Is Hawkings right ?????

Is Hawkings right ??

  • They will turn us into sex slaves

    Votes: 13 38.2%
  • They will be peaceful and give us great knowledge

    Votes: 6 17.6%
  • They want to force their religion on us

    Votes: 9 26.5%
  • No such thing as ET

    Votes: 6 17.6%

  • Total voters
    34

Big Rig

Well-known member
May 6, 2009
2,422
514
113
Hawkings says aliens will do to us what we did to the Indians so best not look for them

I say :


Given

All species evolve in a Darwinian fashion IE survival of the fittest
.This is a universal law that has to be accepted until there is evidence to the contrary

therefore

although some species are passive - IE worms - all advanced species evolve tribal and warlike in order to survive

However

To explore the universe a species has to have highly advanced technology

But

Darwinian evolution means species kill each other with said technology and do not explore the universe (this is the evolutionary stage we are at )


Therefore

If there are aliens in spacecraft they have evolved to overcome their violent nature and are peaceful like Vulcans
 
Show me a country without an Army that has launched a maned rocket.
 
Can I volunteer to be this alien's sex slave?

EY3PX.jpg


Please..... Pretty please?????
 
Hawkings says aliens will do to us what we did to the Indians so best not look for them

I say :


Given

All species evolve in a Darwinian fashion IE survival of the fittest
.This is a universal law that has to be accepted until there is evidence to the contrary

therefore

although some species are passive - IE worms - all advanced species evolve tribal and warlike in order to survive

However

To explore the universe a species has to have highly advanced technology

But

Darwinian evolution means species kill each other with said technology and do not explore the universe (this is the evolutionary stage we are at )


Therefore

If there are aliens in spacecraft they have evolved to overcome their violent nature and are peaceful like Vulcans

Horseshit. If aliens somehow figure out a way to travel through the universe to reach our little blue dot of a planet, they're going to be hungry. Hungry for what exactly I'm not entirely sure.
 
WTF is that supposed to mean ?

It means that space exploration developed out of military programs. For the most part, the boosters that launch satellites and other spacecraft are descended from ballistic missiles. Since the end of the Cold War, both Russia and the USA have used turned their excess supply of ICBMs into launch systems for satellites and other spacecraft.

The Vostok, the spacecraft that Yuri Gagarin used, had the same basic design as the Zenit spy satellite. It allowed Sergei Korolev to get political and militay support for a human spaceflight progam.
 
It means that space exploration developed out of military programs. For the most part, the boosters that launch satellites and other spacecraft are descended from ballastic missiles.

The Vostok, the spacecraft that Yuri Gagarin used, had the same basic design as the Zenit spy satellite. It allowed Sergei Korolev to get political and military support for a human spaceflight program.

Brilliant

I think you are right

That brings up another point which is warlike peoples develop technology out of necessity

So do you have to be warlike to develop space travel ??
 
Brilliant

I think you are right

That brings up another point which is warlike peoples develop technology out of necessity

So do you have to be warlike to develop space travel ??

I would say, most likely yes. If you are satisfied with what you have, why would you need to travel such great distances? If the human model is anything to go by, exploration has always been about conquest.
 
Assuming they have the technology to get here, they would have to be an evolved species, and I assume more civilized then us. They wouldn't be coming here to conquer our planet cause they should be smart enough to develop renewable sources of energy, and have no need for further resources.

I don't see us turning into sex slaves for the same reason we haven't turned dogs into sex slaves, and if they've developed the ability to travel light years, they're probably not religious.
 
Assuming they have the technology to get here, they would have to be an evolved species, and I assume more civilized then us. They wouldn't be coming here to conquer our planet cause they should be smart enough to develop renewable sources of energy, and have no need for further resources.

Uh huh. So why would they be coming here in the first place? Just for shits and giggles?
 
Assuming they have the technology to get here, they would have to be an evolved species, and I assume more civilized then us. They wouldn't be coming here to conquer our planet cause they should be smart enough to develop renewable sources of energy, and have no need for further resources.

I don't see us turning into sex slaves for the same reason we haven't turned dogs into sex slaves, and if they've developed the ability to travel light years, they're probably not religious.

Good point but there would still be greater profit in explotation I would think

Wealth does not create peace in the human experience
 
Uh huh. So why would they be coming here in the first place? Just for shits and giggles?

Why would I want to visit the moon, go sky diving, party in Vegas, or have fun in Japan? Because I can. My friends and I once rented a boat without knowing where the hell we were going, but it sure didn't stop us from doing it.

Good point but there would still be greater profit in explotation I would think

Wealth does not create peace in the human experience

I wonder if aliens would even use money or something like it. They could be traders or something. Or maybe treat everyone in their species like family, "nobody starves or goes homeless."
 
From what I understand when I saw the news clip, Hawkins was referring to the diseases they would bring to earth that would kill us, referring to smallpox that wiped out something like 90% of the population in the Americas.

Exactly right. Assuming they were carbon based life forms, they could knowingly, or unknowingly, bring a whole host of diseases our bodies wouldn't recognize or be able to combat. Not to worry. I'm fairly confident they ain't coming. We have bigger things to worry about.
 
If we discover a planet (like Mars, for example) that has some form of primitive life on it, that life won't stop us from doing whatever we want with Mars once we finally get there.

Similarly, an ET species that travels all the way to Earth is likely to look upon us the same way would look at insects or (at best) lesser animals. If they want to mine Earth for their personal gain, I don't see that they'd allow our presence to prevent them for getting what they want. They might try to deal with us because that would be easier than fighting...but if we didn't wan to give up what they were after (like Oxygen, perhaps) they'd crush us like bugs to get what they want.

I didn't vote because "crush us like bugs" wasn't an option.
 
Why would I want to visit the moon, go sky diving, party in Vegas, or have fun in Japan? Because I can. My friends and I once rented a boat without knowing where the hell we were going, but it sure didn't stop us from doing it.

So you're saying another lifeform would travel across the universe just to spend some time on the beach at Waikiki. Somehow I doubt that.
 
None of the above ...

even if there are ET (very good chance - somewhere in the infinite or nearly-so universe) they won't be coming here and we won't be going there. All the interstellar travel stuff is just so much science fiction fodder, same thing with time travel - so get real, Steve!!:rolleyes: