Strikes?
However after making that choice, to strike for better conditions is insulting. If I don't like my job, I move on to a different company or career. I make the choice. I don't call a strike and shut down the company or hold my clients for ransom.
An interesting point. It goes to the heart of the history of the labour movement. Unions were born in large part due to the excesses with accompanied the birth of capitalism. Most of us are familiar with the basic principals of capitalism especially the founding principle of controlling the means of production. This ideal did not serve poor Bob Cratchet very well until Bob and the few of the boys got together and made the point that however powerful this new concept was, it was merely a tool, a way to make life better for the peoples of the countries it served. Now in most cases those directly involved in commerce (yourself I assume) find a direct correlation between the success of their enterprise and their salary. Market forces work well in this arena. The unfortunate fact is they don't work as well for us in the service industries. History has made that fact quite clear to teachers, nurses and others. Check out some staff rooms and you will see the reproduction of a turn of the century poster depicting the rights duties etc. of a teacher. Good for a laugh now but I'll bet they weren't laughing back then. In the natural course of events management will pay as little as they can get away with. The philosophy is that in negotiations the other side can look after themselves. Education and nursing for example are not crucial to showing a profit. Their contribution though while valuable cannot be directly related to a profit margin. It is easy for politicians looking for election credits to make cuts here. The optics are not as attractive as for those in the corporate world seeking remuneration for their efforts. So you say why not let market forces have a go anyway and when the line up of young hopefuls dwindles to nothing? After all, then we will have achieved normative levels.
First: don't be fooled by those long lineups. I have had the opportunity in my travels to speak with many of them shortly after they entered the profession and one theme stands out
Disillusionment. I have been doing this many years so I know of which I speak. Many have no clue what its like on the other side of the desk. I particularly recall years ago one workshop I attended at Nortel. It came to light that the young lady, one of the presenters had first entered the field of education. I spoke with her at length. She much preferred the sharks of the corporate world to teaching the "new kid" within the modern day educational environment. At present there is an unacceptable attrition rate among young teachers. This has become so alarming that the College of Teachers for Ontario has advocated a teacher mentorship program where the older ones help the younger ones through their first years. It is that bad.
Second: You offer the helpful suggestion, "Why not just switch occupations?" Perhaps for the very young this is a viable option and many today are taking that route. But for someone who has invested 10 or 20 years of his or her life into this specialized field the prospects are dismal. And why after all should they? Do you see politicians using teachers as pawns in a vote garnering campaign as justification for teachers to just sit back and accept the roller coaster ride? Let's not take the moral high ground here. No one in this world will give a damn about you if you don't give a damn about yourself.
Third: I am sick of hearing the old platitude, 'Those who can, do and those who can't teach." That is pure unadulterated horse manure. But it is often the root cause for the attitude that the work teachers do has somehow less value than that of those in private industry. I am sure you have met many in business who couldn't communicate their way out of a paper bag.
Fourth: The word union is not a dirty word. They do provide a very necessary service to those of their membership who are faced with anything from administrative bullying to unwarranted allegations of impropriety. An unfortunate spinoff is that far too often they (as do their opposite numbers in management) often fall victim to an inborn culture which often supplants the wishes of its membership as the motivational engine which drives their actions. This at times creates the excesses which make for poor optics in the public eye. This is regrettable at times I agree. But I often see where this is the case.
Fifth: Teachers are not involved in the manufacture of automobiles, they don't create foodstuffs and they don't plow the roads. They deal with possibly the most sensitive product going, the education of peoples children. Try to find an occupation where the outcomes are guaranteed to engender debate within such a raw emotionally charged climate. This cuts very close to peoples hearts minds and personal pride. It is perhaps the only profession where when any kind of job action is initiated, the public will take it personally. To hope for impartiality in any type of negotiations under that cloud is well nigh impossible. It doesn't matter what the reasons may be, the children are being held hostage. "How dare they do that to my child!"
Sixth: Teaching is not just a job you might consider the day after that job washing dishes in a restaurant loses its sparkle. It is a field requiring a high level of education with excellent communication and people skills. There are a host of complex issues which are dealt with on a constant basis and which the public never sees. The level of sophistication to which program delivery has risen far outshines that of years past. Plus there is a whole host of collateral issues which the education system is asked to deal with today. Teachers have the right be remunerated as professionals similar to that of other professionals in occupations requiring similar qualifications. Now in a response above I argued that comparing one occupation to another is a virtually impossible task. But there are some generally accepted commonalities. In short teachers do have the right to seek fair remuneration. You can bet the rent money that management and government are not averse to playing hardball. In the spirit of fairness you might consider taking them to task also.