Is this all just teacher bashing?

I would like all the people who are complaining about teachers to list their profession and income. Also list your reasons why you did not become a teacher. Please have this completed by 4:00pm or I will be calling your mommy.


x
 
incognito6969 said:
If teaching is such a great job, why are you not all lined up to jump in the classroom. Lets face it, most people with a University degree, 2 if you count teachers college (which it is a seperate degree) make an equal amount to what any teacher makes. I have also seen what comes off of their check to union and pension dues, if I invested that much my self into my retirement, I would not be far behind them when I turn 60.
Bottom line teaching is an open opportunity there has to be a reason not everyone is lining up for it, God knows i wouldn't do it

just because you have a better opportunity does not preclude one from commenting on the activities of public servants.
 
Indiana said:
As in all professions, there are good teachers and there are bad teachers. ..........................................The odd part is that teachers are surprised why most people in the public lack respect for them when they do this.

My $0.02

Agree.

Another odd part is that they seem to want to take credit at every opportunity, however it's always Harris' fault whenever any shortcomings in the education system or its effectiveness are pointed out. Don't ask them to be held accountable for anything.....my god that's just un-Canadian;)

Together with the examples set by the union over recent years - are these the type of role models that tou want to expose your kids to ? Not me.
 
Strikes?

However after making that choice, to strike for better conditions is insulting. If I don't like my job, I move on to a different company or career. I make the choice. I don't call a strike and shut down the company or hold my clients for ransom.

An interesting point. It goes to the heart of the history of the labour movement. Unions were born in large part due to the excesses with accompanied the birth of capitalism. Most of us are familiar with the basic principals of capitalism especially the founding principle of controlling the means of production. This ideal did not serve poor Bob Cratchet very well until Bob and the few of the boys got together and made the point that however powerful this new concept was, it was merely a tool, a way to make life better for the peoples of the countries it served. Now in most cases those directly involved in commerce (yourself I assume) find a direct correlation between the success of their enterprise and their salary. Market forces work well in this arena. The unfortunate fact is they don't work as well for us in the service industries. History has made that fact quite clear to teachers, nurses and others. Check out some staff rooms and you will see the reproduction of a turn of the century poster depicting the rights duties etc. of a teacher. Good for a laugh now but I'll bet they weren't laughing back then. In the natural course of events management will pay as little as they can get away with. The philosophy is that in negotiations the other side can look after themselves. Education and nursing for example are not crucial to showing a profit. Their contribution though while valuable cannot be directly related to a profit margin. It is easy for politicians looking for election credits to make cuts here. The optics are not as attractive as for those in the corporate world seeking remuneration for their efforts. So you say why not let market forces have a go anyway and when the line up of young hopefuls dwindles to nothing? After all, then we will have achieved normative levels.

First: don't be fooled by those long lineups. I have had the opportunity in my travels to speak with many of them shortly after they entered the profession and one theme stands out Disillusionment. I have been doing this many years so I know of which I speak. Many have no clue what its like on the other side of the desk. I particularly recall years ago one workshop I attended at Nortel. It came to light that the young lady, one of the presenters had first entered the field of education. I spoke with her at length. She much preferred the sharks of the corporate world to teaching the "new kid" within the modern day educational environment. At present there is an unacceptable attrition rate among young teachers. This has become so alarming that the College of Teachers for Ontario has advocated a teacher mentorship program where the older ones help the younger ones through their first years. It is that bad.

Second: You offer the helpful suggestion, "Why not just switch occupations?" Perhaps for the very young this is a viable option and many today are taking that route. But for someone who has invested 10 or 20 years of his or her life into this specialized field the prospects are dismal. And why after all should they? Do you see politicians using teachers as pawns in a vote garnering campaign as justification for teachers to just sit back and accept the roller coaster ride? Let's not take the moral high ground here. No one in this world will give a damn about you if you don't give a damn about yourself.

Third: I am sick of hearing the old platitude, 'Those who can, do and those who can't teach." That is pure unadulterated horse manure. But it is often the root cause for the attitude that the work teachers do has somehow less value than that of those in private industry. I am sure you have met many in business who couldn't communicate their way out of a paper bag.

Fourth: The word union is not a dirty word. They do provide a very necessary service to those of their membership who are faced with anything from administrative bullying to unwarranted allegations of impropriety. An unfortunate spinoff is that far too often they (as do their opposite numbers in management) often fall victim to an inborn culture which often supplants the wishes of its membership as the motivational engine which drives their actions. This at times creates the excesses which make for poor optics in the public eye. This is regrettable at times I agree. But I often see where this is the case.

Fifth: Teachers are not involved in the manufacture of automobiles, they don't create foodstuffs and they don't plow the roads. They deal with possibly the most sensitive product going, the education of peoples children. Try to find an occupation where the outcomes are guaranteed to engender debate within such a raw emotionally charged climate. This cuts very close to peoples hearts minds and personal pride. It is perhaps the only profession where when any kind of job action is initiated, the public will take it personally. To hope for impartiality in any type of negotiations under that cloud is well nigh impossible. It doesn't matter what the reasons may be, the children are being held hostage. "How dare they do that to my child!"

Sixth: Teaching is not just a job you might consider the day after that job washing dishes in a restaurant loses its sparkle. It is a field requiring a high level of education with excellent communication and people skills. There are a host of complex issues which are dealt with on a constant basis and which the public never sees. The level of sophistication to which program delivery has risen far outshines that of years past. Plus there is a whole host of collateral issues which the education system is asked to deal with today. Teachers have the right be remunerated as professionals similar to that of other professionals in occupations requiring similar qualifications. Now in a response above I argued that comparing one occupation to another is a virtually impossible task. But there are some generally accepted commonalities. In short teachers do have the right to seek fair remuneration. You can bet the rent money that management and government are not averse to playing hardball. In the spirit of fairness you might consider taking them to task also.
 
Last edited:
I'm still waiting for the complainers to submit income and profession. Come on people, you don't mind discussing teachers salaries but you don't want to discuss your own. Some people might even call that hypocritical. Not on this site. Heavens to Betsy.

x
 
Keep the faith

The SI for my area hates me I think, I have written and phoned so much. I have gotten more for my son then anyone I know in Durham. Then on top of it I pass the info on to other parents. The funding is there, the people are there, it is the policy that needs some changing. At least in this circumstance. The problem is, the 3 yrs he spent in a "special" class has labelled him, lowered his esteem, completely lowered his grade level, and that was all because the teachers and the CYW couldn't give a shit about thier jobs. That was quite clear and stupid me, I trusted them as they were the "professionals". I take responsiblity for subjecting my son to them for so long.

I can tell you if this new route doesn't work, then the government will be paying for a full time in home private teacher. Y'all will finally see who KWI is because my story will be all over the news come thanksgiving this year. Y'all think I am bitchy here, wait until then. Most times I am having fun here and it is taken the wrong way but when it comes to my kids I don't fuck around. At all!!!!

Thanks for the support.

Hey KWI sounds like your kid has a great Dad and I'll bet he's a real sweet guy. I am assuming that this is a straightforward learning disability problem and not complicated with behavioural issues. If that is the case then in your dealings with the board go right for the jugular. Play hardball. If this is the only problem I'd take a hundred of your guy over just one extreme behaviour problem whose parents insist it is the school's fault. (I have virtually no patience with that kind of thing. It has reached epidemic proportions in our schools.).

On the positive side some of the most intelligent successful people had learning disabilities. Once you find the key to how to handle it they just take off. Push the specialists to find that key. Check the IPRC with a fine-toothed comb. Educate yourself as to the terminology and concepts involved so you can better know how to discuss the issues intelligently. Make them give you complete explanations until you understand it well. Too many resources are spent on behavioural issues when they should be spent on those they were originally intended for, your son. I literally see red when that happens. Keep up the good fight. If I can help in any way, pm me.
 
That's funny for the last 4 years that I've taught we've never striked.

BTW I like xdogs comment. It is interesting that very few teacher bashers explain what their job is and why they didn't become teachers.
 
My apologies KWI. That's the trouble with these forums. I assumed it was all guys here. In one sense though with the way you are going at it, sounds like you are doing enough for both roles. lol. Bravo and God bless you.
 
That's funny for the last 4 years that I've taught we've never striked.

BTW I like xdogs comment. It is interesting that very few teacher bashers explain what their job is and why they didn't become teachers.

Yes, come to think of it the last strike I was ever on (notwithstanding the political action which we took back in the ninties) was in the seventies. Never got to carry one of those nifty signs though. Guess I was too young.

Yes I think xdog made his point. I didn't really expect a response in any event. I'm glad he joined in forcing the issue. This business of bashing teachers has to stop and the only way we will ever do that is through educating the public (no double meaning intended) and standing up for ourselves. I don't know why people think they can simply engage in name calling with a simplistic rationale for context. But that is where we are at and its time we worked to put a stop to it. Xdog doesn't seem to be finding any takers.
 
No problem guys. I know how it feels to be singled out. There's always gonna be whiners out there. It's human nature. What's amazing is that so many people have benefitted from changes to employer practices because of workers standing up for their rights. If people are angry with teachers benefits, they should complain to their employer.
I just wanted to see if any of the winers had the courage to compare their profession and income versus those of a teacher's. As usual, just a bunch of hypocrits.
BTW, enjoy your summer off.


x
 
KWI said:
Thank you, but my son has no Dad, just a great mom. LOL

Common mistake but I am a woman.

KWI

Another case of immaculate conception I guess :p

Sorry I couldn't resist. At least there has been no need to bring up strawbeeries and plumes