Kobe Bryant vs Tim Duncan

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
45,727
11,186
113
I hear Tim Duncan is contemplating retirement. At this point he has nothing left to prove. If he does, it fits with his humble demenour - not for him the fanfare that Kobe has gotten.

Duncan won just as many NBA titles as Kobe. If you were building an NBA team from scratch, which of these two franchise players would you choose?
 
Duncan. Not all about him and I think he is one of those star talents that helps to make his team mates better.
 
Tim.
 
Depends on whether I needed to be successful quickly. Kobe had the flash and scoring punch to draw crowds and money to the organization. Tim would be better in the long run teaching players all the other parts of success.

And of course Duncan's retirement will get less fanfare, that's the kind of guy he is.
 
Wow ... These two guys shouldn't be in the same discussion .... Two different positions .... Although unlike Jordan and Kobe ... He proved you could win without being an ass ... Love Jordan but the stories are out there how he treated his teammates
 
They played different positions and had different roles on their teams, but with advanced statistics, we really don't need to resort to making subjective arguments that can't really be settled anymore. Kobe is an all-time great player, but when it comes to measuring who contributed more to winning by delivering more value for his team, it's not even close. This article (http://espn.go.com/nba/insider/story/_/id/16983549/undefined) requires a paid subscription, but what it shows is that Duncan is way above Kobe on career wins above replacement (WAR) in the regular season and in the playoffs -- Kobe isn't even #2 (Shaq is). The upshot: "Bryant has been the better offensive player over the course of their careers, but the difference isn't enough to make up the gap on the defensive end of the floor." Kobe's got the gaudy scoring stats, but he did so more due to volume than efficiency. On the defensive end, his individual stats and team stats are in an all together different league from Duncan's.

Kobe played with flash on THE marquee franchise in the NBA, but given what we now understand about what contribute to winning basketball and how to measure it, it's actually pretty cut and dried who the greater player was.
 
Eventhough they play different positions, i think kobe was a better player skill wise but duncan was a way better role model.
 
Wow ... These two guys shouldn't be in the same discussion .... Two different positions .... Although unlike Jordan and Kobe ... He proved you could win without being an ass ... Love Jordan but the stories are out there how he treated his teammates

So true, Kobe called out Dwight Howard for not being a winner. In an indirect way he called him a Big Pussy.

 
Brendan Shanahan is hoping that Lady Luck will smile on the Leafs like she did with the Spurs.

In the 1996-97 season, the Spurs lost David Robinson for the season - so they tanked. They gambled and got the top lottery pick, Duncan. When he first entered the NBA Duncan was shy and deferred to Robinson. His instincts were good, David Robinson was a graduated from the US Naval Academy majoring in Mathematics. Kobe was always his own man, never accepted mentoring from anyone and he had a adversarial relationship with The Big Aristotle. Not sure if Kobe ever endured a baptism of fire like Duncan did. Duncan took a kick to the face from Karl Malone and he lived to tell the tale! Not sure Kobe could survive that.

 
Kobe the better talent but I would easily choose Duncan over Kobe if building a hypothetical team.

I tend to agree, as much as I love Kobe's talent and desire to win, Duncan is the ultimate team player. Tim couldn't take over a game like Kobe, but he also won't shoot you out of a game as well.
 
Such an interesting comparison.

Obviously you can't build a sports league on guys like Duncan. It takes style, charisma, flash, and incredible talent.

However, the backbone of the sport is players like Duncan who skillfully stick to the fundamentals to win. Guys like the mailman and Duncan will always be underrated because of this but immersed fans of the game know better.