Is the US Really the Problem on Global Warming....

onthebottom said:
Actually, my point was that the US takes all short of shit for global warming (including that asswhipe in Germany who thinks hurricanes are something new....) yet Canada, while signing the Kyoto protocol is in worse shape.
The only way Canada will meet its Kyoto targets is by buying credits (or instead, if it really increases energy prices). That is not necessarily a bad thing. The U.S. uses a similar system of tradable pollution permits for their power system. The idea is that if it is cheaper to meet an overall pollution reduction target by having those who can cut pollution at a lower cost undertake deeper cuts. If Russia can cut pollution cheaper than Canada it makes economic sense for Canada to pay Russia to undertake the cuts on Canada’s behalf. Both parties are better off and the target has been meet (well, with private firms that have no choice, both are better off, with sovereign nations who don’t have to be part of the system, it is not as clear whether buyers are better off). The questionable part is why countries voluntarily agree to such a system when it is clear that they are going to be the buyers of credits. In the case of U.S. utilities, those with high costs have no choice but to join the system.
 
someone said:
The only way Canada will meet its Kyoto targets is by buying credits (or instead, if it really increases energy prices). That is not necessarily a bad thing. The U.S. uses a similar system of tradable pollution permits for their power system. The idea is that if it is cheaper to meet an overall pollution reduction target by having those who can cut pollution at a lower cost undertake deeper cuts. If Russia can cut pollution cheaper than Canada it makes economic sense for Canada to pay Russia to undertake the cuts on Canada’s behalf. Both parties are better off and the target has been meet (well, with private firms that have no choice, both are better off, with sovereign nations who don’t have to be part of the system, it is not as clear whether buyers are better off). The questionable part is why countries voluntarily agree to such a system when it is clear that they are going to be the buyers of credits. In the case of U.S. utilities, those with high costs have no choice but to join the system.

I'm a strong fan of tradable credits, the cheapest way to achieve an objective. I was in a pretty silly email dialogue with a pretty famous guy from the Sierra Club because he'd written an article criticizing such credits (being bought by Ohio utility companies) he was just hugging trees, reminded me how really stupid much of the media is....

OTB
 
Am I missing something? I skimmed through this thread, and no one mentioned that the Kyoto accord is just another socialist ploy to transfer wealth from rich nations to poor nations. The effect on the climate is negligible. The WSJ summarized it best: “. ..while a scientific consensus about the true nature of climate change is still lacking, we know for certain that the impact of Kyoto on the average global temperature will be negligible at best. The U.N.'s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change forecasts that without the ratification of Kyoto, the average global temperature will rise about one degree Celsius by 2050. The same panel predicts that after the implementation of Kyoto, the temperature will still rise 0.94 degrees. In other words, the benefits from Kyoto amount to about 0.06 degrees in half a century....”

So let’s bankrupt our nations to reap a whopping .06 degree delta in 50 years!

And here are four more environmental issues with outcomes NOT based on science:

Ban on DDT
Acid Rain
Asbestos ban
Ozone Hole and CFC ban (Freon)

“Once the demand for objective truth is surrendered, society has lost the capacity for outrage and its sense of common direction.”
M. Mihkel Mathiesen, “Global Warming in a Politically Correct Climate: How Truth Became Controversial,” Universe Star, Lincoln, NE., 2004.
 
arclighter said:
Am I missing something? I skimmed through this thread, and no one mentioned that the Kyoto accord is just another socialist ploy to transfer wealth from rich nations to poor nations. The effect on the climate is negligible. The WSJ summarized it best: “. ..while a scientific consensus about the true nature of climate change is still lacking, we know for certain that the impact of Kyoto on the average global temperature will be negligible at best. The U.N.'s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change forecasts that without the ratification of Kyoto, the average global temperature will rise about one degree Celsius by 2050. The same panel predicts that after the implementation of Kyoto, the temperature will still rise 0.94 degrees. In other words, the benefits from Kyoto amount to about 0.06 degrees in half a century....”

So let’s bankrupt our nations to reap a whopping .06 degree delta in 50 years!

And here are four more environmental issues with outcomes NOT based on science:

Ban on DDT
Acid Rain
Asbestos ban
Ozone Hole and CFC ban (Freon)

“Once the demand for objective truth is surrendered, society has lost the capacity for outrage and its sense of common direction.”
M. Mihkel Mathiesen, “Global Warming in a Politically Correct Climate: How Truth Became Controversial,” Universe Star, Lincoln, NE., 2004.


Do you have a link for that WSJ quote, that's beautiful, how many jobs would you trade for .06 of a degree.....

LOL

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I'm a strong fan of tradable credits, the cheapest way to achieve an objective. I was in a pretty silly email dialogue with a pretty famous guy from the Sierra Club because he'd written an article criticizing such credits (being bought by Ohio utility companies) he was just hugging trees, reminded me how really stupid much of the media is....

OTB
Then I'm not sure where we disagree. What is wrong with Canada meeting its targets by paying others to reduce pollution?
 
someone said:
Then I'm not sure where we disagree. What is wrong with Canada meeting its targets by paying others to reduce pollution?

Nothing is wrong, has Canada paid anyone for credits?

OTB
 
someone said:
Then I'm not sure where we disagree. What is wrong with Canada meeting its targets by paying others to reduce pollution?

The only way buying credits from the third world will reduce pollution is through the bankrupting of the first world, thereby reducing GDP, standard of living, and of course those obnoxious GREEN HOUSE GASES!
 
onthebottom said:
Nothing is wrong, has Canada paid anyone for credits?

OTB
I'm not up to date on this. I have read about various proposals but I don't know which have been signed. Most of the ones I have heard seem to involve projects in the third world rather than buying credits from other Kyoto countries (both possibilities under the agreement). However, I’m not sure if any of the proposals have been finalized yet. Canada is good at living up to international commitments when they are clearly defined. However, I suspect that until the election is over, the government wants people to believe that the it will be possible to have the reductions in Canada without higher energy prices.
 
someone said:
I'm not up to date on this. I have read about various proposals but I don't know which have been signed. Most of the ones I have heard seem to involve projects in the third world rather than buying credits from other Kyoto countries (both possibilities under the agreement). However, I’m not sure if any of the proposals have been finalized yet. Canada is good at living up to international commitments when they are clearly defined. However, I suspect that until the election is over, the government wants people to believe that the it will be possible to have the reductions in Canada without higher energy prices.

Fair enough, I'm sure that won't be high on the election promise parade. I am surprised I've not read more about this given all those nations in Montreal talking about it.....

OTB
 
harleycharley said:
good to see that. seems that over and over the states are taking progresive steps where the adminstration is fucking up.....

Hate to break it to you

but you buy a car you decide not me
 
If we read carefully onthebottom's excerpt, it seems to be the current rate of emissions is rising faster in Canada than in America; I imagine this changes cyclically. Total emissions are not discussed; I don't know the statistics on total emissions, but I would imagine America's huge industry out produce's Canada's industry and cold climate.


However, I believe regions in the old USSR and all of Africa are much greater polluters than North America. Any one who has been in any African big city down to a town has seen thick choking clouds of pollution: vehicular, industrial and charcoal cooking fires. The entire continent, ±1B people, cooks and heats itself with charcoal, denuding great areas and producing staggering amounts of green house gases. Millions upon millions of untuned vehicles, no industrial emission controls.

Also, these areas have no environmental monitoring, whereas in North America there is 24/7 monitoring everywhere, constantly studied and reported on.
 
antaeus said:
If we read carefully onthebottom's excerpt, it seems to be the current rate of emissions is rising faster in Canada than in America; I imagine this changes cyclically. Total emissions are not discussed; I don't know the statistics on total emissions, but I would imagine America's huge industry out produce's Canada's industry and cold climate.


However, I believe regions in the old USSR and all of Africa are much greater polluters than North America. Any one who has been in any African big city down to a town has seen thick choking clouds of pollution: vehicular, industrial and charcoal cooking fires. The entire continent, ±1B people, cooks and heats itself with charcoal, denuding great areas and producing staggering amounts of green house gases. Millions upon millions of untuned vehicles, no industrial emission controls.

Also, these areas have no environmental monitoring, whereas in North America there is 24/7 monitoring everywhere, constantly studied and reported on.

This very basic truth is all to often forgotten..very good post. Without the inclusion of those countries the whole Kyoto protocol is a waste of time..

I would think that those "new economies" would have a much easier time to start cleaner?
 
In addition to being a world leading, global-warming abuser and proliferator, Canada and it's truly world-class, NIMBY-leading city Toronto catapults it's own 10 million tonnes of filth and waste into pristine Michigan.
 
to quo que, m***** f*****!

rogerstaubach said:
In addition to being a world leading, global-warming abuser and proliferator, Canada and it's truly world-class, NIMBY-leading city Toronto catapults it's own 10 million tonnes of filth and waste into pristine Michigan.
At a price. You're saying profit is bad? (See, two can play your idiotic "straw man, straw man!" game.) (Except I'm gonna stop after this; because I can..)

MW