is this something that NEEDS to be done?

Reminds me of a friend about 10 years ago. To make his wife happy he replaced the entire kitchen. Then renovated the basement, washrooms, and built an extension on the back of the house. A couple years later his wife got tired of the noise from the nearby railway tracks. He got tired of listening to his wife complain. So when some random guy asked him if he was interested in selling, he said make me an offer. The offer was for $1 million. He and his wife agreed so he called the guy back and asked him if he wanted to see inside. The guy said no, I'm tearing it down...

All that work for nothing.
 
Reminds me of a friend about 10 years ago. To make his wife happy he replaced the entire kitchen. Then renovated the basement, washrooms, and built an extension on the back of the house. A couple years later his wife got tired of the noise from the nearby railway tracks. He got tired of listening to his wife complain. So when some random guy asked him if he was interested in selling, he said make me an offer. The offer was for $1 million. He and his wife agreed so he called the guy back and asked him if he wanted to see inside. The guy said no, I'm tearing it down...

All that work for nothing.

Not exactly. They enjoyed the use of all those rooms for a few years. Maybe they didn't get their "money's worth", but you can't view renovating your primary home just as investment. Completely different story if you're house flipping.
 
Reminds me of a friend about 10 years ago. To make his wife happy he replaced the entire kitchen. Then renovated the basement, washrooms, and built an extension on the back of the house. A couple years later his wife got tired of the noise from the nearby railway tracks. He got tired of listening to his wife complain. So when some random guy asked him if he was interested in selling, he said make me an offer. The offer was for $1 million. He and his wife agreed so he called the guy back and asked him if he wanted to see inside. The guy said no, I'm tearing it down...

All that work for nothing.

When we did ours I added another bathroom in the basement, which added value, convenience, and as we only had one, was required. We also renoed upstairs to make a bigger master bedroom and greater improve closet space. Also the bathroom, which meant 4 months without it. So no choice. But worth it.

We do plan on selling, but we will get 10 years out of it in total. Good enough, I figure, because we are both MUCH happier for it. And I don't care if they teardown, I will get my price.

Btw yer buddy didn't see the signs. The first thing I said was sell and move? What are you looking for? Sometimes they don't even know until you really talk about it over time.