Jacinda Ardern

Who did execute covid policies well according to you?
Trump?
DeSantis?

There are people who just disagree with anything anyone else does. And those reflexive contrarians are usually none too bright, despite their self-admitted genius and expertise on everything from medicine and running the country or the world! Especially when it comes to COVID.
 
Jacinda Ardern’s legacy of national division and excessive use of power

Jan 20, 2022

New Zealand’s Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has resigned after months of rumours. Ardern, whose popularity has plummeted during the last six months, told us “she had nothing left in the tank”.

The backstory to this resignation is a tale of woe. Ardern said she wants to be remembered as someone who tried to be kind. The subtext is: the country is in an unprecedented mess but don’t blame me.

Last year school attendance was reported as running at just 67% on any given day. Machete-wielding teenagers are ram-raiding liquor outlets, vape shops, dairies, and jewellery stores daily in a frenzied crime wave. The health system is overwhelmed. Ardern’s government promised to build 100,000 new homes over three years. It has delivered just 1500 to date.

Our tourist, farming, and hospitality industries have not recovered from lockdowns and border closures. It now takes weeks to get a visa to visit New Zealand – it used to take two days – and the government says it only wants rich people to come. No wonder, we are all poor now.

Ardern famously insisted on universal covid vaccination mandates. There is a suspicion that our 90% vaccination rate has left everyone in a lethargic fog. Excess all-cause deaths are still running 15% above the long-term trends, and it is not covid.

History will judge Ardern harshly, but don’t blame her alone. This was a Parliament that woke up on all sides of the house to the weakness of our constitutional arrangements – there are none worth the name. The Bill of Rights was tossed aside and no one in Parliament cared.

The leader of the National opposition, Chris Luxon, famously said pre-pandemic if he was in power, he would withdraw benefits from unvaccinated single mothers. David Seymour, leader of the ACT party wrote on his Facebook those losing their jobs through vaccine mandates only had themselves to blame. Labour’s coalition partners, the Greens, led by example, encouraging mothers in labour to ride to the hospital on a bicycle (yes, they did).

Politicians of all parties were afraid to meet protestors and turned the hoses on them rather than listen to their concerns.

Revelations this week (HERE and HERE) that Ardern personally overruled her scientific advisors, who were expressing doubts about the safety of covid vaccines for young people and the wisdom of mandates, have circulated very widely and no doubt this has further undermined confidence in the government.

Ardern introduced “rule by regulation.” Adopting the enabling model favoured by fascists in the 1930s, her government has empowered authorities to tell us all what to do, when to stay at home, and where not to go. The courts, the Human Rights Commission, and the broadcast regulators have all followed the government line meticulously which has had a devastating effect on business, families, communities, and professions. To cement her policies, Ardern introduced massive government funding of our media and broadcasters – a hallmark of repressive regimes.

Ardern was a protege of Tony Blair and a graduate of the Klaus Schwab World Economic Forum Young Global Leaders programme. Both must shoulder some blame too. What fantasies of global power did they offer to a young person who was given to idealistic dreaming that segued into fanaticism?

Ardern’s government, in an absurd overreach, has also funded a nationwide effort to discredit critics of policy, labelling them terrorists. This has divided a formerly egalitarian society, instituting a snitch culture that encourages us to dob in a neighbour. Government Disinformation Project employees appeared in funded films aired on television against a backdrop of atomic bombs exploding and Nazi stormtroopers marching. Absurdly they labelled knitting, blond hair, braids, vaccine hesitancy, love of natural foods, Yoga, and yes motherhood as signs of terrorism that should be reported to the intelligence services – yes they did, view it HERE on TVNZ if you can stand watching this nasty piece of propaganda and hate.

Why did Ardern suddenly change overnight in August 2021 from being a kindly figure saying she would never mandate vaccines, to being one of the world’s most draconian proponents? We can only speculate. NZ is a member of the Five Eyes intelligence network. Given the Pentagon’s recently revealed massive involvement in US covid policy and gain-of-function research funding, was she fed information that a bioweapon was in play? We will likely never know.

The cynical will say that Ardern left early like Key to avoid the ignominy of U-turns and election defeat. Leaving open the possibility of political rebirth. The New York Times wrote this morning that Ardern, like Helen Clark, is in line for a global role and a bigger platform. We live in dread.

For a couple of weeks now government announcements and advertisements encouraging vaccination and boosters have been conspicuously absent. Has the penny finally dropped? We doubt it. It will take an honest, intelligent politician (are there any left?) to roll back Ardern’s dictatorial powers and kickstart New Zealand. Why would any aspiring newbie give up that much power? The prospect will be too intoxicating, but that is what it will take. Someone must rise above the mire of our current politics and realise that governments should represent the interests of the people. Leadership is about fulfilling the aspirations of your followers, not just telling them what to do.

Our final verdict: It is not Ardern but the whole NZ Parliament elected in 2020 that will be judged as the worst in our short history as an independent island nation, formerly famous for championing the underdog and offering opportunity to all. Ardern’s resignation lights a bonfire of the excesses of modern democracy. To find a way ahead at the very least the NZ Bill of Rights needs to be entrenched, beyond the reach of power-hungry politicians and compliant courts.

 
Who did execute covid policies well according to you?
Trump?
DeSantis?
It doesn't really matter in this discussion. Each country (or state) and their electorate including New Zealand has to decide how to navigate their way through Covid.
 
There are people who just disagree with anything anyone else does. And those reflexive contrarians are usually none too bright, despite their self-admitted genius and expertise on everything from medicine and running the country or the world! Especially when it comes to COVID.
This is a nice little statement, but I'm not sure it considers that New Zealanders and any country for that matter can have their own debate.
 
It doesn't really matter in this discussion. Each country (or state) and their electorate including New Zealand has to decide how to navigate their way through Covid.

If there are only wrong answers then there is no reason to say NZ did worse.
You could use metrics, like deaths, job losses, economic changes.

But then you'd have to note how poorly right wingers did in general.
 
If there are only wrong answers then there is no reason to say NZ did worse.
You could use metrics, like deaths, job losses, economic changes.

But then you'd have to note how poorly right wingers did in general.
Canada has 8 times more people than NZ

Canada has 25 times more deaths from Covid than NZ.

Unless you are director of the Society of Morticians, you must agree that NZ did well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
If there are only wrong answers then there is no reason to say NZ did worse.
You could use metrics, like deaths, job losses, economic changes.

But then you'd have to note how poorly right wingers did in general.
I don't think I have said anything of the sort. For like the twelfth dozen time, you have to really read what is written on the thread.

I think she did a good job during the outbreak, but New Zealand was also an exceptional situation. It's an island nation of 5 million in a remote part of the world. How she did in the post-vaccine environment seems to be a subject of debate by her constituency.

Perhaps you are in accord with her overall policies, but it's fairly routine for political parties to be cycled into power and cycled out regardless if they are liberal, conservative, etc.
 
Last edited:
I won't mind pulling a PM swap with New Zealand. Notwithstanding
her wokeness Ardern is nonetheless brighter than Trudeau. Kiwis are
way smarter than Canadians and will dump Trudeau in no time.
That's a pretty low bar saying she's brighter than Turdeau.
 
I don't think I have said anything of the sort. For like the twelfth dozen time, you have to really read what is written on the thread.

I think she did a good job during the outbreak, but New Zealand was also an exceptional situation. It's an island nation of 5 million in a remote part of the world. How she did in the post-vaccine environment seems to be a subject of debate by her constituency.

Perhaps you are in accord with her overall policies, but it's fairly routine for political parties to be cycled into power and cycled out regardless if they are liberal, conservative, etc.

I asked you if there was a country that you thought did well through covid.
You couldn't name one, or wouldn't name one.

It just sounds like you are echoing right wing talking points, you can't name specifically what she did that you think was so wrong, you can't name better policies and you can't name a place that did better.
Which makes it sound like you have no actual clue if NZ did better or worse than anyone else, just that you heard Carlson or someone else say they did poorly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SchlongConery
I asked you if there was a country that you thought did well through covid.
You couldn't name one, or wouldn't name one.

It just sounds like you are echoing right wing talking points, you can't name specifically what she did that you think was so wrong, you can't name better policies and you can't name a place that did better.
Which makes it sound like you have no actual clue if NZ did better or worse than anyone else, just that you heard Carlson or someone else say they did poorly.
The problem you routinely have Frank is that you seem to be having these inflexible discussions playing in your head. You respond to thoughts that aren't on the page.

Where did you ask me in this thread what country did well through Covid? I have no idea. I do believe you were trying to bait me into yet another Trump and DeSantis discussion. Perhaps I am mistaken, but isn't this thread about Ardern?

For the umpteenth time, every extreme progressive here should stop thinking they know how everyone thinks. Other than some short clips here on Terb, I believe I haven't seen Carlson's entire schtick in over two or three years. I actually didn't know he was on Ardern's case.
 
The problem you routinely have Frank is that you seem to be having these inflexible discussions playing in your head. You respond to thoughts that aren't on the page.

Where did you ask me in this thread what country did well through Covid? I have no idea. I do believe you were trying to bait me into yet another Trump and DeSantis discussion. Perhaps I am mistaken, but isn't this thread about Ardern?

For the umpteenth time, every extreme progressive here should stop thinking they know how everyone thinks. Other than some short clips here on Terb, I believe I haven't seen Carlson's entire schtick in over two or three years. I actually didn't know he was on Ardern's case.
It is the standard modus operandi here on TERB. It is much easier to attack somebody for against statements than for what he actually have said.
 
Frank, I'm having trouble following you. You obviously want to talk about Trump.

So to be clear, you did not ask me specifically which countries did a better job. And I had already said Ardern did a good job handling the Covid outbreak.

However, the locals might have decided for a change of direction. That very well could be due to Ardern and her party's post-vaccine management of the economy.

Frank, you're pretty much one size should fit all in your politics around the globe. You may choose to defend and fight for Ardern here, just know the Kiwis are sending a message to the NZ Labour party. It has nothing to do with Trump (or DeSantis for that matter) in the United States.
 
Frank, I'm having trouble following you. You obviously want to talk about Trump.

So to be clear, you did not ask me specifically which countries did a better job. And I had already said Ardern did a good job handling the Covid outbreak.

However, the locals might have decided for a change of direction. That very well could be due to Ardern and her party's post-vaccine management of the economy.

Frank, you're pretty much one size should fit all in your politics around the globe. You may choose to defend and fight for Ardern here, just know the Kiwis are sending a message to the NZ Labour party. It has nothing to do with Trump (or DeSantis for that matter) in the United States.

I did ask you which countries did better, I just also made reference to rump and the DeSantis to see if you thought they might be your models for covid policies.
Sorry if putting two ideas in one post was too much for you to follow.

So to be clear, you're against NZ policies, can't specify why, can't specify what could have bee done better, can't specify better policies and can't find an example of a country or party that you think did better than NZ.
 
I did ask you which countries did better, I just also made reference to rump and the DeSantis to see if you thought they might be your models for covid policies.
Sorry if putting two ideas in one post was too much for you to follow.

So to be clear, you're against NZ policies, can't specify why, can't specify what could have bee done better, can't specify better policies and can't find an example of a country or party that you think did better than NZ.
It's obvious I'm not interested in having this thread digress into another Trump discussion. If you really want to know who did well, I think several of the Asian countries did very well. They have more densely populated countries and managed through with far less fatalities. There is also a cultural aspect where the populace of these Asian countries are more risk averse and had experience combating flu outbreaks in the past.

It's very simple Frank. Ardern stuck with extreme lockdowns for too long. Covid isn't a one size fits all proposition. It's a matter of how much risk aversion a culture will support and permit.

As is fairly obvious, New Zealand is an outlier. A world map alone would attest to that geographical fact. They got a jump on things and were able to lock up their remote island nation. Good job yes, extraordinary no.

The current appraisal of Ardern's tenure can be summed up by the quotes below. I believe I specifically noted here that good policy in 2020 was not necessarily good policy in 2021 and beyond. This is in the eyes of the Kiwi electorate.

“A lot of the world was opening up, but New Zealand stayed closed, and that’s the point when the polls started to turn against her,” said Julian McCrann, a poll manager at Roy Morgan. “She got the pandemic right, until the end.”

"Ms. Ardern’s resignation, which surprised some of her supporters, shows how incumbents who were widely praised for their early pandemic response are now finding it difficult to pivot to meet the challenges of the post-Covid world."

 
Last edited:
By no means, do my posts on Ardern underestimate the political challenges of navigating through Covid and its aftermath. No matter the party leanings, leadership in democratic nations has been questioned and second guessed.

I actually concur with Fred's post below. Although, I think he's coming at it from a vote of support for Ardern. I'm coming at it from the practical realities of NZ politics.

I believe that like every other Gov't that implemented policies with the hope that they were protecting citizens, no one was going to get it right, ever.. I believe she had good intentions. As do people who see it differently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fred Flinstone
It's obvious I'm not interested in having this thread digress into another Trump discussion. If you really want to know who did well, I think several of the Asian countries did very well. They have more densely populated countries and managed through with far less fatalities. There is also a cultural aspect where the populace of these Asian countries are more risk averse and had experience combating flu outbreaks in the past.

It's very simple Frank. Ardern stuck with extreme lockdowns for too long. Covid isn't a one size fits all proposition. It's a matter of how much risk aversion a culture will support and permit.

As is fairly obvious, New Zealand is an outlier. A world map alone would attest to that geographical fact. They got a jump on things and were able to lock up their remote island nation. Good job yes, extraordinary no.

The current appraisal of Ardern's tenure can be summed up by the quotes below. I believe I specifically noted here that good policy in 2020 was not necessarily good policy in 2021 and beyond. This is in the eyes of the Kiwi electorate.

“A lot of the world was opening up, but New Zealand stayed closed, and that’s the point when the polls started to turn against her,” said Julian McCrann, a poll manager at Roy Morgan. “She got the pandemic right, until the end.”

"Ms. Ardern’s resignation, which surprised some of her supporters, shows how incumbents who were widely praised for their early pandemic response are now finding it difficult to pivot to meet the challenges of the post-Covid world."


I had no intent on derailing the thread.
Thanks for actually answering the questions.

If I have the time later I'll check the stats of NZ vs other asian countries to see how they did. China did a similar long lockdown which worked until it didn't. Ford, here, gave us the longest lockdown in NA which didn't really help out as he also cut funding from nurses and health care.
But really we need to check the death rates/hospitalizations vs economic issues
 
By no means, do my posts on Ardern underestimate the political challenges of navigating through Covid and its aftermath. No matter the party leanings, leadership in democratic nations has been questioned and second guessed.

I actually concur with Fred's post below. Although, I think he's coming at it from a vote of support for Ardern. I'm coming at it from the practical realities of NZ politics.
There's no denying I liked her as a politician..