Twinkle,
Please do not confuse a spirited discussion for a flame war. I know how to flame for crying out loud..LOL. For the record I am a casual watcher of basketball. Footaball is my favorite sport. What is of interest here is that we have yet another high profile black athelete in a mess with the law. So I'm looking carefully at the fairness of the public debate. I'm not lionizing Kobe for his behavior, but I'm also not going to be giving any passes to this "naive country girl" as you would describe her. Her prior actions would indicate she is capable of being as cold and calculating as they come. Yes Kobe should have known better. When you're in his position, you have to constantly be on guard. He made the stupid mistake of letting his guard down the same as many other high profile figures, most notably even a former President of the United States. In that particular instance, Monica Lewinsky was given a pass by many of the President's enemies because it served their purpose to further excoriate him. But in that case, there was plenty of evidence, Miss Lewinsky's youth not withstanding, that she was quite deliberate in her actions as well.
I don't look at this as a "double standard" as you would characterize it. I'd say let's look at it as applying the standards bilaterally. By law that naive girl is an adult. The fact that she is a small town girl is not a mitigating circumstance under the law any more than Kobe being 20 something. That doesn't excuse her naivety of going to Kobe Bryant's room. Why is it that you choose to overlook that fact and instead don't hold her accountable for her own actions? Her plight, given that we assume she was raped, was clearly due to her bad choice. I haven't passed any judgement on whether Kobe is guilty or innocent. The fact is I don't know because I wasn't there. There may be facts or medical opinions that support her case. I'd like to wait and see. But what I do know is that this woman is guilty of poor judgement by allowing herself to be in that position, just the same as Kobe Bryant is guilty by taking advantage of the situation, if in fact he did.
Nothing I've written here says that I believe the young lady consented to sex by her mere presence in the man's room. The law is what a jury interprets it to be. It considers culpability of the parties in determining whether there indeed was a crime. If this young lady consented to sex and then later recanted, no jury with those facts before them would consider this rape. As an employee of this hotel, the woman broke their rules by even being in the room. She had no reason to be there, and ventured there without regards to her employer's instructions. Whether she is naive, and should have known better are questions for a jury to decide. But even without the possibility of trouble in the room looming large, it would be evidence on record that as an employee of that hotel, she had no business there by her own employers instructions, and it is facts like that, that will make all the difference as to sorting out intent of the two parties. It comes down to credibility, and as big of a dog as we'd make Kobe out to be, one must consider that the woman was not kidnapped for crying out loud.
And finally to your statement:
"BTW- Even many adults may naively think that a cute, rich and famous pro athlete, surrounded by willing groupies and probaly oversexed, a man who could have almost any woman he wanted, would never WANT or NEED to rape a woman. But rape is about control and not sex. "
Quite true, rape is indeed about control. And sex is about control as well. And women control sex, and many are masters at using that control to evoke responses from men. Since women are in control of such a volatile and precious commodity, at what point are they going to be held accountable for their incitful actions?
Funny, but the law does recognize this concept. Crimes of passion provide mitigating circumstances for spouses to be acquitted of capital murder in several states in the US. I don't know about Canada. This same concept applied to rape, would inject some element of culpability to the women involved in terms of the clear choices that they made to place themselves in such situations. And no, I'm not talking about wearing short skirts in a public venue, I'm talking about such deliberate actions as represented by visiting this man's room under dubious pretense.
EBS