Keesmaat: Tear Down This Wall

We HogTowners are not so stupid as we'd have to be to make your imagined chaos into reality.

You apparently think the evidence is that Toronto has always planned and responded wisely in response to traffic congestion concerns, and therefore will do so again. Most people who have to frequently travel around this city think the evidence points to the opposite conclusion. I just took a 1 hour and 45 minutes trip this morning that takes 35 minutes at the posted speed limits. As a result, "just trust us" sounds like an absurd argument to many.

I think too many Torontonians have an insular view of the city, and don't realize just how dependent everything it offers is on the ability to attract commuters to work here, the ability of businesses to efficiently pick up and deliver goods here, and the ability of people employed in a vast array of occupations to travel efficiently around the city during the work day. You can build the entire city to be one great big lovely park, but then don't be surprised when it quickly falls into neglect when the tax base dries up.
 
You apparently think the evidence is that Toronto has always planned and responded wisely in response to traffic congestion concerns, and therefore will do so again. Most people who have to frequently travel around this city think the evidence points to the opposite conclusion. I just took a 1 hour and 45 minutes trip this morning that takes 35 minutes at the posted speed limits. As a result, "just trust us" sounds like an absurd argument to many.

I think too many Torontonians have an insular view of the city, and don't realize just how dependent everything it offers is on the ability to attract commuters to work here, the ability of businesses to efficiently pick up and deliver goods here, and the ability of people employed in a vast array of occupations to travel efficiently around the city during the work day. You can build the entire city to be one great big lovely park, but then don't be surprised when it quickly falls into neglect when the tax base dries up.

That's some dumb ass trip planning to take an alleged 35 minute road trip and turn into an alleged 1 hr 45 minute fiasco.

Should planners make allowances for such dumb ass drivers and to what degree?
 
You apparently think the evidence is that Toronto has always planned and responded wisely in response to traffic congestion concerns, and therefore will do so again. Most people who have to frequently travel around this city think the evidence points to the opposite conclusion. I just took a 1 hour and 45 minutes trip this morning that takes 35 minutes at the posted speed limits. As a result, "just trust us" sounds like an absurd argument to many.

I think too many Torontonians have an insular view of the city, and don't realize just how dependent everything it offers is on the ability to attract commuters to work here, the ability of businesses to efficiently pick up and deliver goods here, and the ability of people employed in a vast array of occupations to travel efficiently around the city during the work day. You can build the entire city to be one great big lovely park, but then don't be surprised when it quickly falls into neglect when the tax base dries up.
In spite of one lousy trip on one lousy day, the overall evidence is that Toronto still attracts businesses and people (which requires constant building and adjustments everywhere) and continues to be the successful "economic engine blah blah". It does that with the inconvenience those constantly needed improvements create.

And you did get where you had to go.

As with explorerzip, I'd appreciate you responding to the topic, or to what I actually said, not to what you imagine I "apparently think". Your record on that score isn't good, likely because I'm not good at saying what you want to read.

To make it easy: Providing more roads for more private cars is wrongheaded and creates gridlock that strangles the City. That extends to maintaining needlessly expensive, deteriorating roads in the sky that do nothing for people living and moving around on the real world, making the City work. In Cities we need roads to move commerce and people; the sooner and faster we get over-sized, mostly empty cars off them the better for all of us.

But that's for another thread, this one's about getting rid of another small part of the Gardiner.
 
That's some dumb ass trip planning to take an alleged 35 minute road trip and turn into an alleged 1 hr 45 minute fiasco.

Should planners make allowances for such dumb ass drivers and to what degree?

Planners work for dumb ass business people doing dumb ass business, as they must, during the dumb ass business day, taking the dumb ass roads available to reach their destinations, so that dumb ass commercial businesses can continue to pay dumb ass commercial property taxes and other dumb ass business licensing fees to continue to subsidize the dumb ass artificially low residential property taxes that Torontonians enjoy so much. That's exactly what should inform planning decisions.

Whereas, they should pretty much ignore the transportation planning views of dumb ass TERB posters who never need to leave their little enclaves.
 
Planners work for dumb ass business people doing dumb ass business, as they must, during the dumb ass business day, taking the dumb ass roads available to reach their destinations, so that dumb ass commercial businesses can continue to pay dumb ass commercial property taxes and other dumb ass business licensing fees to continue to subsidize the dumb ass artificially low residential property taxes that Torontonians enjoy so much. That's exactly what should inform planning decisions.

Whereas, they should pretty much ignore the transportation planning views of dumb ass TERB posters who never need to leave their little enclaves.
Glad to read you think Torontonians should pay higher taxes to give you better roads to drive around. You did say you lived within the City limits didn't you?
 
Glad to read you think Torontonians should pay higher taxes to give you better roads to drive around. You did say you lived within the City limits didn't you?

I think they could provide better roads with the existing tax base. The arts funding alone would fill a lot of potholes!

My point to Anne of Rubber Bandy is that you shouldn't push commercial business to the outskirts by neglecting transportation planning. That's how you end up with a hollowed out city.
 
I think they could provide better roads with the existing tax base. The arts funding alone would fill a lot of potholes!

My point to Anne of Rubber Bandy is that you shouldn't push commercial business to the outskirts by neglecting transportation planning. That's how you end up with a hollowed out city.
Nonetheless, you did call "the existing tax base"…"dumb ass artificially low residential property taxes". Just how that "could provide better roads" when it clearly can't even maintain existing ones is an explanation — a plan if you like — that you owe us. Otherwise we'll have to credit you with a version of English all your own.

And just by-the-bye, do reassure us you're not one of those out-of-town suburbanites who drive in from places like Mrs Sauga or Markham and bitch about Toronto roads you drive on for free.
 
Glad to read you think Torontonians should pay higher taxes to give you better roads to drive around. You did say you lived within the City limits didn't you?

Nonetheless, you did call "the existing tax base"…"dumb ass artificially low residential property taxes". Just how that "could provide better roads" when it clearly can't even maintain existing ones is an explanation — a plan if you like — that you owe us. Otherwise we'll have to credit you with a version of English all your own.

And just by-the-bye, do reassure us you're not one of those out-of-town suburbanites who drive in from places like Mrs Sauga or Markham and bitch about roads you drive on for free.
That is what struck me with his dumb ass, trip planning induced road rage like reply.

Obviously a 'perpetually aggrieved by Toronto' elitist 905'er trying to impose his will on Toronto.

He chooses to live in the vast expanses of suburbia but refuses to take responsibility for his decision. In fact, he expects we Torontonians to bow to his will and subsidize his lifestyle.
 
Actually what you called the existing tax base was: "the dumb ass artificially low residential property taxes" Just how that can pay for better roads when it clearly can't even maintain existing ones is an explanation — a plan if you like — that you owe us. Otherwise we'll have to credit you with a version if English all your own.

And just by-the-bye, do reassure us you're not one of those out-of-town suburbanites who drive in from places like Mrs Sauga or Markham and bitch about roads you drive on for free.

No, the tax base is comprised of the commercial property taxpayers AND the dumb ass artificially low residential property taxpayers.

While I don't divulge personal information here on TERB, there are no free roads or transit systems for suburbanites who commute. First of all, as every candidate for mayor acknowledges, large capital projects (roads or public transit) are supported by the Province. That means all Ontarians pay for them. Two, there is much higher disparity in the 905 between taxation levels and government spending than there is in Toronto. As a result, the 905 effectively subsidizes Toronto.

The City of Toronto still spends a great deal of money on what I will call, to be generous, "non-core services". Arts funding is just one example. A good start would be for Toronto to admit it is under performing in its core responsibilities, focus its spending on that, and then let's see where we are. Large capital projects (like an aggressive expansion of public transit) should be largely shouldered by the Province, as I've already stated that the success of Toronto as the hub of Ontario commerce is important to the entire province.

Let's start with easy decisions:

1. Redirect non-core spending to core spending, like road repair and maintenance.

2. Don't eliminate any current roads.

3. Don't reduce current road capacity with any more dumb ass bike lanes (and remove the dumbest of them).
 
I think they could provide better roads with the existing tax base. The arts funding alone would fill a lot of potholes!

My point to Anne of Rubber Bandy is that you shouldn't push commercial business to the outskirts by neglecting transportation planning. That's how you end up with a hollowed out city.
"They" as opposed to "we".

"They" as in the elected representatives of those actually residing in Toronto as opposed to the "we" who like you don't reside in Toronto but in the 905.

Yet the "we", which is also YOU, from the 905 feel it is imperative to impose their and your will in jurisdictions where you actually have no standing.


Let's start with the easy decision:

1) Butt out of jurisdictions where you and your fellow 905'ers have no standing.
 
"They" as opposed to "we".

"They" as in the elected representatives of those actually residing in Toronto as opposed to the "we" who like you don't reside in Toronto but in the 905.

Yet the "we", which is also YOU, from the 905 feel it is imperative to impose their and your will in jurisdictions where you actually have no standing.


Let's start with the easy decision:

1) Butt out of jurisdictions where you and your fellow 905'ers have no standing.

Well, Columbo, I guess you could fairly conclude that I am neither a Toronto councillor or mayor, nor a Toronto city planner, and that I eschew the Royal we. After that, you're out on thin ice on a very sunny day. (p.s. What did you make of the "we" in post #49. LOL!)

Besides, didn't I already explain why the planning of Toronto's transportation infrastructure is important to the entire province? (And, without attaching this comment to myself, I think you're also forgetting about circumstances which give some people a direct say in the municipal politics of more than one municipality).

I am disappointed, however, in having been urged to make some simple concrete suggestions, that your only response is "I'm not listening!". Maybe that's the unwritten subtext of all your posts.
 
It's obvious you're having a really bad day which commenced with piss poor trip planning decisions this morning navigating through a land foreign to whichever 905 vast suburban, free flowing commuting landscape to which you rightly belong to and choose to reside in.

Still waiting as to how this particular indignant 905'er and others feel that their voices are somehow as relevant to this particular discussion regarding the eastern Gardiner than those 416'ers who are actually impacted by it, not just as a way of saving 2 minutes of commuting time in and out, but as it effects their daily lives by actually live there 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, week after week, month after month......

And let's not forget that the City of Toronto has jurisdiction over the DVP/Gardiner, not the Province nor you 905'ers, and that the City and it's taxpayers, not the Province nor you 905'ers, are paying for their operation, upkeep and their possible future redesigns to which the Province and the 905'ers contribute not one bloody red cent.

It's obvious you reside in a west or northwest 905 suburban enclave and are not impacted by the eastern end of the Gardiner.

Surgical, suburban commuting strikes into and out of the downtown core or areas nearby are obviously not your forte, nor should they take prominence in any discussion regarding a livable city for those who actually live in the city.
 
It's obvious you're having a really bad day which commenced with piss poor trip planning decisions this morning navigating through a land foreign to whichever 905 vast suburban, free flowing commuting landscape to which you rightly belong to and choose to reside in.

Still waiting as to how this particular indignant 905'er and others feel that their voices are somehow as relevant to this particular discussion regarding the eastern Gardiner than those 416'ers who are actually impacted by it, not just as a way of saving 2 minutes of commuting time in and out, but as it effects their daily lives by actually live there 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, week after week, month after month......

It's obvious you reside in a west or northwest 905 suburban enclave and are not impacted by the eastern end of the Gardiner.

Sorry for calling you Columbo. Columbo often got things right. You're more of an Inspector Clouseau.

Maybe I could entice you to answer to one of my points. Don't you think that Toronto's place as the hub of Ontario commerce gives all Ontarians a say in the transportation planning of the city? If not, why not?
 
Sorry for calling you Columbo. Columbo often got things right. You're more of an Inspector Clouseau.

Maybe I could entice you to answer to one of my points. Don't you think that Toronto's place as the hub of Ontario commerce gives all Ontarians a say in the transportation planning of the city? If not, why not?
LOL.

If only you could take your talent for veering off into oblique tangents in any discussion that you have on Terb and apply it to your catastrophic trip planning travails through this foreign city you may actually find an alternate route or two that will take you in the style and comfort you are accustomed to, to your temporary destination in a land that you are foreign and alien to.
 
LOL.

If only you could take your talent for veering off into oblique tangents in any discussion that you have on Terb and apply it to your catastrophic trip planning travails through this foreign city you may actually find an alternate route or two that will take you in the style and comfort you are accustomed to, to your temporary destination in a land that you are foreign and alien to.

Playing tennis on two separate courts gets old quickly. See you next time.
 
Hopefully you'll take 'the lessons learned' in this thread and apply it to your self-induced torturous commute back home to your insulated suburban enclave in 905 nirvana land.

The day I learn something from you, I'll be sure to let you know. It didn't happen today.
 
No, the tax base is comprised of the commercial property taxpayers AND the dumb ass artificially low residential property taxpayers.

While I don't divulge personal information here on TERB, there are no free roads or transit systems for suburbanites who commute. First of all, as every candidate for mayor acknowledges, large capital projects (roads or public transit) are supported by the Province. That means all Ontarians pay for them. Two, there is much higher disparity in the 905 between taxation levels and government spending than there is in Toronto. As a result, the 905 effectively subsidizes Toronto.

The City of Toronto still spends a great deal of money on what I will call, to be generous, "non-core services". Arts funding is just one example. A good start would be for Toronto to admit it is under performing in its core responsibilities, focus its spending on that, and then let's see where we are. Large capital projects (like an aggressive expansion of public transit) should be largely shouldered by the Province, as I've already stated that the success of Toronto as the hub of Ontario commerce is important to the entire province.

Let's start with easy decisions:

1. Redirect non-core spending to core spending, like road repair and maintenance.

2. Don't eliminate any current roads.

3. Don't reduce current road capacity with any more dumb ass bike lanes (and remove the dumbest of them).
So the 905 is the engine of the engine? And the taxes Toronto ships upstream to the Province don't outweigh the bits and bobs it gets back from Bewdley and Brampton along with some of our own money? It is to laugh.

When you lead the Plug Party to a majority Victory at City Hall or Queen's Park, that platform of yours will be more than one person's opinion. Some easily better planks IMHO:

1. Moving people effectively and safely through the city is a core function, so the easiest best decision is to make space-clogging, road-hogging killer cars entirely secondary to that: Mass transit, and individual transit by shared car, bike and foot always prioritized before any private car-related spending. And commercial vehicles making the City work always prioritized over personal automobiles on the roads left for cars and trucks.

2. No foolishly over-broad pronouncements, on roads or anything.

3. Bike lanes should be everywhere in the City; Picovian tolls, taxes, rents, and permits to monetize and discourage any use of City roadways and private and City properties as parking lots, and to finance safe, protected bike lanes, pedestrian crossings and pedestrian squares and malls throughout the City.
-------------
PS your response on whether we should read your opinions as a fellow Torontonian or an out-of town visitor seems to have been eliminated by the VBB software. As a sort of default, I'll take it that you speak from the wisdom of distance rather than close personal involvement
 
On June 3, 1971, Davis rose in the Provincial Legislature and stated:

Cities were built for people and not cars. If we are building a transportation system to serve the automobile, the Spadina Expressway would be a good place to start. But if we are building a transportation system to serve people, the Spadina Expressway is a good place to stop.
— Bill Davis, June 1971

Almost 50 years later and we still have to try to drag these backward Neanderthals into the present, never mind the future.
 
"The river I step in is not the river I stand in". Gosh! Who knew! Every place is a different place from every other. What a world of marvels we inhabit! Thank you for that immense spiritual insight!

Now, it's your turn: Kindly make a point about what you quoted, or at least about the topic.

You brought up the point about the area between Leslie and the Don, which is not even the area we're talking about. I brought up the point of the area of Jarvis, Lakeshore and the Gardiner, which is the area we're talking about.

Since searching is apparently tough let's contrast the two areas shall we?

Here's the area of the DVP and Lakeshore: https://goo.gl/maps/Vq3X352Qrmv

Not sure if you noticed, but I see mostly low density residential and some industrial / commercial areas including the old Unilever factory. There are 3 major intersection in that area: The Don Roadway leading north to the DVP, Carlaw and Leslie.

Here's the area of the Gardiner near Jarvis: https://goo.gl/maps/JLkU4soMBvT2

I see a lot more high rises and 4 major intersections namely: Jarvis, Sherbourne, Parliament and Cherry Street. I'll admit that I don't get down the St. Lawrence Market area that often, but the traffic has been crazy the few times I've been in the last few months. That was at noon time. Even right now (9pm on a Thursday night) the traffic is quite heavy.

What do you think will happen when we close the intersection of Lower Jarvis and Lakeshore for Gardiner demolition work? That traffic has to go somewhere and it will be forced onto King, Front, Sherbourne, Parliament, etc. Ditto for the "small number of cars" that will be exiting the DVP at Eastern Avenue or Bayview to get to downtown during construction.

I can also admit that I don't know how long it takes to do demolish a small section of the bridge deck, but it's not a short time. Then we start that process over again at the intersection of Sherboune and Lakeshore, Parliament and Lakeshore, and Cherry and Lakeshore.

Here's an example of a so-called "grand boulevard" or at least it was pitched that way. https://goo.gl/maps/bcTTeL8ax942

In Richmond Hill, there's a stretch of Highway 7 near Leslie that has a VIVA bus lane (including special red paint) down the middle of it. There's bike lanes on each side, beautiful (and overly complex) glass bus shelters, concrete planters in the middle of the road with flowers and even concrete signs in front of the bus-shelter to tell you what the street names. Naturally, those concrete planters and signs are prime targets for cars that can't quite make a left turn.

Here's the reality: the middle lanes of Hihgway 7 were closed to make way for the bus lane and the overly complex and expensive shelters. When they were done in the middle, the right lanes were closed to build those bike lanes. You'd think that would be it, but they closed the right lanes a second time to paint the bike lanes green and make the pavement markings.

Then they closed the middle lanes again so they could put those flower planters and install those concrete signs. As far as I know, that areas is still an active construction zone. I can't say exactly how long it has been, but it certainly feels like the city of Richmond Hill has been toiling there for years! Sure it looks all nice, but traffic has not improved appreciably in that area and might have gotten worse. There's essentially been construction in that area for years (and they're still not finished.) There's not even a roadway on top or limited space, or lots of high-rises, etc.

As a result, I have no confidence the city of Toronto can be any more efficient in pulling off this kind of project.
 
No, the tax base is comprised of the commercial property taxpayers AND the dumb ass artificially low residential property taxpayers.

While I don't divulge personal information here on TERB, there are no free roads or transit systems for suburbanites who commute. First of all, as every candidate for mayor acknowledges, large capital projects (roads or public transit) are supported by the Province. That means all Ontarians pay for them. Two, there is much higher disparity in the 905 between taxation levels and government spending than there is in Toronto. As a result, the 905 effectively subsidizes Toronto.

The City of Toronto still spends a great deal of money on what I will call, to be generous, "non-core services". Arts funding is just one example. A good start would be for Toronto to admit it is under performing in its core responsibilities, focus its spending on that, and then let's see where we are. Large capital projects (like an aggressive expansion of public transit) should be largely shouldered by the Province, as I've already stated that the success of Toronto as the hub of Ontario commerce is important to the entire province.

Let's start with easy decisions:

1. Redirect non-core spending to core spending, like road repair and maintenance.

2. Don't eliminate any current roads.

3. Don't reduce current road capacity with any more dumb ass bike lanes (and remove the dumbest of them).

Or reconfigure an existing road (Queen's Quay) so that it's totally different and counter-intuitive vs all other roads in the city. Where streetcar tracks suddenly (and for no good reason) move from the middle to the the south side of the road. Then the roadway moves to the north side and they have to install a myriad of road signs and dedicated signals, etc.