Re: Re: Re: Wake up....
Pallydin said:
As it is, it's already clear to some that the UN members *did* allow it. How so? Did you ever ask yourself why the US didn't push their resolution to its conclusion to make their point that France was wrong if it had vetoed after passing (which it wouldn't have passed but let's ignore that)? The reason was that if the resolution was defeated, it would have become illegal to attack Iraq instead of legally grey as it was in 1441, and that obviously wasn't something the US wanted because they didn't push forward. Now, if France and Russia were *truly* serious about stopping the war and the US need to test some new toys, they would merely bring their own resolution that copied the US/UK one and then see it defeated or vetoed to prevent the war through the illegality. Why did that not happen? While no doubt you will respond with "the US is so powerful that none dare stand in its way", I say that there are a whole host of other possibilities that people should wake up and perhaps look at more objectively.
The US and UK didn't proceed with the vote because they didn't have the votes to win. The reason they didn't have the votes is that the smaller countries on the Security Council didn't want to get caught in the middle of a fight between US/UK and France/Russia. France didn't want to propose a resolution with a 10 day timeline because they had no timeline, they wanted to appease until the cows came home.
From a legal perspective I think the US feels 1441 covers the coalition.
France and Russia had much to loose if Sadam was overthrown, they did what they could do to save him. It didn't work. History will tell us if their intentions were honorable.
Pallydin said:
The US projects power against nations that don't have nukes in vast numbers or equal technology and the understanding of it. Since the US has already said they are ready to use theirs in pre-emptive strikes against rogue nations, what is stopping other nations from using theirs on US assets? Not a pretty conclusion to everything, but also very likely given the US's new method of neglecting diplomacy for military action. If the US will not act rationally on the world stage, why assume other nations will?
I think your assertion was that NATO would forcibly remove the US from control of Iraq. That's simple not possible. No other entity has the ability to project that much power around the world, period.
So now, since you were wrong, you change the topic. There are very few countries that have "vast numbers of nukes" (France, Russia, China, UK) a few other countries have a couple (Israel, India, Pakistan, North Korea). I don't know that a preemptive strike from France, Russia, China or the UK is in the cards anytime soon so I don't understand your point. North Korea could pop a nuke against South Korea (and 37k US servicemen) or a terrorist could do it, which gets us back on topic.
Pallydin said:
While you perceive it as ass kissing, it could just as easily be a case of the other nations reminding the US of the price they pay for acting without authority on the world stage. I think the next few months will be very interesting to say the least.....the US has nowhere enough money to rebuild Iraq and they know they'll need the UN sooner than later. Otherwise they will face a rebellion by the Iraqi people when they fall short on their promise to help them after the UN tells them to deal with their own mess.
PAL
What price to pay? As stated in the links the dissenters are already softening their rhetoric to get in on the action. That's the funny part, there is no price to pay because they have no leverage. The US has more money to throw at Iraq than the UN does, and that's not the point, the Iraqi oil money will be used to rebuild the country and the US will administer that money and the government.
OTB