Is this even legal?

needinit

New member
Jan 19, 2004
1,191
1
0
My SO thinks my son may hook up with her daughter - we are living together but not married....would this even be legal (assuming legal age etc is not an issue)? (ie in theory, step brother and sister getting together)...I'm pretty sure it's not acceptable but my SO thinks it would be okay
 
My SO thinks my son may hook up with her daughter - we are living together but not married....would this even be legal (assuming legal age etc is not an issue)? (ie in theory, step brother and sister getting together)...I'm pretty sure it's not acceptable but my SO thinks it would be okay

Not married, so not step brother and sister, and not blood relatives and of legal age. I would say there is no impediment unless you feel it is too close to home. For you ! They will sort it out.
 
Has an american ring to it.

It would be more interesting if the father marries the daughter and the son marries the mother. Then the brother in law would be his mother, and ......
 
http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/M-2.1/page-1.html#s-1.

"Marriage (Prohibited Degrees) Act
S.C. 1990, c. 46

An Act respecting the laws prohibiting marriage between related persons

Her Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Senate and House of Commons of Canada, enacts as follows:

Marginal note:Short title
1. This Act may be cited as the Marriage (Prohibited Degrees) Act.

2. (1) Subject to subsection (2), persons related by consanguinity, affinity or adoption are not prohibited from marrying each other by reason only of their relationship.

Marginal note:Prohibition
(2) No person shall marry another person if they are related lineally, or as brother or sister or half-brother or half-sister, including by adoption.
1990, c. 46, s. 2;2005, c. 33, s. 13.


Marginal note:Marriage not invalid
3. (1) Subject to subsection (2), a marriage between persons related by consanguinity, affinity or adoption is not invalid by reason only of their relationship.

Marginal note:Marriage void

(2) A marriage between persons who are related in the manner described in subsection 2(2) is void."

So not unless you adopt her daughter, or she adopts your son.
 
Yeah...my first thought was...this is freakin weird...and I'm not sure why my SO is even bringing it up.
BTW she did ask if I would adopt her daughter if we got married so that does bring it into Hillbilly territory!!!

Loved some of the responses BTW
 
Yeah...my first thought was...this is freakin weird...and I'm not sure why my SO is even bringing it up.
BTW she did ask if I would adopt her daughter if we got married so that does bring it into Hillbilly territory!!!

Loved some of the responses BTW
It is also interesting, seeing people's pseudo-knowledge about consanguinity and genetic disease.

Having children with a sibling is not a good idea, First Cousins if you keep "line breeding" is probably not the very best of ideas, but second cousins, Half-Uncles etc. . . come on perhaps time to talk to the folks at a genetic counseling clinic and find out what the facts actually are.
 
So not unless you adopt her daughter, or she adopts your son.

The Act speaks to marriage. Nothing stops common-law relationships (or as my father once put it, "living in sin")

As for adoption, why bother? The Family Law Act would make your SO's daughter your child as soon as you demonstrate a settled intention to treat as a child of his or her family. Take her to play soccer, The Ex and family vacations together and she's your daughter for the purposes of that Act (i.e. child support.)
 
This is marriage. Nothing stops common-law relationships (or as my father once put it, "living in sin")
Read the law again. Perhaps I am incorrect, but I know of no provision of Canadian or U.S. law that provides that when you marry someone who has children, that you by function of the marriage have adopted the children.

It is the adoption that would make any marriage of these two unrelated (or at least unrelated closely) two children void. The Family Law Act has nothing to do with this.
 
It is also interesting, seeing people's pseudo-knowledge about consanguinity and genetic disease.

Having children with a sibling is not a good idea, First Cousins if you keep "line breeding" is probably not the very best of ideas, but second cousins, Half-Uncles etc. . . come on perhaps time to talk to the folks at a genetic counseling clinic and find out what the facts actually are.

Just look at the British Royal family. At least they are now trying to get some fresh blood stock.
 
The Act speaks to marriage. Nothing stops common-law relationships (or as my father once put it, "living in sin")

As for adoption, why bother? The Family Law Act would make your SO's daughter your child as soon as you demonstrate a settled intention to treat as a child of his or her family. Take her to play soccer, The Ex and family vacations together and she's your daughter for the purposes of that Act (i.e. child support.)

Some would say the same regarding marriage. Act like a couple for so long, and you are, under the law. But many people do the formal thing and marry. Same with adopting.

I am curious about how old the kids are in the OP's case, and why it is the daughter's mom even thinks this is a possibility. Have the kids even shown a romantic interest in each other? Or is this just a case of a hyopthetical conversation along the lines of "Say, wouldn't it be funny if Mike and Debbie decided to hook up? Gee, I wonder if they even can?"
 
Just look at the British Royal family. At least they are now trying to get some fresh blood stock.
Actually not all that many first cousin marriages and even more distant relationships have not been to the same line repeatedly.

Since the Electress Sophia only George I and Victoria have married their first cousin.
 
It is not illegal since they are not blood related, but it will be all the talk that will be psychologically damaging to them and the family.
 
Is your SO your sister... if not you should be OK...
 
Read the law again. Perhaps I am incorrect, but I know of no provision of Canadian or U.S. law that provides that when you marry someone who has children, that you by function of the marriage have adopted the children.

It is the adoption that would make any marriage of these two unrelated (or at least unrelated closely) two children void. The Family Law Act has nothing to do with this.

If you read my post carefully, you'll see that I noted two things. First is the issue of legal marriage which is quite different than common-law relationships. Can the courts prevent step-siblings from shacking up and hooking up. No, it can't. Incest is a sexual offence and defined as blood relationship, parent, child, sibling, grandparent, grandchild. So while it might be distasteful, step-siblings can have sex with each other as much as they like when they're teenagers, move out, live together and continue to do the wiggly-jiggly.

My second point is questioning the need to go through the formal process of adoption. The OP will have to jump through a bunch of hurdles, maybe have to seek consent from the biological father and go through the courts for an order of adoption.

For the purposes of family law, the OP doesn't need to get a court order to "adopt" a child formally under the Child and Family Services Act for him to be considered a parent. If the OP treats his SO's daughter like he would a child that's all it takes for the OP's daughter to be his child and for him to be her parent on matters related to family law.
 
If you read my post carefully, you'll see that I noted two things. First is the issue of legal marriage which is quite different than common-law relationships. Can the courts prevent step-siblings from shacking up and hooking up. No, it can't.
We are beating a dead horse.

However, note that the Marriage (Prohibited Degrees) Act states that certain marriages are void. Without looking up any rullings on this, I'd say that would apply to Common Law marriages as well.