Karla Movie

Who will go see the Karla Movie?

  • I don't want to see it.

    Votes: 26 34.2%
  • I would like to see it.

    Votes: 32 42.1%
  • I don't care.

    Votes: 18 23.7%

  • Total voters
    76
Questor said:
I didn't really think they owned it. I believe they would be prevented by law from profiting in this way. But I think you may have missed my central point. As long as they aren't profiting from it, what is the big deal? Why not make a movie about it? And why do you care if anyone goes to see it?
This was a very sick crime...It involved everything bad about society...
Torture, rape and murder of young girls....

If you don't think it is a big deal then you don't have to participate in this thread. Bottom line.
 
Questor I am not going to debate this issue with you.. these are my feelings, I am not asking you to share them.. Thank You.
 
A-ROD said:
This was a very sick crime...It involved everything bad about society...
Torture, rape and murder of young girls....

If you don't think it is a big deal then you don't have to participate in this thread. Bottom line.
I agree with you that it was a very sick crime. And....?

Of course I don't have to participate in this thread. The crime I think was a big deal. The movie, I don't think it is a big deal. Why are you so offended that I have an opinion about the movie that is different from yours? And if you would explain your own feelings to me more clearly, perhaps I would come to understand your point of view and maybe even agree with you. That seems like a good reason for you to want me here in this thread, but if I am not mistaken, you in a round about way invited me to leave. Please elaborate your position.
 
A-ROD said:
Questor I am not going to debate this issue with you.. these are my feelings, I am not asking you to share them.. Thank You.
Very well A-Rod. No offence intended. I guess I misunderstood you originally. You are certainly entitled to your feelings, but I thought you were asking me to agree with you by not going to the movie.
 
A-ROD said:
This was a very sick crime...It involved everything bad about society...
Torture, rape and murder of young girls....

If you don't think it is a big deal then you don't have to participate in this thread. Bottom line.
What about the movie " Monster" starring Charlize Theron who played the murderous Prostitute Aileen . She killed her johns at gun point , leaving victims without a father, husband or partner .

Same thing , Karla is a true crime story and should get equal billing like any other high profile crime movie .
 
popcorn nation

interesting poll.

I didn't vote because none of the options really fit how I feel and to be perfectly honest I'm not sure how I feel.

The thought of people lining up for the opening of this movie and buying their popcorn makes me ill.

I definitely don't need to see it and won't be seeking it out, so I wouldn't exactly say I'd "like" to see it.

On the other hand it might be interesting to see how the events and characters are depicted, but I'd be somewhat apprehensive and skeptical in watching it.


I didn't particularly want to see "Monster" - not because of the subject matter, but I couldn't see how yet another serial killer movie could add anything of value, although it turned out to be an interesting interpretation/vantage point.

However, if I were the family or close to the victims I'd be mortified that it was made at all, but we sometimes sacrifice our personal rights for the rights of all - unfortunately as humans we do not have enough consideration or courtesy toward others and are far too self absorbed to deal with such apparent freedom.

I wasn't sure where I was going with this when I started the post. Ironically, I don't believe in censorship, but it seems that ultimately if people were to boycott the movie we'd be exercising our freedom to say it's not acceptable and I think that is what this thread is partly abt ... respect for the family ... I suppose that was obvious to some of you.

So, my answer is, I do not need to see this movie, especially given it was made at the expense of possibly perpetuating others already tragic loss.
 
I started a thread almost a year ago asking the same question....at the time the movie was to be called "Deadly".

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=80913

One point made in that thread basically sums up the "Is it right or wrong" Question for me..

Cardinal Fang said:
"Death is private. Murder is public".

I will most definitely see the movie. Not because I`m looking to be "entertained"....moreso because the subject matter touched me quite personally.

(BTW. I agree that there are a few tasteless remarks in this thread....)
 
Some people think that by watching the movie you somehow sympathize with Karla or that you have no respect for the victims. I think it will have the opposite effect depending on the slant of the movie. As for generating profits, I will just download the torrent.
 
Movies about true crime events are nothing new. One of the best movies I ever saw was In Cold Blood which must have had a profound effect on the families of the victims. Ironically it starred Robert Blake who knows about true crime.
 
pool said:
interesting poll.

I didn't vote because none of the options really fit how I feel and to be perfectly honest I'm not sure how I feel.

The thought of people lining up for the opening of this movie and buying their popcorn makes me ill.

I definitely don't need to see it and won't be seeking it out, so I wouldn't exactly say I'd "like" to see it.

On the other hand it might be interesting to see how the events and characters are depicted, but I'd be somewhat apprehensive and skeptical in watching it.


I didn't particularly want to see "Monster" - not because of the subject matter, but I couldn't see how yet another serial killer movie could add anything of value, although it turned out to be an interesting interpretation/vantage point.

However, if I were the family or close to the victims I'd be mortified that it was made at all, but we sometimes sacrifice our personal rights for the rights of all - unfortunately as humans we do not have enough consideration or courtesy toward others and are far too self absorbed to deal with such apparent freedom.

I wasn't sure where I was going with this when I started the post. Ironically, I don't believe in censorship, but it seems that ultimately if people were to boycott the movie we'd be exercising our freedom to say it's not acceptable and I think that is what this thread is partly abt ... respect for the family ... I suppose that was obvious to some of you.

So, my answer is, I do not need to see this movie, especially given it was made at the expense of possibly perpetuating others already tragic loss.
Very well articulated point of view pool. I have to agree with you that the idea of people lining up for popcorn is not a pretty one. In fact, I have decided that I am not going to go see this film in St. Catherines out of respect for the family. It is right that the community pull together and support the families of the victims in this way. I would hope that the film is not even shown in St. Catherines. As for the rest of the world, I think it is only natural curiosity, as horrible as the crime was and as much as the families have suffered. I do hope that the film is appropriately done with all due respect given to victims of this crime and that the film examines the events leading up to cutting of a deal for Karla and all the implications of this. The film could even delve into how some have tried to exploit and make a profit from this crime. There is much to learn from this case. I don't think it serves society to ban this film any more than it serves the community here at terb to ban discussion of this subject, out of respect for the victims and their families.
 
bouncer12 said:
.

I'd like to suggest that every actor, cameraman, grip and assistant that worked on this film has no regard for humanity. From the clips on the news, it also looks like crap. This film should be banned in Canada for being so insulting to the families.

QUOTE]


Did you object so much when they made a movie about Manson ? To suggest that a camera man has no regard for humanity is nonsense to them it's just a job , they didn't commit the crimes . It's simple don't watch the movie if you object , I would watch it.
 
Hey, just curious, after all this talk about the movie did anyone go see it? And do you think she went?