I find it odd that peeps that argue that its OK or fine for sp's to work johns for extra's (gifts, cash ...), but it totally wrong for johns to ask for discounts, and its just as odd to argue the opposite.
Just for the record, I have never asked for discounts from a sp, but I tip for service that I believe is above minimum expectations, just as I would not at, say, a restaurant. Similarly, I find it offensive if I believe that a sp is pushy in charging for extra's or tips and, what i find is that usually in those cases, the sp isn't even worth the base fee. I think that most of us, sp's and johns alike, don't appreciate when this happens to any of us. The sp's that conduct themselves in a professional manner, will hopefully, as a rule, be treated in kind.