Is refined, bleached table salt healthy?

i barely eat processed, fast foods or restaurant food... cook yourself :)

You're better than most, but you don't buy bread, one of the largest sources of daily salt intake? I do cook, and more importantly others eat my cooking and seldom add salt to it. I let others season their own food with whatever salt they want to. When I do eat fast food, my teeth sing because of the salt and probably the preservatives.
 
Sea salt is healthier than regular table salt. Its also more expensive.

Its better to eat sea salt, but just because its healthier still doesnt mean you should eat it every day. I eat sea salt twice a week only, no more then that
 
High sodium level is a problem with many prepared foods. Not only does it clog your arteries it leads to weight gain as it turns to water.

Did you graduate from High School? (Serious question, I find it amazing that someone lacks basic chemistry).

Salt (table salt) is NaCl. Water is H2O.

Turning salt into water would be about as easy as turning steel into gold.

clog arteries? How is something as soluble as salt supposed to be able to do that? Your body is pretty much just a big bag of sea water. You pump out surplus salt in your urine. It does however contribute to hypertension so can shorten your life.
 
High sodium level is a problem with many prepared foods. Not only does it clog your arteries it leads to weight gain as it turns to water.

Your description of salt clogging arteries is a correct in an indirect way, which can confusing. However, to help clarify:

Excess sodium may lead to hypertension
Hypertension may lead to damaged blood vessels
Damaged blood vessels may lead to coronary heart disease and atherosclerosis

I prefer to use sea salt when seasoning my food. I think it tastes better and it is better for you simply because it's natural.

Enjoying some sea salt is perfectly fine but I wouldn't assume that things are "better for you simply because [they're] natural." A lot of 'natural' things are not good for you.

For example, fugu (pufferfish) produces tetrodotoxin in a completely natural way but less than 25 milligrams will kill an adult human if eaten (even less is needed to kill a human if injected intravenously).

Botulinum will kill at 1 ug per kg (roughly 8 times more lethal than tetrodotoxin) and is produced naturally by bacteria you'd find in the soil around your house.

A lot of marketing makes us feel that 'organic' and 'natural' are better for us when really it's just another way to sell more stuff at a higher price, and doesn't really reflect reality (i.e. they really aren't better for you).
 
High sodium level is a problem with many prepared foods. Not only does it clog your arteries it leads to weight gain as it turns to water.

I prefer to use sea salt when seasoning my food. I think it tastes better and it is better for you simply because it's natural.


It doesn't turn to water, it causes water retention which can add to the weight.
 
Another substantial difference is that table salt is iodized (also spelled iodised). Some counties make it illegal to 'hide' medicine or drugs in food so the salt there isn't "iodized" but most table salt in North America is.
 
Added salt is not good, if you have to use salt to get some flavour get used to a low sodium diet. There should be enough natural salt in most foods, and especially eating out, they pour in on for flavour, be careful. Too much salt will eventually increase your blood pressure and you don't want to take medication for that.

Same goes for sugar, enough natural sugar in foods we eat, don't add.
 
Another substantial difference is that table salt is iodized (also spelled iodised). Some counties make it illegal to 'hide' medicine or drugs in food so the salt there isn't "iodized" but most table salt in North America is.

The iodine is added because it is an essential element in everyone's diet that is usually missing from overly processed and refined food. It is also a safety feature - in the event of either a nuclear reactor accident or atomic bomb explosion, one of the more dangerous fallout ingredients is a radioactive iodine isotope - having a certain amount of iodized salt in your diet means your body is less likely to absorb the radioactive form.

Interestingly, iodine is one of the elements that does not have a liquid state, it sublimates from solid to gas. Over time it will escape from the salt as a gas. If you have a container of iodized salt that has not been opened for some time, open it and take a sniff - there will be a sharp, pungent odour, not unlike the smell of chlorine to which iodine is chemically similar.

I agree with everyone who has posted that you should be getting enough sodium from a well balanced diet that does not include very much "processed" food. Foods that are natural sources of iodine include rice, corn, dairy and, not surprisingly, fish.
 
The iodine is added because it is an essential element in everyone's diet that is usually missing from overly processed and refined food. It is also a safety feature - in the event of either a nuclear reactor accident or atomic bomb explosion, one of the more dangerous fallout ingredients is a radioactive iodine isotope - having a certain amount of iodized salt in your diet means your body is less likely to absorb the radioactive form.

Um, that's interesting.

But the real reason for iodised salt its to prevent thyroid gland goiters and mental retardation.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iodised_salt
 
I am reminded of a friend I had in my high school days, his father was a diplomat and he traveled to many countries. He told me of an occasion where he went swimming in a salt flat, the water was so saturated with salt that people floated very easily on the surface of the water. He was told not to take in any of the water but he did accidentally. This cause him almost immediate stomach distress. Before he could swim back to shore, he evacuated into the water. So there he was floating in pain in salty water with several small submerged submarines around him.
A short distance away, people collected salt to sell at the market. Any dead animal, any substance you put into that salty water will slowly disolve and incorporate itself into the salt.
 
Sea salt is much tastier and healthier for you! Always opt for sea salt over table salt.

I doubt whether one is healthier than the other. This is like thinking brown sugar is healthier than refined sugar. There is nothing redeeming or benificial in sea salt or brown sugar.
 
I doubt whether one is healthier than the other. This is like thinking brown sugar is healthier than refined sugar. There is nothing redeeming or benificial in sea salt or brown sugar.

and let us not forget white flour. White is bad for you. I mean as food. ;). I rather like white in other contexts :)
 
" "Salt is a silent threat," says Jennifer Nelson, R.D., chief of clinical dietetics at the Mayo Clinic Food & Nutrition Center in Rochester, Minnesota. "Often, people are simply unaware and don't realize they're consuming too much." Many of us go beyond the recommended limit of 2,300 milligrams a day. And while we need sodium for proper nerve and muscle function, too much increases our risk of osteoporosis, kidney stones, gastric ulcers, and high blood pressure."

"...A salt shakedown could provide a great payoff: A study in The New England Journal of Medicine found that halving your sodium intake may benefit your heart and blood pressure as much as cutting tobacco use in half or shrinking your body mass index (BMI) by 5 percent."

http://www.womenshealthmag.com/nutrition/salt-alternatives


----------------------------------------------------------------------------


I can't believe that you would fall for all the crap in this song
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcmeJSYVb2Q&feature=relmfu
 

" "Salt is a silent threat," says Jennifer Nelson, R.D., chief of clinical dietetics at the Mayo Clinic Food & Nutrition Center in Rochester, Minnesota. "Often, people are simply unaware and don't realize they're consuming too much." Many of us go beyond the recommended limit of 2,300 milligrams a day. And while we need sodium for proper nerve and muscle function, too much increases our risk of osteoporosis, kidney stones, gastric ulcers, and high blood pressure."

"...A salt shakedown could provide a great payoff: A study in The New England Journal of Medicine found that halving your sodium intake may benefit your heart and blood pressure as much as cutting tobacco use in half or shrinking your body mass index (BMI) by 5 percent."

lenny are you just trolling or do you have a point?

You started this post and title it asking if 'bleached' salt is healthy. The answer is pretty obvious. All salt is bad at the quantities eaten by North Americans. You quote some weird pretend science site that wants people to replace low cost pure table salt with some uncontrolled product.

Now you are talking about North American diet containing too much salt. Does anyone over the age of 12 not know that North Americans consume too much salt and sugar and are shortening their lives because of it? Dahhhhhh also they should get more exercise and not breath polluted air. Does anyone not know that?

Do you have a point are are you just trolling and quoting things randomly?
 
Last edited:
All salt is bad at the quantities eaten by North Americans.

Even those on low sodium diets or using salts that have not been demineralized?

What do you know about alternate salts, like Celtic sea salt:

http://www.celticseasalt.com/Dr-Recommended-Sea-Salt-W280C549.aspx
http://www.healthy.co.nz/ailment/2028-celtic-sea-salt-alternative-to-table-salt.html
http://www.natural-cure-alternatives.com/celtic-sea-salt.html
http://www.livestrong.com/article/168886-celtic-sea-salt-benefits/
http://www.waterbenefitshealth.com/celtic-sea-salt.html

Do you know how much your daily sodium intake is?

Some info states those over 50, such as myself, should keep it under 1500 mg/day:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt#Recommended_intake

How can one go about achieving this, whether or not they eat out a lot?

As you can see above, the recommendations vary widely from country to country.


clog arteries? How is something as soluble as salt supposed to be able to do that? Your body is pretty much just a big bag of sea water. You pump out surplus salt in your urine. It does however contribute to hypertension so can shorten your life.

Can refined table salt clog arteries? Some opinions state:

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Does_salt_clog_your_arteries
http://ezinearticles.com/?Does-Salt-Clog-Arteries?&id=5206310
http://www.mnwelldir.org/docs/cardio/cardio9.htm

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Something For The Girl With Everything
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnM3Iq977JU&feature=related
 
Gee there is a link with "expert" opinions

I'd be interested in what any "experts" opinions have to say. Do you know of any?

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Does_salt_clog_your_arteries

Salt indeed does seem to "clog" arteries, as well as have other health-harming effects such as raising blood pressure, especially in individuals already predisposed to hypertension.
In laboratory tests with rats, there is noted thickening of cells walls with high sodium diets:

"...vascular morphology was significantly, resulting in significant thickening of the aortic media between the 10th and 20th week of age, in association with the development of extracellular matrix and excess collagen."



Another study notes:

"...the high-salt diet was associated with significant increases in the arterial thickness."




Many studies also show high salt intake makes arteries less elastic.


"a correlation between salt and pulse wave velocity (PWV), a measure of the stiffness of the arteries, was observed, suggesting an effect on vascular health independent of blood pressure."





Note, about half the population is considered more salt sensitive than others.

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Does_salt_clog_your_arteries
 
Neither One Is Healthy
Sea salts retain the trace elements that table salt doesn't, but may also include pollutants from the air, chemicals from rain and other elements from the soil surrounding the water or deposits.
Your title is an overstatement, and as wide of helpful fact as imagining the micro-traces in salt from seas their ancestors never saw are essential to anyone's health today. The exception is iodine, naturally present in sea-salt and essential for healthy thyroid function, but which we must add back to refined salt.

Two cardiologists have prescribed salt for my health. One reason that neither mentioned sea-salt may be that all the salt you can by was is sea-salt, whether processed from water industrially, or dug in mines from deposits—like the one in Windsor—laid down by prehistoric seas. It's all natural, even if what's dug with it is not.

With respect to 'organic/natural' [sic] sea-salt and it's non-salt elements, we should remember what W.C. Fields had to say about water: Fish fuck in it. Are you sure they got all the algae and shrimp poo out?

As an omnivore, the choice is yours, but eat everything in moderation. Especially shrimp poo and diesel dust.
 
Your title is an overstatement, and as wide of helpful fact as imagining the micro-traces in salt from seas their ancestors never saw are essential to anyone's health today.

Two cardiologists have prescribed salt for my health. One reason that neither mentioned sea-salt may be that all the salt you can by was is sea-salt, whether processed from water industrially, or dug in mines from deposits—like the one in Windsor—laid down by prehistoric seas. It's all natural.

As an omnivore, the choice is yours, but eat everything in moderation.

As for organic [sic] sea-salt and it's non-salt elements, we should remember what W.C. Fields had to say about water: Fish fuck in it.

The regular salt you buy is pure NaCl (with stabilizers and Iodine added). It contains none of the other mineral salts found in Sea Salt.

If you look at the ingredients in your multivitamin pill, you will see that it contains a lot of mineral elements. They are there for a reason.