Kitchen Cabinet Fabricator - Recommendations??

james t kirk

Well-known member
Aug 17, 2001
24,059
4,068
113
I am looking to be buying new kitchen cabinets shortly.

I have redone the kitchen and am almost ready to start the hunt for cabinets.

I am looking for custom stuff and of good quality. I have been to a few of the home shows, interior design shows and noted a couple of good places to go. Bloomsbury, Irpinia, Downsview are a few that I have seen and been impressed with.

1. http://www.bloomsburydesign.com/Kitchen/

2. http://www.irpinia.com/


Wondering if anyone there in terbland has any experience with these guys, or if they can recommend a good fabricator.

I am looking for quality all the way. I will pay for it (without being crazy).

I don't want some guy with a table saw in his garage who built some cabinets for your cottage 5 years ago. I want somebody who knows what they are doing.

Lastly, I have a good background in construction, etc. but any pointers as to what to look for in terms what makes one cabinet better than another would be appreciated.

thanks..
 
yes... try canac if you want cheap reliable builder standard quality and aren't prepared to look into kitchen cabinets. Quality kitchens are not made in mass quanitity, they are made one at a time (hence the expense) for the individual.
If your looking for top of the line then be prepared to pay big time for the staples of the industry "Smallbones" or "Downsview". However, most people don't realize that the best kitchens are the one's that require the individual touch of a craftsman and for that, you have to go to a professional who has built and installed cabinets for years with proven quality. Best advice... is find a kitchen you like and ask the owner who made it..or pm me and i'll give you the name of a guy that I'm using in my new house.
 
as i work for a company that supplies these customers with their materials i would look for a custom shop as canac and raywall are production shops and charge more then a independent millworker.check out the shops on saunders road in barrie there is about 8 guys in a 1/4 mile stretch.Any time pm me and i'll pass names onto you
 
thanks.

I am aware of canac, they are actually a kohler company i believe.

Holmes on Homes uses Olympic Kitchens, and yes, I would like to meet holmes too. I like his work ethic and his attitude. He believes in doing a better than minimum code job (so do i) and he believes that that means a fair price (not dirt cheap) and so do i.

I need to get moving on some quotes probably in the next 2 weeks. I am just finishing off the walls, and will be moving onto the flooring. It's taken far longer to do than I ever thought it would.

If anyone has some pointers on what consitutes true quality, I would be happy.
 
perfectly straight

james t kirk said:
thanks.

If anyone has some pointers on what consitutes true quality, I would be happy.

Make sure your walls are perfectly straight. Specially the area where the edges fo the cabinets are going to reach.
Reason: if the wall is not straigth, whent he cabinets arrive there will be cracks/holes in between wall and cabinet. I seen it happen. So PAY for the LEVELER.
 
xix said:
Make sure your walls are perfectly straight. Specially the area where the edges fo the cabinets are going to reach.
Reason: if the wall is not straigth, whent he cabinets arrive there will be cracks/holes in between wall and cabinet. I seen it happen. So PAY for the LEVELER.


Ha, the leveller is me!

I have used metal studs for framing the kitchen walls for that reason.

Squared the walls using the 6 8 10 rule.

And laser lined the wall.

I can't do any more than that.

The only visible wow is the ceiling, which was the guy who built the house in 1920. It's got a rise of about half an inch on the outside wall.
 
james t kirk said:
Ha, the leveller is me!

I have used metal studs for framing the kitchen walls for that reason.

I hope you have some plywood/wood behind your drywall to support your upper cabinets, they're usually located 3 inches below the top of your upper cabinets.
 
gar said:
I hope you have some plywood/wood behind your drywall to support your upper cabinets, they're usually located 3 inches below the top of your upper cabinets.

Yes.

My house is structural brick.

I gutted the old kitchen which was just 1" air gap with wood strapping and wood lath, then plaster.

I then installed a layer of insulation on the outside wall to act as a thermal break to prevent the studs from getting overly cold.

Metal studs were set up in an H configuration (back to back studs).

I then braced the studs to the masonry by tapconing into the brick an angle, then screwing the angle to the center of the H stud (to brace and reduce the effective length of the stud.)

I then installed 3/4" plywood between the H studs and screwed that in place in order to have something to screw the future cupboards to. (This was done at the top of the uppers, the bottom of the uppers, and the top of the lowers.

I then insulated and vapour barried the outside wall.

I originally bought 2x4's but within a couple of days of bringing them home, they were so badly warped and twisted, they were virtually unusable.

Took them all back to the big orange store.

Wood would be easier in some ways, but it is almost impossible to get good wood in 2 x 4. Could have gone 2 x 6, but my kitchen is small, and like she said, every inch counts.
 
What are you out fitting with?

I have clients come in all the time for appliances that say "I wish I had known"
eg Sub Zero or GE monogram's drawer freezers or fridges in tanden with drawer dishwashers that naturally lead to things like pot drawers etc. that will populate an island.
Also adequete ventalation that will move a total CFM of 1% of the total BTU output of a cooktop. Are you using an interior or exterior blower? Interiors are 400 to 900 CFM and exterior are 600 to 1500 CFM.
Consider a micro/convection oven if you are doing built in's and that gives you the benefits of a second oven without the expense and as an ongoing feature you can preheat and utilize 1.1 cu ft easier and CHEAPER than a full sized 4.6 cubic foot one.

Just a couple of appliance thoughts
 
james t kirk said:
I am aware of canac, they are actually a kohler company i believe.

Holmes on Homes uses Olympic Kitchens, and yes, I would like to meet holmes too. I like his work ethic and his attitude. He believes in doing a better than minimum code job (so do i) and he believes that that means a fair price (not dirt cheap) and so do i.
...
I know few works at Canac, unhappy with Kohler as owner.

Holmes many times exaggerate but fun to watch.

My idea of quality is for the lady from 'Everyday Italian' on Food Network
http://www.foodnetwork.com/food/hosts_celebrity_chefs/article/0,1974,FOOD_9889_1842136,00.html
on the countertop showing how to roll paste dough while I play with her cookies:p

No gaps around cabinet seams, doors that fully opens and mood spotlights to warm things up.
 
Being a contractor and also a custom cabinet maker (among other things) I also believe in Mr Holmes' attitude about doing it right the first time. Unfortunately what he never gets into is the homeowners input into the projects.

Many times (too many to mention) the homeowner makes wholesale changes to the project about halfway through and then either bickers about the added cost of this, or beats you over the head with threats of going elsewhere so you're left just covering your expenses.

Holmes also doesn't EVER mention the fact that when he comes onto a job, cost is NO object as the homeowner ISN"T paying for all the extra labour, overtime, custom this, custom that. Hell, if I had a pretty much unlimited budget I could do what he does, NO problem...Plus it is so easy to meet a budget when half the companies DONATE their time, product and or materials.

I know a supplier for that show and was hoping to meet Mr Holmes at a recent christmas party but he never showed.

Also, his pricing is out to lunch. $20,000.00 for a complete custom finished basement? Yeah ok, but what about the material costs? Oh yeah, that's right, they're DONATED but in the real world, we DON"T get home desparate to donate materials.......

Anyways, I've been on about 20 complete home renos and the CUSTOMER's input, indecision and change of mind is 90% of the problem.

ANyhow, if you want I can give you a competitive quote (I know I'm not a paid advertiser here) but if you want a cookie cutter kitchen, go with canac or one of the others. If you want a true custom kitchen, send me a PM...

Word of warning though, last kitchen I did was $40,000.00 so if that's what you're looking for, let me know.....
 
Being a Holmes fan and having my own construction skill set, i will say, I like Mike. He strikes me as a straight up guy. I am in total agreement with his attitude of building something better than code.

That being said, he makes mistakes, but not big ones.

The major thing that I see time after time on the show are safety violations. Like the one time Holmes and Shawn had a "race" to see who could trim a window the fastest. With automatic nailers. This is just plain stupid. Makes for great TV, but on a real job site, that would get your ass thrown off the site. One other time, I saw some schmuck standing in an excavation beside a basement wall that had to be 6' deep. No shoring, no 1:1 cut, no nothing. Flagrant disregard for the occupational health and saftey act. Whatever.

As far as the show goes, I betcha 90% of the people on there have gotten three quotes or more, and have gone with a guy who is stupid low. Well, what do you think was going to happen for that price?

Then they call in Holmes.

In actual truth, the people on the show have to pay for the work to be done to their house, though, the show does try to keep costs down, and undoubtedly, there are freebees. But all in all, they have to pay.
 
daty said:
I have clients come in all the time for appliances that say "I wish I had known"
eg Sub Zero or GE monogram's drawer freezers or fridges in tanden with drawer dishwashers that naturally lead to things like pot drawers etc. that will populate an island.
Also adequete ventalation that will move a total CFM of 1% of the total BTU output of a cooktop. Are you using an interior or exterior blower? Interiors are 400 to 900 CFM and exterior are 600 to 1500 CFM.
Consider a micro/convection oven if you are doing built in's and that gives you the benefits of a second oven without the expense and as an ongoing feature you can preheat and utilize 1.1 cu ft easier and CHEAPER than a full sized 4.6 cubic foot one.

Just a couple of appliance thoughts

I am using an interior blower hooked up to a 3.5" x 10" duct. I want the cook top hood to be made in wood to match the cupboards, then a fan unit mounted inside of that. I have not yet bought the fan.

I have already bought my appliances in order to aid fabrication of the cupboards. I have a gas cooktop and a separate built in oven.

I don't believe in microwaves (they cause cancer) so that won't be happening. The oven is a convection oven.

I have a small kitchen, so a HUGE fridge is not an option. (I live in the old part of the city, not out in the burbs where you can fit a fridge the size of a Buick. There is just (and I mean just) enough room to fit the fridge between the window and the basement door.
 
"In actual truth, the people on the show have to pay for the work to be done to their house, though, the show does try to keep costs down, and undoubtedly, there are freebees. But all in all, they have to pay"

I will enquire with my friend who is a supplier for the show but I can safely say if they DO in fact have to pay, they aren't paying full pop.

There was one episode where the family was broke, on the edge of losing the house, living in a motel, and had NO money (according to the show) and good ol Mikey shows up and redid the entire house. If they had to pay, how'd they pay if they had no money? I've heard various stories through the industry and the most logical is that the homeowner has to pay something but it is greatly reduced (last rumor I heard was they paid 10% and the show covered the rest).

I agree, doing it right the first time is the ONLY way but when the person paying the bills tells you to do it their way or the highway, it is oft difficult to simply walk away from a job (which I am SURE has happened to some on that show).

Have you noticed that in a lot of cases he gets the homeowners out of the house and out of the picture until he's done? THAT is basically impossible in the real world.

If I get any hard evidence on what happens in regards to payment of services I will let you know.

When you're shopping for a kitchen here's some things to look for when you're visiting their showrooms:

1) are the slides full extension ball bearing or the standard white 70% opening ones?
2) are the carcasses made of 5/8" or 3/4" melamine?
3) Are the carcasses made of Low Med or High density particle board?
4) Are the gables of the carcasses mounted on top of the bottom panels or to the sides?
5) Are the hinges Blum or ??
6) Are the hinges cheapo stamped knockoffs or are they cast zinc?
7) Are the backs of all the carcasses 1/2" or just 1/8" masonite?
8) Are the drawers constucted of 5/8" or 1/2" melamine?
9) Are all the exposed edges of the drawers taped or just the top edges?
10) Are the bottoms of the drawers 1/2" or just 1/8" masonite? If it is 1/2" is the bottom biscuited in, or is it just screwed to the sides?
12) Do they cap all exposed fasteners?
13) Are all gables drilled for shelf pins?
14) Are the shelves edge taped on all sides?
15) are the shelves 1/2" or 5/8"?

Anyhow, there's a bunch of stuff to look for, there's probably more but that's all I can think of right now.

I've installed a few "system" cabinets (Kitchenkraft was one of them) and IMHO their finish is good, but the quality leaves a lot to be desired. Plus they used only 5/8" mel on the carcasses and IMHO it isn't strong enuff for a kitchen that should last you 20 yrs. (I've seen homeowners overload a shelf and broken out the shelf pins).
 
Indeed, good cabinets, major appliances and exhaust fan are long-term investments, if kept in good condition that can make or break a real estate deal.

JTK, know what you mean about tight spaces. With my 1st house, I had to hire movers to carry appliances on their backs up long flight of stairs, as there was no way for a 2nd person to get in that space. These appliances are already the older miniature models that are hard to find.
 
"Indeed, good cabinets, major appliances and exhaust fan are long-term investments, if kept in good condition that can make or break a real estate deal."

You are right goodtime, it is proven that when you upgrade your bathroom or kitchen you will realize a 100% ROI. That is, as long as you don't put a $50,000.00 kitchen in a $150,000.00 house.

Another good investment is hardwood flooring. Whenever doing hardwood make sure you use select or better grade, the lower grade crap looks horrible with all the knots and flaws.

As for range hoods, I just did a solid cherry unit for a customer of mine and they got a great deal on a commercial blower unit from the depot. Seems someone special ordered it and then changed their minds. I think my customer paid $200.00 for it and they said it was regularly priced at $400.00. I don't remember the cfm but when I hooked it up and turned it on, it just about sucked me and all my tools into the duct work lol.