Jewish terrorism deniers

Does evil and terrorism exist on both sides?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 41 58.6%
  • No.

    Votes: 16 22.9%
  • Maybe.

    Votes: 2 2.9%
  • Who cares lets just nuke the camel jockeys?

    Votes: 11 15.7%

  • Total voters
    70

solitaria

New member
Jun 1, 2005
737
0
0
Two plus years ago I started a thread on the topic of Holocaust denial. It was a very long thread but the consensus of the poll was that Holocaust denial was "The purposely distorted reality of people who are driven by their hate."

The more things change the more they stay the same. Now on Terb, you have an influx of people who deny any and all wrong-doing of the Zionist movement in its establishment of the state of Israel and label any contrary position as racist. Their ignorance is simply astounding.

The realization that Israel immorally seized land from the Palestinians is a very important consideration in how you view the current conflict. If the Israeli government obtained land through terrorism and destruction then the responsiblity is with the Israeli government to rectify their past wrongs in a proactive manner instead of just reacting to violence with exponentially greater violence.

There are many examples of how the Zionist movement used terrorism and destruction to obtain land from the Palestinians. Any attempt to show that there were many Israeli PM's that agreed with these measures is met with claims of "fabrication" from pro-Zionist websites. Let's look at the record. How did Israel's first PM, David Ben-Guiron acquire land for his people?

I will use a Jewish historian and history professor at the Ben-Gurion university, Benny Morris, to provide insight into the Zionist movement and origins.

http://www.palestine-studies.org/enakba/history/Morris, Falsifying the Record.pdf


p 48 said:
According to the original Weitz diary entry for 5 June, Weitz had informed Ben-Guiron that the committee had already begun "here and there destroying villages." In the published diary, Weitz had amended this to "here and there 'improving' villages" (the single quotes presumably designed to signal his more perceptive reader what was actually meant.) In both versions, Weitz wrote that Ben-Guiron "gave his approval" to the work. Indeed, according to Weitz, Ben-Guiron had not only approved the "whole policy" but had thought that the proposed actions in Israel (destruction of villages, prevention of harvesting, settlement of Jews in abandoned sites) should take precedence over efforts to resettle the refugees elsewhere...

This is what Benny had to say about Ben-Guiron.

p 48 said:
Ben-Gurion ever wary of the historian who would at some point cull his diary, simply exercised self-censorship as he jotted down each entry; Weitz, less sophisticated, left the tampering to the 1960s, when he prepared the notebooks for publication.

Here is an account of how the Jewish soldiers often "resettled" the villages while Ben-Guiron was PM. It sounds like a Palestinian Holocaust on a smaller scale to me.

p 55 said:
In Safsaf; after . . . the inhabitants had raised a white flag, the [soldiers] collected and separated the men and women, tied the hands of fifty-sixty fellahin [peasants] and shot and killed them and buried them in a pit. Also they raped several women . . . At Eilaboun and Farradiya the soldiers had been greeted with white flags and rich food, and afterwards had ordered the villagers to leave, with their women and children. When the [villagers] had begun to argue . . . [the soldiers] had opened fire and after some thirty people were killed, had begun to lead the rest [towards Lebanon] . . . In Saliha where a white flag had been raised [,] . . . they had killed about sixty-seventy men and women. Where did they come by such a measure of cruelty, like Nazis? ... Is there no more humane way of expelling the inhabitants than by such methods . . .?

The questions on Terb shouldn't be focused on whether the Israeli government has a right to defend itself by killing exponentially more innocent people than were killed leading up to that right to self-defense. The real question is why these same people whom are so interested in Israel's "right to self-defense" aren't holding Israel at least partly responsible for the conditions in the Gaza strip and for the violence and hatred that has resulted from their very own policies of destruction and terrorism. I've not seen real solutions from the Israeli government; just actions that belie words. The solution can never be more violence so why do people on Terb cheer Israel when they continually follow down that path?
 
I don't deny that Israel has perpetrated terrorism in the past. The Haganah was made up of two self defence groups - the Irgun and the Levi who turned into terrorist groups. As far as the state of Israel's actions today I don't think it qualifies as terrorism because it doesn't fit the definition below

"Terrorism is an anxiety-inspiring method of repeated violent action, employed by (semi-) clandestine individual, group or state actors, for idiosyncratic, criminal or political reasons, whereby - in contrast to assassination - the direct targets of violence are not the main targets."

The direct targets of Israel's violence are Hamas in Palestine (Hezbollah in Lebanon). Its unfortunate that innocent civilians are being killed but they aren't being targeted (although many media outlets would like you to believe that).
 
To deny actions in the past would be wrong.

During the period from the 1920's-1948 and beyond, there were numerous terrorist activities going on from Jews and Arabs (and the British powers could likely be included).

What is infantile is your one-sidedness on the issue. You seem to revel in past acts of Israelis/Jews all the while ignoring the parts of history that detail the terrorist activities of Arab groups. Even in your post from wikipedia, you ignore the continual attacks on Israel by Arabs (who would be called Palestinians today) which instigated the Israeli response.

Just like in the current situation in Gaza, Israel (and before that Jews in Palestine) were repeatedly attacked by terrorist groups and when they respond there is a public outcry.

The actions of the Israelis have been at times wrong. Like all democratic nations with western ideals, Israel has worked at overcoming the baser human emotions for simple revenge but are not perfect.

The biggest challenge for Israel is that there are groups like Hamas that see nothing wrong with taking revenge upon innocent civilians, except when it is their innocent civilians who suffer. Then it becomes a cynical propaganda incident.
 
I suppose your point is that things are never one sided. On that I agree. I’ve always maintained that Israel is not completely innocent.

I think that everything that Israel has done in the last few decades has been in self defense and they have brokered for peace in good faith. Lately it is the Palestinians and more specifically Hamas that have pretty much the exclusive franchise on hate and evil.

Your understanding of history is completely wrong. Like your example of the holocaust deniers, there is a deliberate distortion of the truth motivated by hatred and jealousy.

You are guilty of the very thing you condemn in others.
 
This thread seems to come down to who was on the land first, news flash it was neither the Jewish people or the Lebanese people. The history of the land goes back 9000 years that can be accounted for. In all likeelyhood people have lived there since people became people.

The imediate question is not who to remove it is how to resolve the problem with the twin goals of security for the Isrealis and a real life for the Lebanese.

Both sides will ahve to give up some ground, the Isrealis will have to ensure the state of Lebanon has a chance to thrive, that will mean removing some if not all of the settlements in the west bank, The Lebanese will have to work with the ISrealis to guarantee that no more missiles happen and the terrorism stops.

It is achievable but the question is are their people with the vision to get there.
 
I voted "yes" for the record.

Solitaria will no doubt try and twist this into some claim that the entire Israeli state is terrorist. She is wrong. The reality is that the Israeli state considers Jewish extremists to be criminals as well.
 
I voted NO. Israelis don't blow themselves up for no reason. That's why there is a Palestinian blockade in which Palestine is operated by a bunch of meat heads, and when those meat heads say something of truth, they get shot in the head by another crazy power hungry Palestinian. Anything the Palestinians say like "blockade", "apartheid", "occupation" is bogus because they are animals. They know how to stop it, but they don't. And, boy, when another ignorant "help me get an Oscar from Hollywood" documentary participant goes into Palestine with a camera crew, his film gets sympathy from a large group of people uneducated about the other side and why it is like that.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
Gyaos said:
I voted NO. Israelis don't blow themselves up for no reason. That's why there is a Palestinian blockade in which Palestine is operated by a bunch of meat heads, and when those meat heads say something of truth, they get shot in the head by another crazy power hungry Palestinian.

Gyaos Baltar.

Her question was not whether the IDF is terrorist but whether there are ANY terrorists on both sides. Plainly there are a few Jewish extremists who would count as terrorists.

No doubt she plans to twist this into some statement that Israel is "just like" Hamas or some other bullshit.
 
fuji said:
Her question was not whether the IDF is terrorist but whether there are ANY terrorists on both sides. Plainly there are a few Jewish extremists who would count as terrorists. No doubt she plans to twist this into some statement that Israel is "just like" Hamas or some other bullshit.

The question is artificial and my answer is correct. There are no terrorists in the Canadian or American military either, right? Obviously not. What is also true as a given for any question is Israel's defense is NOT NEGOTIABLE. :cool:

solitaria said:
The questions on Terb shouldn't be focused on whether the Israeli government has a right to defend itself by killing exponentially more innocent people than were killed leading up to that right to self-defense. The real question is why these same people whom are so interested in Israel's "right to self-defense" aren't holding Israel at least partly responsible for the conditions in the Gaza strip and for the violence and hatred that has resulted from their very own policies of destruction and terrorism.

Because the people of Gaza are NOT the responsibility of Israel. They are the responsibility of Hamas, who claims to be the government of Palestine, when they are not even recognized to exist by the community of nations. Israel out numbers and outweighs Hamas, so if Hamas allows their people to be slaughtered, proves that those terrorists are not becoming to the safety of their own people. However, may I say, that Israel could just kill everyone there and the situation is over with no Israeli troop killed. They don't and actually provide rules of engagement. Israel has given x number of proposals and treaties to allow Palestine to become a state and flourishing economy with Israel and the world, but the criminal, gang-like, racist elements in Palestine squash it. Again and again. I refer to the Barak/Clinton/Arafat proposal in 1999. It was all there, Arafat refused it and made the Palestinians suffer further today. Anyone in Palestine that disagrees with Arafat for his blunder gets shot. That's the reality.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
I guess it depends on how you define "sides". If the sides are IDF/Israel versus Hamas then Hamas are the only terrorists. If the "sides" are all Jews versus all Palestinians, which is how Solitaria tends to describe things, then yes there are terrorists on both sides--far more terrorists on one side than on the other--but on both.
 
fuji said:
I guess it depends on how you define "sides". If the sides are IDF/Israel versus Hamas then Hamas are the only terrorists. If the "sides" are all Jews versus all Palestinians, which is how Solitaria tends to describe things, then yes there are terrorists on both sides--far more terrorists on one side than on the other--but on both.

Her description is artificial. Since something is artificial, there is no debate in the matter. The FACT is there are not all Jews vs all Palestinians. Both sides cross each other's territory and work for a living. The problem lies within the civil conflict between Palestinians own political problems first. Then there can be negotiations with Israel. The Palestinian civil conflict is: one side, moderate, wants to talk, the other side, terrorist, wants to attack. So Israel is removing the terrorist side, because the terrorists boxed themselves in Gaza with NO ESCAPE and Israel will succeed.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
fuji said:
No doubt she plans to twist this into some statement that Israel is "just like" Hamas or some other bullshit.

Let's hope that she doesn't. I voted 'Yes' because I believe that there is fault on both sides, not necessarily equal, that has propogated and perpetuated the killing and violence. Again, that does not mean that the blame shoudl be assiged equally.
 
“If I were an Arab leader, I would never sign an agreement with Israel. It is normal; we have taken their country. It is true God promised it to us, but how could that interest them? Our God is not theirs. There has been Anti - Semitism, the Nazis, Hitler, Auschwitz, but was that their fault ? They see but one thing: we have come and we have stolen their country. Why would they accept that?” ~ Ben-Gurion

Israel stole the country from the Arab people in the area. To steal a country you have to no doubt kill a lot of innocent people. Is that fact no longer relevant to the current situation? If the Jews acquired the land through destruction and terrorism sixty years ago should we expect any less from the Arabs in trying to get it back?

Have the Jews given the Arabs any reason not to hate them? How is killing 800+ Arabs in 2 weeks an appropriate response to the situation and its underlying factors in that context.
 
When you refer to Israelis as "Zionists" you lose all credibility to anyone who might otherwise be sympathetic to your arguments.

Just a hint. ;)
 
Keebler Elf said:
When you refer to Israelis as "Zionists" you lose all credibility to anyone who might otherwise be sympathetic to your arguments.

Just a hint. ;)

Zionism: A Jewish movement that arose in the late 19th century in response to growing anti-Semitism and sought to reestablish a Jewish homeland in Palestine. Modern Zionism is concerned with the support and development of the state of Israel.

I used the word Zionism/Zionist in this thread twice. Both times I used the term correctly.

Ben-Gurion on the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs website is referred to as a "Zionist leader".
 
solitaria said:
...

Israel stole the country from the Arab people in the area. To steal a country you have to no doubt kill a lot of innocent people. Is that fact no longer relevant to the current situation? If the Jews acquired the land through destruction and terrorism sixty years ago should we expect any less from the Arabs in trying to get it back?
...
What a historical farce you are trying to perpetrate.

The UN tried to create a Jewish state and a Palestinian state in 1948. The Palestinian state was stolen by Jordan and Egypt After the Arab states refused to accept the existence of a small Jewish state in their midst. They initiated the war that resulted in Israel having a larger than planned state and it was the Arab states that prevented the Palestinian state from existing.

Have the Jews given the Arabs any reason not to hate them? How is killing 800+ Arabs in 2 weeks an appropriate response to the situation and its underlying factors in that context.
Beyond your now standard racist use of "THE JEWS" yes they have. Israel's existence has provided it Arab citizens with not only a standard of living higher than any of their neighbors but also far more political freedoms than their brethren in Syria, Egypt, or Jordan.

"THE ARABS" in Jordan and Egypt have seen the benefits of peace. In fact, Jordan has Israel as one of it's largest trading partners. Most of the region's governments seems to be content with Israel's war on Hamas judging by the muted response. The only people perpetuating hate are the power hungry zealots of Hamas, Hezbollah and the like and the poor dupes who fall for their propaganda.
 
The is a huge and important difference between "evil" and "terrorism." Does evil exist on both sides - of course, does terrorism exit on both sides - no.
 
solitaria said:
Israel immorally seized land from the Palestinians
So, Solitaria are all U.N. resolutions invalid or only those 1946-1948 dealing with the partition of the British Mandate in the Holy Land?
 
solitaria said:
Israel stole the country from the Arab people in the area.

Israelis were people in the area too. It was a civil war. As many Jews as Arabs lost their homes and were forced to move from where they lived. Jews moved to Israel. Arabs moved out of Israel.

You write like it was one-sided. It wasn't, people on both sides had their homes taken and had to flee.
 
What we must be careful about...

..is the subtle difference. EVERY COUNTRY IN THE WORLD has rogues who join bad groups and gangs and may well be described as terrorists. (Tim McVeigh).... All countries would have terrorists without question.

But the difference one must understand is when ROGUE countries..sponsor and encourage this terrorism in the name of the country.....in that case..very few countries fall into that definition.

Gaza would..in that HAMAS, sponsored by Iran, Syria and whoever else, conducts itself in the way that it has. PURE TERRORISM at its finest.