Is this all just teacher bashing?

Regular Guy said:
I have read with interest and not a little disappointment the comments bashing teachers. . So if you wonder why I feel many here are ““shooting from the lip””, that is why. The whole discussion up to now has suffered from an appalling lack of first, fact, second, objectivity and third, logical premise. Without these, it does teachers a great disservice and, second, definitely fails to rise above the level of ““bashing.”” IMHO educated people should refrain from being a part of any of the threads here related to this topic unless they are able to contribute in a more enlightened fashion. I don't feel this is an unreasonable expectation on my part.


Well let me tell you , on this subject I am not shooting from the lip , my brother teaches although as a guest artist in music , his wife teaches , my cousin teaches . I do not bash teachers therefore but I know from experience that they think their profession only has problems , they fail to realize the business world has problems also. That is my beef with them , plus people in the corporate world don't get 2 months vacation .
 
Questor said:
Very interesting information frankcastle. 3% over 3 years, eh? Those greedy bastards. LOL It never ceases to amaze me how some people begrudge the fact that other people actually are not horribly exploited in the workplace. Such people would be happy if we all had McJobs at minimum wage (as long as they themselves didn't have to do it). I think you are right on the money about taxpayers being the biggest whiners of all. Now what about those hated teachers pensions? After 40 or 45 years in the classroom, devoted to educating OUR children, just how much of a pension is a teacher entitled to? The objection seems to be that if it is above the poverty line, then it must be too much.

Do the math and quit the hyperbole. With the 85 rule no one works 40 to 45 years "devoted" years in the classroom. Hope you are not a math teacher.
 
Hyperbole? There you go with the vague accusations again. I don't think there is anything wrong with my math. If someone graduates in their early 20s and begins teaching, in 40 years they will be thinking about retiring. I think I know what it is that is bothering you. It bugs you that anyone can be "devoted" to anything but making money for themselves.
 
Questor said:
Hyperbole? There you go with the vague accusations again. I don't think there is anything wrong with my math. If someone graduates in their early 20s and begins teaching, in 40 years they will be thinking about retiring. I think I know what it is that is bothering you. It bugs you that anyone can be "devoted" to anything but making money for themselves.

With the 85 rule, if they start teaching at 23 they can retire at 54 at full pension ( age plus service) that is 31 years of teaching, not the 40 to 45 you toss around. I am not just devoted to making money, I spend a lot of time planning for and enjoying hedonistic pleasure so you see that I am not a one dimensional person.:D
 
Salary

Thanks Regular Guy for initiating an intelligent discussion. I really don't believe those who continue to lash out at teachers know what they are talking about. If they did, they would be quoting facts rather than spewing hatred. So how much does a Toronto elementary school teacher make, if it such an outrageous amount? How much has their pay increased over the last 10 years, if their pay increases are so much? And how does the pay compare to salaries in professions with similar qualifications? If the allegations are true, I'd reallly be interested to know the facts, rather than vague accusations that really amount to nothing.

Frankcastle basically covered the nitty gritty of salary structure. But I think it bears emphasizing that reports of salary in the media almost invariably involve the top echelon of the salary structure just like it would in most careers which refer to themselves as professions. This does not in any way reflect the reality of teacher salaries. The salary for a beginning teacher is, for the most part considerably less. And there is a large proprtion of the teaching profession working their way up the ladder. And many of these have the additional burden of having to pay off student loans for years to come. I don't think I need to quote tuition fees here. They are atrocious. I hope that will mollify those horrified at the disposition of their tax dollar.
 
2 months vacation?

This idea of two months vacation has an interesting history. In days long past we were largely an agrarian society. The most productive time of the year involved the growing season and this was the time when the presence of children (a valuable labour asset) was required at home, especially for the harvest. As the years went on the labour requirement was slowly replaced with the concept of letting children be children as well as the increasing practise of the family vacation. This is largely where we are at today. There has been talk of semestering the year but quite frankly the voting public has expressed little interest in the idea. It might keep those pesky teachers busy but would also inconvenience everyone else. Different schoolboards subsequently developed different postures on the subject where contracts were concerned. At one time the old Ottawa Separate School Board or Nepean (I can't remember which) told its teachers that they were on a ten month contract. Now if it were proposed to semester again I honestly doubt whether the idea would be well endorsed by the public. But hey give it a whirl. But please consider also the adjustments to the system which might need to be made. Be careful what you wish for.
 
teaching time

Now let's talk about a teacher's time expenditure. The public notes the actual time teachers have contact with their students. This is the high profile aspect of it all. This is why, for example, coaching often comes up in debate. The public sees their kids on the bus by 3:30 and says: "What a cushy job. There they go, home to lie in the sun." Well I have a little news flash: Time spent in the classroom is only the tip of the iceberg. A case in point: A complete set of report cards prepared electronically with usually a week to do it in, requires at least 20 hours. Now some teachers may be able to shave time on the comments but if anyone can do them(elementary or secondary with custom comments) in under that I will buy them a steak dinner(I took my own poll on that one).
What about prep time. Again if you are lucky enough to be left with the same preps year after year you can often get it down to a system. But that happens only very rarely these days. Many new initiatives are shoe-horned into the curriculum. Teachers are often shifted around with a frequency which would make the NHL gasp. How about Administrivia. I n days past a teacher had to dust out the mail box. Now they need a crowbar to get it all out and time to "tame the paper tiger."
Now I don't know what perceptions have been formed about teaching which are rooted in past years but the job is very different today. Now I have definitely not covered all of the issue teachers have to deal with on a daily basis. You can take what I have discussed and multiply it times three. And at the risk of triviality and in all fairness, the workload will vary from teacher to teacher depending on the circumstances they happen to be in at the moment. But then isn't that true of all your offices as well?
 
Last edited:
I feel for you, really

Had another meeting the school today. Finally new tech. programming for him. Personal in-school laptop with specialized software, only possible to get .5 per day EA support but I will fight that for more. I will get no other support for him and for the whole 1 h 15 min meeting I had to stress the education. I will not have any teacher or any member of the Durham Board or the Ministry of Education work towards placing my son in the "route to employment" high school program and give up on giving him the chance to even make it to college. I don't care what numbers are in what class, what taxes need to be paid, I don't care about any of the reasons and excuses that can and will be given. Every child has the right to a full time, proper education and should not be labelled and given up on at any time. The simple fact that high school is put into catagories of work placement, college placement or University placement is nuts.

Having said all that, I will say this as well, just as the teachers and board of education{s} have a responsiblity to the children that they teach, the government needs to change some things on their end as well. I don't care about either side, I care about my child's side and every other kid out there like him who is suffering because of the BS games the teachers, unions, boards and government play together. I just happen to deal with the teachers all the time. That is what I see first hand every day and so that is the problem that is going to naturally in the front of my mind.

Sounds like you are having quite a frustrating time of it. I understand how that can be a source of frustration and disappointment. It sounds like your son was having problems academically, that this was spotted by his
teacher(s). I hope and am assuming that an IPRC was done with all in agreement and a course of action prescribed. Learning disabilities or the like can be a heartbreaker. Our system is following a design instituted over a hundred years ago, maybe earlier. When you think of it classroom design has changed very little since the 1800's. Individual learning differences are balanced against resources available. I don't know the answer. Policy ultimately does not reside with teachers. This is often a case of common practice. For example, some school boards subscribe to the practice of streaming. I can tell by your sentiments that you feel the process to be unfair. Personally, if it is merely a case of a lack of academic horsepower I would bust my butt for that child within reason of course(It has always been my contention that every taxpayer with a child in class deserves bang for the buck).
It is often the case, however, that a child cannot function within a normal classroom setting and requires intervention. Unfortunately more and more children are showing up today and being IPRC'd as "Extreme Behaviour". They can be literally, at times, impossible to handle. A new policy has surfaced, probably as a result of objections from parents such as yourself citing the charter of rights and freedoms. This policy offers the parent the final say as to whether a child should be streamed or not. Such a policy often mollifies a parent but you can kiss goodbye to many of those well planned lessons. A child requiring intervention can make a shambles out of a class not to mention, at times being a hazard to others. Those are the pros and cons. So try to be a little bit objective when it comes to deciding a course of action. And remember that as members of a society not one of us lives in a vacuum. Whatever each of us does affects the other. I am not saying to cease advocating for your child but to keep an open mind.
 
Just a further as to who will have to pick up the tab for the pension fund shortfall: The teachers will. I hope that satisfies the whining taxpayers lol.
 
OMFG! Do you teachers not understand that WE went through school in Ontario? That our kids and friend's kids are now going to school in Ontario? And that we have seen a DECREASE in education standards from the teachers? Do you not get it's our collective experiences that make us puke whenever we hear you overpaid buffoons whine and complain while NOT TEACHING OUR KIDS? ARGH! Ontario public school teachers are disgrace to the teaching profession.
 
Pilotas said:
frankcastle or anyone, I would be interested in knowing more facts about teachers renumeration.i.e.
vacation entitlement
sick leave (i have heard that they can accrue their leave if not taken - is this true?)
how much union fee $'s per annum
prep time allowance (and is it really needed if they have been teaching the same course yeaer in year out?)
Any other benifits I haven't thought about?

Vacation time is march break (1 week), Xmas (2 weeks), Easter (2 days), Thanksgiving (1 day).

**Whoops** coach noticed I forgot to list (2 months in the summer) but really who didn't know about that one.

Sick days you get 20 per year and if you accumulate a max of 200 some odd when you retire you can cash them in for money.

If you want to take time off during the school year it is frowned upon and difficult to do honestly (I suppose you could call in sick for several days). If you are honest you can take days off but not get paid. But if you get caught being dishonest you can get in trouble.... how much I don't know.

Union fees.... not sure but here's what I get after all deductions.

I did a little calculation as for deductions (EI, CPP, income tax, Pension, health benefits) I take home 49% of my original salary. But when I retire I get 2% for each year that I work for a max of 70% (for 35 years of teaching.... but you can qulaify to retire when you reach the 85 factor.... your age + years of teaching=85).

Benefits include a dental plan, drug plan, eye glasses ($200 max per year), orthotics, massage ($700), you also get discounts at certain stores like the Brick and a few other places.

One cool thing you can do is call 3 on 4 or 4 on 5. Which is where you can take three or 4 years of pay and spread it over 4 or 5 years and take a year off. But that slows down your retirement age.
 
Last edited:
LancsLad said:
Do the math and quit the hyperbole. With the 85 rule no one works 40 to 45 years "devoted" years in the classroom. Hope you are not a math teacher.

You gotta teach 35 years or lose 2% of your salary for each year you retire early. So if you retire at 55 (assuming you start teaching at 25) you get 60% of 85 000 which is good but I think you'd stick around for another 5 years or lose out on 10% of 85 000 (i.e. $8500/year)
 
rama putri said:
OMFG! Do you teachers not understand that WE went through school in Ontario? That our kids and friend's kids are now going to school in Ontario? And that we have seen a DECREASE in education standards from the teachers? Do you not get it's our collective experiences that make us puke whenever we hear you overpaid buffoons whine and complain while NOT TEACHING OUR KIDS? ARGH! Ontario public school teachers are disgrace to the teaching profession.

Decrease in education standards. Please clarify this.

One of the most damaging things was when participation/ homework/latemarks could no longer be held against students for marks.

How about an elementary system that has to bow to the demands of a parent if they want their kid not to be held back the kid won't. So surprise surprise when the kid gets to high school and can't multiply or do fractions and tries his/her hand at calculus.

Look I went through school here to and sometimes I'm surprised but Rama, did you take all advanced courses? I'm guessing you did so how do you know what it was like in general and basic courses? and how do you know what it's really like in school now.

Unfortunately you guys are basing this on your limited experiences and hearsay. Hearsay is not allowed in a court of law because it is not necessarily based on any facts.

Show me numbers that support your argument.

Furthermore, show me data that suggests a decline is the sole responsibility of the teachers. I think the increase in two parents working or single families have a far greater impact on the children than anything else. People are working harder these days and don't have the time to put towards their kids as people used to. Now I'm not saying everyone is a bad parent..... I'm saying that parents are busier than ever and this is having a negative impact on children.

When I was a kid vid game time and tv time were regulated. I never hear kids talk about things like that at all.

So is it the teachers sole fault or also partly the responsibility of the government for changes in policy and changes in society and parents?

The success of a student is a multifactored equation and far more complex than the quality of the teacher. I'm sorry but it's just too simplistic.

Oh yeah another huge policy change was the shift from 5 to 4 years for HS. A lot of kids were affected by this try squeezing what used to be done in 5 years into 4 and see what happens..... the most dramatic effect of this is seen in math.

So again.... bad teacher? Or bad policies.

People who complain about how bad things are should do something about it. Do you guys vote, talk to principals, talk to super intendents, write letters to the minister of education. There are things you and others can do but choose not to.

Hey KWI,

More power to you. You are doing the best you can, principals try their best to please parents.... if they didn
't hear from you nothing would happen.

I wish they could give your son an EA all day but remember an EA makes probably 30 some odd k or more (but far less than a teacher) and unfortunately there's no way a school can afford to provide enough of them to go around.

Best of luck with your son's education. I know it's not much comfort but at least the government is footing this bill even if it's not to the tune that you would like.
 
I'm curious here what is the average income of a person with 4 to 5 years in university? That would be the best way to compare how teachers stack up in terms of being overpaid.

As for retirement age it is probably on average higher than 54/55 because a fair number of teachers teach in the private sector first (pensions don't start till you join the public school system).

Also, quite a few teachers have other jobs before becoming a teacher.
 
Why is it that none of these taxpayers complain about the government helping to fund catholic schools?
 
Quite a diatribe!

OMFG! Do you teachers not understand that WE went through school in Ontario? That our kids and friend's kids are now going to school in Ontario? And that we have seen a DECREASE in education standards from the teachers? Do you not get it's our collective experiences that make us puke whenever we hear you overpaid buffoons whine and complain while NOT TEACHING OUR KIDS? ARGH! Ontario public school teachers are disgrace to the teaching profession.

Well Frankcastle covered most of the salient points so I wont repeat.

It would have been great if you had read the thread in its entirety before sounding off. Like Frankcastle I will ask: Have you really seen a decrease in educational standards from the teachers. All is not as it seems my friend. Society has changed in many ways and this has directly affected how effective teachers can be with program delivery. Like Morpheus in the movie The Matrix we can't tell you it is so, we have to show you. The orderly learning environment of years past has undergone a major change, and not for the better. Apply for a job occasional teaching and see for yourself. Don't take our word for it(since you don't seem to want to read what we have written.) And I think teachers are getting a little fed up with being whipping boy for all who come up a bit short on parenting skills and take it out on the teacher.(And yes I realize there are many great parents out there - God bless them). So perhaps some plain talk is needed here. Clean your own house first before you go looking at what we can do. Canada has the finest teachers in the world. They are in demand internationally at all levels and in the US. Check it out.

The teachers are the first cohort in the hierarchy in Education. It is they who have to take the heat for the misguided initiatives that filter down from the top. Don't try to lay illiteracy on us when it was the Ministry of Education who enforced the screwball approach referred to as "Whole Language." Now if you want to debate this rationally how about dealing with the points made by Frankcastle and myself.
 
"Vacation time is march break (1 week), Xmas (2 weeks), Easter (2 days), Thanksgiving (1 day)."

What about the summer? They are paid for teh summer, they just get their money throughout the school year. Who else gets this amount of time off?

"Sick days you get 20 per year and if you accumulate a max of 200 some odd when you retire you can cash them in for money."

20 days a year? They accumulate? Unreal!!

These are so far above the norm, even for executives & professionals.
 
20 days is a lot I usually use 4 or 5. But it is a lot easier to get sick in proximity to kids who are not as good at preventing the spread of illnesses as CEOs. :D

As for the summer.... technically we are paid for 10 months of work and the money is spread over 12 months. But I didn't mention it because I forgot.

Yes the holidays are nice but remember the pay is a salary just like most professional jobs.

It used to be that teachers were paid only for 10 months of the year but a lot didn't budget well so they spread the same amount of money over 12 months.

In my school board I get a lump sum at the beginning of the summer. Not a good idea seeing as I'm a sucker for a good slide.

Yes the holidays are great.

You guys knew full well even as children about these days off so quit complaining that you don't get that in your job. Sorry but if you want to use that argument against complaining teachers the same logic has to be applied to you guys as well (i.e. the argument that teachers shouldn't complain because they knew what they were getting into).

I really wonder what people on this board do for a living if they are all comparing themselves to teachers you can't be doing that well. When I go to places like HFH or IT (when it was open) I was usually pulling up in the worst car (i.e. a $25 000 car versus the lexus, acuras, bmws, benzs etc. You guys need to figure out what those guys are doing.
 
Let's see, 8 weeks in the summer, 2 at Christmas plus 1 at March break, plus 5 weeks "sick"....16 weeks!!!:eek:
That's "nice"? Holy s*** that's unreal, you guys are spoiled. What bothers me most is that I rarely hear a teacher appreciate just how good they have it, they have an attitude of entitlement . They forget they are public servants, our taxes pay their wages and contribute to the gold plated pensions.
They are spoiled children.
 
Lets not forget an added perk, retired Teachers hiring themselves back into the system as "Subsitutes", when the regualr teachers callin sick, at an hourly rate of $40/Hr....not bad for what amounts to being a glorified day-babysitter.