John Stewart on CNN

zydeco said:
I pretty much agree with your assessment OTB. Not sure about the B & S angle though. The fact that some mistake his show for "real news" - is really much more of a statement about those individuals, than it is about the purpose or intent of his show.

I think the easy to fool MTV generation (to which I used to belong ;-) mistakes the Daily Show for news - same people who think Michael Moore makes documentaries instead of political comedies.

OTB
 
In these dangerous times, we have to watch for the propaganda machineries. In propaganda, since the time of Dr. Goebbels, the goal is always to hijack words and give them new meaning.
The neo-cons have hijacked the word liberal and given it a negative meaning, liberal=unamerican.
As an example, questioning the war in Iraq, or even (as Kerry) the way it is being executed, is unamerican=liberal.
By any normal standard, Kerry is a conservative, although not as rabid and warmongering as the current administration.
 
danmand said:
In these dangerous times, we have to watch for the propaganda machineries. In propaganda, since the time of Dr. Goebbels, the goal is always to hijack words and give them new meaning.
The neo-cons have hijacked the word liberal and given it a negative meaning, liberal=unamerican.
As an example, questioning the war in Iraq, or even (as Kerry) the way it is being executed, is unamerican=liberal.
By any normal standard, Kerry is a conservative, although not as rabid and warmongering as the current administration.

And the Liberals have hijacked the term neo-con (see above for example). The first neo-con (a term Liberals applied to a group of Democrats that started the movement - again another example of your point) defined a neo-con as a Liberal mugged by reality.

I just love the fact that Liberals in the US are afraid to call themselves Liberals, they now use Progressive, which means Liberal without the backbone.


OTB
 
bbking said:
The word Liberal was used by Conservatives in the 80's to define someone who will tax and spend peoples money with such glee as to be frightening and to help define Trickle down Economics. Your defining as Kerry as a Conservative is an example on how successful that campaign was. A true Liberal believes that Government has a responsibility to the welfare of the people and as such favours large Government programs and regulation where as Conservatives believe that people are better off without Goverment involvement or as I call it Economic Darwinism. Kerry in no way would ever be mistaken for a Conservative. As for the un-American stuff, American's have always prided themselves in self reliance and as such Conservatives have wraped themselves in the flag and trumpted the American Dream. Clinton did a great job of destroying the myths the Conservatives like to hold dear and I think this election will show that Americans see thru the Conservative's lie.

But to call Kerry a Conservative just tells me you don't know what the guy stands for - if anything read his medicare program.
bbk

Sorry mate, you have bought the propaganda, hook line and sinker.
 
danmand said:
Sorry mate, you have bought the propaganda, hook line and sinker.

Nice response - concise without any thought required - the perfect Liberal response.

OTB
 
bbking said:
You really read some books dan - A mind is a terrible thing to waste and you are approaching the beyond help stage.
The current definiations of Liberal and Conservative have been set from the FDR days. bbk

You really need to go a bit further back and away to look for these labels.

The hallmark of conservative parties are fiscal responsibiliy. The current neo-con movement may best be described as populist, in the tradition of the populist movements in Italy, Canada, France, Denmark, Norway, Germany etc. They tend to favour the abolishment of the income tax, focus on a perceived enemy like immigrants, jews, arabs or what have you.

As to your example, conservative parties in the democracies in Europe and Canada are not opposed to universal health care.

My main point is that I am not accepting the neo-con hijacking of words for their own propaganda purposes.
 
danmand said:
You really need to go a bit further back and away to look for these labels.

The hallmark of conservative parties are fiscal responsibiliy. The current neo-con movement may best be described as populist, in the tradition of the populist movements in Italy, Canada, France, Denmark, Norway, Germany etc. They tend to favour the abolishment of the income tax, focus on a perceived enemy like immigrants, jews, arabs or what have you.

As to your example, conservative parties in the democracies in Europe and Canada are not opposed to universal health care.

My main point is that I am not accepting the neo-con hijacking of words for their own propaganda purposes.

But you seemed to have adopted the Liberal hijacking of the term neo-con. This is such a classic Pot - Kettle post!

OTB
 
bbking said:
Once again, so you understand - Liberal/Conservative has more to do about government involvement in peoples lives, be it thru regulation or new programs.

You are of course right according to your definitions. Again, I do not know why I try to argue with you, it leads nowhere. I better go and play poker somewhere.
 
You, au contraire, are an expert on poker, no doubt.

The purpose of a debate is not winning or losing, but the gaining of new knowledge. However, that requires one to consider the arguments of one's opponent, which is something you sadly are incapable of.

go and read a book, please, any book!
 
The thread is about John Stewart right?
It is hard to stay creative and funny for a very long time. Sooner or later it becomes impossible.Some guys know when to quit or re-invent themselves. John seems like he has become desperate and he is forcing himself to be funny.
Too bad, because i really like him. He is sharp and witty and easily can point out the obscure in even the most mondane story.
 
langeweile said:
The thread is about John Stewart right?
It is hard to stay creative and funny for a very long time. Sooner or later it becomes impossible.Some guys know when to quit or re-invent themselves. John seems like he has become desperate and he is forcing himself to be funny.
Too bad, because i really like him. He is sharp and witty and easily can point out the obscure in even the most mondane story.

The end will come for Jon when he takes himself seriously, something he came dangerously close to on the CNN clip.

OTB