is this something that NEEDS to be done?

barnacler

Well-known member
May 13, 2013
1,781
1,304
113
So...

I own a house. Apparently it is worth about $1.2 million, and it is nothing really special. It is paid off.

This house has a kitchen. There is a sink, with a faucet, and a drain. No leaks. A gas stove, and an oven. Work perfectly.

Cupboards, with doors. The doors have hinges, and if you grasp the handles of the cupboard doors, the doors open and close perfectly. Some doors line up straighter than others.

There is a fair bit of counter space, and if you put a water jug on the counter, the counter can handle the weight, it does not collapse. The fridge is maybe 6 years old. To me, it is new.

Tiled floor, no cracks.

Now, to me, this is a good kitchen, but for 4 years now I have been hearing nothing but how this kitchen is "DATED". It was not installed yesterday, so it is "DATED". Dated means I guess that it doesn't look new. It isn't really impressive to be in, but I like it fine. I have enjoyed many an egg over easy with toasted rye bread in it.

So something has crept into the household conversation, and it is beginning to get on my nerves.

Apparently the kitchen NEEDS to be replaced because it is dated.

Things that I know that NEED to be done are oil changes. New tires as required. New roof when the shingles are overdue.

But a cabinet hinge? A counter top? Do they wear out so that they are imminent danger of collapse?

Do the pyramids need to be replaced because they are "Dated"?

WTF, apparently a new kitchen will cost around $75,000. Now, that is after-tax, so I need to earn $150,000 to get that because I earn about $285,000 a year.

So i am supposed to work for over a half YEAR for a new kitchen merely to look better?

And, when will IT become dated? When will the bathroom, and every other room become dated?

Time to draw a line in the sand I think.

Starting to think SHE is dated!
 
If you don't move in the "upper echelons", and aren't planning to sell the house, and everything works...

You may be right...

She watches too many HGTV reno programs
 
  • Like
Reactions: SQUAD51 and y2kmark
So...

I own a house. Apparently it is worth about $1.2 million, and it is nothing really special. It is paid off.

This house has a kitchen. There is a sink, with a faucet, and a drain. No leaks. A gas stove, and an oven. Work perfectly.

Cupboards, with doors. The doors have hinges, and if you grasp the handles of the cupboard doors, the doors open and close perfectly. Some doors line up straighter than others.

There is a fair bit of counter space, and if you put a water jug on the counter, the counter can handle the weight, it does not collapse. The fridge is maybe 6 years old. To me, it is new.

Tiled floor, no cracks.

Now, to me, this is a good kitchen, but for 4 years now I have been hearing nothing but how this kitchen is "DATED". It was not installed yesterday, so it is "DATED". Dated means I guess that it doesn't look new. It isn't really impressive to be in, but I like it fine. I have enjoyed many an egg over easy with toasted rye bread in it.

So something has crept into the household conversation, and it is beginning to get on my nerves.

Apparently the kitchen NEEDS to be replaced because it is dated.

Things that I know that NEED to be done are oil changes. New tires as required. New roof when the shingles are overdue.

But a cabinet hinge? A counter top? Do they wear out so that they are imminent danger of collapse?

Do the pyramids need to be replaced because they are "Dated"?

WTF, apparently a new kitchen will cost around $75,000. Now, that is after-tax, so I need to earn $150,000 to get that because I earn about $285,000 a year.

So i am supposed to work for over a half YEAR for a new kitchen merely to look better?

And, when will IT become dated? When will the bathroom, and every other room become dated?

Time to draw a line in the sand I think.

Starting to think SHE is dated!
I guess it depends, if you’re house is a tear down once sold, don’t put in any upgrades. If it’s big and solidly built, then the upgrades are an investment
 
I was gonna say the same thing. Sounds like your partner is also dated and needs to be replaced.
 
If your are married and improve the house she gets 50% of the improved value. Even in Ontario Common-law the family home value will be divided.
Suggest to her that you both borrow and share the costs that way she might think twice about getting a costly kitchen reno done on her dime.
Next up would no doubt be a total reno to other areas of the house which could morph into $250,000 or more.
If you plan to move do nothing and let the new buyers tear it down or reno - detached houses will sell. Ask a realtor whether it makes sense.
 
Houses in my area are 50 years old. Immediately after being sold a dumpster shows up and major renovations begin. (A fire in one nearby - the house is still standing , but will be a tear down. ) In a kitchen . repainting solid cabinetry , goes a long way . OR changing the hardware - pull tabs , handles. In my frugal opinion
 
Keep telling her you'll renovate next year. This worked for me for about 15 years.
 
So...

I own a house. Apparently it is worth about $1.2 million, and it is nothing really special. It is paid off.

This house has a kitchen. There is a sink, with a faucet, and a drain. No leaks. A gas stove, and an oven. Work perfectly.

Cupboards, with doors. The doors have hinges, and if you grasp the handles of the cupboard doors, the doors open and close perfectly. Some doors line up straighter than others.

There is a fair bit of counter space, and if you put a water jug on the counter, the counter can handle the weight, it does not collapse. The fridge is maybe 6 years old. To me, it is new.

Tiled floor, no cracks.

Now, to me, this is a good kitchen, but for 4 years now I have been hearing nothing but how this kitchen is "DATED". It was not installed yesterday, so it is "DATED". Dated means I guess that it doesn't look new. It isn't really impressive to be in, but I like it fine. I have enjoyed many an egg over easy with toasted rye bread in it.

So something has crept into the household conversation, and it is beginning to get on my nerves.

Apparently the kitchen NEEDS to be replaced because it is dated.

Things that I know that NEED to be done are oil changes. New tires as required. New roof when the shingles are overdue.

But a cabinet hinge? A counter top? Do they wear out so that they are imminent danger of collapse?

Do the pyramids need to be replaced because they are "Dated"?

WTF, apparently a new kitchen will cost around $75,000. Now, that is after-tax, so I need to earn $150,000 to get that because I earn about $285,000 a year.

So i am supposed to work for over a half YEAR for a new kitchen merely to look better?

And, when will IT become dated? When will the bathroom, and every other room become dated?

Time to draw a line in the sand I think.

Starting to think SHE is dated!
you are a practical guy and see the kitchen as usable. she sees the kitchen as dated and it reflects poorly on her because its old and not keeping up with the jones. its all about image for some people.

my parents still have some of the original furniture that they had when I was a kid. its still in great shape and works, just dated. I see nothing wrong with that, it beats pissing away thousands to impress other people.

how about this solution. tell the misses if she wants a new kitchen she can pay for it out of the money she earns and not yours :)
 
From your detailed description - the kitchen is fine mate. Enjoy many more mornings with the eggs and rye. BTW - rye bread is a game changer - love it, try sour dough rye bread mate - amazing.
 
sold my 70 year old house,,, almost in original condition,, same ole bathroom, same ole kitchen. Painted the place and removed the carpet...wood floors refinished.. SOLD,, way over asking
 
She watches too many HGTV reno programs

Holy crap, you are dead-on! I see her watching shows like that all the time, I can't stand them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roadhog
So on the other side........

We did a reno about 3 years ago. Total tear out. Redid everything. And it was worth it. We open concepted between the kitchen and dining toom, added an island, increased counter space, filled in a North facing side window that looked out to a brick wall, put in a huge pantry, added pot drawers(so good), added appliance drawers(even better!), spice rack slide out, extra dedicated plugs for appliances so chargers etc could be added. New touch faucet(so convenient). A dedicated space beside the patio door off the dining room(extended from kitchen as counter space) for bbq gear. Soft LED lights undermounted we never turn off(great at night). I can go on. So many modern convenience things out there now.

As the cook I can tell you it was worth it to me. And the structural changes will hold up in value.

I organized it myself, and three years later I'm still a hero. We laugh about the "husband" points earned but really it was worth it. And I make Alot less that you. Money is cheap to borrow now. Credit lines cost so little you can spread it out and not notice it.

Take another look at this. And make it a negotiation point. Explain what has to be given up to do it. Make it her decision to cut costs on other things. Make it an "our future" argument to rid yourself of other costs you hate. I did this. She is actually happy about the cost cuts now. Has realized some stupid consumer spending was just that.

If you plan to stay in the house its worth it.
 
First, we need pictures. How old is the kitchen? Do you plan on staying in the house for a while? If so, Butler1000 is absolutely correct. And with an annual salary of $285K, why not enjoy some of the finer things in life? A renovated modern kitchen is a pure joy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thumper18474
House prices in the GTHA are just going off the charts these days. My son in law has been transferred to Milton From Bowmanville so they are looking now.Its crazy!
 
Tell her to paint a room and rearrange the furniture. Tell her she can do it as a project. You will get the supplies and move the furniture with her but she can paint and come up with the new arraignment.

She will get annoyed painting and won’t want to do it. Then you can say - I don’t want to do the kitchen.

LoL

Well hopefully that will work if it was me - I would be all for it. LOL I repainted the whole house Dec 2019. I should have waited a few months because then I could have done it during COVID but it was fun. For me at least.
 
See if you can find a well qualified home inspector. Check plumbing, wiring airflows, any moisture problems etc... Score a few points is you can find a qualified female to more easily deal with the wife...
 
Of course you don't "need" to do a full reno if everything is in working order. But there are fairly cheap things you can do to make the kitchen look nicer or more functional.

Paint the front or change out the cabinet and drawer doors. That obviously only works if you cannot see the sides of the cabinets.
Give all the kitchen surfaces (inside and outside of cabinets and doors, range hood, range, toaster, etc) a deep cleaning. You'll be amazed how much oil and grease gets caked onto these things.
Change the drawer and door knobs.
Add pull out shelves in hard to reach areas like under the sink or deep cabinets
Add soft closing hinges so your cabinet doors don't slam
There are soft closing tracks for drawers too. The tracks are quite thick and are installed on the outside of your drawers. So you will very likely have to rebuilt or replace your drawers.

The easiest thing to do is do a kitchen "detox." Get rid of or store any old or seldom used utensils, appliances, or even food stuffs that you don't use that often. I'm always amazed of how much junk accumulates in the kitchen over the years. Get some kitchen organization stuff from Ikea, Kitchen Stuff Plus, etc so that everything has its place.