Kerry on Iraq

DonQuixote said:
Read my post about being a grunt in the war you
so realish. You're about as real as a wooden nickel.


When was the last time you put your ass on the line.
All bluster, all BS. Others sacrifice so you can
bluster. BS dear sir. BS.

I've never been through what you've been through, and I must say honestly I'm glad for it. I think in every war your story would be told, not that that fact diminishes the importance of it but amplifies the importance of the sacrifice made by those who serve.

If you think that only people who've been in combat can comment on how military might can be used, then fair enough - I wouldn't agree but I'd respect the perspective. What do you think those who are serving now think about the value of their service?

Your story is important because it is real, it happened, it's personal and not just a statistic. That is no less true for those who died today in Iraq, for those children who died under UNSC sanctions or to Nick Berg. To say I "relish" this war and "bluster" is a bit unfair, IMHO, but at the end of the day you've been there and have earned your opinion.

OTB
 
The_Jaded_One said:

You contain a dictator through bribery and boosting his economy. Saddam Hussein wasn't gonna bite the hand that fed him. Let's get real.
.

This is, with out a doubt, the stupidest thing ever written on TERB. Be proud my friend because that is some accomplishment.

OTB
 
Don said:
Jeez! Don't you guys get tired of arguing politics all day?

Its night now ;-)

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
This is, with out a doubt, the stupidest thing ever written on TERB. Be proud my friend because that is some accomplishment.

OTB

Please tell me you aren't really this stupid and naive. Force is the worst way to exert control over a situation and is only temporary in measure. You have a power vacuum in Iraq and if SH doesn't rule by a dictatorship it will only be someone else. Knowing this you have to work with the political structure in place, and you do that by bribery and boosting his economy. The bribery keeps him happy and boosting the economy keeps his people happy so SH doesn't have to worry about a coup and if you put that in place for him he will do what you want. If you don't think bribery works to obtain a political end just look at the United States. You went to war for big business contracts and Bush, Cheney and Co. did it all for the dirty money. It works like a charm every time.
 
The_Jaded_One said:
Please tell me you aren't really this stupid and naive. Force is the worst way to exert control over a situation and is only temporary in measure. You have a power vacuum in Iraq and if SH doesn't rule by a dictatorship it will only be someone else. Knowing this you have to work with the political structure in place, and you do that by bribery and boosting his economy. The bribery keeps him happy and boosting the economy keeps his people happy so SH doesn't have to worry about a coup and if you put that in place for him he will do what you want. If you don't think bribery works to obtain a political end just look at the United States. You went to war for big business contracts and Bush, Cheney and Co. did it all for the dirty money. It works like a charm every time.

You know you're right, it worked so well for Neville Chamberlain....

I used to think you were a smart guy, wrong much of the time, but that’s just because you don’t have much life experience. Now I know, you are the village idiot….

OTB
 
Re: No

DonQuixote said:
We're Americans. It's our birthright. Next to debating religion
and enjoying sex it's the most fun we have. Give us our space.
We don't have a queen, we just have rancour. And
we love it. That's the price of being a democracy.
OTB and I are more alike than different.

As Mr. Franklin once said:

"In those wretched countries where a man cannot call his tongue his own, he can scarce call anything his own. Whoever would overthrow the liberty of a nation must begin by subduing the freeness of speech."

Battle on.....

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
You know you're right, it worked so well for Neville Chamberlain....

The difference being Chamberlain had no bargaining power and he was offering what Hitler was gonna take anyway. Bribery doesn't work unless you are offering something that the other can't acquire on their own w/o having to do your bidding. I probably should have said that initially but I thought that much was obvious. The United States was in a position of power where they could offer Saddam Hussein material economic gains that he couldn’t otherwise get and could militarily contain him with ease. The two situations are TOTALLY different.
 
bbking said:
I may not have mispoken after all - I was reading my Time mag. and I noticed that they where reporting that according to the new Congressional Budget Office report that the top 1% got an average tax cut of $78,460 which seemed rather large for an annual income of 200k to 300k, so I looked up the report:

http://www.cbo.gov/showdoc.cfm?index=5746&sequence=2&from=0

Hell an income of 200K doesn't even make it to the top 10. I really should learn to trust my instincts. What gets me hear is how Bush go out on the stump and lie and say that Kerry's tax hikes (which are really rollbacks) of the top 2% would effect Small business owners beacuse these hikes would effect incomes over 200k. Even more surprising is why Karry doesn't call Bush's sorry ass on this.
One thing I couldn't help notice was the huge gap within the middle class for income.

Jaded One - instead of a separte post I thought I would add it hear - as for Chamberlain and no bargaining chip, your wrong - he had a big one, cheap access to oil, something Hitler needed in a big way.

bbk

Kerry is proposing a tax increase (or roll back of tax cut, all the same thing) for anyone making more than 200k, as you said, doesn't even make it into the top 10%. This is the segment that pays the bills in the US.

OTB
 
bbking said:
Jaded One - instead of a separte post I thought I would add it hear - as for Chamberlain and no bargaining chip, your wrong - he had a big one, cheap access to oil, something Hitler needed in a big way.

You are still missing the difference. Hitler's ambition was to create an Aryan nation and rule the world. He didn't have to concede anything to Chamberlain since the balance of power was hugely in his favour at the time and he could get what he wanted by force. Bribery can't work with a bully that has power over you. It is like trying to bribe a robber with a gun who is holding you at gunpoint by offering him $20.00 not to rob you when he can easily steal what is in your wallet for $100.00.

With the Iraq situation the US called the shots and had Saddam Hussein contained big time. It was in Saddam Hussein's benefit to take the bribes b/c that was the best he could do given the balance of power. Hitler thought/knew he could do way better than the concessions/bribes Chamberlain was offering and Chamberlain had no power to enforce anything on Hitler, so the situation was ineffective for bribery.
 
onthebottom said:
Sure, how about:

- Madeline Albright, Clinton Secretary of State, Nov. 10, 1999
- Letter to President Bush, Signed by Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL,) and
others, December 5, 2001
- Sen. Carl Levin (D, MI), Sept. 19, 2002
- Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002
- Sen. Ted Kennedy (D, MA), Sept. 27, 2002
- Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Oct. 9, 2002
OTB

And all of these quotes are from before the inspectors being allowed back into Iraq, so that makes them about as relevant as pointing out that Bush said prior to 9/11 that he didn't believe in nation building.

How about this quote:

“What really happened for the analysts is they had two levels of evidence,� he said.

“Anything that would confirm WMD in Iraq – very little scrutiny. Anything that showed Iraq didn’t have weapons of mass destruction, had a much higher gate to pass because if it were true, all of US policy towards Iraq would have fallen asunder. "

Or this one:

“I think the Prime Minister as I would say the US President should have been able to tell before the war that the evidence did not exist for drawing the conclusion that Iraq presented a clear, present and imminent threat on the basis of existing weapons of mass destruction,� he said.

“That was not something that required a war and inspectors like myself going in if you’d fairly interpreted the evidence that existed.�

David Kay - July 18, 2004.

http://news.scotsman.com/latest.cfm?id=3221103
 
Ickabod said:
And all of these quotes are from before the inspectors being allowed back into Iraq, so that makes them about as relevant as pointing out that Bush said prior to 9/11 that he didn't believe in nation building.

How about this quote:

“What really happened for the analysts is they had two levels of evidence,� he said.

“Anything that would confirm WMD in Iraq – very little scrutiny. Anything that showed Iraq didn’t have weapons of mass destruction, had a much higher gate to pass because if it were true, all of US policy towards Iraq would have fallen asunder. "

Or this one:

“I think the Prime Minister as I would say the US President should have been able to tell before the war that the evidence did not exist for drawing the conclusion that Iraq presented a clear, present and imminent threat on the basis of existing weapons of mass destruction,� he said.

“That was not something that required a war and inspectors like myself going in if you’d fairly interpreted the evidence that existed.�

David Kay - July 18, 2004.

http://news.scotsman.com/latest.cfm?id=3221103

I don't think those were the conclusions of either inquiry (US or UK). You have to follow the whole thread to see why I used old quotes (JTE and others said Bush lied and that's why everyone voted for war, I said they believed it before W was elected).

I do think that because "everyone" believed it that they tended to discount other views, I also think that because SH kept kicking out inspectors we were drawing the wrong conclusion from that action.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I don't think those were the conclusions of either inquiry (US or UK).

No, just the conclusions of the guy who was hand picked by Bush to go to Iraq and do the looking.

You have to follow the whole thread to see why I used old quotes

You used old quotes because that's all you had. As evidenced by your bringing out quotes from 2002 after being confronted with the age of the quotes you used from 1998. And frankly, i don't care about who thought what or when. It was Bush's job, not theirs, to make sure we don't get into the fiasco we're now in unless we're right. He screwed up, a screw up of epic proportions when talking war, and he needs to be held accountable. He asked for the job and with that comes the responsiblity involved. It's on him. And even assuming it's the fault of the intelligence agency, you have no right to hold him blameless for that if you dare come on here and praise him if the CIA or FBI does something right.

I wonder what you would think of a CEO if you bought stock based on what that CEO was saying about the company based on what his people were telling him......only to have that stock tank because he was shown to be wrong. With the very real possiblity that he knew he was wrong as he was convincing you to buy it.

(JTE and others said Bush lied and that's why everyone voted for war, I said they believed it before W was elected).

http://www.villagevoice.com/issues/0240/ridgeway3.php

The facts suggest otherwise. In a September 7 press conference with Prime Minister Blair, Bush leaned on what he called a report from the International Atomic Energy Commission, based on Hussein's nixing of inspections in 1998. "I would remind you that when the inspectors first went into Iraq and were denied—finally denied—access, a report came out...that they were six months away from developing a weapon," the president said. "I don’t know what more evidence we need."

But last week the commission claimed that no such document exists. "There’s never been a report like that issued from this agency," Mark Gwozdecky, head of the group, told Reuters last week.

Asked why Bush referred to an apparently imaginary document, the White House claimed he was really talking about a report from 1991. But Gwozdecky told Reuters no paper to that effect was issued by his agency in 1991, either.


What part of that wasn't a lie?

I do think that because "everyone" believed it that they tended to discount other views, I also think that because SH kept kicking out inspectors we were drawing the wrong conclusion from that action.

Or you could say that "everyone" believed it because other views were discounted. I stopped believing it specifically because i was seeking out and hearing the other views. Interesting that large amounts of people were saying he was lying before the war, he turned out to be wrong on just about everything he was saying, yet we're now supposed to believe he wasn't lying? Yeah, ok.
 
bbking said:
Was it Worldcom or the Bankers that caused this mess - and lets not forget some very greedy investors had their hand in this.
bbk

A pretty surreal analogy. The Bush administration as Worldcom - putting out the false info, we the people as the bankers for blindly following along (well, some of us), and certainly, there are plenty of people making a financial killing out of this whole thing.