Is this oil change overkill?

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
30,283
2,692
113
I change my own oil because I can do it in 20 minutes. I have a 3 ton jack and jack stands. I also use synthetic oil at 8000km intervals. Every 4th. oil change I empty the oil out without changing the oil filter and use some regular oil to flush out the dirt in the engine. I run the engine for a week with the regular oil. Then I change the oil with synthetic oil and replace oil filter. The oil is so clean that it is even hard to see it on the dipstick. My last flush and synthetic oil change was 3000kms ago, and the oil looks like honey on the dipstick.
Is this overkill?
 
You really should be using pure virgin olive oil and changing it on a weekly basis. Where were you raised anyway?
 
I am not Italian. Minchia!
 
I just got a new truck a few months ago - dealership recommends oil changes every roughly every 7k with conventional, or 12k with synthetic; Ford (it's an F150 with the 5.0L) recommends conventional oil, and to go by the oil-life monitor, which should be somewhere between 7-10k depending on driving habits...

I think your routine is overkill - but, personally, I'd rather change it too often, then not often enough (my ex FIL used to do an oil change once a year - and he was a highway commuter - he never understood why he never got more then 3-4 years out of a car... Hmmm)
 
Unless you drive an insane amount of miles, a modern car should rust away long before the engine fails. This is Ontario not Arizona.
 
There is a study done (I have it somewhere) they took a fleet of taxis in NY city and changed the oil regularly on some and some were left without a change for the whole year. The result was that there was exactly the same wear on all of them. So I called the the automobile protection association and they confirmed the same and supported the study.
 

Is this overkill?

Definitely!!!
Best to go by what your manual says.
Doing it more often won't hurt but you are just throwing money away.
 
Definitely!!!
Best to go by what your manual says.
Doing it more often won't hurt but you are just throwing money away.

I wait for the synthetic oil to go on special and buy enough for 4 or 5 oil changes. Specials on synthetic oil can be as cheap as $16 for 4 liters, but most of the time the specials are $20-$24 / 4 liters. The filters are about $6 each.
 
Last edited:
I have changed my own oil eons ago but no more (fuck it).

Ya it's overkill when we speak of today's cars, but are you driving a vintage or classic car? I would think more frequent oil changes (like 3,000 km or 3 months, whichever comes 1st) are recommended for older vehicles. Anyone?
 
It is massive over kill, unless you only do 8000 km every year and rarely dive more then 10 km. If you use syn.. 10K km is more then enough...
 
I would think more frequent oil changes (like 3,000 km or 3 months, whichever comes 1st) are recommended for older vehicles. Anyone?

Since the 80s I have changed my own oil every 5000 miles and never had any problems. Back then I put a lot of mileage on my vehicles keeping them till ~100,000 miles before trading them in for a new one.

Now I rely on the GM Oil Monitoring System and wait till it goes down to ZERO before changing the oil. FWIW changed the oil a couple weeks ago when the Oil Monitoring System hit ZERO after putting ~7,000 miles on the vehicle, on the last oil change.

BTW the dealer still recommends oil changes every 3000 miles, which is total BS!
 
The only draw-back I can see is on start-up, there is a dry run moment while the filter fills up. usually, we hear a little knock-knock on first start-up after an oil change. this may not matter. i'm not sure. if you feel better doing it, tho, go ahead. i don't know where you got that interspersing regular oil with synthetic as a cleansing. i think you're over-thinking this.
 
What kind of Vehicle? cost of car under $100K, yes overkill, over $100K..... you can afford it......engine oil is the blood of your car
 
The only draw-back I can see is on start-up, there is a dry run moment while the filter fills up. usually, we hear a little knock-knock on first start-up after an oil change. this may not matter. i'm not sure. if you feel better doing it, tho, go ahead. i don't know where you got that interspersing regular oil with synthetic as a cleansing. i think you're over-thinking this.

I fill the oil filter up with oil and let it stand for a few minutes and let it soak in before I install it on the engine. This way the new oil flow is much quicker through the filter.

When the synthetic oil is used for 8000km. the oil is black. Every 4th. synthetic oil change I put in some regular oil and wrinse out all the crap in the engine, I run it for a week and it comes out dark like cola. Then I do a complete synthetic oil change with new filter. The engine oil looks like when you got the car new, you can barely see it on the dipstick.

 
You're being extremely conservative in your approach & never really approaching the service life of your synthetic oil. How do you drive? Mostly city, highway or some combination? Do you run your motor at high revolutions, or do you tow heavy loads around? Modern motor oils, especially the synthetics, can go a lot longer than the oil company's marketing people would have you believe. Motor oil turning a darker color is not an indication that it's dirty - it's a function of the detergents in the oil doing their job. That being said, you're not hurting your engine at all by your approach, but one could argue that you're spending more money on oil than you need to.

I drive my 550i fast, which in our city means I'm hard on brakes, tires, & clutches. I go with a 10,000km oil & filter change interval.

R2R
 
What kind of vehicle do you drive C Cat?

S Cat, I wouldn't bother with the extra flush you do. If it made that much of a difference, manufacturers would include it as part of their regularly scheduled maintenance. After all, they're the ones who warrant their product.

Yes. Wayyyyyyy overkill.

Most modern engines are exceedingly clean running and have very little combustion blowby and wear metals...

Have to agree with rub100 an all his points. The only other thing I would add is that you should always use a an OEM filter and not a Motomaster special. The Crappy Tire ones have 1/2 the amount of material in them.

Very few engines nowadays wear out.

The only exception is if they have an inherent problem or design flaw.

It's a good idea to fill the filter with oil before you install it. Another thing you can do is place a Neodymium magnet on the drain plug which will attract any particles of metal that don't get caught by the filter.

A good percentage of engine wear is on startup when a lot of the oil has worked its way to the bottom of the engine. Synthetic oils help alleviate this problem. They also flow better through the tiny passages.