Is Kindle dead?

Feb 21, 2007
1,397
1
0
Looking for a birthday gift for the SO. She loves to read, so I was thinking of a Kindle. I see now that there is a new Kindle DX, with a 9.7" screen, that can be shipped to Canada, and will download on a G3 network.

Buying through Amazon.com is pretty pricey ($700.00 includes the a $49 leather cover, shipping, handling, taxes/duties) versus $329 for the 6" screen size($259 + $29 leather cover, includes tax/duties etc). It has a smaller memory...1500 books versus 3500.

It seems like the smaller Kindle approximates the experience of holding a paperback, versus the larger one holding a hardcover. SO commutes on the GO train....I don't think the larger Kindle would fit that well into her purse.

Can you buy these retail anywhere in Toronto? I'd actually like to handle one, just to get a feel for it.

I know...Apple with the iPad...already less than steller reviews, and it's not even here in Canada yet.

I did a search for this...answers were somewhat vague (other than Kindle is dead), so I thought I would throw into open discussion. Maybe this should be in the tech section, but thought it might get some more responses in the lounge.

Thanks to all who respond.
 
Yes, Kindle will be dead.

Since you can get the Kindle app for an iPhone/Pod/Pad.

And, the iPad reviews have been more positive, then negative (FUD).
 
I don't think the Kindle will be dead.

In fact, I bought a Kindle 2 when the iPad was announced. I was looking for a ebook reader and just wasn't impressed with the iPad in that regard.

My experience so far:

* The shipping is fast. Ordered it Wednesday, got an email that my order was shipped on Thursday, received it on Friday.
* Solid design. Without memorizing the button layout, I started reading. I would move my thumb to where I expected the next page button and it was there. It feels very natural. The keyboard however is a little rough but it does the job.
* The software is equally good. The built in dictionary for looking up words while reading, ability to take notes, search within the book, etc add value. There's a few things that weren't obvious (like deleting items off the Kindle) but I found out quickly after googling for answers.
* It doesn't feel cheap considering its measurements. There's the just right amount of weight to make it feel study but not too heavy that its problematic after extended reading.
* 3G wireless is great. Search, read reviews and purchase books. Delivery was under 60 seconds. I also like I don't have to pay to use the 3G data to use it. That being said, free books on Amazon's Kindle store have a $2 surcharge when purchased under non-US accounts.
* You can read the screen in direct sunlight. Good luck trying to do that with a glossy screen.
* It took me about 20 minutes to mentally ignore the bezel and focus on the screen. After that it felt no different from reading a paperback. Turning a page took about 2 seconds.
* You will be able to sync and store your ebooks on your computer using Kindle for PC.
* Battery life goes quick if you leave wireless on. It's Sunday evening (I started using it on a full charge on Friday) and I think I'm at 20% battery life (there's no % metric for the battery icon). I'm going to leave the wireless off unless I'm buying books or syncing changes.
* There's no backlight. I'm going to buy a light that you can attach to the Kindle from Amazon or eBay. I find the screen not bright enough for my liking.
* Amazon has a huge online community for the Kindle -- http://www.amazon.com/tag/kindle/ref=tag_cdf_bkt_itdp

I think the iPad is more for someone who wants a netbook experience more than a ebook reader. The glossy screen will really reduce its utility as a dedicated ebook reader. The Kindle DX is great for someone who wants to read textbooks or technical books with large graphics. I think your gf will enjoy the Kindle 2 more if she's a paperbook reader.

If you have any specific questions, ask away.
 
It isn't dead yet, but down the road there's a limited future for single-purpose e-readers. So, Kindle may be the thing now, just don't lock yourself too much to it.
 
I'm wondering how successful (or not) the Kindle is?
Amazon hasn't released any sales figures -- who knows, it could've sold 100 million or 10,000 units?
 
Fark 'em all. I still prefer a real book....:o
 
My SO has a Kindle 2 that I bought her a year ago, she loves it.... I don't know that the DX is worth the extra coin but that's up to you.

Amazon sells 6 ebooks for every 10 hard copy they sell..... so the Kindle isn't going anywhere - and this from a huge prospective fan of the iPad.

OTB
 
Being able to read a Kindle screen in sunlight is a major deal.

Everyone else needs to see if they can make their monitors better and read like actual books or documents.
 
Kindle is dead for 2 big reasons.

DRM. Kindle uses very restrctive DRM or copy protection. You can't copy a book onto anywhere else, you can't move it around. Apple is going no DRM, just recently got rid of copy protection for iTunes music.

Single Use. The iPad is just as good a reading experience but can do so much more, not to mention full colour. Games, web, mail, photos....
 
Kindle is dead for 2 big reasons.

DRM. Kindle uses very restrctive DRM or copy protection. You can't copy a book onto anywhere else, you can't move it around. Apple is going no DRM, just recently got rid of copy protection for iTunes music.

Single Use. The iPad is just as good a reading experience but can do so much more, not to mention full colour. Games, web, mail, photos....

Apple still uses DRM for Movies and Apps. I don't think this will change anytime soon. It took awhile for the music studios to realize they had very little to lose by dropping DRM. Hollywood and book publishers still feel that DRM protects their content and provides ROI.
 
I had a kindle at a conference in Las Vegas earlier in the month to read through journals, etc..

reading on Kindle made my eyes tired, each time i read i could not get past 10 pages and needed to put it down... just my experience. it worked well in natural sunlight though, which I wouldn't get from my netbook or cell phone for that matter... but, page turning was horribly slow. the ipad's page turning is real time- in fact alot about the ipad is revolutionarily improved from anything else out there. just wait until the million different software choices become available for that thing (ipad)
 
And here's a very good article about the recent Amazon/Macmillan/Apple fight going on in the ebook business.
Suffice it to say that the iPad will result in both cheaper ebook pricing and more cash going to authors, which is similar to what happened with iTunes and the recording industry.

http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2010/01/amazon-macmillan-an-outsiders.html

Amazon has changed their agreements to reflect the same revenue split that Apple offers.

http://www.appleinsider.com/article...on_kindle_adopts_app_store_revenue_split.html
 
I had a kindle at a conference in Las Vegas earlier in the month to read through journals, etc..

reading on Kindle made my eyes tired, each time i read i could not get past 10 pages and needed to put it down... just my experience.

Damn. So far, I haven't experienced that. If OP is concerned his gf might experience this, I recommend she try out one of Sony's readers first. Both use the same e-ink technology.

I prefer the Kindle over the Sony due to better usability and larger selection. Sony brags they offer more books but many of them are public domain from Google Books -- http://books.google.com/

When you remove those ebooks, Amazon has the larger selection.
 
I dont thimk kindle is dead or will be dead for the following reasons:

Kindle right now have a lot of books that can be downloaded.They let you download the first 2 chapters free.
With Kindle, you can sync with iphone or ipod and eventually with ipad. You buy a book at Kindle, read half of it on the machine and read the other half with the ipad, iphone or ipod.
You can buy books on Kindle anywhere that have 3G cell service, on the bus, in Europe without any cell phone charges.
Ipad have to make deals with Roger, fido or bell to have that service, which the analyst said that may take a long time. With unlimited data plan.
Kindle is easier to carry around.

I have a Kindle, but I will buy an ipad as well. Kindle have no color or pictures from magazine.