bbking said:
Once again Fort. you got your facts wrong.
Quite the contrary. Once again, you show you just don't understand much.
bbking said:
It is the Federal Government's resposility to define what a marriage is
That's exactly what I said. Under section 91, item 26 of the Constitution, that is clearly identified.
bbking said:
- the Provincial Governments are resposible for the adiministration and procedural requirements.
Yes. EXACTLY. Also what I said under section 92, item 12 - The Solemnization of Marriage in the Province. I know you're a little dull, but "solemnize" means to duly perform. They issue licenses... they issue the REQUIREMENTS of GETTING A LICENSE. That is their job. That is their power. That is their constitutional RIGHT. The Feds can define marriage however they like... but the provinces can AND DO stipulate requirements - age, mental capacity, premarital counsel/course requirements, consent requirements, and (if they want)... sex*. They don't give a licence... no marriage. Regardless of the federal "definition". End of story*.
bbking said:
All the Feds are doing Fort is defining what marriage is.
Where have I suggested otherwise? The Feds get to decide what "married" means... the Provinces get to decide the requirements of GETTING MARRIED in that province.
bbking said:
Believe it or not Fort the Canadian Federal Government cannot do as you suggested - you know the rule of law. I think if you look closely Fort a great deal of Canadian Law is set up like the Marriage Laws and I believe that includes education, Health care etc.
Wrong (as always). Nowhere does the Federal government have jurisdiction over education... and the only jurisdiction they have over health care is in Marine Hospitals (section 91, item 11). Yet they pass legislation in these areas regardless, despite their lack of jurisdiction.
bbking said:
Anyways your first reaction will be to freak - but I've included a link that even you can figure out. I will be very interested in seeing you dance out of this one. Have fun.
Dance out of what? Mr. Someone suggested that the Provinces have no jurisdiction on the topic of marriage... I pointed out that this notion is simply not true. The provinces are the ones who actually DO marriages, and as such... very much their jurisdiction - regardless of how the feds "define" it.
As for your article... you might be better served to read the actual constitution. I know, I know... too many "big words" for you... but if you have someone "dumb it down" for you, you might find it informative...
http://laws.justice.gc.ca/en/const/c1867_e.html#distribution
Good bye, genius.
F.
*before you run off in a tizzy, this would of course be subject to court challenges, etc.