Legal Question??

icespot

Well-known member
Jul 7, 2005
1,688
76
48
scenario:

MPA has lawyer client that sees her at a MP and is a regular costumer of the MP that she works at.

1) Can he represent her in legal matter.

2) If the MPA gets arrested and needs a surety can her lawyer client bail her out and become her surety, if he is using money from his law firm to pay her 5000 a month.

3) If he does bail her out and is granted to be the surety by the courts. Can he represent her as a solicitor during a police investigation?

I am pretty sure this would result in the lawyer being disbarred by the Law Society, but just wanted to know if you guys could shed some lite. THX. :D
 
It's very unlikely the lawyer is representing her and acting as surety. He can represent her during any investigation where he does not have a conflict. If she subsequently gets charged with breaching bail, he would not be able to represent her.

My opinion is that you sound like you are too involved in her business. Take a step back.
 
Put aside the fact that she is an MPA, I've seen the rest of it happen before in the "real world". Then again, I've seen this happen at least twice (and maybe a third, but not heard directly from the MPA) in the rub and tug world.

Do you think MPAs would actually pay for legal services (or accounting or car mechanic or ??? services? LOL)

The bigger possible problem is the lawyer using firm funds to pay the girl. If it's from the firm's general account, I wonder what his partners think of that. If from the trust account, he's fucked.
 
If the legal matter is unrelated to the MP, it's maybe ok but still a bit dicey... representing someone you have a sexual relationship with. Probably not a good idea. As others have pointed out using other people's money is illegal on its own and acting as a surety is likely incompatible with representing.

If the MPA is being charged criminally in connection with the MP then the lawyer not only has a conflict, but the sort that would become a media circus if the press got hold of it.
 
1) The mere fact that the lawyer is the MPA's client does not preclude the lawyer from representing her. He could also feel free to represent his mechanic, accountant or real estate agent in legal matters. The question becomes whether he is in a sexually intimate relationship with the MPA (I am assuming that is a yes if he is paying her $5k a month but you have not said that is necessarily the case). Even then, there is no definite rule that a lawyer cannot represent someone he/she is in a sexual relationship with. But it is very dicey and my read of the landscape is that the LSUC would generally see it as inappropriate;

2) A lawyer can act as surety for whoever he/she pleases - the same as any other citizen; a personal relationship, even a sexual one, does not preclude a person from being a surety;

3) I cannot see under any circumstances how a lawyer could represent someone in a criminal matter while simultaneously acting as a surety. When you become a surety you pledge to the Court to immediately inform the Court/police if the accused breaches the conditions of their release. As a lawyer you owe a duty of absolute confidentiality to your client. These two duties are completely incompatible with one another. I don't think it would be a good idea for a lawyer to act as someone's surety unless the accused had another lawyer defending them (i.e., was not self represented). If the person was self represented there would be too much temptation to ask for opinions from the lawyer and the question of whether the lawyer is acting as the accused's lawyer or not would become too blurry.

4) Not entirely sure what you mean by paying her $5k a month from "his firm". If he is a sole practitioner and is simply making payments from his firm's general account in order to avoid a wife/sig other seeing the transaction there is nothing wrong with that. If he is falsifying paperwork/records to cover the payments he is almost sure to be screwed because a LSCU spot audit is eventually going to catch it.
 
Only the Law Society can say what they would do. Members of the Society might speculate more wisely than we TERBians. But unwisdom has never stopped us before.

1. If he can't represent an MPA with whom he's had a commercial relationship, then neither could he represent the owner of the garage where he gets his car serviced, nor his cleaning lady. It may at some point be unethical not to disclose that non-lawyer-client relationship, but I can't imagine how or why it should be of real significance to the other side. It may well however be a strategic weakpoint. Two points you should clarify in your question: What sort of legal matter? A will? buying a house? a DUI? a bawdy-house charge? On that last, we should all remember that simply paying, or receiving money for sex is entirely legal, and unless the MPA is also the keeper of the bawdy-house, her charges—if any—will depend on getting the operator convicted first. There's a lot this guy can do before he has to put on his robes to speak for her.

2b) Again you need to clarify: If the lawyer is "…using money from his law firm", is he using clients' money held in trust, money that belongs to the firm which entrusted him with signing and spending authority, or earned compensation he receives from the firm. The first two would clearly be breaches of trust, the last would be no one's business but his. $5000 a month is a lot of bodyslides no matter how he raised the cash.
2a) Whether one can stand surety and post a bond for one's client would be more technical. But I can't see how it could not affect the quality of representation they'd get in Court compared to what other clients would. Barristers are supposed to be equal-service advocates like taxis at a cabstand. My bet would be that it's forbidden. I it isn't I think it should be.

3) Again very technical, and dependent on ever shifting police procedures as well as the Law Society. Since it is not a Court proceedings, and all he's doing as her solicitor is advising, I can't see why a qualified lawyer of the MPAs choice—client, surety, cousin or whatever—could be barred. But that would also depend on whether he is also acting or intending to act as her advocate before the court, and was discussed above.
 
This does sound like a conflict of interest IMO, but I'm no legal expert by far. You have to steer clear of any such conflicts in business especially in the legal profession because they have a nasty habit of coming back to haunt you. These days you have to be absolutely squeaky clean.
 
1] Yes he can represent her. Unlike doctors, lawyers can represent someone with whom they are having a sexual relationship. That being said, it opens the lawyer up for all sorts of complaints and a potential malpractice claim. These cases have occurred, it is nothing new. The lawyer who does it is a fool but has not broken any of the Rules of Professional Conduct by doing what you described.
As someone else already posted this depends upon your local Rules of Professional Conduct. For instance under rule 1.8 of the ABA model rule of professional conduct

(j) A lawyer shall not have sexual relations with a client unless a consensual sexual relationship existed between them when the client-lawyer relationship commenced.
 
Since this is the TORONTO Escort Review Board then the answer is given relative to the Rules of Professional Conduct for the Province of Ontario as administered by the Law Society of Upper Canada.

Since the original post refers to the lawyer acting as a surety the jurisdiction is more than likely Canadian not American. The Canadian bail system is totally different from the U.S. model.
How is this contradictory to the statement "this depends upon your local Rules of Professional Conduct?"
 
Sorry to go off track! Ha ha, what happens if a lawyer has been accused of being intoxicated at discoveries, true story, court reporter notes it?
 
To clarify,

The firm has partners and associates.....

He is married and has a relationship with her and pays her or used to pay her $5000 a month for legal services. I do remember seeing the stub and pretty sure I still have a picture.

I know he can rep the MPA, but the relationship has to be changed.

The MPA was arrested for a particular offense and needed a surety.

He went to court and became her surety, now this I had never seen before. The court allowed him to be the surety even though he will be at home with his wife and she will be all alone in her apartment. He will not be checking on her on a regular basis, but the court was ok with him setting the rules that she is to follow. Now if they are having an affair and doing each other..... Well you guys see what is going on.

Then the MPA is asked to give a witness statement to police in which she will disclose her own behavior. He is present during the interview and ids himself as her solicitor to ensure she doesn't make an inculpatory statement....
 
To clarify,

The firm has partners and associates.....

He is married and has a relationship with her and pays her or used to pay her $5000 a month for legal services. I do remember seeing the stub and pretty sure I still have a picture.

I know he can rep the MPA, but the relationship has to be changed.

The MPA was arrested for a particular offense and needed a surety.

He went to court and became her surety, now this I had never seen before. The court allowed him to be the surety even though he will be at home with his wife and she will be all alone in her apartment. He will not be checking on her on a regular basis, but the court was ok with him setting the rules that she is to follow. Now if they are having an affair and doing each other..... Well you guys see what is going on.

Then the MPA is asked to give a witness statement to police in which she will disclose her own behavior. He is present during the interview and ids himself as her solicitor to ensure she doesn't make an inculpatory statement....

Really, the biggest problem here seems to be that he is likely defrauding his partners by misrepresenting payment to his sugar baby as "legal services". The rest is dodgy, but just how dodgy depends on whether he is in any way potentially implicated, as a witness say, to anything she has been charged with.

If it relates to an illegal bawdy house he frequents, say, he should run the other direction.
 
I have been a surety several times, and the surety does not have to supervise the person, let alone live with them. it means you have to insure that they return to court on the date set, or you become financially on the hook for the amount of money the judge set to insure that you get them there. If you know of them breaching a condition of their terms of release, you are obligated to report it, but you do not need to follow them around to make sure they do not break the conditions.
 
Put aside the fact that she is an MPA, I've seen the rest of it happen before in the "real world". Then again, I've seen this happen at least twice (and maybe a third, but not heard directly from the MPA) in the rub and tug world.

Do you think MPAs would actually pay for legal services (or accounting or car mechanic or ??? services? LOL)

The bigger possible problem is the lawyer using firm funds to pay the girl. If it's from the firm's general account, I wonder what his partners think of that. If from the trust account, he's fucked.

( I had to chuckle at the MPA qualification).

If he's a sole practitioner and drawing $5K per month from his own capital account, then he can blow his money how he likes but anything else would break an LSUC convention or tax law if not a partnership agreement if that was the case.
 
1) The mere fact that the lawyer is the MPA's client does not preclude the lawyer from representing her. He could also feel free to represent his mechanic, accountant or real estate agent in legal matters. The question becomes whether he is in a sexually intimate relationship with the MPA (I am assuming that is a yes if he is paying her $5k a month but you have not said that is necessarily the case). Even then, there is no definite rule that a lawyer cannot represent someone he/she is in a sexual relationship with. But it is very dicey and my read of the landscape is that the LSUC would generally see it as inappropriate;

2) A lawyer can act as surety for whoever he/she pleases - the same as any other citizen; a personal relationship, even a sexual one, does not preclude a person from being a surety;

3) I cannot see under any circumstances how a lawyer could represent someone in a criminal matter while simultaneously acting as a surety. When you become a surety you pledge to the Court to immediately inform the Court/police if the accused breaches the conditions of their release. As a lawyer you owe a duty of absolute confidentiality to your client. These two duties are completely incompatible with one another. I don't think it would be a good idea for a lawyer to act as someone's surety unless the accused had another lawyer defending them (i.e., was not self represented). If the person was self represented there would be too much temptation to ask for opinions from the lawyer and the question of whether the lawyer is acting as the accused's lawyer or not would become too blurry.

4) Not entirely sure what you mean by paying her $5k a month from "his firm". If he is a sole practitioner and is simply making payments from his firm's general account in order to avoid a wife/sig other seeing the transaction there is nothing wrong with that. If he is falsifying paperwork/records to cover the payments he is almost sure to be screwed because a LSCU spot audit is eventually going to catch it.


So no different if I'm representing Tony Soprano and I know he broke the law but have to keep quiet because he's my client?
 
To clarify,

The firm has partners and associates.....

He is married and has a relationship with her and pays her or used to pay her $5000 a month for legal services. I do remember seeing the stub and pretty sure I still have a picture.

I know he can rep the MPA, but the relationship has to be changed.

The MPA was arrested for a particular offense and needed a surety.

He went to court and became her surety, now this I had never seen before. The court allowed him to be the surety even though he will be at home with his wife and she will be all alone in her apartment. He will not be checking on her on a regular basis, but the court was ok with him setting the rules that she is to follow. Now if they are having an affair and doing each other..... Well you guys see what is going on.

Then the MPA is asked to give a witness statement to police in which she will disclose her own behavior. He is present during the interview and ids himself as her solicitor to ensure she doesn't make an inculpatory statement....


He will eventually get caught. I read years ago about a Chartered Accountant who embezzled at least $1 Million from his firm (I think it was a national one) to pay for his mistress. Then another guy who was my senior in earlier years, who got caught juggling term investments for a realty firm. He didn't report to the office that morning when they called him in but jumped in the path of an incoming subway car. Left a hot wife, kids, nice house and cottage in the Muskokas.
 
Is he a criminal lawyer or does he work in another area. Most criminal lawyers do not go to an interview in a police station with a client. Most criminal lawyers would tell her not to make a statement once she has ben charged. You have an issue in that you are hearing her version of what is happening. Most people charged get confused, misunderstand the process. And now she may not be telling the entire truth as clearly you seem into her. Are you paying her as well I wonder.