Is refined, bleached table salt healthy?

The regular salt you buy is pure NaCl (with stabilizers and Iodine added). It contains none of the other mineral salts found in Sea Salt.

If you look at the ingredients in your multivitamin pill, you will see that it contains a lot of mineral elements. They are there for a reason.

Okay , I'm calling bullshit on this, you don't know what minerals you are getting because you don't know what is in the water source.

Here is what the Mayo clinic thinks on the subject (they say sea salt is not healthier) :

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/sea-salt/AN01142

Sea salt is produced through evaporation of seawater, usually with little processing, which leaves behind certain trace minerals and elements depending on its water source. The minerals add flavor and color to sea salt, which also comes in a variety of coarseness levels.
 
Two cardiologists have prescribed salt for my health. One reason that neither mentioned sea-salt may be that all the salt you can by was is sea-salt, whether processed from water industrially, or dug in mines from deposits—like the one in Windsor—laid down by prehistoric seas. It's all natural, even if what's dug with it is not.

.

Prescribed salt or advised you to add more to your regular diet? If it's something other than low blood pressure they are treating I'd be interested to hear if you are willing to share.
 
I'd be interested in what any "experts" opinions have to say. Do you know of any?

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Does_salt_clog_your_arteries

:frusty: :frusty: :frusty:

I wish people stopped trying to practice "pop science". Wiki is not science. It is not evidence based treatment. It is not 'expert'. Most of the information on the internet is at best an opinion.

Partovian, Beierwaltes, Benetos, Hassid, Mischler, Pommiès, and a dozen others dating back to the 90s are experts in the true sense of the word. They do not write dumb down articles for consumption by people without the training to understand what they are saying.

At least your wiki source had sufficient knowledge to use quotes when they said: 'Salt indeed does seem to "clog" arteries, as well as have other health-harming effects '. The reason for the quotes is that salt does effect the arterial walls in many destructive ways. One of the side effects of the arterial walls thickening and loosing elasticity can be secondary damage to the interior of the vessels walls, and this might lead to platelet collection. But no expert would accept the concept of salt being a direct cause of clotting. Or for that matter even support the statement "salt clogs arteries".

Experts do not in general have the desire or the time to write for the masses.

"the high-salt diet was significantly associated with cardiovascular hypertrophy and increased arterial elastin and collagen, and2) Hoe-140 alone induced carotid hypertrophy. A high-salt diet plus Hoe-140 acted synergistically on carotid hypertrophy and elastin content in SHR, suggesting that the role of endogenous bradykinin on arterial structure was amplified in the presence of a high-salt diet."

And people like lenny and other self appointed pop science experts ignore the research and read wiki's dumbed down version and assume they know what the experts are saying.

Let me use an example most of us are familiar with. In grade school we learn that everything is composed of atoms. In the first years of high school we learn that we were taught a grossly oversimplified version of the facts and learnt that everything is composed of nucleus and electrons spinning around them. In the more advanced years of high school we learn that we were taught a grossly oversimplified version of the facts and learnt that everything is composed of protons and neutrons and electrons spinning around them. In the first years of university we learn that we were taught a grossly oversimplified version of the facts and learnt that everything is composed of protons and neutrons and an sort of energy cloud spinning around them but that it was impossible to identify a single particle's real location and we just labelled that an electron and the odd shaped probable locations an orbit. By the end of undergraduate studies some learn that we were taught a grossly oversimplified version of the facts and learnt mostly everything was empty space held together with assorted forces. I was recently informed that we were taught a grossly oversimplified version of the facts and that mu-mesons were the first clue that matter and energy are analogous to ice and steam and that the E=MC2rd formula defines the ratio.

Guess what? Lenny you need a hell of a lot of math and schooling to understand the research being done on the effects of salt on organisms. And right now, most of the research was done on rats :) so we have no proof that it is the same in humans.

We need some salt in our diet because we evolved from creatures that lived in the sea. We literally piss out our salt. Most North Americans have too much salt intake. It will take years to know what is the right amount, but for most people it is way too high. We do not need whale shit, rotting animals, decomposed sea bird feathers, and radioactive nuclei along with the salt. All the 'good things' taken out of raw sea salt may help us, but all the filth and garbage in it hurts us. "Natural" makes a lot of $. DO you know arsenic is a natural product ?

Get knowledge and stop playing with pop science. :)
 
Now you are talking about North American diet containing too much salt. Does anyone over the age of 12 not know that North Americans consume too much salt and sugar and are shortening their lives because of it?

If all American adults know they are killing themselves with their salt intake, then why do most of them keep doing it?

"...The average American gets about 3,400 mg of sodium a day — much more than recommended."

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/sodium/NU00284

Do all black Americans, like Obama, also know they should keep their daily sodium intake under 1500 mg? I doubt it.

"The 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend limiting sodium to less than 2,300 mg a day — or 1,500 mg if
you're age 51 or older, or if you are black, or if you have high blood pressure, diabetes or chronic kidney disease.

"Keep in mind that these are upper limits, and less is usually best, especially if you're sensitive to the effects
of sodium."

If i eat just 3 pieces of bread in my fridge thrice daily, i've already exceeded my daily sodium limit, without eating anything
else with sodium in it! Man shall not live by bread alone. What's an old white (or young black) guy to do?

------------------------------------------------------------------


Throw her away and get a new one
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HWw_vvi06jE
 
Last edited:
If all American adults know they are killing themselves with their salt intake, then why do most of them keep doing it?

"...The average American gets about 3,400 mg of sodium a day — much more than recommended."


Well men in general are not known for being the most logical of gods creatures. But anyone who has not heard they are consuming to much salt must be living in a cave. Why are you going on about it?
 
"Too much or too little salt in the diet can lead to muscle cramps, dizziness, or electrolyte disturbance, which can
cause neurological problems, or death.[43] Drinking too much water, with insufficient salt intake, puts a person at
risk of water intoxication (hyponatremia).

"...The effect of salt consumption on long term health outcomes is controversial.[47] The effects of salt reduction
appears to have an unclear effect on mortality[48] and its effect on morbidity is contentious.[47][49]"


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt
 
"Is sea salt better for you than regular salt?"



The main thing sea salt has going for it is happy vibes. Salt mines have long been proverbial sites of drudgery. In contrast, you rarely hear anyone gripe about having to get back to the beach.

The alleged health benefits of sea salt, ranging from improving digestion to imparting "harmonious energy," are credited to minerals and trace elements that are refined out of table salt. Since the underground salt deposits that produce most table salt are the result of evaporating seawater or salty lakes, you'd think the chemistry would be pretty much the same, and mostly it is. Both rock salt ( i.e., from mines) and sea salt contain, besides sodium chloride, such chemicals as calcium, potassium, and magnesium sulfates. However, when a large body of water evaporates, the chemicals in it precipitate out in stages - calcium compounds get deposited first, then sodium, and finally magnesium and potassium. Because of this, a rock salt deposit is often a more homogenous mass of sodium chloride than what you get by drying out seawater commercially. Since rock salt destined for human consumption is typically processed to remove grit and other impurities, by the time it reaches the shaker table salt is nearly pure sodium chloride.

Sea salt generally is far from pure - the impurities are its big selling point and frequently an identifying mark, such as the tiny bits of clay that give gray sea salt its color, or the iron-rich red volcanic clay added to Hawaiian sea salt. Although fans tout sea salt's trace elements, the major constituents are the aforesaid calcium, potassium, etc. The importance of minerals in the diet can't be dismissed; after all, the iodine commonly added to table salt helps prevent thyroid conditions. But there's little (actually, from what I can tell, no) research demonstrating that consuming sea salt is helpful in ways that consuming the ordinary kind isn't. Conceivably a benefit will someday be shown; for example, a few studies claim mineral-rich Dead Sea water - when bathed in, not drunk - is useful in treating psoriasis.

Meanwhile, as with all health fads, be careful that in your quest for self-improvement you don't make things worse. You're right in supposing that sea salt can be contaminated - industrial water pollution, in fact, has led some French sea-salt works to shut down. Sea salt also usually contains less iodine than you find in iodized table salt. Goiter has largely disappeared in the developed world; why help bring it back?
http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2718/is-sea-salt-better-for-you-than-regular-salt
 
Okay , I'm calling bullshit on this, you don't know what minerals you are getting because you don't know what is in the water source.

Here is what the Mayo clinic thinks on the subject (they say sea salt is not healthier) :

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/sea-salt/AN01142

Independent analysis of pure, medium crystal, sun dried, French sea salt, supplied by the Laboratory of Analytical and Hydrological Chemistry of Nantes University in France.

Major-elements

Chloride: 51%. Sodium: 32%. Water (from crystallization): 7%. Sulfur: 1.12%. Zinc: 0.87%. Magnesium: 0.50%. Iron: 0.38%. Potassium: 0.26%. Manganese: 0.026%. Copper: 0.018%. Calcium: 0.012%. Silicon: 0.011%.


Micro-elements

Carbon: 0.034%. Strontium: 0.009%. Boron: 0.004%. Hydrogen: 0.003%. Fluorine 0.001%. Nitrogen: 0.0008%. Argon: 0.0005%. Lithium: 0.0002%. Rubidium: 0.00014%. Phosphorus: 0.000112%. Iodine: 0.00007%. Barium: 0.00002%. Molybdenum: 0.000012%. Nickel: 0.000008%. Arsenic: 0.0000037%. Uranium: 0.0000038%. Vanadium: 0.0000024%. Tin: 0.0000009%. Cobalt: 0.00000045%. Antimony: 0.00000035%. Silver: 0.00000032%. Krypton: 0.00000024%. Chromium: 0.0000002%. Mercury: 0.0000002%. Neon: 0.00000012%%. Cadmium: 0.000000112%. Selenium: 0.0000001%. Germanium: 0.00000007%. Xenon: 0.00000006%. Scandium:0.0000005%. Gallium: 0.00000035%. Zirconium: 0.00000003%. Lead: 0.000000026%. Bismuth: 0.000000024%. Niobium: 0.000000023%. Thallium: 0.000000022%. Gold: 0.000000019%. Pico-traces of: Helium, lanthanum, neodymium, thorium, cerium, cesium, terbium, yttrium, dysprosium, erbium, ytterbium, hafnium, gadolinium, praseodymium, beryllium, samarium, holmium, lutecium, tantalum, thulium, europium, tungsten, protactinium, and radium.
 
"Too much or too little salt in the diet can lead to muscle cramps, dizziness, or electrolyte disturbance, which can
cause neurological problems, or death.[43] Drinking too much water, with insufficient salt intake, puts a person at
risk of water intoxication (hyponatremia).

"...The effect of salt consumption on long term health outcomes is controversial.[47] The effects of salt reduction
appears to have an unclear effect on mortality[48] and its effect on morbidity is contentious.[47][49]"


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt

Wiki and wikipedia are pop science. Believe what ever you want. lenny is just milking the topic for attention. He seems to enjoy doing that.
 
Independent analysis of pure, medium crystal, sun dried, French sea salt, supplied by the Laboratory of Analytical and Hydrological Chemistry of Nantes University in France.

Major-elements

Chloride: 51%. Sodium: 32%. Water (from crystallization): 7%. Sulfur: 1.12%. Zinc: 0.87%. Magnesium: 0.50%. Iron: 0.38%. Potassium: 0.26%. Manganese: 0.026%. Copper: 0.018%. Calcium: 0.012%. Silicon: 0.011%.


Micro-elements

Carbon: 0.034%. Strontium: 0.009%. Boron: 0.004%. Hydrogen: 0.003%. Fluorine 0.001%. Nitrogen: 0.0008%. Argon: 0.0005%. Lithium: 0.0002%. Rubidium: 0.00014%. Phosphorus: 0.000112%. Iodine: 0.00007%. Barium: 0.00002%. Molybdenum: 0.000012%. Nickel: 0.000008%. Arsenic: 0.0000037%. Uranium: 0.0000038%. Vanadium: 0.0000024%. Tin: 0.0000009%. Cobalt: 0.00000045%. Antimony: 0.00000035%. Silver: 0.00000032%. Krypton: 0.00000024%. Chromium: 0.0000002%. Mercury: 0.0000002%. Neon: 0.00000012%%. Cadmium: 0.000000112%. Selenium: 0.0000001%. Germanium: 0.00000007%. Xenon: 0.00000006%. Scandium:0.0000005%. Gallium: 0.00000035%. Zirconium: 0.00000003%. Lead: 0.000000026%. Bismuth: 0.000000024%. Niobium: 0.000000023%. Thallium: 0.000000022%. Gold: 0.000000019%. Pico-traces of: Helium, lanthanum, neodymium, thorium, cerium, cesium, terbium, yttrium, dysprosium, erbium, ytterbium, hafnium, gadolinium, praseodymium, beryllium, samarium, holmium, lutecium, tantalum, thulium, europium, tungsten, protactinium, and radium.


Although in general I respect your posts and comments, in this case I think it is important to point out elemental analysis is interesting and a valuable tool, it does not flag things like hydro carbons, feces, etc. Even though you did not flag the source I suspect it was part of a flurry of activity in reaction to a few French sea salt sites being closed because of contamination. Organic compounds are destroyed in order to provide elemental analysis.

:) Translation, things are not always what they appear.
 
Although in general I respect your posts and comments, in this case I think it is important to point out elemental analysis is interesting and a valuable tool, it does not flag things like hydro carbons, feces, etc. Even though you did not flag the source I suspect it was part of a flurry of activity in reaction to a few French sea salt sites being closed because of contamination. Organic compounds are destroyed in order to provide elemental analysis.

:) Translation, things are not always what they appear.

Lecturing me on chemistry is unnecessary, as is your warning about feces in reputable french sea salts. Let us keep this discussion on a sober level.
 
Lecturing me on chemistry is unnecessary, as is your warning about feces in reputable french sea salts. Let us keep this discussion on a sober level.

It was more for the information of those who are into pop science than chemistry that I made those comments.

Personally other than Fleur de Sel de Camargue I would never consume a French salt from the south coast. Average lead content of French sea salt went from under .2 PPMs in 1998 to over .7 ppm in 2007. So the date and source of the sample are both critical. My guess is that the data is at least 10 years old. Probably older.

To quote Greenpeace: http://www.greenpeace.org/internati...he-mediterranean/mediterranean-other-threats/

"The Mediterranean Sea is one of the most heavily polluted marine areas in the world. Thousands of tonnes of toxic waste are pumped directly into the sea by industry each year. Sewage facility dumping into the Mediterranean. Heavy metals and persistent organic pollutants (POPs) are a serious threat to human health and marine life. High concentrations of mercury, cadmium, zinc and lead in sediments are found at "hot-spots", generally located in the coastal zones receiving high levels of industrial effluents, solid waste and domestic sewage. These substances can travel thousands of kilometers, across national boundaries, far from their source."

Granted the 2009 rules are supposed to make it better. :)