Julian Assange

It seems likely that a site named "wikileaks" was intended to encourage people to submit leaks. Don't you think?
The question is raised when there reportedly is e-mail correspondence which seems to go beyond 'I'd be happy to have you submit it to us, and into what do you have to give us, can you get more of it, we'd really like to have. . .'
 
The question is raised when there reportedly is e-mail correspondence which seems to go beyond 'I'd be happy to have you submit it to us, and into what do you have to give us, can you get more of it, we'd really like to have. . .'

So you agree he has a reasonable fear that the US plans to try and extradite him based on a US law that purports to apply even in jurisdictions where that email would otherwise be perfectly legal.
 
This disussion is completely foolish. All of you seem to pretend that the US gives a hoot about the law.
We all knowvthat the US keeps people in jail for decades without trial, and subjects them to torture. The president maintain that he has the right to kill people that have not been convicted of any crime.
 
So you agree he has a reasonable fear that the US plans to try and extradite him based on a US law that purports to apply even in jurisdictions where that email would otherwise be perfectly legal.
Well other than places like Russia, the PRC, or Iran pray tell us where encouraging someone to steal and send you classified (indeed Top Secret) U.S. information is "perfectly legal."

Still the charge would not be a "slam dunk conviction," there is no evidence that there has been an indictment, and for over a year before he fled to the Ecuadorian Embassy the U.S. could have requested his extradition.
 
Well other than places like Russia, the PRC, or Iran pray tell us where encouraging someone to steal and send you classified (indeed Top Secret) U.S. information is "perfectly legal."

I see that word places there. Trying to reconcile it with the fact that the United States isn't a place that he was.
 
This disussion is completely foolish. All of you seem to pretend that the US gives a hoot about the law.
We all knowvthat the US keeps people in jail for decades without trial, and subjects them to torture. The president maintain that he has the right to kill people that have not been convicted of any crime.

Absolutely.

Shouting that you are the land of the free won't undo the damage of running black ops torture prisons in your own back yard.
https://theintercept.com/2016/02/05...tan-guantanamo-pretrial-solitary-confinement/
 
So your view is that he hasn't violated any US law? Aardy disagrees with you.

I don't think he has, I think the US might want to talk to him about his sources... Unless he hacked US Government systems I'd bet he's fine.
 
Another U.N. viewpoint

"Vladimir Tochilovsky

The adopted Opinion raises serious question as to the scope of the mandate of the Working Group.

It is assumed in the Opinion that Mr. Assange has been detained in the Embassy of Ecuador in London by the authorities of the United Kingdom. In particular, it is stated that his stay in the Embassy constitutes “a state of an arbitrary deprivation of liberty.”

In fact, Mr. Assange fled the bail in June 2012 and since then stays at the premises of the Embassy using them as a safe haven to evade arrest. Indeed, fugitives are often self-confined within the places where they evade arrest and detention. This could be some premises, as in Mr. Assange’s situation, or the territory of the State that does not recognise the arrest warrant. However, these territories and premises of self-confinement cannot be considered as places of detention for the purposes of the mandate of the Working Group."


https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...trarily-detained-one-didnt-heres-his-dissent/
 
Last edited:
I posted a link to the convening of the grand jury. Do you know what grand juries do?

And as usual you know more than everyone else and have evidence of the grand jury demanding extradition?


BTW. I'm still waiting to hear how extradition from Sweden is easier than the UK who already had him in custody.
 
And as usual you know more than everyone else and have evidence of the grand jury demanding extradition?


BTW. I'm still waiting to hear how extradition from Sweden is easier than the UK who already had him in custody.

No one will have evidence of whether the Grand Jury headed down an indictment until it is unsealed. You asked whether there was any evidence that the US had begun proceedings and I pointed out that they convened a Grand Jury.
 
... You asked whether there was any evidence that the US had begun proceedings and I pointed out that they convened a Grand Jury.

You seem to have as many problems with reality as groggy.

basketcase said:
Do you really believe the US isn't sitting on a sealed warrant waiting try and extradite him, possibly to gitmo? Foreign nationals detained by the US have not exactly had their rights upheld.

As I said, conspiracy theory - unless you have any actual evidence. No? Conspiracy theory it is.

And it makes absolutely no rational or legal sense that a guy choosing to seek asylum can be 'illegally detained' at the same time (unless they are saying Ecuador is preventing him from leaving).

So where is your evidence of the US "sitting on a sealed warrant waiting try and extradite him"?
 
You seem to have as many problems with reality as groggy.



So where is your evidence of the US "sitting on a sealed warrant waiting try and extradite him"?

I provided a link to the convening of the grand jury. Your claim that it was a conspiracy theory exploded at that point. DoJ clearly presented a case that Assange should be indicted and a Grand Jury returned a decision on that question.

Plainly it is sealed so neither of us know if there is an indictment or not, but what we do know is DoJ believed strongly enough that it could get an indictment that it convened a jury and presented a case.

That is not a conspiracy theory. That is just an unknown. And until the US gives assurances it won't extradite, Assange has a reasonable fear that grand jury delivered a sealed indictment that would be used to bring him to the US to face life in solitary confinement and very possibly waterboarding.
 
No one will have evidence of whether the Grand Jury headed down an indictment until it is unsealed. You asked whether there was any evidence that the US had begun proceedings and I pointed out that they convened a Grand Jury.

Yeah that grand jury system... what a joke of justice. Just shy of a death squad. The laaaaand of the freeee and the home of the bravvvvveeeeeeeee hahahhahahahahahah what a sick joke.
 
I provided a link to the convening of the grand jury. Your claim that it was a conspiracy theory exploded at that point.....

Is illiteracy part of your problems or just your need to have the last word even when you know you are wrong?

You claimed the US has a sealed warrant WITH ABSOLUTELY NO EVIDENCE.
 
Is illiteracy part of your problems or just your need to have the last word even when you know you are wrong?

You claimed the US has a sealed warrant WITH ABSOLUTELY NO EVIDENCE.

Wow I always thought you and Fuji were the same person. Bipolar? Accusing yourself of being a liar lmao.
 
Is illiteracy part of your problems or just your need to have the last word even when you know you are wrong?

You claimed the US has a sealed warrant WITH ABSOLUTELY NO EVIDENCE.

The convening of a grand jury is evidence. Whether or not you like it.
 
The convening of a grand jury is evidence. Whether or not you like it.

You obviously have evidence of what that Grand Jury decided that the rest of us don't have available so why should I doubt the words of the all-stubborn fuji that his conspiracy theory isn't a conspiracy theory.
 
You obviously have evidence of what that Grand Jury decided that the rest of us don't have available so why should I doubt the words of the all-stubborn fuji that his conspiracy theory isn't a conspiracy theory.

A "conspiracy theory" generally refers to some claim completely out of the realm of normal possibility. Unlike the possibility that a Grand Jury convened specifically to indict Assange actually indicted him.

I could equally call it a "conspiracy theory" that there isn't an indictment, using your ludicrous logic that any unknown whatsoever is a conspiracy theory--but then, like you, I'd be misusing the term.