I still like Marner, believe it or not he is the most productive player point wise than any of the other top guys. I think he gets flack because he doesn't produce at reg season level.IMHO, if the Leafs have a poor playoff showing this year, both Marner and Tavares are gone for sure!! Probably Shanahan will be gone as well. I think the Leafs have to at least get to the 3rd round of the playoffs, in order for the season to be a success.
Good news is that Tavares' 7yr contract finally expires at the end of this season. So the Leafs can use Tavares' approx $11 million/yr salary against the cap, to get in some more players. Also, the Leafs just might have to let Marner walk, if Marner's contract demands are too greedy. if Marner tanks this season in the playoffs, like he usually does, then it will be easier on the Leaf fans when Treliving decides not to sign Marner to a huge contract extension etc
He also brings a lot of other things to the table that don't show up on the score sheet.
Having said that, I agree that if he wants to hold a gun to management's head at contract time, he can go.
I've had enough of players draining every nickel they can at the expense of building a balanced team, especially when they got paid top dollar at RFA
and they've been treated like royalty by management.