Is home brewed beer any good?

rafterman

A sadder and a wiser man
Feb 15, 2004
3,504
101
63
Just curious.

Was in my local beer and wine making store recently and it seems fairly foolproof. Even for me.....ha ha ha.

$200 for a couple of big brew jugs and assorted sundry hardware. Store owner recommended plastic bottles for the finished product which are of course reusable with tear off plastic caps.

Costs about $30 for beer kit and there are a dozen or more different beer types you can brew up.

Seems like the variable cost of production is about 25% of the cost of store bought.

I'm not really a big drinker but with spring now here the idea of tipping back a tall frosty brewski after some sweaty yard work is appealing particularly when I've made it myself and I'm not paying the man a bunch of excise taxes like in the liquor store.
 
I have gone the brewed-from-scratch home brew route and the go to a brew-it-yourself business route. I never made a good beer with the former but frequently did with the latter. Pure home brew usually relied on secondary fermentation in the bottle for carbonation and often produced very "yeasty" tasting beer. The stores have lots of expensive filtering equipment and often use artificial carbonation and proper bottling equipment. I find that true home brewing (with success) requires more expense than just the basic starter kit and a fair bit of experience.

Temperature control while brewing is pretty important for some beers too. So you may need a good spot like a cool basement to do it in.
 
Last edited:
I have gone the brewed-from-scratch home brew route and the go to a brew-it-yourself business route. I never made a good beer with the former but frequently did with the latter. Pure home brew usually relied on secondary fermentation in the bottle for carbonation and usually produced very "yeasty" tasting beer. The stores have lots if expensive filtering equipment and often use artificail carbonation and proper bottling equipment. I find that true home brewing (with success) requires more expense than just the basic starter kit and a fair bit of experience.

My experience exactly, and you're absolutely correct that brewed from scratch beer has a tendency to taste yeasty. Plus it can be a very time consuming cooking process, requiring you to carefully bring the malt up to different temperture stages and holding them there. I had best success with the darker malts which tended to hide the yeastiness better. After a year or so I decided it wasn't worth the bother.
 
I like homebrew.

I think you'd probably get better results at a U-brew shop than doing it at home. Better filtration, artificial carbonation, expert advice.

I have heard that regular cane sugar is one of the things that gives homebrew an off taste. Personally, I have made some recipes using extra malt extract and no added sugar, with good results.

Some people have suggested that dextrose brews better than glucose. Might be worth investigating.
 
We brewed a few batches at home, and it was pretty decent. We bought the premixed wort, so you do not have to do as much, it sits in a barrel for a while, then you bottle it, then it sits more. We went to to a home-brew store in Hamilton, they were pretty helpful. If you drink a lot of beer, and your time is not worth too much, then you should consider it.
 
I tried the brew yourself method at one of these shops and I was very pleased with the results.

However, the beer has no preservatives and has a shelf life of about 6 weeks before it starts to go skunky. The batch size was about 50 liters if I remember correctly. That means that 50 liters of beer needs to be drank in a month and a half.

That's an average of more than half a liter of beer a day. That was a little too much for me. I ended up throwing the last few bottles away.

If you're not a big beer drinker, I suggest going splits with someone else on a batch.
 
I tried the brew yourself method at one of these shops and I was very pleased with the results.

However, the beer has no preservatives and has a shelf life of about 6 weeks before it starts to go skunky. The batch size was about 50 liters if I remember correctly. That means that 50 liters of beer needs to be drank in a month and a half.

That's an average of more than half a liter of beer a day. That was a little too much for me. I ended up throwing the last few bottles away.

If you're not a big beer drinker, I suggest going splits with someone else on a batch.

That's the rub of the whole thing although you can push it for a little longer but only for the darker beers. They can easily go 6 months or more.
 
I have brewed beer for over 15 years. If done well the results will rival craftbrewed product...

It is not inexpensive and you better have the very best set-up for sterilizing your equipment. You will need to learn first so a u brew shop is a good start.

Plan on buying lots of bottles, at least 6 carboys, and a bottle washing attachment for your faucet... Dont brew from canned kits, but rather buy specialty malts raw malt syrup and hops...

Carbonation... u brew shops that artifically carbonate the brew suck... the bubbles are course and dont allow the best head on the beer. Natural carbonation is better, just as Champagne is carbonated... except you wont be freezing the yeast plug and extracting it, so the beer sits on the yeast and when you pour it if you are not careful you get yeast in your glass... hence the comments about the yeastly flavour.

The better approach is to not bottle your beer, but rather purchase kegs. You can get soda syrup style kegs which take less room. The yeast in the keg is flushed out during the first pre-pour so that you get natural draft flavour with each beer...

The savings on beer for the average real canadian beer drinker will more than make up for your costs... but be warned, it you are not good with hygiene you will ruin many a batch of beer. On the positive side, lots of really great beer i almost any style yu can imagine...

Finally, find a natural spring to get your water... tap water has chlorine which inhibits the initial fermentation and lends an off taste that a discerning palate can detect
 
Would agree with previous posts. For me there was also another side effect....I was drinking a lot more beer, and the bottles are 500 ml. So I started putting on weight, until I just decided to get off beer for a while.

still love it but it was an obsession for a while.
 
By all accounts ...

Temperature control while brewing is pretty important for some beers too. So you may need a good spot like a cool basement to do it in.

My German grandfather produced some kick-ass beer in his basement (before, during and after prohibition.) Don't think he had any $100 brew jugs though. My mom doesn't remember the smell as bad, but does remember how much she loved running the bottle capper!
 
I basement-brewed for a half dozen or so years, and earned a some compliments for my product. But I would absolutely never recommend it only as a cost-saver, or for someone who just likes the occasional beer. As was said above, shelf-life is not indefinite—unlike blue beer. And if blue beer's (slug-bait) is your taste, you'll have trouble finding home recipes that bland.

It's not onerous but it is work—so you need to enjoy that—and it needs discipline, about sterilizing, scheduling etc.—so you'd better be into that too. Think of it like serious cooking (BTW, you'll want some serious stove access with very large pots of boiling stuff. Discuss.) or breadmaking. If that's not the sorta thing you enjoy, look for another pastime.

If you're still intrigued, get a one off kit, a fermentation lock and scam a cooler sized water jug, to keep your costs down. Save the investment for later batches. Or do a U-brew batch first, and imagine it all in your laundry room.

But if that hasn't put you off, then you're the type. Enjoy.
 
Making wine is okay it comes out pretty good, but making Beer at home does not seems right, as making Beer is a long process
& it needs industrial process in its brewing a fine finished product, as i was associated with Beer & Liquor Industry for a long time and i have seen the brewing of a very famous brand of German Beer at the old Brewery, therefore making a Beer at home is not at all a feasble idea:)