LA commuter train engineer was texting before crash

Reports would indicate that he drove the commuter train right through a red light.

Good thing he died because otherwise, he'd have to live with the guilt of killing all those people (assuming he is to blame)

The situtation could be prevented if they would install trip arms at red lights to apply the brakes on a train should a train driver miss or ignore the signals.
 
Hes dead and can not defend himself...first they claimed he falled asleep, now he was texting...how do we know IF the light was red like they claim it was? If the light was not working right, then they are to blame big time....that means lawsuits and biggier pay outs...better to say they were not at fault and blame a dead person. Then the lawsuits will not get as much $$$.

Well thats how I see it....Does seem like a rush to judgement, not even 24 hours after the crash they were blaming him and of course not their equpiment.
 
S.C. Joe said:
Hes dead and can not defend himself...first they claimed he falled asleep, now he was texting...how do we know IF the light was red like they claim it was? If the light was not working right, then they are to blame big time....that means lawsuits and biggier pay outs...better to say they were not at fault and blame a dead person. Then the lawsuits will not get as much $$$.

Well thats how I see it....Does seem like a rush to judgement, not even 24 hours after the crash they were blaming him and of course not their equpiment.

Yeah, it's probably too early to be definitive. Have a look at this article. It seems there will be lots of information to determine what happened. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/26692834/

jwm
 
The only person who knew the answer is dead...everything else said is irrelevant! CASE CLOSED!
 
The cell phone records might have shown that he was using his cell phone just before the crash...so their "he fell alsleep at the wheel" didn't make sense anymore...so now its "he must have been sending a text message".

Sounds like there was no video camera in his train--just the other train, so we might never know if the light was red or green...I don't care what the computers claim...maybe the light did not change as it should have....its hard to believe he did not know if you go though the red light there be a head on crash....he ran the train for years. Unless they find drugs or alcohol in his system, I'm not going to buy he just blew the red light. They said theres two yellow lights before the red light...so he missed all three lights?
 
Tarkus said:
Still lots of people out there convinced they handle their cell phone, blackberry, monitor their GPS and drink their coffee while jerking off to the porn on their mobile DVD resting on the passenger seat while they weave in an out of traffic. I guess driving a train isn't much different.

Nah, only the papparzie go to that extent.
 
If he ran a red, they'll know.

RTC (Rail Traffic Control) will have records of the orders for Track Occupancy Permit given to each driver. Each driver would have been told that they have permission to enter the track from Mile X to Mile Y each and to stop in in the siding or at the red signal at Mile Y.

The instructions from RTC to each driver will have been recorded both in writing and with Audio Tape.

RTC would have known that there were two trains on the track heading towards each other. One or the other would have been told to enter the siding and wait for the opposing to train to pass.

It's very simple.

They will listen to the tapes, one train or the other will have ended up on a portion of track that it should not have been on.

For example, if the Commuter train was given orders to proceed to Mile 40, and they find that train at Mile 41, that means he went too far on a portion of track that he was not authorized to be on. (Vice versa for the freight train.)

They already know for 100% certainty who is to blame. One driver or the other, or RTC is at fault. The only question right now is how did the person at fault screw up? Was he indeed "texting"? or was it something else?
 
james t kirk said:
If he ran a red, they'll know.

RTC (Rail Traffic Control) will have records of the orders for Track Occupancy Permit given to each driver. Each driver would have been told that they have permission to enter the track from Mile X to Mile Y each and to stop in in the siding or at the red signal at Mile Y.

The instructions from RTC to each driver will have been recorded both in writing and with Audio Tape.

RTC would have known that there were two trains on the track heading towards each other. One or the other would have been told to enter the siding and wait for the opposing to train to pass.

It's very simple.

They will listen to the tapes, one train or the other will have ended up on a portion of track that it should not have been on.

For example, if the Commuter train was given orders to proceed to Mile 40, and they find that train at Mile 41, that means he went too far on a portion of track that he was not authorized to be on. (Vice versa for the freight train.)

They already know for 100% certainty who is to blame. One driver or the other, or RTC is at fault. The only question right now is how did the person at fault screw up? Was he indeed "texting"? or was it something else?
Entirely true. From what I've read, it would appear that the Commuter Rail train did not have the right to proceed, and failed to obey the stop signal.
 
They could also presumably check the engineer's cell phone records and compare the timing of the alleged 'text message' with the time of the crash.

The thorough investigation that is in progress will bring the true facts to light.
 
(Esco found this and posted it on another thread...I'm just copying it here)

LOS ANGELES, California (CNN) Sept 18 -- The California Public Utilities Commission banned texting on the job Thursday after it was shown that a Metrolink train engineer involved in last week's deadly collision near Los Angeles sent text messages from his cell phone.

It was unclear what 46-year-old Robert Sanchez was doing at the time of the crash Friday. The National Transportation Safety Board is investigating claims that he was sending text messages when his commuter train slammed into a Union Pacific freight train in Chatsworth.

Twenty-five people were killed, including Sanchez, and at least 130 were injured.

Investigators subpoenaed the phone records of the engineer and determined that he "had sent and received text messages on the day of the accident, including some while he was on duty," according to an NTSB statement Wednesday.

Investigators were trying to determine at what time the messages were sent.

The commission's emergency order passed unanimously Thursday.

In pushing for the ban, Commission President Michael Peevey said that cell phone use by engineers "may have been a factor" in train accidents this year in San Francisco and Sacramento, California. He did not elaborate on details of those incidents.

Thursday's order is temporary until the state commission decides whether to make it permanent.
 
LOS ANGELES, California (CNN) -- A Metrolink engineer driving a commuter train sent a text message about 22 seconds before the train collided with a Union Pacific freight train last month, the National Transportation Safety Board said Wednesday.

On Wednesday, the NTSB said that Sanchez, 46, sent a text message at 4:22:01 p.m. on September 12, the NTSB said, citing information on his cell phone activity that the safety board subpoenaed from his service provider.

The preliminary estimate of the time for the head-on collision is 4:22:23 p.m., NTSB said, citing Union Pacific train's onboard recorders.

The crash killed 25 people, including the engineer, Robert Sanchez, during Friday rush hour in Chatsworth, a northwest Los Angeles suburb.

From 3:03 p.m. -- when Sanchez returned from a break that had lasted several hours -- until the collision, the engineer received seven text message and sent five, the NTSB said. The safety board did not identify with whom Sanchez was exchanging text messages.

From 6:44 a.m. until 8:53 a.m. that day, when Sanchez was also in charge of a train, he received 21 text messages and sent 24, the NTSB said.
 
alexmst said:
LOS ANGELES, California (CNN) -- A Metrolink engineer driving a commuter train sent a text message about 22 seconds before the train collided with a Union Pacific freight train last month, the National Transportation Safety Board said Wednesday.

On Wednesday, the NTSB said that Sanchez, 46, sent a text message at 4:22:01 p.m. on September 12, the NTSB said, citing information on his cell phone activity that the safety board subpoenaed from his service provider.

The preliminary estimate of the time for the head-on collision is 4:22:23 p.m., NTSB said, citing Union Pacific train's onboard recorders.

The crash killed 25 people, including the engineer, Robert Sanchez, during Friday rush hour in Chatsworth, a northwest Los Angeles suburb.

From 3:03 p.m. -- when Sanchez returned from a break that had lasted several hours -- until the collision, the engineer received seven text message and sent five, the NTSB said. The safety board did not identify with whom Sanchez was exchanging text messages.

From 6:44 a.m. until 8:53 a.m. that day, when Sanchez was also in charge of a train, he received 21 text messages and sent 24, the NTSB said.

There you have it.