Lasik Horror Stories

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Global TV did a feature on their "16:9" program to-night about Lasik surgeries gone bad:mad:. Do you have any Lasik stories, good or bad?
 
i was going to get it done, but changed my mind at the last minute when i read the waiver....scary stuff.
 
I can pretty much echo WorkingMan's story (good piece of writing). I had the Custom Wavefront procedure done at the LASIK clinic on Mud@Paramount in Hamilton last December as an Xmas present to myself and I recommend them whole-heartedly to anyone considering the procedure. Before the surgery w/o my glasses life started getting blurry about 6" from my face and I had been wearing glasses since Grade 1 (in my 40s now).

It does not hurt to get the surgery. There was some discomfort during the prep as they had to push down on the eye to seat the ring around the operating site. This ring vacuum seals itself onto your eyeball so you do end up with a ring of broken blood vessels around your iris that lasts for a couple weeks. Looks far worse than it is.

Once they start doing the surgery it really feels like you are watching stuff being done on the other side of a pane of glass as there was no sensation being reported by your eye's nerves. After the flap was open it became a frosted pane of glass. :)

A few minutes per eye and the surgery was over. Right out of the hop my vision was about 80% of perfect, the remaining 20% settled in over the next few days as the flap began to heal up. Which was exactly as the clinic told me it would happen.

Post-op is a lot of drops and I recommend following their instructions to the letter as it's a) the best way to heal 100% and b) the drops make your eyes feel better. I didn't have a lot of problem with the gritty sand feeling, but that may be a personal tolerance thing (renovating oftens gets dust in your eyes despite safety glasses), but I can definitely state that you should not touch your eyes during the healing process. I had been told by the clinic not to do so, but I'm a guy so couldn't resist touching them lightly by the end of the first day. My god was I glad I only touched lightly. It felt like someone had driven a nail into my eye! So don't be a typical guy and DON'T TOUCH!

After the first week my vision was 20/20. Initially there was a starburst/halo effect around light sources, mostly noticeable at night, but that diminished to next to nothing after about a month or so. My night vision is actually better now than before the surgery.

Having a wider field of vision-in-focus (as opposed to being bounded by the frames of my glasses) which was a bit irritating until I got used to it. Walking down the aisle of a grocery store would start to give me a headache for example. I'm guessing because my brain now got to "see" so much more than it used to.

Was I worried going into the surgery? Hell yes! They offered and I accepted the tranquilizer (Ativan?) before the surgery.

Am I glad I did the surgery? Unqualified 100% yes.

Only negative I could report would be that there was a delay in taking me into surgery that was not explained to me. All I knew is that patients who had arrived after me were being done before me which was a little aggrevating. Turns out because I have a slight "lazy eye" it was producing some odd readings during the tests (it just wouldn't look straight where it was supposed to) and my doctor was sure that everything was fine, but emailed my results to all the other doctors in the clinic that were available to give him their opinion that what he saw was what they saw as well. So kudos for making the extra effort to ensure my surgery would be a success but it was aggravating to be told only that there was "going to be a slight delay, don't worry". Sorry ma'am, you are going to whittle away on my eyeball, not worrying is not an option. <grin>
 
i cannot keep still long so i am not going to do laser eye surgery
 
I've considered this. I've looked at the pros and cons and it really seems exceptionally safe. However, there is a very, very small chance it can go wrong, and when it does go wrong the consequences are just unacceptable to me. The one sense I could not live without is descent vision, and this is what you put at risk--although it's a miniscule amount of risk. Apparently your more likely to incur some kind of eye injury due to use of contact lenses than the Lasik surgery. But, the type of injuries may not be comparable.

It's kinda like nuclear power--very, very safe. But when something goes wrong . . .YIKES!

I have also heard, but have not data to point to, that such procedures make one more prone to detached retinas later in sports injuries.

For what it's worth, I personally have known over 10 people now who have done it. All have no regrets and have urged me to do it. I'm 50 and have been wearing glasses now for 38 years. I think I've just accepted the fact that I'll always be a four-eyes.
 
I've stay away form it based on a few facts, it's not permanent, it's like peeling back the levels on an onion and therefore limited, and there has been little good research on long term effects. It's contacts for sports and glasses for all other times.

Even now my eyes are getting better as I age.
 
I've stay away form it based on a few facts, it's not permanent, it's like peeling back the levels on an onion and therefore limited, and there has been little good research on long term effects. It's contacts for sports and glasses for all other times.

Even now my eyes are getting better as I age.

Blackrock, your following points are wrong:

1. it is not permanent - its like peeping back the levels on an onion and therefore limited
2. there has been little good research on long terms effects

Laser corrective vision is very safe and there are only three major issues that come up after the procedure:
1. dry eyes - this is temporary
2. halo's at night that diminish with time
3. possible need to wear reading glasses in later life

There is substantial clinical evidence and randomized clinical trials that show the current technology is very safe and show the long term effects have no negative side-effects.

Of course this procedure is not permanent, our eyes and our body are always changing and if there is any physician that says any surgical procedure such as plastic surgery or lasik is not properly giving you 'informed consent'.

If any of you are considering this procedure I would suggest getting a few different opinions. The 'bladeless' lasik is a marketing gimic and there the RCT (randomized clinical trials) do not show bladeless lasik is anymore effective than the regular 'bladed' version. The 'bladeless' procedure makes patients less apprehensive about the procedure because there is no 'knife' and people are therefore more likely to accept treatment. The margins around the initial cut of the 'bladeless' laser procedure are not as sharp/clean as the more known blade procedure of peeling back the outer layer of the cornea.

Unfortunately there is a lot of hype from ill-informed patients that point to procedures which are promoted by both the physicians and companies that make the equipment that have a financial stake rather than providing sound clinical advice.

If you do get a consultation make sure you can speak to the Physician because alot of these places have the optometrist performing the initial consultation and 'selling' you the procedure. In terms of companies and surgeons to get a opinion from:

1. Rootman - he is on yonge and englinton; good guy but only performs bladeless lasik
2. Lasik MD - they have probably the best opthomologists nation wide - they give you real expectations of outcome
3. TLC - they have some good doctors - i didnt get to see the physician

I would highly recommend Lasik MD. Their customer service on the front end might be less than desirable but their physicians and optometrists are very good.
 
Blackrock, your following points are wrong:

1. it is not permanent - its like peeping back the levels on an onion and therefore limited
2. there has been little good research on long terms effects

Laser corrective vision is very safe and there are only three major issues that come up after the procedure:
1. dry eyes - this is temporary
2. halo's at night that diminish with time
3. possible need to wear reading glasses in later life

There is substantial clinical evidence and randomized clinical trials that show the current technology is very safe and show the long term effects have no negative side-effects.

Of course this procedure is not permanent, our eyes and our body are always changing and if there is any physician that says any surgical procedure such as plastic surgery or lasik is not properly giving you 'informed consent'.

If any of you are considering this procedure I would suggest getting a few different opinions. The 'bladeless' lasik is a marketing gimic and there the RCT (randomized clinical trials) do not show bladeless lasik is anymore effective than the regular 'bladed' version. The 'bladeless' procedure makes patients less apprehensive about the procedure because there is no 'knife' and people are therefore more likely to accept treatment. The margins around the initial cut of the 'bladeless' laser procedure are not as sharp/clean as the more known blade procedure of peeling back the outer layer of the cornea.

Unfortunately there is a lot of hype from ill-informed patients that point to procedures which are promoted by both the physicians and companies that make the equipment that have a financial stake rather than providing sound clinical advice.

If you do get a consultation make sure you can speak to the Physician because alot of these places have the optometrist performing the initial consultation and 'selling' you the procedure. In terms of companies and surgeons to get a opinion from:

1. Rootman - he is on yonge and englinton; good guy but only performs bladeless lasik
2. Lasik MD - they have probably the best opthomologists nation wide - they give you real expectations of outcome
3. TLC - they have some good doctors - i didnt get to see the physician

I would highly recommend Lasik MD. Their customer service on the front end might be less than desirable but their physicians and optometrists are very good.

So a friend who was one of the first of my friends to get the surgery and who had his eye go again, not necessarily back to square one, and is wearing glasses again, because he chose not to get the procedure again, is wrong.

I've also had my eyes doctor that I known for about 20 years explain it using the peeling onion description.

So you say I'm wrong to say it's not permanent but then follow it by saying the changes are natural. You're kind of hedging your bet and can't have it both ways. Some people I've talk to use to think they'd never have to wear glasses again.
 
I had it done.... Had an accident that is not spoken about much.
So first hand knowledge and extremely informed.
The instrument used to cut the flap is call a microkeratome.
Uses suction to draw in the cut then cuts the happy face smile on your eye creating the flap.
Mine malfunctioned during the cut and left me scared, which causes triple vision, dry eye and pain.
It took them about three days to contact me with a settlement that I didn't even consider.
Plus the map your eye in a computer and did a save as instead of a new save. This using a map of another persons eye.
They also forgot to get me to sign the waiver and the whole procedure is tapped for some reason.

When I turned down the settlement and spoke to a lawyer I found it very difficult and expensive to go after them and was told by the lawyers to not fight with the big boys cause they have big pockets.

My lawyer was judging me on my appearance not my means. Which I understand. So I did reasearch and found a firm I wanted but they didn't want to shake up the big players either.

Being a graphic artist I produced a perfect picture of a 4 year old girl and then the same picture in the way that I saw it with fuzzy edges, ghosting and contrast pulled way down. Sent it to all the people in the firm and asked them if this is how you'd like to see the world for the rest of your life. They took me on.

Your body adapts to injury so I blink much more now and the fluids fill in the scare every so slightly to enable you to see better for a short, short period.

I'm not saying don't do it... I'm just saying be aware and informed and look at all the risks.

When I went down to see another doctor to see if he could fix the error he told me that in the states they would have never attempted my eye. Regulations are different there and it would have been a no go from the initial visit. I still have options but I'd rather live with what I got than risk worse.

My 2 cents
 
even with lasik your eyes naturally age and your vision will again be where you started pre-op :p

Yes you can require either further touchups or even glasses down the road. LASIK will do nothing in regards to the need for reading glasses as that is due to the aging of the muscles, not the lense of the eye.
 
So a friend who was one of the first of my friends to get the surgery and who had his eye go again, not necessarily back to square one, and is wearing glasses again, because he chose not to get the procedure again, is wrong.

I've also had my eyes doctor that I known for about 20 years explain it using the peeling onion description.

So you say I'm wrong to say it's not permanent but then follow it by saying the changes are natural. You're kind of hedging your bet and can't have it both ways. Some people I've talk to use to think they'd never have to wear glasses again.

I've never hear it described as a "Peeling onion" procedure, my understanding is they carve your lense back into the proper shape.

As for the people who "thought they'd never have to wear glasses again" either didn't listen or went to someone who didn't properly explain the procedure. My LASIK team repeatedly told me that there was the likelihood that down the road I would require touch-up surgery and that the need for reading glasses was a completely separate issue from correcting my distance vision. Not only did they tell me, it was repeated several times in the documentation they gave me and the forms they had me sign.

In regards to the long-term research... I believe we're up to 20 yrs now since they started doing it and showing good results. At what point is the research sufficient? The answer to that will be up to the individual and their "comfort level" of course. For me, 20 yrs will put me into my 60s. So for me a 20-yr expectation that things will most likely be okay is enough for me. For my eye doctor, he says he wouldn't look at it until 50-yrs has gone by so he's sticking with his glasses. Which is his choice. I have decided that the positives of having several years without having to wear glasses for a change outweighs the risks.
 
So a friend who was one of the first of my friends to get the surgery and who had his eye go again, not necessarily back to square one, and is wearing glasses again, because he chose not to get the procedure again, is wrong.

I've also had my eyes doctor that I known for about 20 years explain it using the peeling onion description.

So you say I'm wrong to say it's not permanent but then follow it by saying the changes are natural. You're kind of hedging your bet and can't have it both ways. Some people I've talk to use to think they'd never have to wear glasses again.

BR, so your friend had a bad experience and now you think the procedure is not proven. You take one case and one consult with some physician and apply it to the whole field. very scientific.

in terms of your point i am refuting "1. it is not permanent - its like peeping back the levels on an onion and therefore limited" - you would infer by my later comments that i am not debating the part about lasik not being permanent and anyone who says a surgical procedure is permanent is not telling you the truth.

Your later part of your comment is false.

One has to either use a laser or blade to make a flap and then reshape the eye. during this procedure you most likely will see different colors and also a 'bad' smell will be emitted due to burning of the protein in your eye. My contention that the part about being it limited and comparing the procedure to peeling an onion is inaccurate. You peel multiple layers in an onion but you only peel back ONE layer in lasik. You got the wrong information.
 
BR, so your friend had a bad experience and now you think the procedure is not proven. You take one case and one consult with some physician and apply it to the whole field. very scientific.

in terms of your point i am refuting "1. it is not permanent - its like peeping back the levels on an onion and therefore limited" - you would infer by my later comments that i am not debating the part about lasik not being permanent and anyone who says a surgical procedure is permanent is not telling you the truth.

Your later part of your comment is false.

One has to either use a laser or blade to make a flap and then reshape the eye. during this procedure you most likely will see different colors and also a 'bad' smell will be emitted due to burning of the protein in your eye. My contention that the part about being it limited and comparing the procedure to peeling an onion is inaccurate. You peel multiple layers in an onion but you only peel back ONE layer in lasik. You got the wrong information.

The original post was about other cases as well that filled 48 minutes of the tele. Apparently my friends problem was not a single case, but one I know of personally. Post #15 also relayed another incident, perhaps not as tragic as some, but it was a problem for the poster. As one who uses my eyes for my work as well, as it would be impossible without good eye sight, I can relate .
 
My friend's sister had the surgery and she said she lost most of her night vision, so she almost never goes out at night. Which is why my friend decided not to get the surgery even though her eyesight was pretty bad too (around -8.0 for both eyes I think). Sticking to eyeglasses and contact lenses is not so bad actually, if you don't wanna risk getting the surgery.