Leafs trade Klee for prospect

With regards to O'Niel, does anyone have any insight as to why Quinn continues to play him? While I was no fan of Marius Chernos(i won't even try) he did at least drive to the net and on the rare occasions he was dressed did appear to be something of an offensive threat. Sure he was a defensive liability but who on this team isn't?

O'Niel, after the first twenty games has shown nothing yet continues to play night after night.
 
Toronto Passions said:
I don't mind Allison. Yeah he is very ssssslllllloooowwww, but I don't think the Leafs could have asked for anything more from him.

I feel O'neill was the biggest bust of the year. They thought they were getting the power forward from 3 years ago, but just got a guy who has clearly lost it.

I like Allison too, but other teams are very interested in him. He is the leafs best forward.

Like O'Neil, Allison isn't the player he was 3 years ago, either. The pickups JFjr did for this season really suck.
 
They gave up Klee and a 5th round draft pick..

They picked up Richardson who is a better defenseman than Klee and
Suglobov who is closer to the NHL than a fifth round pick.

If they sign Richarson for another season at a low salary...


I think overall not bad, not spectacular but hey anything on the Leafs can be deemed an improvement
 
21pro said:
I like Allison too, but other teams are very interested in him. He is the leafs best forward.

Like O'Neil, Allison isn't the player he was 3 years ago, either. The pickups JFjr did for this season really suck.
JFjr's hands were tied when the CBA was signed

He had to pair an almost $70 million payroll down to less than $40 million.

With a few big contracts already on board I don't think he had much choice.

At the time O'neill, Allison and Lindros looked like deals. The best thing is that all of their contracts are up I believe.

I will wait and see what JFjr can do with more wiggle room under a cap that is supposed to be increased dramatically after the season
 
Richardson better? i don't think so... more similar then anything except Richardson has concussion issues and is a slower skater. Richardson is also older.

Good point, though about Suglobov being closer to the NHL then a 5th rounder... i still doubt Suglobov will ever play an NHL season, though. I think JFjr is just keeping the AHL roster full.

agree about the Leafs salary issues...

that was my reasoning behind why i thought the leafs would be in for a tough season this year and probably not make the playoffs and got heavily criticized for saying that back in September.

however, it was bad management to pick up beaten up cheap players when this year and the next 2 years have the most talented crop of incoming prospects that the NHL has and will ever see for a long time... when the leafs unloaded, they shoulda went for high draft picks, not soon to be retiree pentioners... (that costs the leafs money too)
 
21pro said:
Richardson better? i don't think so... more similar then anything except Richardson has concussion issues and is a slower skater. Richardson is also older.

I think Klee is a classy guy and a good defenseman, but he has looked terrible this season..

come to think of it the whole Leaf team has looked terrible this year
 
so did Richardson... have you watched him much?

got stripped of his 'C' and has been a 'healthy scratch' a few times on a near bottom of the league team that really needed defense.
 
Mysteris of Hockey

All these years I never understood what keeps Richardson in the NHL. The guy has always seemed to have an inside track on a spot in the lineup even though his play never justified it.

When he came up he was basically a replay of Nylund & McGill, which was borderline acceptable in 1982 but by '88 the standard for defensive play for Junior grads already started to improve. This was the type of D-man you'd find hanging on in the 80's after breaking in with one of those '70s expansion teams - basically a clumsy big guy whom coaches could send out to do jobs on soft targets.

There were guys who survived in the 90's without mobility - like Ludwig, Green, Lalor or even Dirk & Marsh - but Richardson never developed the timming and intuition for defense that those types had.
 
Hard Idle... you just summed up the ideal Toronton Maple Leaf!
 
One final piece of Richadson-bashing:

Whe he broke in with Toronto, the whole organization was salivating about his size, but all I ever noticed was a bully who nailed smaller players but never got within 30 feet of a guy that might do something back to him.

I remember the back to back playoff series with the Red Wings, neither Richardson nor Nylund could be found on the same side of the zone as Probert, Kocur, Bridgman or even Barr. Instead, it was another newcomer, Todd Gill (185lbs at the time) who dropped the gloves with BOTH Kocur and Probert during the road games. I could never forgive how bad that looked on the whole team.

I figured Gill would stay in the league a lot longer then Richardson, but there's that inside track again...
 
though his toughness has been questioned many times:

he has fought Probert once as I recall and once gave Brett Lindros a concussion after a sweet open ice hit.

he's definitely an nhl'er, but i thought the leafs woulda been lookin for a 1st or 2nd line defensive defenceman....