transmission fluid, etc etc etc. Not to mention air filters, oil filters, fuel filters, etc etc etc etc etc.
Hybrids are worse than conventional cars, because they have all the bad things that a conventional car has, plus the giant, toxic batteries.
 
My Master Plan for Future Lack of Pollution

I have been disagreeing with tboy and other's posts, so I decided to post my own plan instead of just disagreeing.

- To me, hybrids and ethanol are not efficient enough to be even worth working on. Even if all cars were hybrid or ethanol, it is still a bunch of combustion, fossil fuels being burned, or food. China and India want to have a bunch more cars, we need something better than somewhat better combustion.
- Batteries are the best way to store energy for cars that is likely to come along for a good long while. They are safe, zero pollution (unlike hybrid or ethanol), the problem is that they do not store enough energy. But if batteries were efficient enough to store 600km or so worth, they would be great. You would also have to deal with toxins involved in making and recycling them, but you could. So I think the most important thing now is to keep investing in battery technology.
- The other thing that has to be done is make all electricity come from hydro, wind, solar or nuclear. Burning coal or natural gas does not cut it. To me, the best solution is to build a few giant plants to power all of North America. I do not think that nuclear waste is such a big deal, you could transport it carefully to the moon and it would still be cost effective. Nobody else has thought of a better use for the moon.
- Once you had clean electricity and good batteries, the infrastructure could be adjusted to make it work better. For example, it should be possible to put electric wires in 400 series highways so that the cars could charge their batteries while you drove, so that recharging was not an issue.

With this plan, there would be no incremental pollution from driving more (e.g. the pollution would all be at the making and disposing of the car stages), so social engineering would not be required. I would hate to see a time when people were forced to live in giant hives, and prevented from owning cars, pollution is bad, but oppression is bad also.
 
tboy said:
C Dick, while you make some interesting arguments, I cannot see

1) how it is MORE efficient to ship a mineral like nickel from Canada, to great britain then to japan, then ship it in completed form to North America. It is far more efficient to produce the batteries here, leave them here, and install them in the vehicles once they arrive here.

Well tboy, if it was more efficient, they would do it so they could sell more cars at a lower price with the same mark-up and make more money. It is not just ‘nickel’ it is a very specific physical product that happens to be currently made in volume only in Canada. The Chinese, Indonesians, and Australians all produce huge amounts of nickel. The cost of building a battery plant too handle the requirements in Canada is just to high, compared to the shipping costs.

tboy said:
2) The comparison is for North American purchasers. While that may be true, something we ALL have to realize is that we can no longer think of it as us vs them. We ALL live on this planet and we ALL pollute it. To make an accurate comparison they should have included ALL variables, not just the cost per mile for North Americans.
Think globally act locally. The decisions for local actions must be based on local conditions and data. The cost of moving a mile is the cost of moving a mile at that point in space and time. The global energy bill is the sum of the local energy bills.

tboy said:
Something that was discussed in that movie that I don't see addressed in the article is the parts/chemicals/waste of a typical internal combustion engine. An electric vehicle and to a lesser degree a hybrid, produces ZERO waste oil, ZERO coolant, a tiny amount of grease, ZERO transmission fluid, etc etc etc. Not to mention air filters, oil filters, fuel filters, etc etc etc etc etc.

So if I get this straight, you are suggesting we pollute like crazy in order to help the development of a theoretical car that according to a movie does not pollute?

A lot of people share that philosophy I guess. Sort of like the idea of throwing away your incandescent bulbs and replacing them with screw in florescent ones. It is obviously true the florescent bulbs consume less power. Equally obvious throwing away a functioning incandescent bulb consumes all the energy used to create it, which exceeds the amount of power it consumes. (yes tboy it must be prorated over the remaining life). More frightening is the effect of mercury ( a really nasty chemical) being released into the environment in previously unheard of quantities.

Don’t you love band wagons and shallow thinking?
 
Actually loki, I believe the hydro ads for the fluorescent bulbs is meant to say when it is time to replace a burnt out bulb, replace it with a more energy efficient one.

The electric car: The ones that were leased to the ppl in Cali in the movie were destroyed long before they were no longer usable. The reason they did this was because Cali put on difficult emission requirments and GM played a political game. FOr the record I drove an electric vehicle back in the late 90's and was amazed at the performance. I have also been following some of the technologies and EV enthusiasts and seem some of the specs,

As for polluting like crazy to produce a realistic vehicle, dude, where do you get your logic from? Why do you say "we have to pollute like crazy" to develope better batteries/electric motors etc for an EV vehicle? BTW: the technology exists to produce better batteries but GM bought the company and stopped production.

As for responses to my query on battery production here. I appreciate C dick's responses as they are less antagonistic. I can understand that building a production facility is extremely wasteful (new construction and the whole industry is extremely wasteful in and of itself) but I can't believe there isn't a production facility here that can produce the batteries.

As for financially beneficial to ship the stuff all over the world. Don't always assume that a company will do the most logical financially viable method. History is full of examples of how companies don't always do the right thing financially for various reasons. For an example take a look around at all the businesses that operate in and around Toronto and other cities. As consumers we constantly purchase items that were made in BC (for eg) where right down the street is a local company that makes the exact same thing or provides the exact same service.

Now if you're so worried about the toxins released/prduced by the batteries in EVs then how do you feel about all the toxins released by less essential products like: ipods, cellphones, and all the other toys we just can't live without?

Here's a great example: the pulp and paper industry. For decades they dumped millions of tons of extremely toxic bleaches etc into our rivers and lakes until someone stepped in and said "no more". Technology was developed where in many cases, toxins released into our water supply was cut to almost nothing. Abitibi is a great example. The waste water coming out of their plant (at least it said so on the report I read) is something like 97% pure....

Loki: it sounds to me like you are one of those that think "leave everything the way it is done now, change is bad bad bad" Sorry, but if we want our planet to last, we have to start somewhere. While EV technology isn't perfect, it is better than doing nothing and sorry, but everyone driving a HUMMER is NOT the answer.
 
dcbogey said:
Perhaps SUVs aren't quite the energy guzzlers we are lead to believe. The same arguement holds for ethanol, discussed on another thread. It's important to think of the total energy cost of anything we use. and what about the replacement cost (buying new ones as well as disposing of the old ones) of the battery units in the new hybrids? Just like nuclear enegry is cheap, but no one wants to talk about what to do about the waste.

Did you get your info from that retarded, non-scientific, article in the Globe and Mail recently?

Let me ask you this... what would you rather clean up:
1. a pile of nickel in your driveway (Prius battery)
2. a pile of lead and acid in your driveway (the battery in every regular car)

As for battery replacement cost... if the battery pack lasts the life of the car, is battery replacement cost even relevant? Apparently the batteries in the 1st generation Prius' are still holding up in most cases. And those cars are now around 7-10 years old.

The other *really* retarded thing about that study is that it considers R&D to be "bad" for the environment... and it applied the R&D that went into the Prius only to that model.[I. Is the Prius the *only* hybrid that uses that R&D?

The real story is who funded that bogas "research".
 
Good point zeke....never thought of that (only applying the cost of R & D to one model).

Then again, what about all the R & D that went into every other vehicle and still continues? Remember this: whenever a manufacturer changes the design of a model, the dies/moulds/jigs used for the previous model are scrapped.

For eg: when hummer/gm brought out the H2....did they allocate the costs of all the hummers before that into the cost per mile of the H2? I bet they didn't....

I will agree however that IF (and that's a mighty big IF) every manufacturer, ONLY used any R & D on ONE model, and only EVER one model, then the cost of R & D is enormous. But we ALL know that isn't and won't ever be the case. Every manufacturer of any item uses any advances in design in as many of their products as they can.

Just throwing another idea out there: WHat about the R & D of the fuels used in the internal combustion engine? Was that factored in as well? Or how about the inefficiencies of previous years of the internal combustion engine? What I mean by this is, during the 60's, vehicles had big engines, heavy bodies and frames, and used massive amounts of fuel. Manufacturers learned from that and now produce big engines that get better fuel economy and are better made. Did they factor in the R & D cost of say a camaro, for ALL the camaros GM ever made?

Then again, how about all the billions of dollars spent on prototypes that never went into production? I know Ford has a warehouse in (dearborne I think) that houses over a billion dollars of prototypes that will never see the light of day.
 
tboy said:
Just throwing another idea out there: WHat about the R & D of the fuels used in the internal combustion engine? Was that factored in as well?

I doubt it. And that's what I'm talking about.

Does anyone really know how much Rudolph Diesel spent developing the diesel engine about 90 years ago? What about the cost of developing the Otto cycle that Nicolaus Otto developed in the late 1800s? Or the cost of developing lead-acid batteries? What about all the R&D that went into making gasoline better? And I could go on and on...

If all that stuff was included, the only thing that would look better than small all-electric car would be a bicycle.

And if governments set their policies based on this retarded study, they would end up with policies that would stifle most, if not all, innovation.