killing off a breed

Status
Not open for further replies.
The problem with the analogy between drunk driving and the pitbull issue is that the booze itself doesn't kill innocent people. To accurately compare the two you would have to invision a scenario like this: a person standing in a bar gets drunk. While he is still in the bar, his car starts itself up and runs over a person standing at a bustop OUTSIDE the bar. So no, it is NOT the same as drunk driving. If you want to stretch the analogy you could say this: driving while inpaired is like a pitbull owner SICCING the dog onto an innocent bystander.

One point many here have overlooked is the fact that in many cases where a pitbull has attacked, and sometimes killed someone, the owners WERE responsible and the dogs were always described as "oh they were so friendly and so loving, I don't know why on earth it did this". For example: the case last year where the grandmother's pitbull attacked and killed her 7 yr old (+/-) grandson. This kid had been around the dog many times before and never had a problem.

If you want an accurate analogy Tzahal this would be like you loading your gun and leaving it on the coffee table accessible by your kids. While you may teach them that they shouldn't touch it, kids being what they are they may eventually pick it up. There are millions of cases where a gun owner WAS responsible and even with trigger locks and ammunition stored separately, kids still have been killed accidentally. So if you feel that you must have a gun in your house, and I don't know if you have ammunition for it or not, and you have kids (don't know how old they are) but IMHO a gun, ammunition, and kids, all in the same place spells trouble waiting to happen.

Now if it was only the owners who were getting hurt or killed by either a pitbull or a handgun or booze, then hey, you deserve what you get. If you play with fire you have to expect to get burned once in a while.

BTW handguns ARE strictly controlled and for the sake of argument, are "banned" from the general public. One has to go through many checks before purchasing one (albeit legally) and even then you can't just go wandering around town with it in your pocket/trunk/briefcase.

If the advocates of owning pitbulls or similar dogs are so keen on keeping them around, why don't you take the next step and become part of the process to modify the law to include rigorous background checks on potential pitbull owners? You could become part of a committee that reviews pitbull breeding/ownership cases and determine who can and cannot own one of these breeds?
 
tboy said:
The problem with the analogy between drunk driving and the pitbull issue is that the booze itself doesn't kill innocent people. To accurately compare the two you would have to invision a scenario like this: a person standing in a bar gets drunk. While he is still in the bar, his car starts itself up and runs over a person standing at a bustop OUTSIDE the bar. So no, it is NOT the same as drunk driving. If you want to stretch the analogy you could say this: driving while inpaired is like a pitbull owner SICCING the dog onto an innocent bystander.



i dont see it the same way. it comes down to responsible owners. nothing more nothing less. the car starting itself up outside the bar is not close to the same. these people are letting their dogs out or are with the dogs when they are biting theswe people and dogs. many of the cases were when the dogs were being walked. they were with the dogs...the same way the drunk driver is in the cars. i dont see your scenario as the same. sorry
 
but i do believe in the rigorous testing of these people who want to own these dogfs. i have no problem with that. i have a problem with banning a breed when there is no proof that more then 50% of these dogs has ever attacked anything.
 
My son owns a pitbull. My daughter owns a pitbull. In the beginning I was freaking out about this, but in getting to know these two dogs, I have come to like them very much. There is absolutely nothing vicious about either of these dogs, because they have been treated with kindness and respect, and both have been trained.

When my daughter was moving (and was going to be homeless for about a month), she needed some place to leave her dog for the month. She couldn't find a kennel that would take her dog. I was not able to take her, and no one else could/would take her. She was forced to take the dog to the humane society. This was before the ban. She had every intention of retrieving the dog as soon as she was put up for adoption. That process takes about a month. They spay the dog, and test the dog for compatibility with other dogs and humans, then put them up for adoption. She knew her dog was very gentle and would pass the tests. Then the ban hit. She went back to retrieve her dog, and was told the dog is no longer eligible for adoption because of the ban, and that she was going to be destroyed. They said...."it's a shame because she is a very gentle dog." But because the dog had not yet been spayed, they could not give her back, and the Humane Society doesn't want to spend the money to spay animals that are going to be put down anyway. My daughter is heartbroken. BTW...the Humane Society does do a thorough check on potential putbull owners before you can adopt them.

This ban is just wrong in so many ways. I totally believe that this ban really was just a smoke screen for McGinty. Pass a law to have pitbulls and any dog for that matter, muzzled when in public, but don't condemn an entire breed for some irresponsible owners.
 
i would think the majority of the speople who want the ban have never or dont even own a dog...let alone a pit bull. or they are just carmudgeonly people. yes it is too bad when accidents happen and dogs hurt people but there is no proof that the vast majority of pit bulls are biting people so that a complete ban on them is warrented. its just that dilly dlaton needs to take some heat of his government that has done absolutly nothing that they should have or said they would by now. someone should ban mcginty for being such a boldface liar during the election...fucking knob that he is.
 
..there are plenty of breeds out there ,one less is no big deal, I hate pit bulls and am not sad to see them go.
 
assoholic said:
..there are plenty of breeds out there ,one less is no big deal, I hate pit bulls and am not sad to see them go.


thats what some of the wrong people in power are saying in sudan now. so what if we wipe out a race..who cares
 
Attorney General Michael Bryant stated the bill is borrowed from the Winnipeg model, including methods to assess dog breed. The bill in no way states or creates a model to kill off the breed. Why do you need to claim this? Such a bill, if drafted, would be stopped in parliament very quickly. Folk's, can't we find a more intelligent, not so obviously poliiticized argument to condemn actions of the present government? They've no end of serious shortcomings. Might as well blame the DM liberals for our less than spectacular summer weather.

Why are dogowners claiming personal indictment? You say you're a responsible owner, OK, we believe you. But, 100% of responsible owners cannot be 100% responsible 100% of the time. A normal, human mistake will occur of which the consequences with pitbulls are terrible. For anyone to claim anything else is disingenuous. This bill is not a personal indictment of you beautiful, responsible dog owners. Nor is it a canine indictment of a breed. Nor will this or any democratically elected government spin into insanity and ban all breeds. It is a bill simply reflecting and hence implementing controls on what's become a too dangerous, unpredictable, not completely controllable situation.

Now my diatribe. You think muzzles are enough? Think again. When a muzzled pitbull escapes and attacks, the ferocity and violence exhibited by the breed will be the same. The personal injury may not be as bad but what the fuck does that matter. The parallels to our human assault and battery laws is precise. While you claim a muzzle is enough, also explain to an assault victim that the restraining order supposedly muzzling the attacker was good enough. Grow up and drop your self indictment vanity claim.

Again, the THS has had a no euthanize policy for over a decade. Call and ask them. It seems to me the important issue is how will the policing be done as well as what will be done across Ontario with the poor ccreatures who are arrested and incarcerated.
 
tzahal said:
thats what some of the wrong people in power are saying in sudan now. so what if we wipe out a race..who cares

Genocide??? get real.

I get a laugh out of you losers who twist this ban, in ontario to mean that a breed will be wiped out... first of all, these are dogs, not people.. and how will this ban, in ontario wipe out all pitbulls, everywhere??

I guess if people are adamate that they must own a pitbull... they will have to leave the province.
 
it will wipe them all out here. and they are overreacting with this ban here because others have overreacted with it in other places. i get a laugh at losers who are losers. are you a dog owner or just someone who has no vested interest in this at all. ever been bitten by a pitt bull or are you just hopping on board for the betterment of all mankind?
 
This group shocks me! I can not believe that there are so many people here believe these dogs are the biggest threat to their safety. They sight no proof except there views brought to them threw the media who's only purpose is to sell commercials..... If you own a house and own a PB your house insurance would be responsible for a lawsuit if your dog bit someone...... why haven't they revoked insurance to owners of these dogs and not other breeds? In fact some companies give a discount if you have a dog because you are less likely to be broken into.
WhOiSyOdAdDy ? is a perfect example of someone that has to call people names like losers and when he should take a good long look in the mirror......... Ontario would be better off with PB's and without him........ he should move to where PB's aren't .... I have never owned a PB and probably never will as they are not the breed for me, but I resent someone telling me, a responsible adult a Canadian!! that I can't when I know that they are and that is not a problem yet alone someone that knows nothing about dogs is telling me how to live and what is right and what is the truth ........
To you the supporters of the ban what are you credentials when it comes to dogs and their behavior .......... ahhh just a scared little man I can tell
b d
 
..equating Genocide with the banning of a breed tells me you care more about the dogs then people, that was a ridiculous analogy.
 
Big dogie, we never said they were "the biggest threat to our safety". Don't invent or twist reasons to support your own arguments. The argument FOR the banning of this breed (and as the new law will state "similar breeds") is that they are an unnecessary risk.

If you are going to use the argument that owning a dog will reduce your insurance rates then there are many MANY other breeds that will protect your property. The key word here is DEFENSE or DEFEND not attack or assault which is what the PB's are doing.

You cannot deny that PB attacks are, in many cases, lethal. While maybe attacks by other breeds are not as publicized, you can bet your ass they would be if a death was the result. You also cannot deny that in cities where they have banned pb ownership, the attacks have dropped from 1 a month to less than 1 a year. IMHO the bans work!

Don't get so high and mighty about someone telling you what you can, and cannot own or what you can or cannot do. Our whole society is based on rules set out by our politicians and our society. New laws and new rules are generally passed whenever a need arises. In this case, society feels that a ban on these breeds is needed.

If you don't like living in a democratic society where majority rules, you have ever right to move to a country or province that has rules that you agree with.
 
These dogs serve no purpose for being in a metropolis, like TO. If you live on a farm or have your own large piece of land- maybe.

If my child or loved one was ever attacked by one of these monsters, I'd go after the owner, in the same way.

Eye for an eye.
 
[
the toronto humane society has 178 dogs currently 152 of which are pitt bulls.. [/B]


Does this not tell you something, there ARE people out there who don't want them because of their viciousness. The statistics prove it...these dogs can snap at any time, and even the owner can't stop them.
 
How many more children will be needlessly killed or maimed, scarred and traumatized for life before people who are against this ban change their mind?

Sure dogs can be muzzled when they are in pulic. What if they get out of the house or backyard without knowledge of the owner?

People who make use of their privilege to drive must purchase liability insurance, people who want the privilege to own a pitbull should also be forced to purchase liability insurance, as well as face a minimum 5 year sentence if their dog attacks someone.. or someone else's pet.

It has been legislated that people may not own many types of exotic / dangerous animals as pets, that people may have once owned. Why should pit bulls be exempt?

After countless incidents were law enforcement has been called upon to protect the public from these canine terrorists, I am sure that every police force in ontario is in favour of this ban as it usually takes more than 1 or 2 bullets to put down one of the animlas on a rampage.

The majority of people FEAR pitbulls. Because a few people think they should be allowed to own a pit bull, the rest of society should live in fear? That is not the way our society works. The ban is long overdue
 
I have read enough about them that I would not trust them. They are not even meant to be a guard dog. If I wanted a guard doy I would purchase a Lab. They are loyal to thier owners and protective of their owners but are not trained to be fighters. I had a Lab as a young girl and she was perfect in every aspect of the way playful friendly and protective of me and well trained. Literally she would never harm anyone unless I said the word and she was very instinctive of my feelings as well. I miss that dog she truly was mans best friend. In my opinion that is the way a dog should be. Truly trustworthy.
 
Re: Re: killing off a breed

The Bandit said:
Does this not tell you something, there ARE people out there who don't want them because of their viciousness. The statistics prove it...these dogs can snap at any time, and even the owner can't stop them.

the humane society has that many pits because of

a. puppy mills
b. abuse or misuse of the dog
c. the treatment and training the dogs go through in which the humane society saves them from so they are not attack dogs
d.people who cant handle the breed once it grows up.. they kick ass as puppies but most people dont know that in order to have an obedient dog they need to do continuous training.
e. unlike other breeds the humane society goes through an extensive background check for who is able and capable to care for these dogs unlike the other breeds they have


I will be going tomorrow morning to go make an application for a pup named tiny who is a big suck and cuddler even tho he is a pitty.

the negative rep proceeds these dogs and what they are actually capable of.. too bad most people dont realize what good pets they make the automatic assumption is they are bad
 
WhOiSyOdAdDy? said:
How many more children will be needlessly killed or maimed, scarred and traumatized for life before people who are against this ban change their mind?

Sure dogs can be muzzled when they are in pulic. What if they get out of the house or backyard without knowledge of the owner?

People who make use of their privilege to drive must purchase liability insurance, people who want the privilege to own a pitbull should also be forced to purchase liability insurance, as well as face a minimum 5 year sentence if their dog attacks someone.. or someone else's pet.

It has been legislated that people may not own many types of exotic / dangerous animals as pets, that people may have once owned. Why should pit bulls be exempt?

After countless incidents were law enforcement has been called upon to protect the public from these canine terrorists, I am sure that every police force in ontario is in favour of this ban as it usually takes more than 1 or 2 bullets to put down one of the animlas on a rampage.

The majority of people FEAR pitbulls. Because a few people think they should be allowed to own a pit bull, the rest of society should live in fear? That is not the way our society works. The ban is long overdue

"Terrorists." ... "Menaces to society." ... "Parasites." ... "The work of the devil."

The Salem witches. The German "Jewish Problem". McCarthy's "Red Menace".

The fact that "the majority of the people" fear something is a TERRIBLE reason to ban it, and has been used to justify some of the most heinous of acts perpetrated by mankind. But, it's used by those who would manipulate you, or who are just stupid to begin with, because they are either unwilling or unable to back up their arguments with facts and reason.

This is what happens when you let the idiots loose, and critical thinking and rational thought are replaced by rhetoric and mob mentality.

I find it interesting that pit bulls are often referred to as "devil dogs".

WIYD's post illustrates the idiocy surrounding the controversy - appeal for the welfare of the children, appeal to the fear of the mob, the repeated use of labels, analogies based upon presuppositions, false statistics - just a hideous mess of bad logic and rhetoric.

Rather than banning a breed of dog, we should be banning the much more dangerous segment of society - idiots like this.
 
..it seems like 80 % of the time I see a pit bull its owner looks like somebody with a chip on their shoulder, those dogs are their for intimidation purposes not companionship.I have no sympathy for the dogs or the owners who may now have to get through life without their buddy to intimidate people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.