What are your thoughts on the movie "Deadly"?

Jennifer_

Active member
Sep 14, 2003
3,438
2
38
Downtown Toronto / Mississauga/ Markham
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/1111537643985_133


Bernardo movie to be released when Homolka is
CTV.ca News Staff

Producers of a movie about notorious sex killer Paul Bernardo and his wife Karla Homolka will tie the film's release to her release from prison this summer.

And that has Tim Danson, lawyer for the families of two girls killed by Bernardo, feeling wary.

"I, personally would have much rather had this come out before she gets out," Danson told CTV News Toronto on Tuesday. "It feels a little ... frankly, it makes me uneasy."

The movie is called Deadly, and stars Laura Prepon from That 70s Show as Karla and Misha Collins as Bernardo.

The still images available on the film's website show Homolka and Bernardo kidnapping a victim at knifepoint. They also show Bernardo and Homolka in bed together, Homolka with black eyes and Bernardo being arrested.

Danson says according to information he's received, some of the terrible things that were done to his clients Kristen French and Leslie Mahaffy will be recreated on screen.

"That is very, very disturbing, and I haven't decided yet whether or not it's legal," he says.

CTV News Toronto's Paul Bliss says the movie's writers used actual transcripts from the trial of Bernardo to help create the movie's script.

Producer Michael Sellers says in a message on the film's website that one goal of his film is to promote "predator awareness.

"I also made a commitment to myself to do nothing to dishonor the memory of the victims," he says.

Danson wanted to see the movie before it's released, but Sellers said it's too late to make major changes to the film.

However, Sellers says he wasn't planning for the film to be distributed in Canada, adding he can't stop people from uploading the film onto the Internet for people to view.

Sellers also says he couldn't prevent a larger distribution company like Miramax, as one example, from buying the rights to the movie and releasing it in Canada.

Background

Homolka began her 12-year sentence after pleading guilty to two charges of manslaughter in 1993.

She is scheduled to be released on July 5.

Authorities are trying to put as many conditions on her release as possible. They fear she may still be a danger to the public.

Bernardo began his crime career as the Scarborough rapist, and was suspected in the sexual assaults of at least 14 women in the late 1980s.

Homolka and Bernardo met in 1987 and were engaged in 1989.

The first death attributed to them was Karla's sister Tammy, who was drugged by Karla so she could be used as a sexual treat by Paul. Tammy choked on her own vomit and died.

Leslie Mahaffy, 14, was kidnapped by Bernardo and Homolka about two weeks before the couple's wedding in late June 1991.

Kristen French, 15, was kidnapped in April 1992.

Videotapes of the two victims' time in captivity were made by their captors. Those tapes were eventually destroyed when their usefulness as evidence reached an end.

In 1993, Homolka left Bernardo after he beat her with a flashlight. She filed charges. This led to his arrest.

While she pleaded guilty, Bernardo went to trial in 1995. Karla was a witness against him.

Besides being convicted on murder and other charges, Bernardo was declared a dangerous offender in October 1995, making it likely he'll never be released from prison.

The case has been the object of books by Ontario author Stephen Williams: Invisible Darkness and Karla: A Pact with the Devil.

There were plans by another movie producer to make a film based on Invisible Darkness, but they never came to fruition.

With a report from CTV News Toronto's Paul Bliss
 
Although this movie does not yet have a Canadian distributer, there is still a chance that "Deadly" will be released in Canada.

Will you see it?

I'm somewhat torn on the issue. I can understand why those closely involved in the case - especially those close to Leslie and Kristin are against the release of the movie.

But at the same time - is it morally or legally wrong to release a movie on factual events? The movie's creators are adament that a great deal of sensitivity was used in the depiction of the events of the case out of respect for the victims and their families.

I have always felt a strong connection to the cases of Bernardo and Homolka from the moment Leslie went missing. My uncle actually taught Leslie and another close member of my family worked with Kristin's father. I was only a few years younger than the two girls when they went missing. Their disappearances and the eventual discovery of what happened to them hit girls in my age group very hard. It was my first realization of the lack of invincibility I had as a young woman.

I devoured every detail of the trials as they were played out. I just felt the need to know.

Now that there is a possibility that "Deadly" will be released - I do think I would see it. I don't believe that I am being disrespectful towards Leslie and Kristin in wanting to see it - I suppose I still have a deep desire to understand - Why?


http://www.deadlythemovie.com/index.htm

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/1099662680412_95071880?s_name=&no_ads=
 
The movie's still just a rough assembly of raw footage, it could still be edited many different ways or be uneditable at all. It may be appropriate for those connected to the case to get involved at this stage, but it smacks of voyeurism and jumping to conclusions for the rest of us 'disinterested' citizens. When the producers actually have a product to release, then there will be something to have opinions about.
 
How is this issue any different than the movie "Monster" about Aileen Wuornos? Her victims had families, some of whom surely saw that movie, which by the way, portrayed her in a fairly sympathetic light. She was portrayed as a victim, and Charlize Theron won an Oscar for that role, thereby boosting her career.

I agree with Paul/IT: the victims' families will never be the same again, whether this movie is released or not. It's only an issue here because it happened in Ontario. People WILL go to see it regardless. What disturbs me is that Homolka could be one of them after July 5.
 
I think it should be made and shown. Unfortunitly for the victims' families, the victims became public domain. Mr. Danson and Roy Green can complain all they want but these murders are no different to any other murders that have happened before. I find it insulting that they are complaining without having even seeing the movie. They feel that the victims will be the central focus. It's about Karla and Paul.
 
I see absolutely no reason why this movie shouldn't be made and I will be seeing it, especially now with all the publicity about it. Yes, it was a tragedy. But since when can movies not be made about tragedies? They've made movies about the Holocaust for cripes sake.

The only part that I find in bad taste is timing it with the release of Homolka. That seems like a cheap publicity stunt, IMO. If the movie is good, it should stand on its own merits and not need to tie itself to the release of a serial killer's sidekick.
 
Keebler Elf said:
The only part that I find in bad taste is timing it with the release of Homolka. That seems like a cheap publicity stunt, IMO. If the movie is good, it should stand on its own merits and not need to tie itself to the release of a serial killer's sidekick.

Actually, I heard on the radio this morning that it was supposed to have been released sometime in spring, but they had to do another week of shooting, which delayed the release till fall. I don't think it was consciously timed to coincide with Homolka's release.
 
Possibly, but I read an article in the star and I'm hearing on the radio that the release is intentionally being made at the same time as Homolka gets out. And I find it hard to believe it's just a coincidence...
 
Historically it has been the arts' purview to record and interpret momentous, difficult events. "Expression of an emotion" is a common semiotic definition of what art is. So, yes, there is value to such a movie, as there is for the examples previously mentioned.

Having said that, this producer is, like all entertainment industry hucksters, disingenuous.

Danson wanted to see the movie before it's released, but Sellers said it's too late to make major changes to the film.
It's too late for non-investor nobodies like Danson. Changes are regularly made up to hours before release, as a friend in Hollywood tells me. Test screenings' response, capricious producers, investors and distributors demand them.

... he can't stop people from uploading the film onto the Internet for people to view.
it looks like he's planting ideas to get earned media freebies. Entertainment industry abhors internet uploading, unless they do it themselves as part of their value chain.

Sellers also says he couldn't prevent a larger distribution company like Miramax, as one example, from buying the rights to the movie and releasing it in Canada.
He would probably do anything to ink a deal with a "large distribution company like Miramax", it's about the only way a B-movie with B-stars can get any ROI. And guess what, a "large distribution company like Miramax" will demand release date marketing tie-ins to something. Whatever could that be.....
 
I'm so glad to finally see some people who are thinking straight and see the hypocrisy in those who piss and moan about this movie as they head to the theatre to see a movie about someone else's tragedy, popcorn in hand.

I'm absolutely baffled when i listen to talk radio and hear them saying it should be banned in Canada. How about a little self-censorship people? No one will be forced to watch it if they don't want to see it.

As for the original question.... absolutely i will see it.
 
Lynn said:
I don't believe that I am being disrespectful towards Leslie and Kristin in wanting to see it - I suppose I still have a deep desire to understand - Why?
Good question.

I honestly don't know why we feel a need to watch movies of real life tragedies.

I've always had a fascination with serial killers, but more so when I was younger. I recently watched a crappy movie trying to retell the story of Ted Bundy. It was an odd movie and almost seemed to lean toward dark satire at times and painted him as a goofy almost comical character. What drove me to rent it ? Well, I read books and have seen documentaries long ago, so was just vaguely curious. I suppose it's based on a need to understand or face what we as humans are capable of. Maybe it's facing our fears in a safe context or trying to come to terms with them. We get to live out empathy, anger and in some cases, dare I speculate, deep seeded desire. This is where further questions arise as to whether such media instigates the actions it depicts. Granted that it cannot do it alone.


I have some severe conflict with such things. On the surface reality TV makes me cringe, as does relentless redundant sensationalism on CNN etc - I just can't watch it, because of the blatant sensationalism aspect. I avoided watching Schindler's List at the time because I didn't think I could handle it emotionally or see it as "entertaining". Though I have no ties to Jewish people. Then recently I watched the documentary series, Auschwitz, which is extremely disturbing and hard to fathom the extremes that the human psyche can reach on such a mass basis - yet it draws you in.

I agree with what Antaues said regarding art being an expression of emotion, and that likely it is not the primary motivation in making the film. I think we live out our emotions through others art, which includes documentaries. I suppose this movie is a docudrama of sorts.

Here's where I disagree with what others have said. I think it will put the family through further unnecessary emotional hell. No doubt it could help them face it and deal with it on some level, but it just seems that we have our priorities all fucked up and put our own needs before those who are actually living the torment.

Will I watch it - probably, but will likely rent it on DVD once it's no longer a new release as I am in no hurry to see it. I kinda got sickened by all the media coverage already. There's a lotta tragedy in the world every day.
 
I would consider watching it if it receives two or more stars from reviewers. I strongly object to any legal decision or government appointed committee deciding if I can or cannot watch the movie. It would be appropriate for name changes to be made for the characters depicting Kristen French and Leslie McHaffy. I would be very upset if Polly by Nirvana appeared on the soundtrack CD.